Dailymaverick logo

Maverick News

This article is more than a year old

BUDGET FALLOUT

‘You can’t hold the country ransom’ — Khumbudzo Ntshavheni claims DA’s Budget opposition is anti-poor

The minister in the presidency says the DA’s opposition to the Budget hinges on political issues such as the Expropriation Act.
Suné Payne
Minister Khumbudzo Ntshavheni at the post-Cabinet briefing at Parliament on 13 March 2025. (Photo Elmond Jiyane / GCIS)

Minister in the Presidency Khumbudzo Ntshavheni has claimed the DA’s opposition to the Budget speech was not about the VAT increases, but “about reversing the gains of transformation”. 

Ntshavheni briefed journalists in Cape Town on Thursday, 13 March 2025, one day after Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana tabled the Budget.

While most government of national unity (GNU) parties indicated they would support the Budget (with conditions for some), the second-largest party in the GNU said it would not.

Read more: Several GNU and opposition parties throw a spanner in the works for Godongwana

Ntshavheni described the DA’s opposition as anti-poor and anti-middle class.

“It’s about reversing the Expropriation Act… and it’s a pity that they’ve got the megaphones and the scribes who can make their voices very loud,” she said. 

“They’ve come out and said it themselves. It’s not me, it’s John Steenhuisen yesterday when he did a post-Budget interview to say their issue is with the Expropriation Act.”

During a News24 budget briefing on Thursday, Godongwana said the DA had tabled the issue of the Expropriation Act, which it opposes, during Budget negotiations, which the minister said was unrelated.

On Wednesday, just as Godongwana started speaking, Steenhuisen posted on X that his party was not in support of the Budget. 

While Steenhuisen had told journalists after the Budget speech that the DA was against the VAT hikes and any increase in taxes, it was willing to continue talking. The party had called for cutting inefficient spending and major reforms to grow the economy.

Steenhuisen had told Newzroom Afrika that the party made several concessions on several key issues and it was time other parties made similar concessions too. 

He said a deal might be put back on the table, but this included possible discussions and concessions around the contentious Expropriation Act. Steenhuisen described this as an “impediment to investment in SA” which could not be “divorced from the Budget”. 

Ntshavheni said about the DA: “You cannot hold the country ransom on the budget because you’ve got other political things to deal with.” 

Now, whether the Budget will be passed is up to parliamentary committees and eventually a vote in Parliament. 

Read more: What happens next for a contested Budget?

Touching on this, Ntshavheni said that, as required by legislation, the Budget had now been tabled.

“And as the speaker has announced, the National Assembly has referred the Budget to the various committees of the National Assembly to deliberate. 

“They must be given space to deliberate and scrutinise that Budget.”

Asked what would happen if the Budget were not passed before the new financial year, Ntshavheni said a clause in the Public Finance Management Act allowed funds to be drawn temporarily under the provisions of the previous Budget.

Later on Thursday, both the ANC and DA are expected to brief the media on their positions on the tabled Budget. DM

Join Daily Maverick’s webinar: The Budget Finally Lands: What you need to know

Comments

Loading your account…
Gary Kimber 13 March 2025 01:47 PM

The "Honourable" minister should step down and go directly to jail. Do not pass begin.

Louise Wilkins 13 March 2025 02:25 PM

Khumbudzo Ntshavheni needs to do a course in Economics.

Gary Kimber 13 March 2025 02:30 PM

And Ethics

Fanie Rajesh 14 March 2025 06:09 AM

Only when the ANC stop stealing and corruption will anything they say have any meaning or credibility. It is the ANC who holds our country and our people to ransom.

Mark Annett 13 March 2025 02:33 PM

Thats hilarious. Let's have a look at all the ways the ANC have uplifted the "poor"................?

Graeme 13 March 2025 03:13 PM

Uhm... I am trying to think of something... anything.

Graeme 13 March 2025 03:13 PM

Uhm... I am trying to think of something... anything.

Sheila Vrahimis 13 March 2025 08:18 PM

?

