Dailymaverick logo

Maverick News

TRAINSPOTTER

Let's not call these Afrikaners refugees — they’re background extras in Maga’s noisy scam

Bathing these Boers in the language of victimhood, Trump has fast-tracked their exodus through an executive order and welcomed them in.
Becs-amerikaners Illustrative image | Newly arrived Afrikaner 'refugees' in the US. (Photo: Chip Somodevilla / Getty Images) | Statue of Liberty silhouette and US flag. (Photo: iStock) | Asylum seekers. (Photo: iStock)

Let’s just say it wasn’t your typical refugee exodus.

One of the dubious perks of 21st-century journalism is reporting on the profusion of migrant camps and settlements pocked across the world. According to the UN, almost 304 million humans are on the run from the horrors of a decaying planet — be it the unkindness of their neighbours, the caprice of their rulers, or the fury of the weather itself.

I’ve seen people inhabiting white tents in DRC, in CAR, in Syria, in South Sudan, in Ethiopia, in Afghanistan and, once or twice, here at home — in filthy church basements, where they hide from the violence of this country, the wounds on their flesh and in their minds suppurating slowly in front of the cameras.

One thing that all these disparate people have in common? A distinct lack of luggage.

On Sunday evening, at Johannesburg’s OR Tambo International airport, a cluster of 50 or so Afrikaners (and their bags) were spirited on to an aircraft chartered by the United States government. These were the first in a tranche of local white, supposedly farmers granted refugee status by the Trump regime, who allege that this minority is targeted for persecution by the South African state.

Worse, the local government, insist the Americans, is a ghastly amalgam of DEI initiatives, intersectional politics, wokeness and anti-white racism. Bathing these Boers in the language of victimhood, Trump has fast-tracked their exodus through an executive order and welcomed them in. Others in need have been told not to bother. They are the anointed. The blessed.

And they are just the beginning.

***

Make no mistake: South Africa is a violent place. The bloodshed comes suddenly, its viciousness often prompted by ancient rage and loathings. The aftermath, for those of us who have witnessed it, resembles nothing more than the floor of a butcher shop. It comes first for the vulnerable: children and women. Next, it comes for men, most often at each other’s hands. The statistics are widely available: a disproportionate number of the victims are black and poor. The rule is simple: The less you have, the more harm you will suffer.

Read more: Trump’s Afrikaner refugees — the search for white victims

This country is steeped in war-making. Its short modern history is little more than a tale of territorial scuffles, culminating in decades of racially defined land grabs. The government of the democratic dispensation, itself birthed in bloodshed, adopted the tenets of liberalisation so enthusiastically that it ceded the state’s monopoly of violence to millions of aspirants. The cops stand by while vigilante groups police the townships, or they scrape away the corpses of those killed by private security groups in wealthy neighbourhoods.

In South Africa, anyone can play a cop.

So it goes.

But what the state has not done is single out a minority group for violent persecution. To allege as much — to even suggest that the government has targeted white Afrikaners — is an unforgivable libel. The game is obvious: to invert the harms visited on black South Africans during apartheid, and to claim the mantle of righteous victimhood for themselves. In this narrative, the real victims of South African history are those families awaiting their chartered flight to the United States.

White Afrikaans South Africans.

To be sure, life is hard for everyone. It is demonstrably, statistically and economically less hard for whites in this country. That being said, we cannot know, at this point, what the faux refugee families have suffered. No doubt some among them have stories that would sear the soul.

But what we do know is that they are just a handful among 304 million who have packed up their belongings and looked for safety and opportunity elsewhere. No other group on Earth can claim such preferential treatment from the richest and most powerful country in human history. Their lobby groups whined on X, and six months later they were on a private plane to the US.

If this isn’t wildly extraordinary privilege, I don’t know what is.

Afrikaans culture is rich and beautiful and rambunctious. At its worst, however, it is shot through with a woe-is-me messianic streak that does no one any favours. Whether they know it or not, the people who boarded that chartered flight are props in a grand performance of white supremacy, conducted by the president of the United States and his henchfolk.

