Dailymaverick logo

Maverick News

This article is more than a year old

AMABHUNGANE

Alleged gang boss goes big — Ralph Stanfield ‘in bed’ with Old Mutual, Atterbury

An amaBhungane and Daily Maverick investigation reveals how entities and associates linked to gang boss accused Ralph Stanfield and his wife, Nicole Johnson, tie them to a R3bn Cape Town industrial development property project — with the blessing of developers Atterbury and Old Mutual.
Alleged gang boss goes big — Ralph Stanfield ‘in bed’ with Old Mutual, Atterbury Ralph Stanfield appears in court on 16 September 2023. (Photo: Gallo Images / Die Burger / Jaco Marais)

Key takeaways

  • The Cape Flats Liberators, a community-based organisation, was instrumental in having businesses associated with the alleged leader of the notorious 28s gang, Ralph Stanfield, and his wife, Nicole Johnson, subcontracted to the R3-billion King Air Industria construction project in Cape Town;
  • For the industrial site to be developed, Atterbury Group and Old Mutual Property’s King Air Industria joint venture signed agreements with the Cape Flats Liberators, whose sole director is Stanfield’s sister Francisca Stanfield;
  • Johnson’s Glomix House Brokers, whose companies have been blacklisted by the National Treasury and the City of Cape Town, was paid R7.2-million for construction work at the King Air Industria site.

Ralph Stanfield, the alleged head of the notorious 28s organised crime gang, and his criminally co-accused wife Nicole Johnson have raked in millions of rands after becoming embedded in the construction of the R3-billion King Air Industria project adjoining Cape Town International Airport.

Ralph Stanfield and his wife Nicole Johnson at the Cape Town Regional Court on 16 September 2023. (Photo: Gallo Images / Die Burger / Jaco Marais)
Ralph Stanfield and his wife Nicole Johnson at the Cape Town Regional Court on 16 September 2023. (Photo: Gallo Images / Die Burger / Jaco Marais)

An amaBhungane and Daily Maverick investigation reveals that Stanfield and Johnson’s construction and business empire became engaged with the King Air development through the Cape Flats Liberators (CFL), an obscure Cape Town entity styled as a “community-based organisation”.

At least one source with knowledge of police investigations into Stanfield and Johnson’s commercial endeavours claims that the multibillion-rand development became one of their largest “legitimate revenue streams”.

The emergence of Stanfield and Johnson’s links to King Air’s construction has shone a light on their extensive commercial enterprise, which allegedly feeds from and into a broader landscape populated by allegations of murder, threats, extortion, police investigations and a lengthening list of arrests.

Read more in Daily Maverick: Spate of shootings in Cape Town linked to political, gang and construction mafia elements

Both Stanfield and Johnson have been detained without bail since September after their arrests for fraud and car theft.

King Air Industria. (Photo: Supplied)
King Air Industria. (Photo: Supplied)

The King Air project appears to be a significant step up for the couple, whose associated businesses had previously done work mainly for the City of Cape Town before being blacklisted by the metro.

It also represents a concerning mainstreaming of what the Global Initiative Against Transnational Organized Crime has dubbed Cape Town’s extortion economy, especially given that Stanfield and Johnson appear to have been onboarded without demur by Atterbury and Old Mutual because they can “deliver”.

Attorney Frans Mashele, who represents Stanfield and Johnson, declined to comment, stating that he did not have instructions to do so.

The 71-hectare King Air site is under development by the international commercial property giant Atterbury Group and is financed by South Africa’s Old Mutual Property.

Atterbury Property, a subdivision of Atterbury Group, has a 99-year lease on the land it leases from the former King David Golf Club.

The King Air Industria business entity was created by Atterbury Property and Old Mutual when they formed an equal-share joint venture. Its directors are Atterbury Property’s Western Cape head of development, Gerrit van den Berg, and chief financial officer, Dawid Kemp, along with Old Mutual Investment Group Property Investments’ deal originator, Robin Bugler, and strategic adviser, Darryl Mayers.

AmaBhungane and Daily Maverick have learnt that Van den Berg and other executives met Stanfield and Johnson on several occasions over the years as part of the King Air development.

Ralph Stanfield and his wife Nicole Johnson appear in the Khayelitsha Regional Court on 1 November 2019. (Photo: Gallo Images / Nasief Manie)
Ralph Stanfield and his wife Nicole Johnson appear in the Khayelitsha Regional Court on 1 November 2019. (Photo: Gallo Images / Nasief Manie)

Now we can reveal that this construction is set to benefit the notorious couple thanks to the involvement of their various entities and associated companies, notably via CFL.

King Air is the Western Cape warehousing home of freight companies Morgan Cargo and The Courier Guy, as well as the retailer Truworths.

Construction began in earnest in January 2020. The site is 2km from the Cape Town International Airport in Matroosfontein, parts of which are strongholds of the 28s gang.

The overall construction is expected to be completed within the next seven years and Atterbury’s website states that King Air will eventually house 280,000m² of warehousing, logistics and distribution facilities.

Old Mutual’s spokesperson Nawhal Foster declined to comment and referred all questions to Atterbury Group.

Threats — then, enter the Cape Flats Liberators

Atterbury Group founder and CEO Louis van der Watt told amaBhungane that when King Air’s construction commenced, local community members threatened the main contractor.

He said the main contractor called the police several times for assistance at the site but they could not defuse the situation. As far as they knew, no formal cases were ever registered.

The disruptions were quickly quelled, however, after King Air appointed CFL as its community liaison.

According to sources with knowledge of the CFL, it is little more than a front for Stanfield, with its sole director being his sister Francisca Stanfield.

Francisca Stanfield failed to respond to questions which were WhatsApped to her.

Until his killing in Cape Town’s suburb of Belhar in March 2023, another man linked to Stanfield, Ernest McLaughlin, was also a CFL co-director.

A police investigator previously told the Cape Town Magistrates’ Court that McLaughlin had worked for Stanfield.

Read more in Daily Maverick: Murdered suspect’s signature suggests company ‘linked to 28s gang’ won defence contract

AmaBhungane and Daily Maverick can reveal that the CFL was hired to source unemployed workers and struggling businesses from surrounding communities for King Air’s construction and to identify a community social development organisation whose projects could be funded by Atterbury and Old Mutual.

Among those hired were businesses and associates linked to Stanfield and Johnson, including Johnson’s construction company Glomix House Brokers.

Van der Watt said Glomix was appointed because it was the only community-owned company at the time “that we were aware of, that had the necessary skills and expertise to deliver”.

Charges

Stanfield and Johnson are facing an array of criminal charges.

Some stem from a 2014 case involving allegations that three (now former) police officers at the Central Firearms Register created fraudulent gun licences for them and their associates. The other accused in the case include Francisca Stanfield and, until his murder, McLaughlin.

 Ralph Stanfield at the Cape Town Regional Court on 16 September 2023. (Photo: Gallo Images / Die Burger/Jaco Marais)
Ralph Stanfield at the Cape Town Regional Court on 16 September 2023. Stanfield and his co-accused are on trial on charges related to the illegal acquisition of firearms licences. (Photo: Gallo Images / Die Burger/Jaco Marais)

While out on bail in that matter, Stanfield and Johnson were arrested for fraud and car theft and have been denied bail.

Stanfield also faces an attempted murder charge relating to allegations that in 2022 there were plans to have an employee killed after he allegedly stole R1-million from Stanfield and Johnson.

Read more in Daily Maverick: ‘I want to empty a gun in his head’ – chilling affidavit about alleged 28s gang boss Ralph Stanfield’s ‘plans’

With three co-accused in their latest case, they are due back in the Cape Town Magistrates’ Court on 27 June.

In April, Stanfield’s brother Kyle was arrested for defeating the ends of justice after Stanfield allegedly asked him to remove items — seen as potential evidence — that police planned to seize for their car theft and fraud investigation.

Read more in Daily Maverick: Nearly R5-million cash, luxury watches seized as 28s gang boss accused Ralph Stanfield’s brother arrested

The blacklisting of Glomix

Over the years Glomix has become increasingly controversial. Concerns first surfaced publicly nearly five years ago, when the company was awarded a City of Cape Town tender to build houses in the suburb of Valhalla Park.

Parts of the suburb, which borders King Air, are also 28s strongholds.

In March this year, the National Treasury blacklisted Glomix.

Read more in Daily Maverick: Glomix ban — Treasury blacklists 28s gang case accused Nicole Johnson’s company for 10 years

According to a Treasury document, the City of Cape Town Metropolitan Municipality authorised the blacklisting, which remains in effect until 27 March 2034.

In December 2023, the City of Cape Town confirmed that it had blacklisted seven companies linked to Johnson “based on the risk they pose to the city’s reputation”. This included Glomix.

Last year, Daily Maverick reported that Glomix was still involved in building houses for the city.

Atterbury’s rationale for involving Stanfield in R3bn project

Despite Stanfield and Johnson’s accumulating criminal accusations and the controversy around Glomix, Van der Watt remains unfazed.

Alleged 28s gang leader Ralph Stanfield and his wife, Nicole, outside Cape Town Magistrates’ Court on 17 August, 2021. (Photo: (Photo: Gallo Images / Die Burger)
Alleged 28s gang leader Ralph Stanfield and his wife, Nicole, outside Cape Town Magistrates’ Court on 17 August 2021. (Photo: Gallo Images / Die Burger)

In interviews and written responses, he has confirmed that Stanfield, Johnson, their businesses, associations and associates have been involved in the development.

“While I do not approve of what Stanfield is allegedly doing, it is something for the police and the Western Cape government to sort out. It is the job of the police to investigate, arrest and put people in jail, not mine. If that happens, then I will work with whoever the next person is who the community elects to work on this project.

“I am not saying what we do is the right way, but working with community-elected businesses and people is the only way we can operate in areas like these.

“Do I know that we work where there is a Ralph on the other side? Of course I do.

“Am I happy? Of course I am not.

“But, that is the representative the community has put forward, and as long as the community and the police do not do anything about it, I am not going to say that I am not going to work with this guy.

“To be honest, I do not think it is my problem.

“As long as Ralph continues to represent the community and as long as I don’t have to pay over and above what I should be, then I will continue to work with him.”

Van der Watt said they always looked to involve a local community first.

“That has been a strategic decision of ours since 2010. It is what we did with this project when we involved the Matroosfontein community.”

He said Atterbury was one of the few companies in South Africa that managed to build in certain mafia-controlled areas and did so by involving communities from the onset of their projects.

“We do this because we know the police will not help at all. The sad fact is that the police are simply not interested in sorting out the construction mafia so we are left with no other choice but to adopt our community approach.”

‘Mafias disappear’

“The only way to make the construction mafia disappear is if we ensure we work directly with the communities. The mafias disappear because communities get upset if they [the mafia] become involved in a project.”

Van der Watt said their community approach involved allocating a portion of a project’s monies to local communities.

“We do this in two ways: by employing people and businesses from the community and by funding charities identified by the communities. This includes supporting feeding schemes and paying for children to go to school and university.”

He said that at the beginning of every development they identified who the community leaders were and engaged with them.

“They [the leaders] then appoint a community liaison officer. In this case it was the CFL. We do not care who the liaison officer is as long as the community says that is their representative.

“We pay the liaison officer a salary. It is their job to identify people and businesses from their community who have the necessary skills which we need for a specific project. They also identify the charities which we fund.

“From the onset, we ensure the liaison officers make it known that while we will employ people from the community first, we will not compromise on quality of work and will not pay a premium for work that is to be done.”

The ‘liberators’ playbook

Van der Watt’s breezy deference to “the community” appears to elide a more prosaic process.

A Special Investigating Unit (SIU) statement issued in December 2023 flagged Stanfield and Johnson’s operation as part of the “Construction Mafia”.

Referencing recent successes of the National Priority Committee on Extortion and Violence at Economic Sites, the statement lauded the “notable recent arrest … of alleged 28s gang boss Ralph Stanfield and his wife, Nicole Johnson”.

The SIU claimed that ”several Cape Town construction contractors had to abandon government housing construction sites following alleged acts of intimidation and violence. Thereafter, the Western Cape Government’s human settlements department awarded Johnson’s company, Glomix House Brokers, the contracts for completing these abandoned projects.”