Marc Caldwell 13 March 2025 09:28 PM

I'm thinking ... hmm, the 10 million receiving the "temporary" Social Relief of Distress Grant? "Uplifting the poor" by trapping them in dependence that actually deepens the spiral of poverty but ... aha ... keeps them voting for the hand that feeds/impedes them!

Hidden Name 13 March 2025 02:41 PM

What a ridiculous woman. Seriously? After all the harm your party has caused, you want to play politics with the DA saying no to increasing taxes that WILL DIRECTLY HARM the most vulnerable? You are either an idiot, or you think we are. Be still - its time for adults to speak, not children.

John Cartwright 13 March 2025 02:58 PM

The DA bringing the land question into the budget debate is like introducing a new rule, favouring one side, in the middle of a game of rugby.

Karl Sittlinger 13 March 2025 06:07 PM

If it is true. From what has been reported, it was mainly about expenditure and corruption. You simply cannot believe the ANC on this.

Karl Sittlinger 13 March 2025 06:10 PM

Lies from a corrupt ANC cadre.

Vincent Bester 14 March 2025 06:30 AM

I think this is ANC spin. The DA is probably saying that they were not going to be caught off guard like BELA and EWC and were going to stand firm on VAT. Good for them.

D'Esprit 14 March 2025 09:15 AM

The DA has been clear from the start that they wouldn't sign off on a budget that increased VAT. Ntshavheni is using smokescreens and mirrors - probably the expensive ones she was 'gifted' as Mayor of Polokwane.

John P 13 March 2025 03:07 PM

The minister is exactly the kind of ANC deployee that is sucking money out of the Fiscus for zero return. Ditch them and how much extra do we have to uplift the poor?

Johan Steynvaart 13 March 2025 03:11 PM

Doublespeak is in style for those who cant solve real world problems.

Cape 13 March 2025 03:19 PM

Oh, how predictable that the ANC mandarins trot out these miserable scraps of dogma every time they encounter opposition. This ex-ruling party is so busy eating itself, it can't see there nothing left to chew on.

Gazeley 13 March 2025 03:22 PM

Let's look at the transformation gains, (1) Bankrupt national airline, massive job loss, (2) Failing Transnet & Prasa leading to no working national rail system, massive job loss (3) Failing harbours (4) Multiple failing municipalities (5) Eskom, Denel failures (6) Failing water & power supplies.

D'Esprit 14 March 2025 09:16 AM

I think the ANC is hugely relieved you only had 300 characters to post your list!

Mark Hammick 13 March 2025 03:54 PM

The ANC has held RSA to ransom and collected it big time with their cANCerous corruption.

Mike Lawrie 13 March 2025 03:57 PM

Next move, accuse the DA of treason.

Andrew Mckenzie 13 March 2025 04:08 PM

What on Earth is this minister talking about. She fails to advance any reasonable argument to support her claims.

Andrew Mckenzie 13 March 2025 04:08 PM

What on Earth is this minister talking about. She fails to advance any reasonable argument to support her claims.

D'Esprit 14 March 2025 09:18 AM

Yip, just dog-whistling the race card, it's the only thing the ANC has left, and even that's not working anymore.

Confucious Says 13 March 2025 04:09 PM

So the person accused of stealing from the State (and therefore its people) is now accusing the DA of rejecting a VAT increase for everyone. She is exactly what is wrong with the anc! And then deflection 101, hits the theme to transformation rubbish.

Fernando Moreira 13 March 2025 04:11 PM

Silly childish comments from the ANC ! The ANC really dont know ,that they dont know , its frightening !

Confucious Says 13 March 2025 04:13 PM

According to a news publication: ..."VAT increase spread over two years has already been rejected by the DA, the EFF, MK and Cosatu". However it is only the DA that is "anti-transformation"? What about the others? No, surely not... The public is not as stupid as the minister hopes!

Bob 13 March 2025 04:22 PM

The DA are actually opposing an act already given assent, namely the expropriation act. The other parties you name are not. Maybe that is why the DA are being singled out.

Karl Sittlinger 13 March 2025 08:34 PM

They are not opposing the entire act, just the part where you your property (any property) can be seized before having a court case. Currently the expropriation takes place and only then if you have the funds may you challenge this in the courts. Nowhere in the world this is the case.

