Dailymaverick logo

Politics

This article is more than a year old

2024 DECISIONUSA

With four weeks to go, Kamala Harris leads US polls while Elon Musk goes Dark MAGA for Trump

The presidential race intensifies as local elections and women's reproductive rights take centre stage, impacting Congress and voter sentiment.
With four weeks to go, Kamala Harris leads US polls while Elon Musk goes Dark MAGA for Trump Illustrative Image: Vice-presidential candidate Tim Walz. (Photo: Stephen Maturen / Getty Images) | Presidential candidate Kamala Harris. | Presidential candidate Donald Trump. (Photos: EPA-EFE / Justin Lane) | Vice-presidential candidate JD Vance. (Photo: Joe Raedle / Getty Images)

On that question of abortion rights, Melania Trump, in her new memoir, has come out fully supportive of women’s reproductive rights – very different from the various positions her husband has taken. Will this help or hurt him with voters? Who knows…

Of course, most of the attention from outside the US is naturally focused on the presidential outcome. Within the country, however, many voters are also paying particular attention to more local races and those referendums on their ballots in their respective states – in addition to the presidential race. 

For example, the Senate seat now held by Democrat Jon Tester in Montana is being fiercely contested. If Democrats lose this race – or one or two other possible seats such as the contest between Larry Hogan and Angela Alsobrooks in Maryland – they would lose control of that half of the Congress, even if they pull out a victory in the presidential race. 

Harris edging ahead

In the presidential race, the most recent polling, according to the Washington Times and similarly reported by many other media channels, “Vice-President Kamala Harris gained a 2-point edge over former president Donald Trump in a new national poll. The survey from NPR, PBS News and Marist found that Ms Harris leads Mr Trump 50% to 48% nationally, though her slim advantage is within the poll’s margin for error.”

This usually means a poll such as this one is said to be accurate at the 95% level of reliability and within a couple of percentage points to either side of the announced levels of support.

“Ms Harris is underperforming among independent voters, however, trailing Mr Trump by 4 points. President Biden carried independent voters by 13 points in 2020.”

The report went on to note, significantly, that the “Marist’s poll, released Thursday, showed that the gender gap of support for the candidates is wide. Men overwhelmingly support Mr Trump 57%-41%. Conversely, Ms Harris has an 18-point lead with women.”

This is largely attributable to the salience of the respective candidates’ positions on women’s reproductive rights.

“‘With the campaigns in high gear, no one has closed the sale,’ Lee Miringoff, director of the Marist Institute for Public Opinion, said. ‘Under the hood, the gender gap continues to widen and, at this rate, the gender gap in this year’s election results will likely outpace what it has been historically.’”

Potentially important for the efforts of the Democratic Party candidate (and incumbent President Joe Biden’s), the report added: “Previous polling found that the economy was the No 1 concern among voters, particularly in swing states. But Marist’s poll found that preserving democracy is the top issue for voters nationally, 64%, followed by the economy, 59%, and immigration, 44%.” 

This shift may be indicative that the message Democrats have been hammering at for months – that this election is about the preservation of democracy – is actually beginning to capture the attention of voters. It may also reflect the increasing recognition of current economic circumstances as opposed to memories of the Covid pandemic and the subsequent supply chain disruptions.

Betting on immigration

Meanwhile, Republican candidates Trump and JD Vance increasingly seem to be placing their bets on still-potent fears by many about immigrants taking jobs, carrying out campaigns of drug dealing, murder and rapine, illegally scoring housing and federal aid funding, and directly causing inflation and climate change (okay, not that very last one, at least, not yet). 

This could be seen in Trump’s bizarre statements in his earlier debate with Democratic nominee Harris about Haitian legal immigrants putting stolen kittens and puppies into their soup pots in a small city in Ohio. 

Read more: Kamala Harris cleans Donald Trump’s clock in American presidential candidates debate — no debate about it

But then there was also vice-presidential nominee Vance’s performance in his recent debate with Democratic vice-presidential nominee Tim Walz, in which he attempted to tie the rises in home prices and rental costs to an exaggerated, imaginary number of 25 million illegal immigrants. This charge continues to be refuted by economists who note illegal immigrants are extremely unlikely to be applying for home loans to buy McMansions or attempting to rent upmarket apartments in “hot” neighbourhoods. 