This seems to be how Johnson and Stanfield became involved in the King Air project.

Van der Watt said that after disruptions during the construction’s initial phase, local residents demanded they be hired.

He said the residents then nominated the CFL as their representative whose responsibility was to help find, among the unemployed local residents and struggling businesses, correctly skilled people who could work on the site.

Van der Watt said that the CFL, which stopped the disruptions, was hired and paid R75,000 a month for its services.

He stressed that payments were made only while construction activities were taking place on the site.

“No payments have been made since August 2023, due to no services rendered.”

By amaBhungane and Daily Maverick’s calculations, the CFL would have been paid nearly R3-million for the services it delivered between January 2020 and August 2023.

Asked for a copy of the CFL agreement, including how many local community members and businesses were employed and how much CFL was paid in total, Van der Watt declined to comment and said the agreement was confidential.

AmaBhungane and Daily Maverick have established that among those who were hired thanks to the CFL were Glomix and GParm Protection Services.

Last year, this security company found itself caught up in a vicious spat involving Stanfield and Johnson and the then owners of a controversial Cape Town nightclub and eatery in which Johnson’s mother, Barbara, is a 50% shareholder.

Hopenest

Information uncovered during this investigation shows that as well as the CFL bringing Glomix into the King Air project, it was also instrumental in linking Johnson’s Hopenest Foundation to the development by ensuring it became the preferred “community upliftment partner”.

On its website, Hopenest markets itself as an organisation working in disadvantaged communities running feeding schemes and skills development initiatives while helping to establish community safety programmes.

Van der Watt confirmed that CFL had introduced Hopenest.

Hopenest, according to Companies And Intellectual Property Commission records, was established as a non-profit company in December 2020 with Johnson, her mother, Barbara, and associate Rachel Samantha Abrahams appointed as directors.

Abrahams is also an accused in the fraudulent firearm licences case against Stanfield and Johnson.

Barbara Johnson resigned in September 2023 shortly after Suraya Manuel, who is an accountant, was appointed co-director. Both were arrested in May, along with Glomix’s quantity surveyor, Phakamisa Nondabula.

Their arrests are linked to Kyle Stanfield’s April arrest for defeating the ends of justice charges which relate to his alleged attempts to remove evidence linked to his brother’s case.

Manuel, Nondabula, Kyle and Barbara Johnson were released on R10,000 bail each and are due back in court on 26 July.

Approached for comment, Manuel’s lawyer Bruce Hendricks said he had been instructed not to comment.

How the money flowed to Stanfield, Johnson and Co

Calculations by amaBhungane and Daily Maverick, based on an analysis of data as well as information provided by Atterbury and other sources, suggest that to date Stanfield and Johnson have directly and indirectly earned more than R52.2-million from the King Air development.

The direct payments were to Glomix for the work it did on-site.

The indirect payment sources come from the R210-million the project’s main construction contractor, Abbeydale Cape, paid to the 37 local Matroosfontein-based subcontractors it hired.

Citing confidentiality agreements, Abbeydale Cape’s managing director, Pierre Rousseau, refused to reveal how much the company itself was paid, the identity of its subcontractors or how much these subcontractors were paid.

However, information amaBhungane and Daily Maverick received shows that the company received some R300-million for its work on the project.

Information also suggests that after paying its subcontractors the R210-million, Abbeydale Cape then split the remaining R90-million in half, paying R45-million to Glomix, while keeping the other R45-million.

It is not known what agreement led Abbeydale Cape to pay Glomix this R45-million.

Rousseau described it as “normal practice” for Abbeydale Cape to subcontract 75% of the value of a project’s work. Subcontractors were drawn from a list jointly prepared by their employer’s quantity surveyor.

“Abbeydale Cape has worked with several of these subcontractors before. Local community subcontractors made up a portion of the employed subcontractors.

“The subcontractors in turn subcontracted other subcontractors. Abbeydale Cape’s subcontractors are not required to share the details of the subcontractors they contracted with.”

Rousseau said it was a requirement that their subcontractors were registered with all necessary regulatory bodies that allowed them to qualify for specific work.

