Dailymaverick logo

World

This article is more than a year old

MIDDLE EAST CRISIS UPDATE: 18 OCTOBER 2024

Israeli troops kill Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar in Gaza; Biden to speak with Netanyahu on ending war

Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar, a mastermind of the 7 October 2023 attack that triggered the Gaza war, was killed by Israeli forces in the Palestinian enclave, said Israel on Thursday.
Israeli troops kill Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar in Gaza; Biden to speak with Netanyahu on ending war Slain Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar. (Photo: Mohammed Saber / EPA-EFE)

US President Joe Biden said on Thursday that Sinwar’s death marked a moment of relief for Israelis and that he would speak soon with Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu about ending the war.

Russia has warned Israel to not even consider striking Iranian nuclear facilities, state news agency Tass quoted Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov as saying on Thursday. 

Israeli troops kill Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar

Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar, a mastermind of the 7 October 2023 attack that triggered the Gaza war, was killed by Israeli forces in the Palestinian enclave, said Israel on Thursday.

His killing marks a huge success for Israel and a pivotal event in the year-long conflict. There are several possible scenarios for what happens next but Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said the war would go on.

The Israeli military said it had killed Sinwar in an operation in the southern Gaza Strip on Wednesday.

“After completing the process of identifying the body, it can be confirmed that Yahya Sinwar was eliminated,” it said.

There was no immediate comment from Hamas, but sources in the militant group said that indications from Gaza suggested Sinwar had been killed in an Israeli operation.

In Israel, families of hostages held by Hamas in Gaza said they hoped that a ceasefire could now be reached that would bring home the captives.

In Gaza, pounded relentlessly by Israeli forces for a year, residents said they believed the war would continue but they still clung to their hope of self-determination.

Netanyahu, speaking in Jerusalem just after the death was confirmed, said Sinwar’s death offered the chance of peace in the Middle East but warned that the war in Gaza was not over and Israel would continue until its hostages were returned.

“Today we have settled the score. Today evil has been dealt a blow but our task has still not been completed,” Netanyahu said in a recorded video statement. “To the dear hostage families, I say: this is an important moment in the war. We will continue full force until all your loved ones, our loved ones, are home.”

Israeli Foreign Minister Israel Katz said: “This is a great military and moral achievement for Israel.”

Sinwar, who was named as Hamas’ overall leader following the assassination of political chief Ismail Haniyeh in Tehran in July, was believed to have been hiding in the warren of tunnels Hamas has built under Gaza over the past two decades.

His death could dial up hostilities in the Middle East where the prospect of an even wider conflict has grown. Israel has launched a ground campaign in Lebanon over the past month and is now planning a response to a missile attack carried out by Iran on 1 October.

But the demise of the man who planned the attack last year in which fighters killed 1,200 people in Israel and captured more than 250 hostages, according to Israeli tallies, could also help push forward stalled efforts to end the war in which Israel has killed more than 42,000 Palestinians, according to Gaza health authorities.

Israel’s Army Radio said the killing had occurred during a ground operation in the city of Rafah in the southern Gaza Strip during which Israeli troops killed three militants and took their bodies.

A ruthless enforcer once tasked with punishing Palestinians suspected of informing for Israel, Sinwar, who was born in 1962, made his name as a prison leader.

He emerged as a street hero in Gaza from a 22-year Israeli jail sentence for masterminding the abduction and murder of two Israeli soldiers and four Palestinians. He then quickly rose to the top of the Hamas ranks. He was dedicated to eradicating Israel.

Israel has killed several commanders of Hamas in Gaza as well as senior figures of Hezbollah in Lebanon, dealing heavy blows to its arch-foes.

The killing also raises new questions about the fate of the hostages still in Hamas’ captivity. Sinwar was involved in negotiations that could have led to their release.

Families of Israeli hostages said that while the killing of Sinwar was a significant achievement, it would not be complete while hostages are still in Gaza.

In Khan Younis in the south of the Gaza Strip, a displaced Palestinian named Thabet Amour told Reuters that the Palestinian fight would continue.

“This is resistance that does not disappear when men disappear. The assassination of Sinwar will not lead to the end of the resistance or to a compromise or surrender and raising the white flag.”