In his most recent, duplicitous outbursts, Trump has been telling voters that emergency government funding to address the circumstances of victims from Hurricane Helene is unavailable because the Biden administration spent the Federal Emergency Management Agency’s money on illegal immigrants. While this is not true of the current administration, it actually was true in the Trump presidency, when FEMA funds were diverted to pay for the roundups and incarceration of immigrants.

Over the past weekend, Trump went back to Butler, Pennsylvania – the site of the rally where there had been that attempt on his life that winged his ear – to continue his interrupted rally. This time, his event featured his new acolyte, Elon Musk, who gave a demonstration of jumping jacks and wore a black MAGA hat, while cheering for his chosen candidate. 

Targeting swing states

Meanwhile, Harris has been trying to lock down wavering support from some would-be backers in the all-important swing states. This has included a meeting with representatives of the Muslim and Arab-American voters in Michigan, many of whom remain wary of the incumbent Democratic president’s policies on the Middle East. Such voters may be a crucial part of the electorate in that state. 

Harris continues to gather endorsements from many dozens of Republican worthies, including former congresswoman Liz Cheney. Cheney appeared with Harris at an event to visibly demonstrate her support – and her apostasy, according to Trump campaign spokespersons.

The former Wyoming representative had been the third-ranking Republican member of Congress until she dared serve on the special congressional committee investigating the 6 January 2021 insurrection attempting to seize the Capitol Building and preventing the vice-president’s certification of Biden’s election as president. Just incidentally, the special prosecutor’s new version of his brief about the then-president’s role has been released and the case may be inching forward again.

Fundraising

Of course, all of these campaign efforts cost money – and tonnes of it. Here, Harris’s candidacy has a clear advantage. The Economist noted that as of 31 August, Harris has gathered nearly a billion dollars in direct campaign contributions, plus contributions to allied groups such as PACs (political action committees), compared with Trump’s close to $700-million.

As Willie Brown, the former San Francisco mayor and former California state speaker of the house, memorably reminded us, “Money is the mother’s milk of politics”. That is true, but it doesn’t guarantee outcomes.

Now that the debates are history, and with only weeks before the election, voters will see the presidential and vice-presidential candidates increasingly on their favourite electronic media shows, including such interesting spots as Walz on Fox News and Harris on The View and 60 Minutes. On the latter, the show’s producers wanted both presidential candidates to appear, but, since Trump declined, Harris will have the time to herself. 

It is also important to remember that an increasing number of voters in many states are already voting in advance by mail. As of last week, 1,139,000 people had already done so. Decisions by millions more voters soon may be baked into the results as well, although such votes will not be counted until election day. 

This election may go down to the wire – and with the nearly inevitable challenges to the results. DM

Comments (7)

maroba001 Oct 7, 2024, 04:09 AM

Trump will show you flames. Been following American politics... this Kamala Harris person cannot win the elections. There is absolutely nothing coming out of her mouth and actions should win her these elections.

Steve Davidson Oct 7, 2024, 06:50 AM

I despair for the world if Demented Donnie gets back in. The bullduster with 33000 confirmed lies from his 4 years in the WH continues in the same vein. The saddest thing of all is that too many thick yanks believe him.

Malcolm McManus Oct 7, 2024, 08:46 AM

Who confirmed the 33000 lies. All politicians including Harris lie, or in her case she avoids telling the truth. Who on earth counts peoples lies. This 33000 lies story gets told frequently in the comments, but if its true, where are the stats coming from? Please elaborate.

Ed Rybicki Oct 7, 2024, 09:12 AM

The New York Times runs a Trump fact-check page?

Beverley Roos-Muller Oct 7, 2024, 09:28 AM

Who counted Trump lies? The New York Times and the Washington Post among other major newspapers. Historians also check lies as we must, as do major research institutes. Easily available on the internet, though not Fox 'news'. Where is your data that ALL politicos lie - is that OK then?

