Defend Truth


No, Gwede Mantashe, State Capture cannot be classified as a mere series of mistakes, nor is it a tool for rebuilding the ANC


Mkhuleko Hlengwa MP is the IFP national spokesperson. @MkhulekoHlengwa

The ruling elite appears hell-bent on watering down the realities of State Capture. This reductionism of facts and realities came to the fore when the national chairperson of the ANC, Gwede Mantashe, dared to refer to the actions of State Capture as ‘mistakes’.

At the heart of South Africa’s trajectory towards the failure and collapse of the state is the delusional arrogance that accompanies the trappings of power. This arrogance has seen the ruling elite drift further and further away from the principles of reality, honesty and accountability.

They myopically take for granted their soft lives, away from the representations of the daily societal realities of the destitute majority. It is in that moment, when they are immersed in their delusions of grandeur, that socioeconomic inequalities and a trust deficit find traction.

Simply put, the ruling party elite is out of touch with the actual realities of the majority.

The release of part one of the report by the Zondo Commission was bound to set the cat among the pigeons. Those who are implicated directly and indirectly have already started to engineer all manner of spin and obfuscation in their misinterpretations of the report. Some opined authoritatively on the report without even bothering to read all 874 pages.

Like politics or journalism, justice is ideological, therefore, facts notwithstanding, both subjective and objective, any interpretation of the report is dependent on one’s vantage point and politics.

While differences exist, the one indisputable conclusion is that there is consensus, anchored in the words of Marcellus in Shakespeare’s Hamlet, that “something is rotten in the state of (South Africa)”.

If one is truly honest, it is this acknowledgment of rot that must be the basis for turning things around. Tragically, it appears that South Africa is far from this reality of the existence of rot because of the ruling party’s elite group and its “party first and the country later” mentality.

The ruling elite appears hell-bent on watering down the realities of State Capture and the associated consequences. This reckless and irresponsible reductionism of facts and realities came to the fore recently when the national chairperson of the ruling party, Gwede Mantashe, dared to refer to the actions of State Capture as “mistakes”.

One is compelled to remind the nation that, like cheating, State Capture and the many corrupt activities that enabled it, comprised a series of thuggish actions, not mistakes.

These were the actions that Mantashe and the ruling party elite were hellbent on defending and protecting. Each time these thuggish actions were questioned in Parliament and elsewhere, we were strongly shot down.

State Capture became a decision of the ANC the moment its leadership and rank and file chose to defend it. It became a deliberate course of action.

As a nation, we must not be swayed by platitudes and cheap political spin which seeks to dismiss the gravity of State Capture as a “mistake”. Simply put, State Capture is not a political ANC problem. It is a problem for South Africa, caused by the ANC and its elite group.

State Capture and poor governance have irrevocably damaged our country. The trail of destruction deepened mass poverty, underdevelopment, inequality and unemployment. To remove the rot, we must prosecute and instil consequence management in line with the laws of this country.

What we need is not a political discussion but law enforcement. There could never be an excuse for less, as we now have clear evidence before us, gathered by a team of experts, laying bare the plundering of hundreds of billions of rands.

It is precisely for this reason that the Zondo Report must be used for the renewal, revival, and strengthening of the country and its institutions.

With all due respect, Mr Mantashe is suspiciously disingenuous to call for the Zondo Report to be used for the renewal of the ANC, and for the report to be “dealt with institutionally”.

The Zondo Commission was not an ANC mandate or ANC-funded endeavour. The taxpayer footed a hefty bill for the report to come to life. Reducing it to a mere tool to assist the ailing ANC to self-correct is an insult to those whose lives have been robbed by the criminals in the black, green and gold T-shirts.

The ruling party might hold the majority in Parliament, but it needs to be reminded of the dividing line between party and state. Its internal processes cannot – and must not – take precedence over state and law enforcement processes.

Mr Mantashe’s outlook, consistent with the “party first” mentality, seeks to water down the extent and impact of the damage caused by the capture of state on South Africans. It presupposes that a renewed and healthy ANC means a renewed and healthy South Africa.

This belief is devoid of truth and reality, and this was reflected in the recent 2021 November polls. South Africans showed us the kind of renewal and health of South Africa they need when they did not vote for the ANC.

Worth noting is that the ANC mentality of “collective responsibility” is precisely why this country is in a state of chaos. It creates a defence laager along party lines, at the expense of the national interest. As politicians, it is the interests of the people that must always be our guiding light – not the interests of the party.

The response of the ruling party’s chairperson to the Zondo Commission clearly indicates that the ANC has failed the test of constitutionalism, democracy and patriotism. Its default position of defending its criminal members is full of thuggish excuses to evade accountability, while continuing to steal from our people.