Biden to speak soon with Netanyahu on ending war, returning hostages

US President Joe Biden said on Thursday that Sinwar’s death marked a moment of relief for Israelis while providing the opportunity for a “day after” in Gaza without the militant group in power.

“Yahya Sinwar was an insurmountable obstacle to achieving all of those goals. That obstacle no longer exists. But much work remains before us,” Biden said in a statement.

“I will be speaking soon with Prime Minister Netanyahu and other Israeli leaders to congratulate them, to discuss the pathway for bringing the hostages home to their families, and for ending this war once and for all, which has caused so much devastation to innocent people,” said Biden.

French President Emmanuel Macron said: “Yahya Sinwar was the main person responsible for the terrorist attacks and barbaric acts of October 7th. Today, I think with emotion of the victims, including 48 of our compatriots, and their loved ones. France demands the release of all hostages still held by Hamas.”

German Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock said: “Sinwar was a brutal murderer and terrorist, who wanted to destroy Israel and its people. Hamas must now release all hostages and lay down its weapons, the suffering of the people in Gaza must finally end.”

UK Defence Secretary John Healey said: “I, for one, will not mourn the death of a terror leader like Sinwar, someone who was responsible for the terror attack on October the 7th, and I’m conscious, like the UK Government is, that that triggered not just the darkest, deadliest day for the Jewish people since the Second World War, but it’s triggered since more than a year of conflict and an intolerable level of civilian Palestinian casualties as well.”

Families of Israeli hostages fear for captives after Hamas’ Sinwar killed

Families of Israeli hostages taken captive to Gaza by Hamas fear their loved ones are in greater danger after Israeli troops killed Sinwar.

“We have settled the score with the chief murderer Sinwar. But now, more than ever, the lives of Matan, my son, and the other hostages are in tangible danger,” said Einav Zangauker, whose 24-year-old son was abducted from their kibbutz home during Hamas’ 7 October 2023 attack.

“There will not be a real closing of the circle, no total victory if we do not save their lives and bring them all back,” said Zangauker in a video after news of Sinwar’s death emerged on Thursday.

So far, 117 hostages have returned home alive, including four released at the start of the Gaza war, 105 mostly women, children and foreigners returned last November during a brief truce with Hamas, and eight rescued by the military.

Thirty-seven were brought back dead. That leaves 101 hostages still in Gaza by Israeli tallies, at least half of whom Israeli authorities believe are still alive

Russia warns Israel not to attack Iranian nuclear facilities

Russia has warned Israel to not even consider striking Iranian nuclear facilities, state news agency Tass quoted Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov as saying on Thursday.

After Iran’s missile attack on Israel on 1 October, there has been speculation that Israel could strike Iran’s nuclear facilities, as it has long threatened to do.

“We have repeatedly warned and continue to warn, to caution [Israel] against even hypothetically considering the possibility of a strike on [Iranian] nuclear facilities and nuclear infrastructure," Ryabkov was quoted by Tass as saying.

“This would be a catastrophic development and a complete negation of all existing principles in the area of ​​ensuring nuclear safety.”

German warship serving Unifil downs drone off Lebanon

A German warship operating as part of the United Nations’ Unifil peacekeeping mission shot down a drone off the coast of Lebanon on Thursday, the German defence ministry told Reuters, as unease builds over the safety of the UN troops in the country.

Unifil positions have come under fire in Lebanon since Israel launched a ground operation against Hezbollah militants on 1 October, raising alarm among European governments participating in the mission.

“The corvette brought an unidentified unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) into the water in a controlled crash,” the spokesperson said, reporting no damage to the German vessel or its crew.

The corvette Ludwigshafen am Rhein was continuing its duties, he added.

Israel stops processing key commercial food imports to Gaza

Israel has stopped processing requests from traders to import food to Gaza, according to 12 people involved in the trade, choking off a track that for the past six months supplied more than half of the besieged Palestinian territory’s provisions.

Since 11 October, Gaza-based traders who were importing food from Israel and the Israeli-occupied West Bank have lost access to a system introduced in spring by Cogat, the Israeli government body that oversees aid and commercial shipments, and have received no reply to attempts to contact the agency, said the sources.

