Dailymaverick logo

Maverick News

This article is more than a year old

COLONEL BOGEY

Air force and army chiefs blasted for playing golf while SA soldiers die in DRC

SANDF reacts swiftly to criticism and cancels further celebrations of Air Force Week in the wake of the deaths of 13 SA soldiers in the DRC and the ongoing military crisis there.
Peter Fabricius
peterfab-Airforce golf -row SA Army chief Lieutenant General Lawrence Khulekani Mbatha (centre left) and SA Air Force chief Lieutenant General Wiseman Mbambo (centre right) during the golf day at Copperleaf golf course. (Photo: X)

The chiefs of the SA Army and SA Air Force are facing a storm of criticism for playing in a festive golf day this week — while South African soldiers have been dying in eastern Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC).

Air force generals and others participated in the golf day at the Copperleaf golf course in Gauteng on Tuesday as part of the celebrations of Air Force Week, an event organised by the chief of the SA Air Force, said Democratic Alliance spokesperson Chris Hattingh.

Posts on social media showed the SA Air Force chief, Lieutenant General Wiseman Mbambo, and the SA Army Chief, Lieutenant General Lawrence Mbatha, playing in the golf day. This triggered strong criticism, including calls for their resignation from members of the public.

Thirteen SANDF soldiers have been killed and several more injured over the last week in ferocious battles with the M23 rebel group, heavily backed by Rwanda, in eastern DRC.

“Tomorrow evening, the air force ball will take place, followed by more celebrations on Friday, including fly-overs and parades,” said Hattingh on Wednesday, calling on President Cyril Ramaphosa as commander-in-chief of the SANDF to cancel the celebrations “in light of the tragedy our military is enduring”.

Mbambo reacted to the criticism by cancelling the “Prestige Evening” (ball) on 30 January and the SAAF parade and flypasts on 31 January “due to the ongoing involvement of the military in the current situation in the DRC”. He said the events had been postponed until June.

Hattingh said Ramaphosa had abdicated his responsibilities by  remaining silent throughout the crisis, “failing to provide any leadership or support to the grieving families of our soldiers … and it is a disgrace.”

He said Ramaphosa was allowing a military festival to take place “at a time when our military is facing a catastrophic crisis… While our soldiers are risking their lives in a foreign conflict, senior officers are celebrating and enjoying festivities. High-ranking officers reportedly even travelled to the [golf] event in air force transport,” said Hattingh.

He urged Ramaphosa to address the nation about the DRC crisis.

The chiefs of the SA Air Force and SA Army used an SA Air Force helicopter to land on the golf course. (Photo: X)
An SA Air Force helicopter at Copperleaf golf course during the event. (Photo: X)

Darren Olivier, defence expert at the African Defence Review, said: “For the chiefs of the air force and army, the two services most directly connected with the fate of the beleaguered South African troops in the DRC, to be spending most of a day laughing and joking around a golf course while soldiers call desperately for support from home is beyond callous and tone-deaf.

“This is a moment where we needed the President, minister of defence, and the most senior military staff officers to stand up and show leadership, but they failed both that test and our soldiers.”

The SA Air Force (SAAF) said the Strategic Networking Golf Day was an annual event organised for the air force to engage with industry partners, business leaders and key stakeholders who had long supported the SAAF.

Beyond networking, the event played a critical role in supporting “the benevolent requirements of the South African Air Force”. The funds raised at the event would help support SAAF families in need, veterans and those who faced hardship.

The proceeds from the event would also help the SAAF to meet its broader social responsibilities through outreach programmes, environmental sustainability efforts or support for educational and healthcare initiatives.

It added that the chief of the SAAF, as host, was in attendance, accompanied by a reduced number of members of the SAAF’s Command Council. The air force chief was supported by the chiefs of the navy and army to “help pull resources and sponsors from all corners of the defence industry”.

It added that two helicopters were committed to the event: a BK117 which was utilised for static display from 8am to 10.30am, after which it was released and a Super Lynx helicopter which was utilised for a flypast at 10am to signal the start of the event.

Siphiwe Dlamini, the spokesperson for the SANDF, declined to comment on the row. DM

Comments

Loading your account…
Jim F. 30 January 2025 04:44 AM

Zero air support for the DRC troops but hey presto, 2 choppers fully available for a fun filled day for the chiefs. Maybe if the ANC had backed the right side in the Ukrainian conflict, our troops could have learned how to fight a modern war using cheap drones for air reconnaisance and offence.

louw.nic 30 January 2025 10:36 AM

We would be laughing, if it weren't so unbearably tragic.

evan ho 30 January 2025 03:14 PM

precisely. nothing more to be said.

Fanie Rajesh 31 January 2025 02:29 PM

I can only hope they're better at golf than they are at running our military.

jackt bloek 30 January 2025 11:42 AM

No western country has fought with ukraine and you want South African troops to go to ukraine

Jim F. 30 January 2025 04:45 PM

Nah, but they could benefit by being trained by Ukrainian troops. Besides air power provided by the drones, they have sunk a 1/3 of the Russian Black sea fleet despite the fact that they have no navy. This is the shape of modern warfare and drones in DRC would give our troops an absolute edge.

Fanie Rajesh 30 January 2025 05:38 PM

While it is of course terrible that 13 soldiers have been killed, I wryly note that daily SA murder stats as at 2024 show 69 people murdered daily.

Tothe Point 30 January 2025 08:54 PM

What are we doing there anyway? As for the golfers it yet again a case of all show and no go. This is why our defence force is a non-entity. Cyril threatens Rwanda with war. What a joke. With what resources? Only a few of our Air Force aircraft are serviceable. The ANC are like locusts. Destroy.

User 30 January 2025 05:31 AM

The SANDF is a sheltered employment agency not unlike the ANC national, provincial and local governments. So traditional norms assigned to entities like 'a defence force' fall away. These people pictured are not generals in any normal sense, so they can play as much golf as they like.

Sydney Kaye 30 January 2025 07:50 AM

Quite right. Just accept the fact that they do not have the capabilities, competence or intent to run the armed forces and no one in the ANC expects them to. It is just another centre for enployment, patronage, and corruption. My god, look at the Minister of Defence

User 30 January 2025 08:20 AM

Yes, what a laugh - Motsheka the Minister of Defence! After having played a useful finger-puppet to the Unions she colluded with in destroying generations of education in SA.

ttshililo2 30 January 2025 06:15 AM

Animal Farm.

n***s@g***.com 30 January 2025 06:25 AM

Regarding our soldiers in the DRC: This is not our circus, so why are we sending in our clowns?

Rod MacLeod 30 January 2025 06:49 AM

Well, it's a circus where certain cadre vested mining interests in DRC have to be protected from those pesky M23 Tutsi backed fighters. And the Tutsis remember 1994, which SA forgets - are those Congolese assets worth dying for?

Jacobus Strydom 30 January 2025 06:32 AM

Why am I not surprised. This behaviour is perfectly consistent with the ANC ideology of having the State as the primary actor in society merely to serve their self-appointed elite, and none of that Western nonsense to protect the lives, liberty and private property rights, of the country's citizens

Malcolm Dunkeld 30 January 2025 07:21 AM

That epitome of a modern Major General Angie Motshekga was in Goma when fighting broke out, and fled. How? Did she snaffle a SAAF plane that could have been used to get our wounded out? I doubt if the luxury private jets favoured by our ruling classes would have been willing to land in a war zone.

Malcolm McManus 30 January 2025 07:36 AM

Instead of a hole in one, we should put a hole in each one.

User 30 January 2025 08:21 AM

Nice. I love it!

D'Esprit 30 January 2025 09:15 AM

Hear hear!

