Dailymaverick logo

Politics

This article is more than a year old

MIDDLE EAST CRISIS

Thousands march in support of Palestine in Cape Town and Joburg, call for isolation of Israel

Thousands of people marched through the Cape Town CBD on Saturday, 5 October in support of Palestine and the isolation of Israel. A memorandum handed to chairperson of the parliamentary Portfolio Committee on International Relations Supra Mahumapelo called for the implementation of the International Convention on the Suppression and Punishment of the Crime of Apartheid.
Thousands march in support of Palestine in Cape Town and Joburg, call for isolation of Israel Pro-Palestine demonstrators march through central Cape Town on 5 October 2024. (Photo: Per-Anders Pettersson / Getty Images)

The handover of the memorandum calling for South Africa to isolate Israel through the enactment of sanctions and boycotts was the culmination of the march led by the Palestine Solidarity Campaign (PSC).

Mahumapelo assured the protesters that National Assembly Speaker Thoko Didiza would receive the memorandum and give feedback on its demands.

“We know that this is a struggle not only of the people of South Africa. We know as Parliament that we don’t exist by ourselves but we exist on behalf of the people. We are an instrument of democracy that must be used by the people to advance the cause of the revolution,” he said. 

The march came almost a year after the 7 October 2023 Hamas assault on Israel that killed 1,200 people. Since then, Israeli forces have killed about 41,802 people in the Gaza Strip, according to the Palestine Ministry of Health in Gaza. The conflict has been described by many activists in South Africa and other countries as a genocide against the Palestinians.

Read more: ‘So many devastating events’ — Humanitarian organisations call for immediate ceasefire in Lebanon and Gaza

In a recent escalation in the Middle East conflict, the Israeli military has warned people to evacuate areas in southern Lebanon that are outside a UN-declared buffer zone, indicating that it may widen the ground operation launched last week against Hezbollah, a Lebanese Islamist political party and militant group that has launched attacks across the Israel-Lebanon border in a show of support for Palestine.

At Saturday’s protest, people held signs with messages such as “Apartheid is a breeding ground for genocide” and “End the killing”. Among the organisations represented at the event were Equal Education, Gift of the Givers, the Congress of South African Trade Unions, the Housing Assembly and the Western Province Council of Churches.

Demonstrators on the pro-Palestinian march in Cape Town on 5 October 2024. (Photo: Per-Anders Pettersson / Getty Images)
Demonstrators on the pro-Palestinian march in Cape Town on 5 October 2024. (Photo: Per-Anders Pettersson / Getty Images)

Call for sanctions

The memorandum calls for an “end [to] apartheid and genocide in Palestine” and demands that Parliament adopt the International Convention on the Suppression and Punishment of the Crime of Apartheid.

“Our Apartheid Convention Bill, to be tabled in Parliament as a private member’s bill, is based on the 1973 International Convention on the Suppression and Punishment of the Crime of Apartheid… South Africa acceded to the Convention on 14 May 2024 and the Convention entered into force for South Africa on 13 June 2024. Our accession to the Convention was informed directly by our experience of Apartheid in South Africa… The Convention declares apartheid a crime against humanity,” the memorandum reads.

According to the memorandum, passing the Apartheid Convention Bill into law will pave the way for South Africa to make boycotts, sanctions and divestment against Israel compulsory and mandatory, as well as prosecute and punish all those implementing or supporting apartheid anywhere in the world.

A woman displays a picture of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu during a pro-Palestinians demonstration on October 5, 2024 in Cape Town, South Africa. Pro-Palestinian demonstrators are participating in national marches across EMEA to mark the start of Israel's war in Gaza after the Hamas attacks of October 7th 2023. They are calling for a ceasefire in the Middle East and an end to the supply of arms to Israel. (Photo: Per-Anders Pettersson / Getty Images)
A marcher displays a picture of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu during the pro-Palestinine demonstration in Cape Town on 5 October 2024. (Photo: Per-Anders Pettersson / Getty Images)

The protesters further called on the South African government to:

  • Give effect to United Nations Resolution 377A, the Uniting for Peace resolution, for an immediate ceasefire and an “end to the genocide and daily terror against the Palestinians and the people of Lebanon, Syria, Yemen and the rest of the Middle East”;
  • Support the return of land and property to Palestinians, along with adequate compensation and reparations; and
  • Declare Zionism an “illegal, racist ideology”, to be outlawed internationally.

March for ‘humanity’

Speaking at the march, Gift of the Givers CEO Imtiaz Sooliman referenced the case brought by South Africa at the International Court of Justice, seeking provisional measures in order to “protect against further, severe and irreparable harm to the rights of the Palestinian people under the Genocide Convention” and to ensure Israel’s compliance with its obligations under the convention. 