The shift has driven the flow of goods arriving in Gaza to its lowest level since the start of the war, a Reuters analysis of official Israeli data shows.

Cogat did not respond to Reuters’ questions about commercial food imports and aid to Gaza. The agency says it does all it can to ensure that enough aid enters the coastal enclave and that Israel does not prevent the entry of humanitarian aid. It rejects allegations Israel has blocked supplies.

Between 1 and 16 October, the overall flow of shipments to Gaza — including both aid and commercial goods — fell to a daily average of 29 trucks, according to Cogat statistics.

That compares with a daily average of 175 trucks between May and September, the data show. Commercial shipments — goods bought by local traders, trucked in after direct approval by Cogat, and then sold in marketplaces in Gaza — accounted for about 55% of the total during that period.

Two sources involved in food supply said the reason for halting commercial shipments was because Israel worried that the Hamas militant group was receiving revenues from the imports.

A Hamas spokesperson denied that the group had stolen food or used it for revenue and said it was trying to ensure the distribution of aid in Gaza.

The commercial system’s apparent closure came as Israel launched a new military operation against Hamas in northern Gaza, a parallel development that has obstructed humanitarian aid deliveries. The UN’s World Food Programme said in a statement on Sunday the operation cut off all aid deliveries through crossings in the north for at least two weeks this month.

A series of measures by Israeli government departments and the military were already reducing food deliveries to Gaza. In August, Israeli authorities introduced a new customs rule on one aid channel and began scaling down the separate track of commercial goods.

Plummeting volumes of aid into Gaza have prompted the US to threaten to withhold military support to Israel and fuelled alarm over the risk of famine in Gaza.

Getting enough food to Gaza’s 2.3 million people, almost all of whom have been displaced, has been one of the most fraught issues of the war.

In May, International Criminal Court (ICC) prosecutors asked the court to issue an arrest warrant against Netanyahu, saying they suspected Israeli authorities had used “the starvation of civilians as a method of warfare”.

Israeli authorities have denied this, saying they facilitate food deliveries despite challenging conditions. They have filed two official challenges to the ICC, contesting the legality of the prosecutor’s request and the court’s jurisdiction.

Following recent international criticism, Cogat said in statements this week that Israel had allowed scores of trucks of aid into Gaza, including dozens via crossings in the north. It did not provide full details or respond to Reuters’ requests for information for this story.

Before the war, some 500 trucks per day entered Gaza carrying a mix of aid and commercial imports, such as food, building materials and agricultural supplies.

“The situation is getting desperate,” said Ibrahim Baraka, a resident of southern Gaza. “We have some non-perishable aid but there’s virtually no fresh produce anymore. A kilo of onions is $15 in southern Gaza.”

His account was corroborated by five other residents, seven traders and five humanitarian workers.

At least 28 dead in strike on Gaza shelter

At least 28 Palestinians including children were killed on Thursday in an Israeli strike on a shelter in the northern Gaza Strip, a Gaza health ministry official said, while Israel said the attack targeted tens of militants at the site.

Dozens were also injured in the strike, said the official, Medhat Abbas, adding: “There is no water to extinguish the fire. There is nothing. This is a massacre. Civilians and children are being killed, burned under fire.”

The Israeli military said the strike targeted militants from Hamas and Islamic Jihad groups, who operated from within the Abu Hussein School in Jabalia that had been serving as a shelter for displaced people.

It said dozens of militants were present inside the compound when the strike took place, and provided the names of at least 12 of them, which Reuters could not immediately verify.

Hamas said in a statement that allegations there were fighters at the school were “nothing but lies”, adding this was “a systematic policy of the enemy to justify its crime.”

Earlier on Thursday, Palestinian health officials said at least 11 Palestinians were killed in two separate Israeli strikes in Gaza City, while several others were killed in central and southern Gaza areas.

Residents of Jabalia, in northern Gaza, said Israeli forces blew up clusters of houses by firing from the air, from tanks and by placing bombs in buildings and then detonating them remotely.

The area has been a focus for the Israeli military for the past two weeks, which says it is trying to stop Hamas fighters from regrouping for more attacks.