Read more: Scant sympathy for ‘plight’ of Afrikaner ‘refugees’ at SA’s premier farm show

Trump just accepted a free 747 jet from the Qatari royal family, and as his regime endeavours to mimic the worst of the Third World kleptocrats, he makes Mobutu Sese Seko seem modest by comparison. (He makes Jacob Zuma look like a priest.)

Fresh white refugees are nothing more than cogs in the distraction machine. The idiocies of US-style progressivism, with its hierarchies of victimhood, have been adopted by Trump’s Maga movement. White men now stand at the very tippy-top of the intersectional grievance chart. This would be embarrassing if it weren’t so hilarious. The white “refugees” who slunk on to that private plane and left a country where their rights were protected by a Constitution, are on their way to another violent place, steeped in racial hatreds. What really bothers their lobbyists is not that they have the same rights as their neighbours. It’s that they don’t have more rights.

Under Trump, they will have more rights. The Boers are moving to an America in which the president insists that it’s time to take back the country from hordes of dusky marauders and Mexican berry pickers. Blacks and other minorities were canned from government positions, and it’s now DEI for drunks with Nazi tattoos. In the background, Trump and his family strip-mine the state of everything that’s not nailed down, while making sure that they flood the zone with a constant stream of shit.

And don’t fool yourself — what Trump and his lackeys, several of whom are ex-South Africans, are trying to build is apartheid. That’s the aim. So it stands to reason that these Afrikaners will feel right at home.

Read more: Ramaphosa calls Afrikaans ‘refugee’ trek to US a ‘cowardly act’ at Nampo agricultural show

They’ve not moved through geography, but through time — backwards to the Valhalla they lost when apartheid hit the skids.

The louder they bitch, the closer they come to the promised land. But let’s not call them refugees. They’re background extras in Maga’s noisy scam. They’re tools. They’re the sum total of the colour of their skins. DM

Comments

Martin Neethling May 14, 2025, 06:07 AM

It’s misleading to state that amongst SA’s many evils, singling out a minority group for violent persecution is not one of them. Reject the ‘genocide’ trope’ sure, or mull the meaning of ‘persecution’, but this Afrikaner group is targeted. Songs about killing them is legitimate. Taking their right to teach their kids in Afrikaans is fine. Passing a law that allows a farm to be stolen by the State is redress. Farm murders are ‘just crime’. The facts say they are targeted.

District Six May 14, 2025, 09:54 AM

This is how one mangles reality. Suitably trumpian. No facts whatsoever - zero, nil, nada, say white farmers are targets. Facts say black poor males rank highest amongst the murdered.

Jubilee 1516 May 14, 2025, 02:07 PM

Stats per 100 000 murders are available. With names, times, MO of the attackers etc? As you say, black poor males rank number 1. Question is, who murders these black folks, and the farmers? Does the president and ConCourt approve of songs advocating the genocide of black folk? Do the government lie about the stats of black people being murdered, as Mchunu was caught out doing re farm murders, after HE challenged Afriforum on the stats?Understating it by 90%. So, no, your argument is false.

Paul T May 14, 2025, 06:18 AM

Brilliant unmasking of the Trump agenda. Embarrassing for the "refugees" who unwittingly became his tools.

Daniel Cohen May 14, 2025, 06:23 AM

Exactly right

David van der Want May 14, 2025, 06:49 AM

Pithy and trenchant as usual RP. A thought experiment.

Willem Boshoff May 14, 2025, 07:01 AM

Has anyone interviewed the "refugees" and asked about their reasons for leaving? Anyone know their individual stories? At least get the facts and then address the issues. Or am I expecting too much from the media?

Rod MacLeod May 14, 2025, 07:47 AM

To continue - "White Afrikaans South Africans" who are "shot through with a woe-is-me messianic streak" and are "props in a grand performance of white supremacy". And then "Fresh white refugees are nothing more than cogs in the distraction machine" and "White men now stand at the very tippy-top of the intersectional grievance chart" and "The Boers are moving to an America". Shame on you Poplak and shame on DM for publishing this.