South Africa is due to file its memorial to the ICJ in October, which will provide facts and evidence that Israel is committing the crime of genocide in Palestine, according to the Department of International Relations and Cooperation.

“South Africa congratulates you, we stand by you and we thank you,” said Sooliman about the ICJ case.

“The Palestinians have only one request – raise your voice; speak for us; don’t forget us… Let’s carry on the message. We’re preaching to those who don’t understand.”

A boy waves a flag during a pro-Palestinians demonstration on October 5, 2024 in Cape Town, South Africa. Pro-Palestinian demonstrators are participating in national marches across EMEA to mark the start of Israel's war in Gaza after the Hamas attacks of October 7th 2023. They are calling for a ceasefire in the Middle East and an end to the supply of arms to Israel. (Photo:Per-Anders Pettersson / Getty Images)
Pro-Palestinian marchers in Cape Town on 5 October 2024. (Photo:Per-Anders Pettersson / Getty Images)
A boy displays a wooden gun during a pro-Palestinians demonstration on October 5, 2024 in Cape Town, South Africa. Pro-Palestinian demonstrators are participating in national marches across EMEA to mark the start of Israel's war in Gaza after the Hamas attacks of October 7th 2023. They are calling for a ceasefire in the Middle East and an end to the supply of arms to Israel. (Photo: Per-Anders Pettersson / Getty Images)
A boy with a wooden gun during the pro-Palestine march in Cape Town on 5 October 2024. The protest, along with another in Johannesburg, marked the start of Israel's war in Gaza following the Hamas attacks on 7 October 2023. (Photo: Per-Anders Pettersson / Getty Images)
Women demonstrate during a pro-Palestinians demonstration on October 5, 2024 in Cape Town, South Africa. Pro-Palestinian demonstrators are participating in national marches across EMEA to mark the start of Israel's war in Gaza after the Hamas attacks of October 7th 2023. They are calling for a ceasefire in the Middle East and an end to the supply of arms to Israel. (Photo: Per-Anders Pettersson / Getty Images)
Demonstrators at the Cape Town march in support of the Palestinians on 5 October 2024. (Photo: Per-Anders Pettersson / Getty Images)

Rafeeqah Watson, one of the marchers, said she was there not only to support Palestinians but humanity too.

“It’s not just the Muslims being oppressed in Palestine and across the world. It’s many other religions as well. We’re here to stand up for those who are unable to and who are being murdered in Palestine and across the world,” she said.

South African Zionist Federation (SAZF) spokesperson Rolene Marks told Daily Maverick that the SAZF “vehemently rejects” calls to isolate Israel and boycott Israeli products in South Africa. 

“Those calling for sanctions against Israel – a democratic nation defending itself against terrorism – remain conspicuously silent on the actual human rights abuses and war crimes committed by Hamas, Hezbollah and other terrorist organisations, as well as the countries supporting them. This selective outrage not only undermines the credibility of the protesters but also exposes their true motives,” she said.

Marks said the South African Jewish community called for the return of hostages and for terror groups to lay down arms in the lead-up to 7 October.

According to GroundUp, hundreds of people gathered outside the US consulate in Sandton, Johannesburg, on Saturday to protest against Israel and condemn the US’ role supporting Israel’s bombardment of Gaza. They included members of the South African Lebanese community, who joined the protest in light of the spread of the conflict to Lebanon. DM

Comments

Stef Terblanche Oct 7, 2024, 01:18 PM

"We know as Parliament that we don’t exist by ourselves but we exist on behalf of the people." I am one of those people, as are millions of other South Africans who do not agree with the vitriol and bloodthirsty hatred spewed at the Cape Town march. Act on our behalf too please.

Peter Geddes Oct 7, 2024, 01:41 PM

Now I can feel proud about the Cape Town community. It kind of makes up for that Russian frigate berthed in Simonstown.

Michael Thomlinson Oct 7, 2024, 01:54 PM

Nobody mentions that Hezbollah has fired 1000's of rockets into northern Israel since 8 Oct 2023. Must Israel simply give this small land away that they have fought so hard to keep? Much like EWC the Palestinians think they will get Israeli farms and businesses. Sounds like the Holocast all over?

Malcolm McManus Oct 7, 2024, 02:25 PM

Thats the good thing about democratic countries. Your allowed to march and protest. Women can also show their faces in public as per the pictures. Try that in some of the countries our marchers support.

JP K Oct 7, 2024, 06:56 PM

How do you square Israel being democratic with the finding by all major human rights organizations that Israel is an Apartheid state & the finding by the ICJ that it's an occupying power? When assessing war crimes of what concern is it whether the country committing them is a democracy or not?