Bob 14 March 2025 10:10 AM

I am not up on the details as you are. My point is that the DA's opposition is not clearly & solely about VAT and that is why they are being singled out. It's a bit unfair. The FF+ is probably similar, but as they're a small party nobody is going to waste time trying to make them look bad.

D'Esprit 14 March 2025 09:21 AM

They're rejecting the budget based on VAT: they have been very clear on this point. Expropriation, BELA, NHI etc are all going through the courts. It's the VAT, and as Confucious says (can't believe I wrote that), why not call the others out for being 'anti-transformation'?

Bob 14 March 2025 02:09 PM

Steenhuisen is quoted in this article as saying that the expropriation act cannot be divorced from the budget. He made the connection. DA are not objecting only on the basis of VAT.

D'Esprit 17 March 2025 07:20 AM

Yip, my bad - skimmed the article and missed that bit. I still think the DA is right though, that simply gouging more money from taxpayers whilst refusing to reform the economy and cutting wasteful spend is spot on: create jobs, you create taxpayers and people invested in the future.

Vincent Bester 15 March 2025 07:06 AM

This is typical ANC rhetoric. They can never argue on facts but always roll out the sad old communist dogma and dog whistle politics

Bob 13 March 2025 04:20 PM

They're sending out conflicting signals. I met the DA candidate for my ward yesterday. He had pamphlets saying the DA would fight any increase in VAT. There's a tweet saying DA cannot support the budget. Now they say it's about expropriation. They need to speak clearly: What are they opposing?

Slightly Irritated 13 March 2025 07:50 PM

Don’t think you are really Bob, maybe a bot perhaps.

Peter Oosthuizen 14 March 2025 08:21 AM

A bot calling the kettle black ? No need to hide behind a nom de plume...........

Jeremy Gabriel 13 March 2025 04:31 PM

This from a minister that has an R80 million corruption accusation dangling over her head. There’s no shame and no embarrassment.

Slightly Irritated 13 March 2025 07:50 PM

Dunning Kruger syndrome comes to mind.

Beyond Fedup 13 March 2025 04:46 PM

This dimwit minister along with all anc the ones, is completely clueless and too stupid to discern between the wood & the trees. All they can do is sprout tired old racist vitriol, lies & misinformation on any/everything that doesn’t suit their nefarious agenda & chronically limited intelligence.

Hilary Morris 13 March 2025 05:40 PM

This comment is so stereotyped and ridiculous it doesn't merit comment. Anti-poor? Anti wasteful expenditure and corruption, but anti poor just doesn't cut it.

Slightly Irritated 13 March 2025 07:46 PM

With a straight face, anti poor my dear is your cadres theft of taxpayers money that should be helping the poor. I think the word is Gaslighting.

Rod MacLeod 13 March 2025 11:39 PM

The ghosts of Denel and Guptagate lie buried in the Zondo report. These along with her embarrassing sojourn at SITA and the CR17 campaign have equipped her well to be able to comment on stealing from the poor. And they have also defined her interpretation of transformation.

Johan Herholdt 14 March 2025 08:54 AM

Agree!

Ian Gwilt 14 March 2025 05:06 AM

When is she being arrested ?

Vincent Bester 14 March 2025 06:27 AM

Rubbish! The budget is anti-ANC lootimg!

Vincent Bester 14 March 2025 06:34 AM

Correction to my previous comment. The DA’s position on the budget is anti-ANC looting.

Peter Oosthuizen 14 March 2025 08:26 AM

This, from someone who couldn't manage Polokwane's finances?

D'Esprit 14 March 2025 09:13 AM

Is R80m (and counting) in alleged corruption whilst she was a mayor, pro-poor? What a joke of a minister. Absolutely shameless, absolutely out of touch with reality, absolutely arrogant and absolutely ANC to the core.

Roodepoort Rocker 15 March 2025 06:25 AM

Absolutely clueless. Expecting people to live off R370 a month instead of creating a pro-employment enviroment?