D'Esprit 30 January 2025 09:19 AM

There was a stunning - in every sense - interview on 702 Drive yesterday by John Perlman with former Chief of Defence Intelligence at the SANDF, Lieutenant-General Mojo Motau. In it, Motau could barely contain his anger and derision at what the SANDF has become. Google it, if you have the stomach.

Heinrich Holt 30 January 2025 09:22 AM

And then call them Flag Officers.

Charles 30 January 2025 10:17 AM

That is certainly the most useful suggestion I've heard in a long time but let's get some more cadres there first.

Devin Norgarb 30 January 2025 11:06 AM

Brilliant. Well said.

chrisf.vz 30 January 2025 07:38 AM

I bet not one of these generals nor senior officers has been in battle. The closest they have been to a weapon is the one in their pants.

cracklin62 30 January 2025 09:18 AM

That weapon comes loaded with the added bonus of a child grant

Tothe Point 30 January 2025 09:06 PM

?The proper defence force (pre 1994) were lead by outstanding soldiers ie. Gen Jannie Geldenhuys. These wannabes of today, with a few exceptions, are embarrasing and an insult to our once proud reputation as a fighting force of note!

i***o@w***.com 30 January 2025 07:49 AM

What did we expect when former MK "soldiers" (yeah, right...) got promoted to exalted ranks, which were far in excess of their extremely limited abilities?

Tothe Point 30 January 2025 09:07 PM

100%

j***y@f***.co.za 3 February 2025 12:28 PM

You're right. A soldier is someone who fights other soldiers. Nobody in the MK fought other soldiers, they planted bombs in dustbins and threw grenades into civilian bars. They are more cowards than soldiers.

Grumpy Old Man 30 January 2025 08:06 AM

Generals, flying in on Choppers to tee off with Defence Force Contractors in branded golf shirts at Copperleaf Luxury Golf Estate whilst our Troops are dying off on a peace keeping mission in Goma for want of ammunition and air support. Remember the sunscreen Generals - it's very hot out there

Richard Kennard 30 January 2025 08:15 AM

Great shot General

D'Esprit 30 January 2025 08:23 AM

Absolute callous scum, there is literally no other way to describe these filthy thugs. They should be tried for treason along with the Defence Minister for lying through her teeth, and the ex-Defence Minister, now on charges of corruption, for dereliction of duty. Scum the lot of them.

Rae 30 January 2025 08:29 AM

C'mon people. Why so shocked and upset? These are ANC cadres and comrades. This is how their party expects them to fly the party colours. Soldiers dying in the DRC? Huh? Ours? Hmmm. See you at the 19th hole for drinks and jokes.

claudemaraisdevilliers 30 January 2025 08:32 AM

Playing on Copperleaf at great expence whilst the Military has it's own golf course in Pretoria where this could have been held at half the cost.

n***s@g***.com 30 January 2025 09:14 AM

Same principle as hiring Russian cargo planes to fly equipment and supplies to the DRC when we have our own planes to do the job. (Oh sorry, due to lack of maintenace they are not flying........)

Richard Kennard 30 January 2025 08:34 AM

Almost like a scene out of Catch 22. If I play I'll be damned, if I don't I'll also be damned as my handicap will be raised.

peter49 30 January 2025 08:37 AM

At least we have one chopper in working order and at least one pilot. What a relief.

Richard Kennard 30 January 2025 09:51 AM

Maybe reconnaissance soldiers can be used to find stray balls.

Fidelma of Cashel 30 January 2025 08:38 AM

Even at the best of times, blasting tax payers' money on golf days should raise questions about wasteful expenditure. But doing so against the backdrop of the casualties in DRC is revolting. The helicopter could have been put to better use than standing around on a golf course!

Jane Crankshaw 30 January 2025 08:51 AM

Fiddling whilst Rome burns - Nero woukd be proud!

Jane Crankshaw 30 January 2025 09:02 AM

Continuing BEE policies are at the heart of all the inadequacies South Africa faces, be it Municipal/Governmental/State Services. Until competent, honest and capable people, no matter their skin colour, are utilised the tax & ratepayers will continue to be marginalised and South Africa will fail.

Johan Buys 30 January 2025 09:06 AM

If just the 406 SANDF generals and admirals and civilian equivalents in DoD had a golf event they would need to spread it over several days. We must have THE most skewed ratios of senior staff to actual soldiers in the world!

s***g@n***.co.za 30 January 2025 12:39 PM

Very true indeed. As a significant taxpayer, I must ask ask what these largely tinpot generals and admirals actually do all day in a virtually non operational SANDF? Any ideas readers?

Tothe Point 30 January 2025 09:12 PM

Wait for their next bloated pay cheque!

L***s@g***.com 1 February 2025 09:20 AM

Why, they play golf of course! Got to practice to be in form for winning the best prizes in the golf days.

louw.nic 30 January 2025 03:04 PM

For comparison, in the USA, the total number of active duty general officers is capped at 231 for the Army, 62 for the Marine Corps, 198 for the Air Force, and 162 for the Navy (per wikipedia).

R***N@C***.CO.ZA 30 January 2025 09:49 AM

Seen pictures that claim to be from the South African base in the DRC. Looks like a pigsty. Would like to find out whether it is true. Also video's of incompetent soldiers. We need to find out what is going on there.

Tothe Point 30 January 2025 09:16 PM

They love drinking and sex Apparently rape is a favorite pastime

R***0@g***.com 30 January 2025 11:00 AM

Well at least consistency is on display, can't fault them for that. Funds were found to service one of our non serviceable helicopters . Couldn't be wasted on and sent to support our troops in the DRC. Needed for our golf day. Despicable are our wounded being treated yet, coming home when?

leslievminnen 30 January 2025 11:37 AM

As an ex SADF and SANDF member I hang my head in shame at these so-called leaders. None of them are half capable of being in the posts they hold. Every one are ANC appointments. Disgusting the lot. I will not even waste my time commenting on the Minister of Defense.

jackt bloek 30 January 2025 11:44 AM

DA should not have put this in the media and with this tone. You dont improve the country by insulting everybody. There are better ways of doing this. The public does not care , the DA will get almost zero votes from making this statement . DA should quietly send message what it expects of army

keith.ciorovich 30 January 2025 06:53 PM

So the truth hurts and we should keep quite to this shocking insensitivity and lack of leadership. I think not.

D Dog 31 January 2025 09:43 PM

No, this is entirely relevant. Why is SA tax money being spent on protecting Cyril and Patrice's mines? All while our defense force fat cats chop up some grass on a golf course.

Gugu1 31 January 2025 10:10 PM

The DA did the right thing. They promised the voter accountability. They're are making good on their promise. What is Hattingh's job then if not to do just that? He's not a member of cabinet. They need to do more of this, including leaking some scandals they stumble upon in the media if needs be.

jackt bloek 30 January 2025 11:47 AM

Imagine if the CEO of a Mining Company or Airline went on a Golf Day irrespective of how much it costs when 14 people died in plane or mine crash? The ANC need to convey message to all public servants and officials to be more circumspect in what they do in tragedies like this

Gavin Hillyard 4 February 2025 11:26 AM

They don't care Jackt, they don't care.

Rob 30 January 2025 12:19 PM

SADF are only there to protect the Ramaposa/ Motsepe mining billions. Soldiers dying is just on the by and by.

T'Plana Hath 30 January 2025 01:01 PM

"We train young men to drop fire on people. But their commanders won't allow them to write FUCK on their airplanes because ... it's obscene."

Gugu1 30 January 2025 01:14 PM

Garbage-in, garbage out! The average member of the US Joint Chiefs has an IQ of a brain surgeon. That's what you need to run a modern military. Human lives depend on you. You must also be a good steward of resourses - technology and a budget. The ANC shouldn't have dropped the standards.

Rob Wilson 30 January 2025 01:33 PM

One day of basic infantry training from the 80's will sort these people out.

dorringtonw 30 January 2025 03:46 PM

Couldnt agree more. Well put.