Peter Dexter Nov 12, 2024, 10:58 AM

I would suggest inhabitants (because they couldn’t be called citizens) in surrounding Islamic countries don’t have equal rights either. The rights of a Jew or Christian in Iran for example. Is that apartheid? The cause? Religion! No proof of these Gods but ample faith to kill millions.

piet64 Oct 8, 2024, 11:00 AM

Spot on! That's the elephant in the room. We now even have Queers for Palestine, f.f.s! This has in fact got little to do with Palestine and everything to do with Critical Theory.

JP K Oct 8, 2024, 08:48 PM

How do you square Israel being democratic with the finding by all major human rights organizations that Israel is an Apartheid state & the finding by the ICJ that it’s an occupying power? When assessing war crimes of what concern is it whether the country committing them is a democracy or not?

Malcolm McManus Oct 9, 2024, 06:42 AM

Because, very possibly the militant leaders of the surrounding non democratic countries would not be in power repeatedly attacking Israel. Maybe there would be more receptive dialogue between these forever hostile forces including Israel.

JP K Oct 9, 2024, 08:13 AM

My question was plain: how can you call Israel democratic when it is an occupier (an aggression) and an Apartheid state since these are not compatible? How does having enemies excuse, for example, Apartheid?

JP K Oct 8, 2024, 09:09 PM

Re. legal definition of genocide vs your dictionary. So you think the genocide convention and the lawyer who interpret it have the definition of genocide wrong? Why would you choose a 2 sentence definition over a convention?

Malcolm McManus Oct 9, 2024, 06:39 AM

Yes, Hitler held conventions. It doesn't make conventions right. Why redefine plain english, just to suit the legal fraternities agenda, particularly when its so far off from what the ICJ legal fraternity came up with. Rather apply for an addendum to the words Genocide, and woman.

JP K Oct 9, 2024, 02:57 PM

MM. Convention = treaty. It's not about redefining. It's about defining with precision required for practical application and party agreement. Any contract begins with defining terms. Why do they do that?

Malcolm McManus Oct 9, 2024, 06:40 AM

And if the legal fraternity doesn't concoct legal BS, then why isn't Zuma in jail.

JP K Oct 9, 2024, 03:01 PM

Did anyone say the law is perfect? Even though it's a truism that it's not, how does it then follow that one should rely on one's dictionary instead?

Scott Gordon Oct 7, 2024, 10:04 PM

The Palestinians do have legitimate gripes . ' Settlers ' ?? What if Hamas / Hezbollah stepped back from the elimination of Israel ? What will Israel do in return ? Clear out the settlers ? Cut the barriers ? Egypt could be more proactive on their border :-)

Roke Wood Oct 8, 2024, 07:43 AM

Its good to see people exercising their rights to picket and protest peacefully. I However, do not agree that Isreals PM is the "devil". Isreal came under an unprovoked attack from Hamas a year ago. Since then Isreal has sought to defend itself, not just from Hamas, but also Hez, houties and Iran.

Roke Wood Oct 8, 2024, 07:55 AM

apartheid? genocide? - ive lived apartheid and this is not it. genocide is the mass extermination of a populace, usualy along racial or cultural grounds. Hamas started the unprovoked shelling of Isreal a year ago, thats indisputable. Palestine is not recognised as a sovereign country anyway.

JP K Oct 8, 2024, 08:18 AM

Apart from relying on your own intuition, have you engaged with any of the literature on the matter (e.g. human rights organisations' reports on Apartheid in Israel or genocide/state crime scholarship?). Have you lived under occupation? Do you think it's benign?

Roke Wood Oct 8, 2024, 09:16 AM

Facts - 1 Isreal does not occupy Gaza. 2, Gaza was given to Palestine by Egypt from a mandate Egypt had with Britain. 3. Hamas started shelling Isreal. 4. Hamas operates from Gaza. 5. Isreal retaliated to Hamas' shelling as it is entitled to do. 6 Palestine is not recognised as a state.

manicm Oct 8, 2024, 10:26 AM

Gaza was not 'given' to Palestine, and in 2005 it was subject to severe blockades and restrictions. You are distorting facts and history. Israel occupies the West Bank which is Palestinian land.

Roke Wood Oct 8, 2024, 01:55 PM

West Bank was no Palestinian land - "The Jordanian administration of the West Bank officially began on April 24, 1950, and ended with the decision to sever ties on July 31, 1988" - it was Jordans land which they ceded to Isreal in 1988. any claim Palestine may have had was annexed by Jordan.

JP K Oct 8, 2024, 11:07 AM

Are you aware of the ICJ advisory opinion on the matter of occupation? As an adv of the high court and someone with legal training, on what basis do you disregard the court's findings? You say no genocide. Have you engaged with literature on genocide and the SA ICJ application?