Christopher Bedford May 15, 2025, 11:50 AM

Shame on you Mr MacLeod for taking issue with facts. All those statements you put in quotation marks are legit interpretations of writing and speech readily obtainable in the media over the last few decades, and in particular in the US during the MAGA era.

megapode May 14, 2025, 08:58 AM

These people refer to themselves as boers. It's not a perjorative label, they are not reclaiming the term as black people did with the N-word. They need a word to differentiate themselves from "white" or even "afrikaner". You see it's not whites in general who are at risk, it's BOERs. They need to build an exclusive case for themselves to fight the statistics that show that whites are better off in every measurable way. There are no statistics for "boer", except maybe inside Afriforum.

District Six May 14, 2025, 09:58 AM

Willem, we know why they're leaving. They got a free pass, again, on the basis of being white. This is literally what trump offered them: "White victims". Two words explains it all.

Willem Boshoff May 14, 2025, 11:23 AM

That's not the point, but I agree, Trump's game is obvious. Commentators in general don't know the "refugees'" personal experience. Why is it so hard to separate the issues, to not descend into stereotypes and try and understand all the facts of the matter? The media is in the forefront. This whole debacle is Trumpian in it's divisiveness and one-sidedness.

Penny Philip May 14, 2025, 01:40 PM

The reason the Afrikaaner 'refugee's' personal experience is irrelevant is because regardless of whatever has happened to them, something similar will have undoubtably also happened to some other South Africans of all racial groups. Crime doesn't respect race.

Willem Boshoff May 14, 2025, 03:13 PM

It's not that simple. I met a farmer; 50+ instances of theft & 2 armed robberies in ONE year on his farm in MP. SAPS don't investigate, even when perps are known. His reality is that the govt (SAPS) conspires with criminals via neglect to force him off "stolen land"; expropriation by crime. That's one instance and certainly not true of SA, but the individual's experience is no less valid. The US's race play here is obvious; but the media vitriol against Afrikaners is also shameful.

Justin Vickers May 14, 2025, 11:59 AM

The US has not allowed/instructed any of the 'refugees' to be interviewed. Which is telling in itself.

Allergic-to-ignorance - May 14, 2025, 03:44 PM

You certainly are expecting too much Willem. This article is not about Afrikaners in South Africa or their reasons for wanting to depart our sunny shores. It's just Richard's irrational hatred for Trump, the person, being disguised as a "thought piece", as he's trying to "enlighten" the rest of us blind folk...

kanu sukha May 15, 2025, 12:55 AM

Why hide behind the pseudonym ? A good cue of the 'ignorance' you are apparently allergic to ? Sounds more like "irrational hatred for Trump " the unethical moron who was found by more than one US court, to be a criminal, but managed to avoid jail time, by running for 'president'. Just ask yourself why his attorneys will/do not allow him to 'speak' at his trails ? So much for 'enlightenment'. Well articulated Richard !

Allergic-to-ignorance - May 15, 2025, 11:29 AM

A couple of comments Kanu: - Ignorance often means that one deems their view to be the correct one, showing little regard for alternative views. Most of your comments on this article suggest that you seem to think the rest of us "just don't get it", while you do. What conclusion shall we draw from that? - I think Trump is a narcissist, a manipulator and generally a very broken human being - However, unlike you, I can ringfence my feelings for him and not insert them into other discussions

beecee.macpherson May 14, 2025, 07:29 AM

Those 50 - odd white Afrikaners have fled the land of their birth in search of a future free of discrimination. Call them refugees - or anything you like. Whatever you call them will not change the discrimination they have faced in South Africa.

Jennifer Hughes May 14, 2025, 07:39 AM

Excellent article. You said all the things I was thinking, only much better. My heart aches for the millions of true refugees, and I am ashamed that my country is being ensnared in Trump's scams and propaganda.

kanu sukha May 15, 2025, 01:01 AM

More than one court and jury in the US found him guilty of being a scam (con) artist, who has also managed to fool huge proportions of Americans in believing he is some sort of 'genius' .

Jubilee 1516 May 14, 2025, 07:49 AM

Hateful article. If a child is born in a white squatter camp, and still has to achieve about 10% more in Matric than a privileged black child of a billionaire to gain access to studying, say Medicine, and if a country's president and Apex court approves songs advocating the genocide of that child's people, and there is a very active campaign by government to destroy that child's Mother Tongue, once the number 1 language of tech and science in Africa, that child is a refugee.

Paul Hjul May 14, 2025, 09:46 AM

How many of the 49 individuals resided at any time in their life in a "white squatter camp"? Make no mistake there is a crisis of grinding poverty amongst individuals who are white, some of whom are also Afrikaans speaking. If you could show that immigration of a segment of an impoverished population would result in escaping poverty the I'd be the first to support a scheme that promotes as much. Except that Zimbabweans can escape poverty but neither SA nor the US allow them the refugee label

Gerrie Pretorius May 14, 2025, 02:16 PM

Well said! Many have experienced exactly that racism against whites. Be they Afrikaans or not.

Michael Bowes May 14, 2025, 07:56 AM

Just about anything Trump is at least dubious...but hey! if it works for them, wish them well on their way. South Africa has become a violent society, farmers tend to live in isolation, and the police are useless or worse. Anybody see that changing anytime soon? (I think they'll be finding that it's not the promised land, but they're Boers aren't they? They'll make a plan... yes?)

Anne van Vliet May 14, 2025, 12:28 PM

100% agree

Balekatou May 14, 2025, 08:02 AM

Is the Slow War not slow enough for you, Mr Poplak? Don't you see the bigger picture? Why did some ANC leaders went into exile voluntarily in the 60's. Wasn't that also seen as refugees? The sum total of legal discrimination against Whites, 144 acts to be specific, and the hypocritical application of race laws by the judiciary, Farm Murders, Expropriation without compensation etc. You just can't see the big picture and the motivation behind these laws, do you? Look wider than the SABC news

megapode May 14, 2025, 10:15 AM

Those ANC leaders were being actively oppressed by their government. They had no franchise, had many restrictions on where they could, where they could own property, had made many attempts to initiate reform peacefully and were rebuffed at every turn. There was a very high chance that they would be imprisoned, possibly worse. We can argue about the number of laws (one law may have wider implications than a dozen others), but the so-called persecuted in this country now are not in the same boat.

kanu sukha May 15, 2025, 01:05 AM

His "look wider than the SABC news" suggests he liked the SABC when it was used as a 'tool' by the apartheid regime.

Allergic-to-ignorance - May 15, 2025, 11:35 AM

Kanu, any additional tools in your debate arsenal other than the "you like apartheid" card?

megapode May 14, 2025, 10:17 AM

Those ANC leaders were being actively oppressed by their government. They had no franchise, had many restrictions on their movements, where they could own property, had made many attempts to initiate reform peacefully and were rebuffed at every turn. There was a very high chance that they would be imprisoned, possibly worse. We can argue about the number of laws (one law may have wider implications than a dozen others), but the so-called persecuted in this country now are not in the same boat.

Richard Bryant May 14, 2025, 08:09 AM

Imagine if trump were to try that stunt with the Uyghurs in China, or opposition in Myanmar. Or minority groups in Sudan. Or anybody who dares to stand up to putin in Russia. People who are being targeted murdered and detained in their own countries. The fact that trump’s fanfare airplane was given landing rights highlights the freedom we actually enjoy. One thing I know is that our Afrikaaners have a rich culture and pride and will feel deeply offended by this rascist stunt in their name.

Johann.mull May 14, 2025, 08:17 AM

Jy is reg Richard. I am a white Afrikaans speaking individual. I cannot identify with these people. My travels shown that the privilege non-blacks have in South Africa is unparallelled because of historical reasons. The ANC has been unable to address the real issues to address this which is quality education and economic growth, which will up lift more people. These "refugees" are going to realize that equality is much worse than their so-called persecution in SA. They are being played.

Willem Boshoff May 14, 2025, 08:47 AM

I read a headline this morn - the first I've seen of any of the "refugees" being interviewed. It's a middle aged lady that said she survived 4 attacks. I assume you can't identify with that either. (ps: I'm not saying it's grounds for refugee status, but people's experiences matter).

Dillon Birns May 15, 2025, 09:33 AM

Willem, your defence of these "refugees" is admirable — individual experiences do matter. If I were a victim of violent crime, I’d also seek escape. But they’re 50 out of 8,000 applications. So, the question is: Do the experiences of a few outweigh the interests of the many? Is their exfil to the US worth perpetuating a lie of geopolitical proportions? Or should they continue to suffer (along with the many non-white South Africans) in the hope that we get our act together as a country?

Willem Boshoff May 16, 2025, 08:59 AM

You're asking good questions and I don't know the answers. I'm appalled by the way the US is playing this, but that's not the whole story. Solly Moeng had some excellent commentary on this. All that I ask is that all the facts and issues are considered. Too many privileged (white) people sitting in safe suburbs presume to judge those who live in perpetual fear on farms/ high-risk areas.

peterdncn May 14, 2025, 08:25 AM

Pure racism on Trump's part. If you want to discredit your cause get Trump's support. Special privileges for white immigrants. Darker ones deported. I wonder if these "refugees" will really get a better life in the USA. There is a problem here which the indignant supporters of the ANC/EFF establishment are ignoring. "Kill the boer kill the farmer" is regarded by our courts as not hate speech. The SAHRC is proud of its own double standards. White people are always guilty. If you are Black you are treated very leniently when you disparage and express hatred of White people. There are still about 140 laws justifying discrimination against White people, hopefully, addressing heritage imbalances but maybe not helping.

kanu sukha May 15, 2025, 01:16 AM

Aha .. that frequently repeated magical '140 race laws' makes your whole case so easy and even incontrovertible ! How many race laws did we have during apartheid rule ? Much fewer I am sure .. but which I assume, eventually got the UN to declare it a 'crime against humanity' .

Louise Wilkins May 19, 2025, 08:11 AM

You make the mistake, as so many do, of inferring that the awful actions of the aparheid years justify racial crimes against white Afrikaans people now. It might be tempting to feel like that, but to progress, revenge must make way for forward thinking.

D'Esprit Dan May 14, 2025, 08:27 AM

Stunning piece of writing and couldn't agree more!

Andrew Mckenzie May 14, 2025, 08:40 AM

Whatever you may think this would not be happening in a society where there is law and order.

May 14, 2025, 08:55 AM

Why don’t journos don’t talk to anyone more or do any investigations? Like many DM journos RP writes solely from his own world view and idealistic bias of how SA should be, not is. Did he speak to Afrikaners or farmers to get their view on how they feel in the “new”SA? Has he been robbed/assaulted and tried to get police support. Has he contacted US Bureau of Homeland Security to see what’s intended for this group? Otherwise just another “show-offy” piece of RP writing.

megapode May 14, 2025, 09:38 AM

I don't think this is meant to be reportage, telling us what happened. It's a person's view on what happened. We are welcome to agree or disagree, but it's unfair to pick on Poplak's lack of reporting when that's not really what he's doing. Though his starting point, that 50 odd people, mostly well fed and with lots of baggage, got a free plane ride to the USA and, it seems, a fast path to a green card because they have claimed that they are being persecuted is surely incontestable.

kanu sukha May 15, 2025, 01:24 AM

I guess they will all be employed by ex-SA Musk, richest man in the world, who 'recommended' these volk/folk to Trump's admin. That is .. if the DOGE policy (slash and burn first & ask questions later) is not in place in his empire !

May 14, 2025, 09:00 AM

And King Donald sits and condemns the millions of Latinos who are a major factor in America's ability to apply the skilled labour and hard work needed in mass production. Not only that, he deports them without any recourse despite many of them being naturalised US citizens. This group of Afrikaner "bitter eindes" have become another pawn in Trump's skewed policies. We'll watch their progress with interest. Many will probably progress back to SA.

Wilhelm van Rooyen May 14, 2025, 01:15 PM

Silly comment. It's only 50 odd people who will disappear in the USA

tokeloshe.smith1 May 14, 2025, 09:09 AM

All the more reason to boycott goods from USA

Freda Brodie May 14, 2025, 03:50 PM

At your own peril

v l May 14, 2025, 09:48 AM

Phenomenal, as usual.

