Dailymaverick logo

Newsdeck

This article is more than a year old

Newsdeck

'Indescribable' crew errors led to Sicily shipwreck, yacht maker says

MILAN, Aug 22 (Reuters) - A series of "indescribable, unreasonable errors" by the crew led to the shipwreck in which British tech entrepreneur Mike Lynch and six others died earlier this week, the yacht manufacturer'sCEO told Reuters on Thursday.
Reuters
Tori-Peter-saffas-yacht Main option A handout photo made available on 19 August 2024 by Perini Navi Press Office shows the 'Bayesian' sailing boat, in Palermo, Sicily, Italy. At least one person died, six remain missing and 15 passengers were rescued, after a 56-meter-long luxury sailboat, the Bayesian, with 22 people on board, sank at dawn on 19 August off Porticello, near Palermo, after a tornado hit the area. (Photo: EPA-EFE / PERINI NAVI PRESS OFFICE)

By Matteo Negri

The British-flagged Bayesian, a 56-metre-long (184-foot) superyacht with 22 people aboard - 12 passengers and 10 crew - capsized and sank on Monday within minutes of being hit by a pre-dawn storm while anchored off the coast of northern Sicily.

"The boat suffered a series of indescribable, unreasonable errors, the impossible happened on that boat ... but it went down because it took on water. From where, the investigators will tell," Giovanni Costantino said in an interview.

Costantino helms The Italian Sea Group TISGR.MI, which includes Perini Navi, the Italian high-end yacht maker that built the Bayesian in 2008. The vessel has been refitted twice, last in 2020, but not by Perini.

The CEO ruled out any design or construction errors, which he called unlikely after 16 years of trouble-free navigation, including in more severe weather than on Monday.

He blamed the Bayesian's crew for the "incredible mistake" of not being prepared for the storm, which had been announced in shipping forecasts. "This is the mistake that cries out for vengeance," he said.

Costantino said passengers should have been summoned out of their cabins and assembled at a point of safety while the boat was being prepared for the storm by pulling up the anchor, closing doors and hatches, lowering the keel to increase stability and other measures.

Six out of 12 passengers died in the shipwreck, and five bodies were found inside the wreck. Emergency services are still trying to locate the body of the last missing person, Lynch's daughter Hannah.

Had correct procedures been followed, all passengers would have gone back to sleep after one hour "and the next morning they would have happily resumed their wonderful cruise," Costantino said.

Another yacht anchored near the Bayesian escaped unharmed. The captain of the sunken yacht and other crew members have not commented publicly on the disaster, while Italian prosecutors investigating it are due to hold a press conference on Saturday.

 

(Reporting by Matteo Negri; Writing by Alvise Armellini; Editing by Richard Chang)

Comments

Loading your account…
g***r@g***.com 23 August 2024 07:29 AM

Comments from Constantino blaming crew and making allegations of incompetence, before an investigation is completed and report is issued, exposes his real intent to deflect, at an early stage, any possible concern that this particular Perini Navi design may have had design deficiencies. Idiot.

MT Wessels 23 August 2024 10:41 PM

Knee-jerk, exactly. Plane goes down and the manufacturer blames the pilots; might be, might not be - Boeing 737 Max case in point. This guy has done his brand a disservice. Idiot indeed.

Megan McDonald 23 August 2024 11:14 AM

To blame the crew after this horrendous incident with searches ongoing is despicable.

Tony Gomes 23 August 2024 10:57 PM

Despicable is a strong word. I must wonder why they didn't lower the keel or raise anchor. If not with a huge storm approaching, then when if ever?

Pieter van de Venter 24 August 2024 06:11 AM

Sounds like the Dept of Education of Gauteng. They know everything before asking anybody a thing.

j***y@f***.co.za 25 August 2024 08:11 AM

Great comment!

David van der Want 25 August 2024 08:52 AM

In 2023 over 3000 people drowned in boats that sank in the Mediterranean.

johnbpatson 25 August 2024 10:07 AM

Captain and deck crew escaped all right. Leaving the cook and passengers to die horrendous deaths as air pockets they swam into found filled with water. I am surprised the Italians are letting the captain leave the country. Even if you sail a dingy you prepare for a storm. This captain did not