Roke Wood Oct 8, 2024, 01:49 PM

its not a genocide....rwanda was a genocide. almost any war or occupation of another countries territory under military control which may result in a few civilian deaths may be "classified" as "genocide"...besides I am allowed to disagree with an opinion..its not binding on certain states.

Malcolm McManus Oct 8, 2024, 02:02 PM

Before we go as far as the ICJ, perhaps the legal fraternity may want to consult the oxford english dictionary. I have observed that the legal fraternity appears to re imagine words, such as "genocide", "woman" etc, depending on the legal imagination of the relevant legal expert/experts.

JP K Oct 8, 2024, 08:47 PM

I asked previously on what basis you dismiss the court's findings. Do you have an argument? As for genocide, I asked if you engaged with literature. Because it seems you have an interpretation not based in law or political science. So again, on what basis do you claim it's not when scholars do?

Roke Wood Oct 9, 2024, 06:56 AM

genocide-"the DELIBRATE killing of a large number of people from a particular nation or ethnic group with the aim of DESTROYING that nation or group- the aim is to annihilate a nation/group. Rwanda was genocide, not war, a result of wars are civilian casualties, that does not equate to genocide.

Roke Wood Oct 9, 2024, 07:27 AM

Malcolm - the ICJ- "The key principle is that the Court only has jurisdiction on the basis of consent. The court has no true compulsory jurisdiction. Jurisdiction is often a key question for the Court, because it is challenged by the respondent. " thats called international law - jurisdiction.

JP K Oct 9, 2024, 08:18 AM

@Roke Collateral damage happens. Sure. But if it were only that, Israel wouldn't be facing genocide charges. E.g., what do you make of starvation as a weapon of war? That's hardly collateral damage and seemingly is based on intent to destroy a people rather than a military objective

JP K Oct 9, 2024, 08:21 AM

@Roke anyway, I asked if you engaged with the literature on genocide. E.g. any genocide scholars? Any political science scholars? Any IHL experts? Because the majority argue that Israel is committing genocide...

Roke Wood Oct 9, 2024, 09:06 AM

JP...im sure you've heard the phrase -"playing the devils advocate" thats exactly what ive been doing here. Its an important tool to spur on proper debate about important issues. you can air your views/opinion and should not be judged by them. that you are expressing your views is important.

Roke Wood Oct 9, 2024, 09:19 AM

jp -in short, It cannot be denied that Isreal has played its part in this, the same can be said for Hamas, Hez, Houties and Iran. My real concern is that the situation blows into a full blown war, with Iran and the USA waiting in the wings. such a war would be catastrophic to all concerned.

JP K Oct 9, 2024, 10:03 AM

@Roke you're evading straightforward questions. Your statements are controversial, which is fine. But you cannot support them (e.g. dismissing the ICJ based on your right to disagree and nothing else). Which is not fine and not does "spur proper debate" as you apparently desire.

Roke Wood Oct 9, 2024, 10:30 AM

jp - keep in mind that when u focus your attack on the opposition and not the case at hand it shows that you have nothing left but to attack ur opponent which is exactly what you are doing, of course thats your choice. Ill not respond on this article any longer, suffice to say I agree to disagree.

JP K Oct 9, 2024, 11:41 AM

@Roke Even in responding you continue to dodge the issue: you are unable to support your claims. What you have said relating to no apartheid, no occupation, no genocide is there for everyone to see. But experts on those matters disagree. Human rights organisations, the ICJ, scholars.

David Jeannot Oct 9, 2024, 03:02 PM

Conducting thousands of phone calls, dropping millions of leaflets, sending millions of texts, using knock-knock bombs, demarcating safe zones for civilians, and providing time windows for citizens to flee... I don't recall the Hutus doing any of this for the Tsutsis in Rwanda or the Serbs :-/.

dexmoodl Oct 8, 2024, 09:34 AM

The suprise is that there is no comment by the South African Jewish Board of Deputies , only the South African Zionist Federation

Terril Scott Oct 8, 2024, 03:20 PM

Easy to collect a mob when unemployment is at 40%. Remember this: a mob does not have a brain.

Malcolm McManus Oct 8, 2024, 03:58 PM

Aaah yes, particularly in that neck of the woods where spook and diesel is so popular after a good gathering.

JP K Oct 8, 2024, 09:05 PM

The crowd I was part of did include some opportunistic political party supporters but they were few. On what basis do you dismiss the crowd as a "mob without a brain" and not people who care about human rights violations and who wish to show solidarity with victims thereof?

Robert de Vos Oct 9, 2024, 06:20 PM

Palestine? Where's that? Apartheid? In Israel? Is that similar to the various cultural groups in SA hating each other? Do you see Muslims next door to black Africans, and Hindu Indians living next door to Muslims or Blacks? The unifying factor in this march is the hatred of the Jews. As usual.