Residents said Israeli forces had effectively isolated Beit Hanoun, Jabalia, and Beit Lahiya in the far north of the enclave from Gaza City, blocking movement except for those families heeding evacuation orders and leaving the three towns.

“We have written our death notes, and we are not leaving Jabalia,” one resident told Reuters via a chat app.

“The occupation [Israel] is punishing us for not leaving our houses in the early days of the war, and we are not going now either. They are blowing up houses, and roads, and are starving us but we die once and we don’t lose our pride," the father of four said, refusing to give his name, fearing Israeli reprisal.

The Israeli military said on Thursday that it seized many weapons in the area, some of which were stashed in a school, and that its forces had killed dozens of militants in airstrikes and combat at close quarters, as troops try to root out Hamas forces operating in the rubble.

Surge in Gaza violence increases famine risk, says monitor

The entire Gaza Strip remained at risk of famine and was experiencing emergency levels of hunger, with intense Israeli military operations adding to concerns and hampering humanitarian access, said a global monitor on Thursday.

About 1.84 million people across the besieged Palestinian enclave are living through high levels of acute food insecurity, including nearly 133,000 people experiencing the most severe, or “catastrophic”, levels, according to an analysis from the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification.

That was down from some 343,000 people suffering catastrophic hunger as of the last update in June, but it was expected to return to that level in coming months, the IPC said.

UN human rights chief Volker Turk described the assessment as “beyond terrifying.”

“This crisis is principally the consequence of decisions made by the Israeli authorities. It is in their power to change the situation — urgently,” he said, adding that starvation of civilians as a method of warfare constituted a war crime.

UN Secretary-General António Guterres said he was alarmed by the IPC analysis.

“Famine looms. This is intolerable. Crossing points must open immediately, bureaucratic impediments must be removed, and law and order restored so UN agencies can deliver lifesaving humanitarian assistance,” he said in an X social media post.

An estimated 60,000 cases of acute malnutrition among young children were expected between September 2024 and August 2025, according to the IPC. The new analysis was conducted between 30 September and 4 October. DM

Read more: Middle East crisis news hub

Comments (10)

JP K Oct 18, 2024, 07:25 AM

Genocide doesn't stop because you have killed your enemy's leader. Genocide is about wiping out everyone. With that understanding, starving an entire population - regardless of whether they are men women, children or infants - makes perfect sense.

Muishond X Oct 18, 2024, 08:08 AM

You watch too much BBC and Sky news. The food trucks are routinely diverted by Hamas as video footage shows, then sold to Gazans. A Jordanian truck driver killed 3 Israeli border guards. Talk about cutting off the hand that feeds you.

JP K Oct 18, 2024, 08:42 AM

USAID, said "the looming famine in Gaza was the result of Israel’s “arbitrary denial, restriction, & impediments of U.S. humanitarian assistance” According to Human Rights Watch "Israel: Starvation Used as Weapon of War in Gaza " How do the anecdotes you provide rebut such findings?

Mr. Fair Oct 18, 2024, 11:49 AM

So the news that Israel puts out, the country 100% prohibiting all press from there, and who's citizens attack aid trucks, is accurate? Why prohibit the press then? Think - why would the entire world say "you're starving them"?Why would everyone make that up? Antisemitism?

Hidden Name Oct 19, 2024, 10:57 AM

Your handle doesnt match your attitude. Chances are Hamas is doing exactly that - it would very much be in character. This is after all how they got the money to buy rockets and build tunnels - by stealing aid. Just an observation based on rational fact - might want to try that.

JP K Oct 20, 2024, 04:09 PM

Any sources for your claims? A variety of credible sources (UN agencies, American government agencies, human rights organisations etc.) attribute the problem to Israel.

John P Oct 19, 2024, 01:12 PM

Possibly you should try the BBC and Sky as opposed to Facebook and Youtube? Also try CNN, Al Jazeera, The Guardian, even Bloomberg and Reuters.

Mark J Oct 19, 2024, 07:20 PM

Yes, and to add to this list, +972 Magazine, for on-the-ground reporting and critical analysis by Israeli and Palestinian journalists.

Malcolm McManus Oct 18, 2024, 09:14 AM

If Israel wanted to wipe out everyone, they would have done it already. Its clearly not the aim. Those fat people in the aid queues are not starving. Look next time you see coverage.

Mr. Fair Oct 18, 2024, 11:32 AM

"Coverage"? From which press? Israel controls 100% of the story coming from there, on purpose. There is no independent coverage, only what Israel wants the world to see, so obviously they show what suits them. Do one thing, say another. If it's the same, let press in, but no. Why not?

Malcolm McManus Oct 18, 2024, 12:07 PM

Theres UN and independent footage and images. Its readily available all over the internet.

JP K Oct 18, 2024, 01:24 PM

Israel is attempting to control the media's ability to report on the situation by killing journalists and restricting their access. It is nevertheless, the first live-streamed genocide.

Mr. Fair Oct 18, 2024, 11:55 AM

Israel cannot simply openly commit genocide. No US aid, sanctions from everyone. They have to hide it and pretend it isn't happening, by prohibiting the press (done), and showing what they want us to see (done - and you lap it up as truth).

JP K Oct 18, 2024, 01:21 PM

Besides the fact that genocide is a process, realpolitik would prevent such open obliteration. I've not noticed fat people in coverage out of Gaza. But besides, the reports on the health situation present a different reality from yours.

louw.nic Oct 18, 2024, 02:52 PM

You reap what you sow. Meaning: "you eventually have to face up to the consequences of your actions."

JP K Oct 18, 2024, 04:17 PM

That's the idea anyway. We'll see if the arrest warrants for Hamas and Israeli war criminals are followed through on. But I don't remember American president ever facing consequences for war crimes. Maybe I missed it.

JP K Oct 18, 2024, 07:33 AM

Defences for Israel are vacuous. Everything is Hamas' fault. That's pretty much the argument. Children routinely killed by sniper shots to the head or heart? Well, it's Hamas that started it and therefore war crimes are permissible. Israel is, after all, the most moral army in the world.

Jeff Robinson Oct 18, 2024, 07:58 AM

There are no good guys in this conflict aside from the brave aid workers and medical personnel. I do however believe that if Hamas was to release all the hostages and lay down arms, Israel would have to stop. That would be the truest test of whether or not Israel is bent on genocide.

JP K Oct 18, 2024, 08:46 AM

(1) I don't think there are good guys, but I also don't think there is a moral equivalence between the 2 sides either. You'd roll those dice? Lay down arms and check whether your enemy stated genocidal intention is real?

Ivan van Heerden Oct 18, 2024, 12:55 PM

Israel does not chant from the river to the sea nor does it call for the extermination of the Palestinians. That in a nutshell is the difference between the two sides

JP K Oct 18, 2024, 01:31 PM

The full refrain is: "from the river to the sea, Palestine will be free". For a people who lost their land and who live under occupation. Have you read the Likud charter? Do you remember all the genocidal statements made by senior Israelis documented in the SA application to the ICJ?

JP K Oct 18, 2024, 01:31 PM

The full refrain is: "from the river to the sea, Palestine will be free". For a people who lost their land and who live under occupation. Have you read the Likud charter? Do you remember all the genocidal statements made by senior Israelis documented in the SA application to the ICJ?

Malcolm McManus Oct 18, 2024, 02:59 PM

Not to mention that Jews have been chased from many muslim states, so if land was "given back" to palestinians, would Jews still be welcome in Israel and if not, where do they belong. I don't see a simple solution, The 2 state option never gains traction.

Mr. Fair Oct 18, 2024, 04:14 PM

Israel's very creation is based on a Jewish majority, created by pushing out almost a million Muslims, it started there. That in a nutshell if the difference - racism created Israel. What do you expect after a lifetime? "Sure, keep it all for yourselves"?

Mr. Fair Oct 18, 2024, 04:16 PM

Malcolm asks where do Jews belong? Well, where do Christians belong? And Muslims? The same place for the same reasons, right? Based on the same old texts. Why do Jews need to create a whole country just for themselves? Muslim states aren't oppressing native Jews there. WW2 is over. Get over it.

JP K Oct 18, 2024, 09:29 AM

(2) Besides, experts from different disciplines are saying it is genocide (as defined by political scientists and by the convention) already...

Mr. Fair Oct 18, 2024, 10:00 AM

You're missing the point of this lifelong conflict. Have you never asked why this are is in constant war? Simple anti-semitism is obviously not it. Stolen land, and oppressed previous owners ever since1948. Stolen and oppressed to be able to create Israel. Lay down arms? Then? More of the same?

Deon de Wet-Roos Oct 18, 2024, 08:53 AM

Israel will continue to destroy Gaza and Lebanon (and anyone else) until there is nothing left. At some point the Palestinians and Lebanese will only be able to survive through the good graces of Israel. When this happens Israel can monetize the rebuilding of Gaza and Lebanon. Very clever.

Malcolm McManus Oct 18, 2024, 09:50 AM

Lebanon could have done without hezbollah attacking Israel from within their borders. This retaliation has been a long time in the making. Israel's daily press briefings were warning of this since Oct 8th. The UN where pretty much absent whilst Hezbollah sent thousands of rockets into Israel.

Mr. Fair Oct 18, 2024, 11:28 AM

If you only read Israel's press, and not Hezbollah's which have said since Oct 8 they will stop attacking Israel when Israel stops attacking Gaza, then you would have a balanced view. Do you really think the Lebanese government has ANY control over Hezbollah? Or the average citizen, dying daily?

Malcolm McManus Oct 18, 2024, 11:43 AM

I agree, Neither the Lebanese government nor its people want this war. Its tragic that Iran uses its Hezbollah proxies to cause mayhem here. I just wonder where the UN were all along.

Mr. Fair Oct 18, 2024, 12:50 PM

It's tragic that the US uses its proxy Israel, to cause mayhem in Palestine. The UN? The body decrying Israels horrors for decades, by majority, while the US vetoes? The UN you want to do something, but the US prevents it? The UN Israel blames, while ignoring it's resolutions?

Hidden Name Oct 19, 2024, 11:02 AM

Rather sounds like they were willing participants in a war. And guess what? Firing rockets into another country is an act of war. Its perhaps time you all grow up and start being rational. The emotional claptrap bleated about Gaza/Israel is utterly ridiculous. Its a war, and Israel didnt start it.

Mr. Fair Oct 18, 2024, 11:29 AM

The UN is not there to get involved in anyone's war. Try to stop repeating Netanyahu's every word as if it were gospel.

Mr. Fair Oct 18, 2024, 04:24 PM

The UN? You mean the organisation that "gave" the land (as if it were empty) to the Zionists to create Israel in the first place? So if the UN is so bad as you and Netanyahu says, better dissolve the state created by a UN resolution in 1948.

Mr. Fair Oct 18, 2024, 07:10 PM

"Thousands of rockets" lol. Two. Exactly TWO Israelis dead since Israel invaded Lebanon (this time). OUTRAGE! THOUSANDS OF ROCKETS! (Thousands of Gazans, Thousands of West Bank Palestinians, Thousands of Lebanese killed by Israel since). Blame the UN! (because we're running out of scapegoats)

Mr. Fair Oct 18, 2024, 10:03 AM

The goal isn't money. The goal is to somehow use violence, racism, and indoctrinated religious superiority in the minds of their citizens and the west (US) to subdue the people who's parents and grandparents homes and land was stolen to create Israel, until they have no fight for freedom left

Deon de Wet-Roos Oct 18, 2024, 11:24 AM

After obliterating Gaza and Lebanon Israel can dictate terms. It is in no one's interest to have war. It is in Israel's (and of course the Palestinians etc.) interest to rebuild Gaza and Lebanon. The war leaves an economic vacuum in Gaza that should benefit Israel primarily.

Kanu Sukha Oct 18, 2024, 11:33 AM

Congrats genocide Joe (& Kamala?) for your direct complicity in the Palestinian genocide! Only 3/4 million more to kill before you move on to the next one. Have you atoned for the one you committed on home soil of indigenous people yet? Only a few more billion to slaughter, opposed to US hegemony.

Hidden Name Oct 19, 2024, 11:04 AM

Hoo boy. There is not a shred of rational thought in your post - just emotion which is essentially meaningless. Come now - use your mind to sift through the rhetoric and propaganda. I can guarantee 2 things: none of us really knows what going on, 90% of what you read is deliberate propaganda.