Pierre Joubert 30 January 2025 03:25 PM

The Pearl Harbour movie Tora Tora Tora showed how far from reality Commander in Chief, General Walter Short, was, heading for golf on the morning of the attack, instead of the radar room. The stricken ships could have been out in the safety of the open ocean. He was fired (relieved of his command)

D'Esprit 30 January 2025 03:50 PM

Given that the Minister thinks kids with 30% are well equipped to enter the workforce, it should come as no surprise that she thinks troops without ammo, food, shelter and air cover are well equipped to fight a war. Pathetic.

Nick Griffon 30 January 2025 05:11 PM

Unbelievable. They have absolutely no shame. Zero integrity, zero capability and zero shame.

Robbed Blind 30 January 2025 05:16 PM

I wouldn’t be surprised if they only found out about the dead SANDF members because of the backlash to the golf day.

D Dog 31 January 2025 09:39 PM

That's so true! LOL!

j***y@f***.co.za 3 February 2025 12:40 PM

C'mon y'all! All the negative comments. These are splendid examples of well-groomed, yet battle-hardened soldiers of days gone by. They have spent a whole day in the sun to raise funds for these poor soldiers because you, the taxpayer, do not pay enough.

bcmmayisela56 31 January 2025 01:04 AM

Where were the Rooivalks in this whole fiasco? Something like this happened in CAR in 2013 when again, 13 South African soldiers were killed by rebels. Special forces operators said they needed just two Rooivalks to defeat the rebels. This is beyond disgraceful! Rest in Power to our fallen soldiers.

Richard Blake 31 January 2025 06:31 PM

None of the top brass in the South African armed forces are qualified or fit for their rank or deserve to wear the uniform.

c***a@g***.com 31 January 2025 06:50 PM

I'm sure the minister of electricity has also been spending too much time on the golf course as loadshedding is back

j***y@f***.co.za 3 February 2025 12:42 PM

Nah, he's just trying to make eskom work while they are stealing R1b+ a month. Anybody with half a brain would've told him that it is not sustainable. But, what can I say?

r***e@g***.com 31 January 2025 08:28 PM

Please, chiefs of what? These loosers are nothing but useless clowns. I have more respect for a flat tyre

Tamsanqa 31 January 2025 08:37 PM

South Africa I know. It's hurting to see top SANDF Generals behaving in this manner. Our ground force needs their support.

linkinmynie 1 February 2025 04:09 AM

Leave the old men to their golf, let’s go reinforce the boys. Who’s with me?

linkinmynie 1 February 2025 04:15 AM

You can be a couch Commander or volunteer whats left of your life to the flag man. Let’s go fight without question for OUR Country.

linkinmynie 1 February 2025 04:16 AM

Air support se gat man! LETS GO!

linkinmynie 1 February 2025 04:20 AM

Don’t hide behind your IP, come show us how to win this skirmish. We need your skills on the battlefield as inept as we are.

linkinmynie 1 February 2025 04:35 AM

We will die for this country. That never changed. Because growing up we saw what kak so called South Africans did with this land. Now you want to be a moerse man on social media. WE ARE DOING THIS FOR YOU! But by all means when we done here, we will make time to discuss your view.

inyathi53 1 February 2025 10:30 AM

Whatever the position is, there are thirteen families mourning the deaths of Fathers, Sons, Husbands. Shame on you. Hang your heads in shame, or better still, retire to your studies, close the door, and take out your service pistols and take the only honourable way out.

Gavin Hillyard 4 February 2025 11:15 AM

Geography is on our side. Thank goodness Rwanda does not border us. If not, SA could be conquered by them no question. Paul Kagame is an astute tactician and politician - streets ahead of our esteemed jellyfish president. Bring our boys home post-haste. Not much force in our Defence Force I fear.

Domini.s.canton 4 February 2025 10:51 PM

I really don’t think our military guys are trained enough for war , they are basically cannon fodder,