Beyond Fedup May 14, 2025, 11:32 AM

Nothing but a vitriolic, shameful & vindictive piece of rubbish from Poplak. They have every right to feel aggrieved - SA is a mess thanks to the odious, corrupt, self-serving & predatory anc, who marginalise minorities. They could have built on what they inherited, like the Asian countries have done, but instead they have stolen, broken & destroyed all that their rapacious hands have touched under the guise of transformation. I say - the very best of luck to these people and wish you well!!

Louise Wilkins May 19, 2025, 08:13 AM

Agreed.

Greg Marcia May 14, 2025, 11:38 AM

In a Country where we should actively be trying to promote racial harmony,but who has had the Constitutional Court protect the right to sing Kill the Boer. I can understand the feelings of a Boer identifying person. We shoot ourselves in the foot by this in my view.

Jubilee 1516 May 14, 2025, 11:56 AM

Same Boerehaat on DM that caused SA's only true genocide, started by the Roberts declaration of 16 JUNE 1900 which was not as bad as the "Kill the boer" song approved by our president + Concourt. Whataboutism about other "more true"? refugees, victim blaming, will not change the incontestable fact childen will suffer racial oppression, race laws, BELA, university quotas in SA. Indeed. Seek freedom from this yoke in the USA. Boiled frogs you will not be.

kanu sukha May 15, 2025, 01:33 AM

Did you 'live' in apartheid SA ? How ?

John Kuhl May 14, 2025, 12:03 PM

POPLAP your view is ""wokeish"", abusive and so unitary. A large part of mankind sees things differently - keep your opinion to yourself . Have you experienced 2 close family incursions into your family space with 2 murdered direct family (85 yrs old) members kicked to death....I have. Wish you the same and then see how you feel and react.

Louise Wilkins May 19, 2025, 08:15 AM

I'm so sorry you experienced this.

Karl Sittlinger May 14, 2025, 01:11 PM

We can deride these 50 people for their choices & the Trump administration for their misinfo & racial divisiveness, but its the ANC that caused most of the issues we are facing now (since 2008 at least), so I question any of their ilk making any comments like CR calling them cowards from a position that can only be called extreme privilege, protecting actual criminals (sofa CR may be guilty to). Its actually sad that people feel so much fear they feel they need to leave.

Allergic-to-ignorance - May 14, 2025, 03:24 PM

CR calling them cowards.... That's the same coward who is terrified to make decision without consulting with another 50 incompetent cadres...

Pieter van de Venter May 14, 2025, 01:21 PM

Well Poplap, there is a woman from van Reenen in KZN, that left her guest farm behind to pack her backs for Trump's plane. She claims to have been attacked on her farm four times in the last 2 years. Surely not just wild nightmares??? So before you start singing the leftist songs, go and interview a few of them. Or maybe, interview some highly skilled Afrikaners that were fires because they were in a job on 27 April 1994.

magwazam May 14, 2025, 01:24 PM

Excellent piece. We're not the Soviet Union, People can leave any time, and if they can grift their way into America, that's up to them. However, the contrast between the savagery inflicted on the Palestinians (who are not being persecuted at all and are not eligible as refugees, per Trump and co.) and the relative privilege that these Afrikaans 'refugees' enjoy is mindboggling. Who's better off right now, the Palestinian in Khan Yunis or the Afrikaner in Klerksdorp?

Freda Brodie May 14, 2025, 03:43 PM

The subject at hand has nothing to do with Palestinians who use their family members as suicide bombers and use the women and children ’ as human shields. This is about Afrikaaner Boers being persecuted by African people, ie Anc, because they are white and allowing the Kill the Boer, kill the farmers, being sung and declared NOT hate speech. Many have been attacked & tortured & killed. White men are not allowed to get employed, unless self employed, and then forced to employ blacks.

t May 14, 2025, 06:52 PM

You should go too. Thanks and bye

Pieter van de Venter May 14, 2025, 01:25 PM

Obviously Poplap is not noticing that the whole world is changing around them. The days of "shame, the poor downtrodden" is now replaced with the empire that is striking back. Maybe adapt or die Poplap!! Socialism, communism en leftists sentiments are on their way to the rubbish dump.

