Defend Truth

Opinionista

We have allowed depravity and dishonesty to fester, now the threat of self-destruction is a few tipping points away

mm

Charles Villa-Vicencio is professor emeritus at the University of Cape Town and a former visiting professor in conflict resolution at Georgetown University in Washington, DC. He was Research Director for the Truth and Reconciliation Commission.

Without the social tissue that unites the nation across the craters of ideological and economic difference, the possibility of weaving a web of human decency and political honesty is remote and far distant.

Former president Thabo Mbeki reminds us of the abuse of Mohamed Bouazizi, a desperate and exhausted street vendor who became a catalyst for the Tunisian and wider Arab revolution in 2010.

Humiliated and abused, the vendor had his wares confiscated for not having a licence to ply his trade. He doused himself with petrol and burnt himself to death. “How do you expect me to make a living?” he shouted.

His immolation captured the attention of the world, resulting in the overthrow of President Ben Ali, the Tunisian dictator of 24 years. Reversing these democratic gains, last Monday Tunisians voted in favour of current President Kais Saied being given total authoritarian power.

The matrix of transition can be ignited by a disgruntled worker, an onlooker, an avaricious politician, or a politically devious entrepreneur. The stalled Tunisian transition is a reminder of the danger embedded in political change.

South African politics faces the inherent contradictions between the needs of the poorest of the poor, restless students, emerging first-generation middle-class contenders, established professional classes and a political elite – each demanding different kinds of delivery to advance their multiple needs.   

Dominant options for tentative conciliation include: the prosecution of the instigators of the KwaZulu-Natal-based rampage of a year ago, the commitment to deal with alleged benefactors of State Capture, and the redress of the deepening economic crisis. Add to this the Phala Phala fiasco, in addition to the suspicion that the President’s grand plan to tackle the electricity crisis could be hijacked by vested interests.

These realities demand buy-in from political leaders, business tycoons, civil society, apparatchiks of political parties, the unemployed and the indigent. A big ask. The ruling party has (at best) until the 2024 election to provide a semblance of delivery on these demands or surrender power. 

This raises concerns about the nature of events surrounding the looming tipping point.

A pertinent question is whether the loudest voices in political and other structures are a bunch of well-fed wolves in sheep’s clothing, or a more serious manifestation of the loss of integrity embedded in the very fabric of South African society. It is difficult to name primary culprits or identify the good guys and girls among them. We have been shocked too often to be complacent or confident about would-be political saviours.

Perhaps we are all guilty. We have allowed depravity and dishonesty to fester and grow.   

Chief Seattle (in 1854) wrote to the “Great Chief” in Washington DC, saying: “Man did not weave the web of life; he is merely a strand within it. Whatever he does to the web he does to himself.”  

The South African web is convoluted and obscure. It is easy to name the blunt architects of colonialism and apartheid. The current web is less clear. It is a web that includes RET ideologues and the proponents of Mandelaism that offers the possibility of non-racism, non-sexism and human inclusivity.

The grand schemes of colonialism and apartheid are today the stuff of political cartoons. We cry out for a new messiah, while being ready to settle for a leader who simply confesses his/her limitations and failures, in drawing the visionaries of the golden days of post-1994 prosperity into a pragmatic liaison with a new generation of leaders who leave racist name-calling and fraudulent activities in the changeroom.   

Without the social tissue that unites the nation across the craters of ideological and economic difference, the possibility of weaving a web of human decency and political honesty is remote and far distant.

It proffers the threat of self-destruction. DM

Gallery

Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • Johan Buys says:

    here, our principled protestors burn other people not themselves :/

  • Gerrit Marais says:

    There’s only one reason for this global malaise: we give too much power to too few people. Why? Doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different outcome. Too much stupid in the system.

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted