First Thing, Daily Maverick's flagship newsletter

Join the 230 000 South Africans who read First Thing newsletter.

Russia’s President Putin wants more than Ukraine

Defend Truth

Opinionista

Make no mistake, Vladimir Putin wants more than Ukraine

mm

Joschka Fischer, Germany’s foreign minister and vice-chancellor from 1998 to 2005, was a leader of the German Green Party for almost 20 years.

By invading Ukraine, Russian President Vladimir Putin is challenging not only that country’s independence but also the broader European system, which rests above all on the inviolability of borders and the law of nations. There has been no comparable event in Europe since the Hitler era.

Russia’s President Vladimir Putin has made his choice. He has brought war to Ukraine. This is a watershed moment for Europe. For the first time since the Balkan wars of the 1990s, which were limited to the area of the disintegrating Yugoslavia, the continent is once again confronted with bombardments of cities and rolling tank divisions. But this time, it is a nuclear superpower that started the fighting.

By ordering an invasion, Putin is showing a brazen disregard for international treaties and the law of nations. There has been no comparable event in Europe since the Hitler era. According to Putin’s latest declarations, Ukraine has no right to exist as a sovereign state – even though it is a member of the United Nations, the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe, and the Council of Europe; and even though Russia itself (under Boris Yeltsin) has recognised the country’s independence.

Putin now claims that Ukraine is an inseparable part of Russia. Whatever the majority of Ukrainians think is irrelevant to him; Russia’s greatness and international standing are all that matter. But make no mistake: Putin wants more than Ukraine. His war is about the entire European system, which rests above all on the inviolability of borders. In seeking to redraw the map by force, he hopes to reverse the European project and re-establish Russia as the pre-eminent power, at least in eastern Europe. The humiliations of the 1990s are to be erased, with Russia once again becoming a global power, on par with the US and China.

According to Putin, Ukraine has no tradition of statehood and has become a mere tool of US and Nato expansionism, thus posing a threat to Russia’s security. In a bizarre speech the day before his troops stormed across the border, Putin even went so far as to claim that Ukraine is trying to acquire nuclear weapons. In fact, when the Soviet Union collapsed in the early 1990s, Ukraine – home to the world’s third-largest nuclear arsenal at the time – surrendered its nuclear weapons to Russia with the active diplomatic support of the “evil” US.

Ukraine did so because it had received “guarantees” of its territorial integrity, as stated in the Budapest Memorandum on Security Assurances of 5 December 1994. That document was signed by the guarantor powers: the US, the UK and Russia, alongside Ukraine, Belarus, and Kazakhstan (the latter two relinquished the smaller nuclear arsenals they had inherited from the USSR).

Set against the historical facts, Putin’s statements are nonsense. His primary purpose, clearly, is to give his own population a justification for invading Ukraine. Putin knows that if ordinary Russians were given a choice between a war to dominate Eastern Europe and a better, more prosperous life at home, they would prefer the latter. As so often in Russian history, the country’s people are having their future stolen by their rulers.

Russia’s ascent to global power in the 19th and 20th centuries resulted in numerous tragedies not only for the neighbours it subjugated and gradually absorbed, but also for its own people. China’s current leaders, in particular, should be mindful of this history, considering that imperial Russia seized more territory from China than from anyone else.

What Putin does not seem to realise is that Russia’s longstanding policy of dominating foreign peoples in its sphere of influence makes other countries focus on how to escape the Kremlin’s geopolitical prison at the first opportunity, by securing protection from Nato. The alliance’s eastward expansion after 1989 attests to this dynamic. Ukraine wants to join Nato not because Nato intends to attack Russia, but because Russia increasingly demonstrated its intention to attack Ukraine. And now it has.

It is worth remembering that in the 1990s, Russian propaganda accused the West of harbouring all manner of evil plans. None of these plots was realised at the time, when Russia was down, because no such Western scheme ever existed. The accusations were fearmongering nonsense.

The Russian imperial project has always been characterised by a mixture of domestic poverty, brutal oppression, florid paranoia, and aspirations of global power. And yet, it has proved to be exceptionally resistant to modernisation – not just under the czars and then under Lenin and Stalin, but also under Putin.

Just compare Russia’s economy to China’s. Both are authoritarian systems, yet Chinese per capita incomes have grown robustly while Russian standards of living have been declining. In historical terms, Putin is taking Russia hurtling back towards the 19th century, in search of past greatness, whereas China is forging ahead to become the defining superpower of the 21st century. While China has achieved unprecedentedly rapid economic and technological modernisation, Putin has been pouring Russia’s energy-export revenues into the military, once again cheating the Russian people out of their future.

Ukraine has tried to escape this never-ending cycle of poverty, oppression, and imperial ambition with its increasingly pronounced orientation toward Europe. A well-functioning European-style liberal democracy in Ukraine would jeopardise Putin’s authoritarian rule. The Russian people would ask themselves and their leaders, “Why not us?”

Putin would have no good answer to give them, and he knows it. That is why Russia is in Ukraine today. DM/BM

Copyright: Project Syndicate, 2022.

www.project-syndicate.org

 

Gallery

Comments - share your knowledge and experience

Please note you must be a Maverick Insider to comment. Sign up here or sign in if you are already an Insider.

Everybody has an opinion but not everyone has the knowledge and the experience to contribute meaningfully to a discussion. That’s what we want from our members. Help us learn with your expertise and insights on articles that we publish. We encourage different, respectful viewpoints to further our understanding of the world. View our comments policy here.

All Comments 8

  • If the world thought they has seen the last of Lenin and Stalin … this should tell you they are re-incarnated ! To think that Leo Tolstoy came from the same region … but it does confirm the theory that the one without the other does not exist – good and evil.

  • What is happening in the Ukraine today is exactly what repeats without end in the history of Russia. Read the story of a small village in Russia parallel to the story of Russia over 1500 years or so. Read the book “Russka” by Edward Rutherfurd.

  • Putin’s argument that Russia is threatened by NATO is rubbish. Nato is a defensive grouping of nations which believe in democracy rather than authoritarianism. The smaller Eastern European nations want NATO’s ‘All for one; one for all’ philosophy to protect them from megalomaniacs such as Putin.

  • How easily entire countries are mesmerised into following one person toward death, carnage and destruction. Putin’s sword will return to him, his family and his nation, with interest. So sad and unnecessary.

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted