Dailymaverick logo

Opinionistas

This article is an Opinion, which presents the writer’s personal point of view. The views expressed are those of the author/authors and do not necessarily represent the views of Daily Maverick.

This article is more than a year old

The deafening silence of feminists not defending the women of Gaza

While we have often been subjected to the boisterous cries of Western feminists speaking up on everything from climate change to why the Barbie movie didn’t win an Oscar, the genocide being perpetrated against the women of Gaza has seemingly left them mute.

‘I have forgotten what it means to be a woman in this war,” 34-year-old Nada Abdelsalam told a journalist earlier this year. “Women in Gaza have borne the brunt of this war. Our burdens have multiplied, and our sense of privacy has vanished.” 

Abdelsalam was forced to flee from the Maghazi refugee camp in Gaza due to relentless Israeli bombing of civilian areas — she is only one of many women suffering immeasurably. 

What has left me perplexed, is that while we have often been subjected to the boisterous cries of Western feminists speaking up on everything from climate change to why the Barbie movie didn’t win an Oscar, the genocide being perpetrated against the women of Gaza has seemingly left them mute. Has the fact that Israel is the perpetrator played a part in their deafening silence and incorrigible double standards? 

The World Health Organization has recognised the impact of Israel’s onslaught against women, citing that the bombardments, damaged or non-functioning health facilities, massive levels of displacement, collapsing water and electricity supplies as well as Israel’s severe restrictions on access to food and medicines, are severely disrupting maternal, newborn, and child health services

There are an estimated 50,000 pregnant women in Gaza, with more than 180 giving birth every day. These women are unable to access the emergency obstetric services they need to give birth safely and care for their newborns. 

Mercè Rocaspana, a Médecins Sans Frontières emergency unit health adviser, agrees: “In contexts like Gaza, where the health system has been decimated and collapsed, late access to care is posing a health risk to pregnant women and their children.” 

Malnutrition

“Every day, we see women and children coming into our clinic suffering from acute malnutrition,” said Dr Maram, the lead physician for Project Hope. The nonprofit organisation said 21% of pregnant women treated in the Deir al-Balah clinic in the three weeks to 24 February were suffering from malnutrition, as were one in 10 of the children seen by its doctors there.  

Only a trickle of aid is reaching Gaza — over the past couple of months, Israel has allowed fewer than 100 trucks a day to enter. The UN has said it is far short of the estimated 500 trucks needed each day to meet people’s basic needs. 

Earlier this year, United Nations Women (UNW) launched its latest Gender Alert on Gaza. In it, an investigative-based gender analysis of the impact of the war in Gaza on vital services essential to women’s and girls’ health, safety and dignity, the facts are highlighted. 

Long before 7 October, access to safe, potable water was already limited in Gaza as a result of decades of Israeli occupation. Today, Gaza’s water supply is at only 7% of its pre-7 October levels. 

UNW estimates that 1.1 million women and girls do not have access to sufficient and safe water to meet their drinking and domestic needs — critical for breastfeeding mothers and menstrual hygiene which is integral to women’s health, dignity, and privacy.

According to the UN Population Fund, there are more than 690,000 menstruating women and adolescent girls in Gaza, all of whom are facing limited access to menstrual hygiene products. 

The killing of women

In addition, based on estimates from Gaza’s Health Ministry and the United Nations Population Fund, more than 10,000 women have been killed by Israel in Gaza over the past year, more than 19,000 have been injured, 3,000 have become widows and heads of households, and an estimated 37 mothers are killed a day by Israel. 

Reem Alsalem, the UN special rapporteur on violence against women and girls, has said that there is credible evidence of sexual assault being used as a weapon against Palestinian women and girls in Israeli detention, including rape. 

Besides the absolute grotesqueness of these statistics, which confer an obvious targeting of women by Israel, the long-term psychological effects on thousands of children who will grow up without their mothers are unimaginable. 

Today, Palestinian women are living through horrors that fundamentally challenge the core values of feminism. Mothers are burying their children with bare hands; families are grieving for their lost homes; women and children face malnutrition and countless communicable diseases — all under the relentless rain of Israeli bombs.

Under these circumstances, silence is not a neutral stance. Silence today is a passive endorsement of Israel’s systematic genocide — of which the majority of self-proclaimed feminists are guilty. DM

Comments (10)

markgcfriedman Sep 19, 2024, 07:49 PM

Not a single word about Jewish women, raped, in some cases gang-raped, tortured, murdered and kidnapped. The Palestinians shills will argue that this is all made up even though a malign and discredited entity such as the UN even acknowledged it. The double standards are shocking on both sides

waheed.sookool Sep 23, 2024, 12:35 PM

Mass rapes, actually any rapes, by the insurgents have never been independently verified as the Israelis refuse to allow this. In fact many credible voices question the veracity completely, with some of the initial reports now being called completely false, even on mainstream Israeli television.