Gavrel A May 17, 2025, 02:16 PM

The ultimate victimhood: privileged well to do people, who still point at other non-white Afrikaners as outsiders, people that are extremely enraged with any right that is not coming their way, are suddenly victims. Put some political ideas around that, and it looks almost real, but basically signals a lack of self-knowledge. As for criminality, many people in the world suffer its results, not in the last place Americans.

Penny Philip May 14, 2025, 01:33 PM

It's a complete farce, motivated by a backward looking group of people who just cannot accept that they are no longer in charge of this country, & perpetrated by ignorant Americans who'll believe any racist line fed to them (without any verification).

David Crossley May 14, 2025, 02:16 PM

Just because Americans speak a sort of fractured, accented English does not hide the fact that as a people, they are light years away from the social structure of South Africans. I predict that this group will have a terrible time trying to adjust to their new country of domicile, as indeed many ordinary emigrants have done before them. Trump is the new Nightmare on Pennsylvania Avenue and it will only get worse. Great article, Richard.

Smudger Smiff May 14, 2025, 03:02 PM

Mr Poplak's piece is disgraceful. And full to the brim with lefty propaganda ad falsehoods. Those 'refugees' voting with their feet for a new life in the US is a terrible loss to SA.

greigdoveygd May 14, 2025, 07:00 PM

If DM endorses this article by Poplak I am cancelling my DM subscription. As a few people have already mentioned, no one has bothered to ask any one of the 49 Safas that accepted the offer to be accepted by the USA as refugees why they decided to uproot themselves and their families and leave SA. I can guarantee you that if the offer had been open to every single person in SA, irrespective of race, colour or creed, there would not be enough airplanes available to ferry the lot of them.

Allergic-to-ignorance - May 14, 2025, 09:24 PM

Greig, why would the author bother with talking to the families leaving SA? He may then find it harder to spew out bitter, pointless, pseudo-intellectual vitriol. This article is not about families leaving SA or whether they should be categorised as refugees. Poplak is burning up inside with hatred for Trump (who is in fact a narcissist) and this is just an excuse for him to vent and make himself feel important by showing us misguided peasants "how the world really works".

D Dog May 14, 2025, 08:33 PM

Call it what you will, this is just activism. If you don't make use of the ears willing to hear your voice, well then you'll get what's coming. Detractors and defenders of the status quo will use whataboutism to diminish the struggles that these people have gone through. I'm happy for them and wish them luck.

M. Venter May 15, 2025, 12:34 AM

I agree that these folks do not fit the decryption of a refugee, but what about economic refugees? To find employment in SA is DIFFICULT for everybody. If graduated Afrikaners go to the USA for a job?

kanu sukha May 15, 2025, 02:58 AM

Despite several efforts to poo poo your 'take' on things (some subtle others quite open or offensive) I enjoyed your analysis. Some people just don't 'get it' that more than one court and jury found Trump guilty of crimes (convicted fellon) and only the excuse of running for president saved him from serving jail time for his crimes. The guy in 'democratic' South Korea was not so lucky ! The gangster and his mob in the white house.

Rod MacLeod May 19, 2025, 08:38 AM

Good point Kanu - nobody knew about Trump's felonies until you managed to point them out, I'm sure. Perhaps you could do us a favour and draw up a list of charges that our own President and his esteemed cabinet OUGHT to be facing, but which they're not because, fortunately, they became President, Vice President and Cabinet Ministers, not through election, but through appointment by the majority party?

Sydney Kaye May 15, 2025, 02:14 PM

This bunch are props in a Trump stunt. They may well benfit or they may not, but it isn't about them. Trump siezed the opportunity ( having been introduced to whites claiming persecution) to demonstrate to his base that he is there to protect Christian Whites from the Others. They have had their 15 minutes and he has moved on. I'd be surprised if there will be another batch.

Lawrence Sisitka May 15, 2025, 02:48 PM

Thanks again Richard for a typically trenchant and accurate analysis. I would point all naysayers to the recent article in the UK Guardian newspaper by Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor: " The rise of end times fascism" and professor Klein's interview with Amy Goodman from Democracy Now. Scary reading and watching but a clear and enormously valuable meta-analysis of the rise of the far right. You have been warned...

Louis Fourie May 15, 2025, 04:28 PM

Trump het die hensoppers kom haal.