Malcolm McManus Oct 7, 2024, 10:00 AM

Thank you for that. Left leaning posts. Who counted Kamala Harris's lies? NYT or WP. Is that also on the web. I heard her doing the new take on Fracking, refusing to agree she was opposed to Fracking a while back. Wouldn't outright deny. Just went into a defensive ramble as she does.

Malcolm McManus Oct 7, 2024, 10:13 AM

There is an endless list of lies by American Presidents, both Dems and republicans. Who can forget the shenanigans of Clintons famous cigar (I wonder where that ended up after its maiden voyage), Bush's WMD lie that destroyed millions of lives, vietnam lies etc, etc. No,It doesn't make it right.

D'Esprit Dan Oct 7, 2024, 10:27 AM

Trump's lies are off the charts. I'm not sure he is capable of speaking for more that 30 seconds without the BS flowing: he has absolutely no interest in the truth, or even facts, just his own ego and power.

Malcolm McManus Oct 7, 2024, 11:00 AM

Thank you for that. Left leaning posts. Who counted Kamala Harris’s lies? NYT or WP. Is that also on the web. I heard her doing the new take on Fracking, refusing to agree she was opposed to Fracking a while back. Wouldn’t outright deny. Just went into a defensive ramble as she does

Iota Jot Oct 7, 2024, 09:43 AM

Fact checkers check facts. Look at [guides.lib.berkeley.edu/c.php?g=620677&p=4333407] for examples of fact checking organisations. Yes, all politicians lie but few as compulsively as Trump. He just makes it up as he goes along. You are being disingenuous or wilfully ignorant if you say otherwise.

Malcolm McManus Oct 7, 2024, 11:32 AM

Truth be told, I don't google much. So yes, in this case I plead ignorance. I am well aware of Trumps and Harris's lies, and many others. I admit it. I honestly didn't think people made a living counting lies. I am quite shocked.

D'Esprit Dan Oct 7, 2024, 10:23 AM

The Washington Post Fact Checker confirmed 30,537 porkies during his presidency alone. I think the 33,000 is a gross understatement. NPR, and independent network of media channels in the US, clocked up 162 lies, distortions and inaccuracies in one 64 minute ramble in August this year!

Malcolm McManus Oct 7, 2024, 08:50 AM

The yanks may be thick, but in democracy, the only right outcome is chosen by the majority. So no matter who wins, as long as the elections are not rigged, the outcome can only be the correct one. So thick peoples choice is just as important as the clever ones.

Richard Kennard Oct 7, 2024, 09:39 AM

Then there's the issue of the Electoral College and the popular vote. The discrepancy is pretty huge.

Malcolm McManus Oct 7, 2024, 09:51 AM

True, which makes one wonder why the Americans have been pushing democracy often through wars, if its so flawed in the US.

D'Esprit Dan Oct 7, 2024, 10:14 AM

I'm going to keep this post for when we next have elections in SA and the usual frothing about the 'sheeple' and how thick they are comes out!

Malcolm McManus Oct 7, 2024, 10:43 AM

Yip, We may not all be happy with democratic outcomes. I know in South Africa It could have better outcomes. But unfortunately we can't choose the average IQ of our citizens. Nevertheless, although we may not like the outcome we have to accept the peoples choice. That's democracy for you.

Hidden Name Oct 7, 2024, 03:42 PM

Carefull there - you are conflating education with IQ, which is exactly what the tests do. Also why we score so low. Our av is reported as low as 72...not a joke. Doesnt mean all Saffers are dumb - just not educated. US is 98. So by and large better educated and more discerning, despite evidence:)

Harold Porter Oct 7, 2024, 08:57 AM

...because the world has been in such a good state in the last four years...oh wait...

Johan Buys Oct 7, 2024, 07:57 AM

Harris will take the national poll by probably 8 million. That matters zip : the electoral college will reduce the Presidential outcome to a few thousand votes in a few states - especially Pennsylvania.

Skinyela Oct 7, 2024, 10:00 AM

Electoral college was deliberately put in place to guard against majoritarianism and populism, it is still very necessary.

Jean Racine Oct 7, 2024, 01:16 PM

Ye olde historical revisionism. It mostly came about because of slavery and the concerns of slaving states.