JP K Oct 20, 2024, 04:22 PM

There are credible reports detailing that what is going on is: Apartheid; illegal occupation; starvation as a weapon of war; direct attacks on UN facilities; attacks on protected persons (civilians, journalists, medical personnel). That is, a genocide. I'm curious. What is the 10% you read?

JP K Oct 20, 2024, 04:20 PM

It's a mistake to merely attribute to the Democrats - guilty though they are. They are merely implementers of the consistent US policy of supporting Israel. The veil of western government interest in human rights has fallen.

David Roux Oct 18, 2024, 12:42 PM

"With Haniyah, Nasrallah, and now Sinwar dead, Israel can finally end its brutal war and resume negotiations towards a two-state solution. Now if you'll excuse me, I have to leave for the Most Gullible Person in the World competition." - quote from post by @JeffreyASachs on X.

alastairmgf Oct 18, 2024, 01:52 PM

There is no genocide in Gaza. Israel just wants to be left alone to live in peace. It is very simple, Hamas sues for peace, surrenders, lays down their arms and hands back the hostages (if any are still alive). Gaza can then be rebuilt and life can return to normal.

Mark J Oct 18, 2024, 02:59 PM

Wow, how much propaganda can you fit into one comment. Do you mean "normal" as in arbitrary detention, torture, blockades, and undermining efforts at Palestinian independence? As Sinwar once said, "It is unfair for the world to expect Palestinians to be well-behaved victims of Israeli violence."

Mark J Oct 19, 2024, 05:22 AM

Correction, the quote above was of a reporter paraphrasing Sinwar. The actual words attributed to Sinwar were: “Does the world expect us to be well-behaved victims while we are being killed, for us to be slaughtered without making a noise?” [source: Al Jazeera]

Hidden Name Oct 19, 2024, 11:07 AM

All the issues you complain about are a direct result of Hamas continuous attacks on Israeli citizens. That may be an inconvenient fact to your perspective - but it remains true. Israel literally cannot free them, because the first thing they will do is attack Israel with Iranian weapons.

Mark J Oct 19, 2024, 02:51 PM

“Israel literally cannot free them.” And we’re back to square one. As long as Israel denies the humanity of Palestinians - the rights to life, dignity and the freedom to return to a land that was taken by force - it will always face resistance.

JP K Oct 20, 2024, 04:25 PM

USAID and other global experts in humanitarian relief have reported that Israel is intentionally hindering aid (you know, killing aid workers etc.) Even if everything else is Hamas' fault, how do you explain starvation as a weapon of war as being Hamas?

Mr. Fair Oct 18, 2024, 03:59 PM

"Gaza can then be rebuilt and life can return to normal" Do you have any clue what life is like without any rights in the land of your birth? Where every item coming in, every watt of power, every medical bandage, everything is controlled by your occupiers? Who wants that as normal?

Mr. Fair Oct 18, 2024, 04:01 PM

You seem to think Gaza is a sovereign state, happy to live, freely next door to Israel. It is a militarily blockaded open-air prison created by a racist state on land that Palestinians owned before being kicked out by the hundreds of thousands. Why do you think they are all unhappy? Anti-semitism?

Mr. Fair Oct 18, 2024, 07:13 PM

"Israel just wants to be left in peace". Israel: After taking all this land, creating a racist undemocratic state for MY people only, subduing the local population for a lifetime, making them out to be the aggressors, and imposing violence and oppression all around, as if 1800 tactics still work..

Mr. Fair Oct 18, 2024, 07:25 PM

"Israel just wants to be left alone to live in peace." Brother, I don't know how old you are, but I assume you live in SA. You know, one of the last countries to finally 'get it' and realise that colonising other people's land and subjugating the locals, trying to fool everyone, DOES NOT WORK?

Mark J Oct 19, 2024, 05:48 AM

In March 2018, Palestinians in Gaza began year long peaceful protests every Friday at the border fence, demanding the right to return. They were met with Israeli gunfire despite posing no threat. 266 innocent people were killed and almost 30,000 wounded, many left with permanent disabilities.