President Cyril Ramaphosa, the report was handed over to you in your capacity as head of state, not the head of the ANC, and accordingly, we, the people of South Africa, demand that those implicated face the full might of the law.

We demand that if you as the President are also implicated, you too lead by example, and face the might of the law.

We demand accountability from those who have stolen the precious resources meant for the people of South Africa. The people of South Africa demand that the recommendations in the report be actioned and actioned swiftly.

The announcements by the National Prosecuting Authority on mechanisms to be set up to process the report must be implemented without delay.

Mr President, it is now up to you to prove to the people who placed their trust in you to serve the interests of the country – and not your party – that they did not make a mistake. DM


Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • Sandra Goldberg says:

    Congratulations Mr Hlengwa on an excellent and hard hitting article!It is of course infuriating to hear of the criminal excesses of the ANC being dismissed as “ mistakes” just as President Ramaphosa talks of “lapses”. ! As the Party always talks about collective responsibility, maybe in this case then, since the facts of malfeasance appear to be clear, the party as a whole should be prosecuted, not individuals, and finally face the might of the law! The cowardly hiding behind collective responsibility would be ended in one mighty swipe!

    • Coen Gous says:

      Fully agree Sandra. This is indeed a brilliant article by the IFP’s Mr. Hlengwa. It would have been so very different in this country if we have had more politicians of his calibre.

  • Hulme Scholes says:

    “What we need is not a political discussion but law enforcement”.


  • Joe Soap says:

    Gwede was originally charged with the ANC’s internal investigation into state capture. He was given only one report and could find nothing like that. 4 years and R 1 billion later, we have a report even bigger than Gwede. How hard did you look Mr Mantashe?

    It is disgusting enough that it cost the taxpayer R 1 billion to extract from the ANC exactly how they organised their theft from all South Africans. Of course, they should have confessed for free, but they are just not those sort of people. Rather the party is led by people like Gwede and Lindiwe. The branches on the ground vote in people like Ace. This is not the sort of organisation that should be running any country. Just like dangerous animals get housed in glass enclosures for the publics viewing pleasure, the ANC needs to be housed in jails, where we can all look at them and point them out to our children and can say, see that sewage flowing down the road, those are the people that caused it, but you are safe now.

    • Charles Parr says:

      The cost will be way higher than a ere R1 billion by the time the taxpayer has paid to get the NPA fit for purpose and then the endless court cases will carry on until all the accused are no longer alive and then surprise, surprise, zilch will happen and funds won’t even be recovered. This is all just a game while the looting continues and the results are oh so predictable.

  • Wim Krynauw says:

    Beautifully written. Compliments to the author

  • Ludovici DIVES says:

    Excellent article and comments. So many truths. Many thanks.
    The ANC is a criminal organisation and must be shut down for the good of the country.

  • A.K.A. Fred says:

    An excellent response by Mkhuleko Hlengwa to the dangerous drivel spewed out by Mantashe. We need to be extra vigilant and extra vocal to knock down self serving politicians or implicated persons who dare to shift the focus or dilute the findings of the taxpayer’s Zondo report. And we need to relentlessly keep doing this until we see the necessary prosecutions. Don’t allow implicated people to drive the narrative

  • Ger pig says:

    Well said! Good luck on any concrete action though

  • Johan Buys says:

    Can’t wait to hear how the “mistake” excuse goes down when SARS comes knocking.

  • Rory Macnamara says:

    well if the State Capture was “mistakes,” the ANC still has not learnt from from its mistakes.
    Intelligent people learn from their mistakes, fools keep on repeating them!
    Perhaps Cabinet Ministers should be banned from making statements – all they do is talk rubbish!

  • Rg Bolleurs says:

    They’re not mistakes, they’re blunders. And just about every policy decision the ANC takes is a blunder.

    It’s no accident we have the world’s highest unemployment rate.

  • R S says:

    “As a nation, we must not be swayed by platitudes and cheap political spin which seeks to dismiss the gravity of State Capture as a “mistake”. Simply put, State Capture is not a political ANC problem. It is a problem for South Africa, caused by the ANC and its elite group.”

    Amen. People seem to have forgotten so quickly that in the early days, Cyril, Pravin, and ALL of the ANC rallied around Zuma to protect him. Everyone else but the ANC seemed to know what was going on, or that they knew what was going on and tried to fix it from within the party (look where that got us), or, more honestly, they probably just didn’t care.

  • Bruce Q says:

    This should become the clarion call of our nation.

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted

Become a Maverick Insider

This could have been a paywall

On another site this would have been a paywall. Maverick Insider keeps our content free for all.

Become an Insider
Elections24 Newsletter Banner

On May 29 2024, South Africans will make their mark in another way.

Get your exclusive, in-depth Election 2024 newsletter curated by Ferial Haffajee delivered straight to your inbox.