Skinyela Oct 7, 2024, 01:53 PM

"mostly" Since you quantified all the reasons, pray tell what were the other ones? Do they still obtain, since slavery no longer does? It'll mean that today it is "mostly" and solely about the other reasons, because slavery is no more.

Skinyela Oct 7, 2024, 02:47 PM

“mostly” Since you quantified all the reasons, pray tell what were the other ones? Do they still obtain, since slavery no longer does? It’ll mean that today it is “mostly” and solely about the other reasons, because slavery is no more.

Skinyela Oct 7, 2024, 10:08 AM

Electoral college was deliberately put in place to guard against majoritarianism and populism, it is still very necessary. Nothing immoral and illegal about it.

jsiebrits Oct 7, 2024, 10:38 AM

So do you think we should do the same? And give disproportionate influence to Northwest Province, Northern Cape, etc?

Skinyela Oct 7, 2024, 11:28 AM

Compare the progress of USA, 30 years from the adoption of the electoral college system, with the progress of RSA 30 years from 1994... That's where you'll find the answer to your own question my dear.

jsiebrits Oct 7, 2024, 12:02 PM

Are you somehow comparing the progress of the US in the latter stages of the 18th century with SA's development in the last 30 years? Strange things to compare.

B M Oct 7, 2024, 10:33 PM

"to guard against majoritarianism and populism": what is Democracy, if not that?

jsiebrits Oct 8, 2024, 12:39 AM

Democracy should be better than crude majoritarianism, if there is a sound constitution and and human rights are entrenched.

superjase Oct 7, 2024, 12:10 PM

the US is a democratic republic. it was set up with an electoral college to ensure that the smaller states (by population) who joined the union wouldn't be overpowered by the larger states. this allows (allowed) smaller states to feel comfortable joining the union.

Biff Trotters Oct 7, 2024, 01:24 PM

Seems the utility of the Electoral College has run its course, now its merely convention or habit.

Craig King Oct 7, 2024, 10:29 AM

In the likely event that Trump wins the Electoral College vote it is extremely unlikely he will be allowed to take office. Given the remarkable efforts made to destroy his first term, then the attempts to keep him off the ballot this time, no doubt something will be used to deny him this time.

cwf5108@gmail.com Oct 7, 2024, 01:45 PM

All politicians lie - possibly only exception is the Argentinian President. Kamilla is either mis-informed about numerous things such as the fact that Biden started both the Ukranian invasion as well as the Israeli massacre & that USA is involved in at least 30 wars currently. Stupidity.

jsiebrits Oct 7, 2024, 02:56 PM

Biden started the Ukrainian invasion? Is he a Russian military officer?

Biff Trotters Oct 7, 2024, 04:44 PM

No silly, he's a Hamas General.

Biff Trotters Oct 7, 2024, 04:54 PM

I don't know so much. Your revered Argentinian President used a monologue from the TV series West Wing in his recent speech to the UN. A lot like a lie in my book.

B M Oct 7, 2024, 10:35 PM

How did this comment pass moderation? Where can I find any news source that states the "military operation" by Russia in Ukraine was started by the American president Joe Biden?

Michael Thomlinson Oct 7, 2024, 02:01 PM

Would you rather have a prosecuted fellon as a president or a past prosecutor as a president? Enough said.

Hilary Morris Oct 7, 2024, 04:17 PM

Depressing as all hell to read as much crap in these South African comments as emerge from the increasingly demented mind of the visibly deteriorating Trump. God help us! And that he apparently has the support of the majority of men, says a lot more about men than we need to know!

Just Another Day Oct 7, 2024, 07:06 PM

Voltaire said, “I may not agree with what you have to say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it.” Also saw this - "Given how far the Deep State have gone, not only would Trump be justified in throwing every single corrupt actor behind bars, he would be irresponsible not to.

Skinyela Oct 7, 2024, 08:19 PM

Yeah, and end all the wars in which USA is directly and indirectly involved. "great nations do not fight endless wars" -Trump That will save America a lot of money and improve their economy. Jail those who've been laundering public funds through wars.