John P Oct 21, 2024, 02:42 PM

Perhaps if Netanyahu had handled things differently and negotiated from the beginning all the hostages would have been home already.

Mr. Fair Oct 18, 2024, 07:52 PM

South African Citizens; You had no choice in where you were born. Put yourself in others' shoes, mentally, emotionally - those you demonise, their little children who also had no choice - and honestly tell yourself, without guilt, that it is righteous to take a country for your own specific people.

Jubilee 1516 Oct 19, 2024, 07:38 AM

Good. The "man" who planned the mass gang rape of children, before slitting their throats in front of their parents on 7 October, is dead.

JP K Oct 20, 2024, 04:28 PM

I'm not sure how your comment passed moderation. The mass gang rape of children? That is misinformation. There is no evidence of systematic sexual violence as a weapon of war. It is that kind of language which dehumanises the Palestinians and which was used as a pretext to unleash a genocide.

Jubilee 1516 Oct 19, 2024, 07:39 AM

Great news. Now when genocidal Hamas let the children they hold hostage go home, the war can stop.

Mark J Oct 19, 2024, 09:20 AM

Can it? How nice of Israel. Can it also release the thousands of Palestinians being held under administrative detention? Can it end the blockade of Gaza? Can it end the settler pogroms on the West Bank? Can it acknowledge the Nakba? Can it allow Palestinian refugees to return to their homeland?

Hidden Name Oct 19, 2024, 11:10 AM

Dunno - can Hamas stop attacking Israeli citizens? Will they stop openly supporting the murder of Jews and the martyring of their citizens (if you want to see a horror show look up what they broadcast to their children). Stop being so naive, man.

Roke Wood Oct 19, 2024, 08:17 AM

"We will wipe Hamas off the face of the earth"- Israel 12 Oct 2023. Hamas is a terrorist org recognised as such by other states. Its common practice for ters to use schools and hospitals as a base in which to hide and keep arms caches. By doing so, the ters are using their own people as shields.

Mark J Oct 19, 2024, 09:45 AM

Israel is a terrorist state. By labelling resistance to tyranny as terrorism, the terrorist state gets a blank cheque to whitewash occupation, dispossession, subjugation and genocide.

Hidden Name Oct 19, 2024, 11:12 AM

Strange - you very rarely hear about an Israeli strapping on a suicide bomb vest and going off to blow people up. Nor do you hear about them going on a random unprovoked rampage stabbing or shooting people. Stop being so naive, man.

Roke Wood Oct 19, 2024, 11:21 AM

"Israel is a terrorist state" - no its not. its recognised as a sovereign state, the world over....as for the rest of your comment iro terrorism - Hamas is recognised as a terrorist org, so is Hezbollah and houties - all 3 backed by Iran. If any state should be seen as a terrorist state its Iran.

Mark J Oct 19, 2024, 12:59 PM

Again, this is about labelling. The reality on the ground is that Israeli warplanes, drones, tanks and snipers are terrorising the people of Gaza and Lebanon, and Israeli settlers are terrorising the people of the West Bank with implicit state support.

Mark J Oct 19, 2024, 01:02 PM

Wrt Iran, I'd recommend reading the interview with Israeli political scientist Ori Goldberg, who challenges the conventional view, in +972 Mag.

John P Oct 19, 2024, 01:25 PM

Hamas etc are considered terrorists by Israel's allies, strange that. Russia is also a sovereign state so you then must agree with their invasion of Ukraine?

Roke Wood Oct 19, 2024, 02:10 PM

John...with respect, your analogy iro Russia makes no sense and is illogical, its not even the same conflict. I will tell you what my late father said about war, since he served war time on more than one occasion.

Roke Wood Oct 19, 2024, 02:11 PM

My father served war time. He would always start a story with the following -"there are no heroes or winners in war, only losers - if you win, you've lost. You've lost good men and women, you've lost innocents, you've lost friends, youve lost family, and the costs of war are marked in blood"

JP K Oct 20, 2024, 04:33 PM

My definition of terrorism is the use of indiscriminate violence to achieve political ends. Such as what Hamas did on Oct 7. Such as what Israel did when it detonated pagers. We may have different ideas of what constitutes terrorism. Could you define it please?