Lorna Monkley Sep 23, 2024, 11:33 PM

Actually you are wrong. An independent investigation by the UN has admitted to the atrocities committed on Oct 7 both of unwarranted violence and mass rapes. Also a lot of independent reporters and people from various governments were invited to watch go pro video footage from the insurgents.

Sean Coetzee Sep 25, 2024, 05:20 PM

Credible voices?

ttshililo2 Sep 19, 2024, 11:18 PM

A thoughtful piece, thank you Dr Soni.

rwyatt Sep 20, 2024, 08:08 AM

Whilst I agree that the conditions for ALL civilians in Gaza are horrific, I constantly wonder why the civilians have never been allowed to shelter in the miles of underground tunnels, which would have protected them from the bombardment.

rwyatt Sep 20, 2024, 08:10 AM

Also, I wonder how different things would have been if Hamas had spent the billions of funds donated to them over the years on improving the lives of their citizens (and building a successful state like Dubai or Singapore) instead of spending it on the tunnels and weapons.

Freda Brodie Sep 20, 2024, 09:53 AM

100%. Many of those women support Hamas. As usual, Israel is blamed. Why does Hamas use hospitals and schools to hide and launch rockets from. Simply, Hamas doesn’t care for their women and children.

Muishond X Sep 20, 2024, 08:22 AM

"Israel the perpetrator"? Did this slip through the editor's perusal? This type of article is exactly why DM is losing its relevance as an independant news source and probably why its having to retrench 10-15% of its workforce.

Lorna Monkley Sep 23, 2024, 11:02 PM

Precisely why I stopped being an insider and take most of their reports these days with a pinch of salt. I always verify their reports with other news sites before I accept them as unbiased.

Mark J Sep 20, 2024, 08:30 AM

Kamala Harris's stance in this regard is concerning. While trumpeting support for women's rights in the US she is simultaneously pledging an unending supply of ordnance to Israel which is directly and detrimentally impacting the lives of women and children in Gaza.

BillyBumhead@MYOB.com Sep 20, 2024, 09:21 AM

The blame lies at Hamas' door.

Mark J Sep 20, 2024, 09:37 AM

Decades of Israeli occupation, routine "mowing the lawn", no recourse to justice for the people of Gaza - is it any wonder that armed resistance will arise? By your logic, the Jews of Warsaw were responsible for their own demise in the uprising of 1943.

Malcolm McManus Sep 20, 2024, 10:29 AM

Perhaps the ICJ should make a ruling on the UN for this problem.

Lorna Monkley Sep 23, 2024, 11:24 PM

Where did you get your facts? Egypt occupied Gaza for 19 years till 1967. Israel only took over during that war, after they were attacked and then withdrew all troops and settlers in 2005 - Gaza has had autonomy since then and voted in Hamas.

Mark J Sep 25, 2024, 09:31 PM

Autonomy? Do you mean like the Bantustans of apartheid South Africa? Autonomy granted by an occupying military power is as meaningless as evacuation orders given to its captive population.

Kanu Sukha Sep 20, 2024, 12:01 PM

When the terrorism of occupation & humiliation - terms even the mainstream media avoid these days (thanks to AIPAC) - & mixed with the heady notion of "God's chosen people" (Gideon Levy).. genocide (supported by US) is likely & even defensible for zionists. Any rational discussion is impossible.

Lorna Monkley Sep 23, 2024, 11:11 PM

A simple bit of research will tell you that - After the 1948-49 war, Gaza was occupied by Egypt for 19 years. Israel occupied Gaza in the 1967 war and stayed until 2005. Israel withdrew its troops and settlers in 2005. Get your facts straight if you want rational discussion.

Karin Swart Sep 20, 2024, 03:16 PM

If my memory serves me right, the good Doctor has not bothered to denounce the effect that Putin's "military maneuvers" have had on the women in Ukraine. It is an unfortunate fact as old as time, that women suffer the most in a war, any war.

alastairmgf Sep 20, 2024, 04:52 PM

Feminism and Islam are like oil and water.

Deon de Wet-Roos Sep 25, 2024, 08:14 AM

Doubt that you will post this but anyway. DM has lost all credibility. Why not just close down?