Over the past few years, it was something of a national pastime to criticise Cyril Ramaphosa. There was usually a sigh at the mention of his name, followed by “he is such a disappointment” or “why isn’t he doing more?”.
To my question “Like what?”, the criticisers usually mumbled a list of actions, many which are beyond the President’s powers (like throwing criminals in jail). Many journalists and commentators have also been on an anti-Cyril buzz, pointing to his lack of decisive action and the lack of progress on many fronts.
I believe that some of this is because of Ramaphosa’s personality and management style, which is not the traditional bull-in-a-china-shop – generally regarded as a sign of strength. He consults widely and includes others in his thinking before making decisions. And, yes, contrary to popular belief, he does make decisions – even unpopular ones – just not necessarily in the way or time frame we want or expect him to.
This has not only helped him to survive for decades – especially during the Zuma years – in a divided ANC, but was also a strength during the Covid crisis. His leadership during that time, which involved constant consultation with medical and scientific experts, is still widely lauded internationally in contrast with that of Donald Trump and Boris Johnson.
Still, the rapid change that so many of us hoped for when Ramaphosa became President didn’t materialise, and it left many, including me, disappointed and wondering if he was perhaps the “right president, at the wrong time”.
Ramaphosa was always destined to become President, and had he succeeded Nelson Mandela in 1999 he would have been one of our great presidents. However, 19 years later, South Africa was a very different place, and many wondered if he was perhaps the wrong man to meet the new demands.
Dealt a bad hand
It must be said that Ramaphosa was dealt a bad hand when he became President in 2018.
There was corruption, State Capture and a deeply divided ANC. No one in the ANC – including Ramaphosa – fully comprehended the extent of State Capture during the Zuma years until the Zondo Commission laid it all bare. In addition, those who had lost their political cover were actively working against the President’s reforms. Then Covid hit and a year later, the country was rocked by the devastating riots following Zuma’s arrest. Ramaphosa also had (and will continue) to deal with severe weather events such as the floods in KwaZulu-Natal and the Eastern Cape, which hampered progress.
Interestingly, while disappointment in Ramaphosa reached fever pitch in South Africa, he was (and is) held in high regard abroad. Leading up to the recent elections, for example, all the international investors I deal with frequently wanted him to remain President.
I can of course list many failures during the Ramaphosa presidency, which are evidenced by the fact that the ANC got only 40% support during the election. Some of that can be blamed on him, but the vast majority of the failures are the consequence of his predecessor’s actions – not least the corrupting of the civil service and the parastatals.
I believe that Ramaphosa’s commitment to improve the country cannot be doubted. He had no need to become President. He was, after all, rich and famous enough. Still, he felt a calling to finish the job he had started at Codesa, by ensuring the economic transformation of the country.
Yes, we have a Cabinet now, but with the many challenges that the Government of National Unity will undoubtedly face, I cannot think of any other politician in South Africa who can keep this diverse bunch of mostly immature politicians together.
So yes, Cyril Ramaphosa is not perfect, but then again nobody is. The bottom line is that there is no one else in South Africa who could in the foreseeable future step successfully into his shoes.
As much as there were questions about whether he was the right man for the job during his first term, he is undoubtedly the right president for our country right now.
So, perhaps we should all lay off the Cyril-bashing for a while and give him and his new team some time and space to govern and improve things in the country. DM