He also confirmed that they had interacted with Ralph Stanfield, Kyle Stanfield, Nicole Johnson and her mother after they subcontracted Glomix on to the project.

“Glomix was subcontracted because it is registered with the Construction Industry Development Board (CIDB). A company’s registration and grade with the CIBD is regarded as a licence to trade with the government and as such carries the credibility we require during our screening process.”

AmaBhungane and Daily Maverick have learnt from Van der Watt that Glomix was directly paid R7.2-million for constructing the site’s main gatehouse, irrigation pump room, centralised sprinkler pumps, tanks and electrical substation.

“This is a market-related price for the work done. To be honest, we are very happy with the work, and the fact that we did not overpay for the work that was done.”

But wait, there’s more

AmaBhungane and Daily Maverick have established that there were also other payments, with more allegedly still to come.

These payments were via associates, including the CFL and Hopenest, with whom King Air has signed agreements.

According to Van der Watt, Hopenest was to help identify community development projects to fund.

Asked for copies of the CFL and Hopenest agreements, Van der Watt declined, “as they contain standard confidentiality provisions … [and] we are not able to make it available to third parties without consent”.

He said the Atterbury Trust, which is the social corporate responsibility arm of Atterbury Group, was holding R1.2-million for Hopenest.

“The payment agreement with Hopenest was that it would be paid R37 per m² of land constructed.

“To date, R1.212-million has been set aside for Hopenest. The calculation of this amount is that since the agreement was only concluded after certain buildings were complete, we agreed Hopenest would receive R300,000 in respect of those completed buildings. We have then further developed and sold land, which equates to R912,000.”

Given that King Air will eventually accommodate 280,000m² of warehousing, the community projects identified by Hopenest should, once construction is completed, have received an estimated R10-million.

Asked why Atterbury Trust had not paid over any monies to Hopenest, Van der Watt said it had been unable to provide proof that it was a registered non-profit welfare organisation and that it was tax-compliant.

He said while some discussions were held on the funding of early childhood development, school upgrades and skills development programmes, Hopenest had yet to identify specific projects for this funding.

“Hopenest has not provided reasons as to why it is not registered. There is no deadline for when it has to complete its registration.”

However, amaBhungane and Daily Maverick have learnt that Hopenest’s tax issues were resolved last year.

It is not known whether the lack of government registration is now the only reason Atterbury Trust is not making the R1.2-million available.

Van der Watt stressed that “up to today not a cent has been allocated to Hopenest and will not be until proof is provided.

“The money remains very much under Atterbury Trust’s control. The money will also not go directly to Hopenest. Rather, it will go to identified projects which we will have vetted. Only once Atterbury Trust is happy will the funds be signed off.”

Stanfield’s links to King Air’s security provider

Stanfield and Johnson also have ambitions in the private security industry, apparently inter alia through GParm, which provides security at the King Air site.

GParm also provides security at the Ayepyep Lifestyle Lounge in Cape Town, a nightclub and restaurant previously at the centre of a controversy that also involved Stanfield and Johnson.

Ayepyep’s former owner, Kagiso Setsetse, last year effectively accused Stanfield and Johnson of trying to muscle him out of the business.

Stanfield then made counteraccusations.

The matter became a legal spat and in September 2023, shortly before Stanfield and Johnson were arrested in the fraud and car theft case, it emerged that a settlement had been reached with Setsetse, who sold his Ayepyep Cape Town shares to Barbara Johnson, giving her a 50% stake in the business

Read more in Daily Maverick: Legal settlement – Cape Town luxury venue Ayepyep to reopen after gang and extortion accusations spat

Van der Watt said that GParm was introduced to the King Air project through the CFL.

He emphasised that GParm was chosen from the list of companies that residents provided to the CFL.

“Whether Ralph is involved in security has nothing to do with us,” Van der Watt said.

“We were never threatened [to employ them]. I am happy with the price and with the quality of their work.

“GParm was subjected to due diligence prior to contract negotiations. It has been fulfilling the security at the park for the last three years, on market-related terms and conditions.”

Approached for comment, GParm’s director Sigqibo Sithole said: “I am bound by a confidentiality and non-disclosure agreement. The business is on sale. I am therefore not in a position to comment on any questions on this matter.”

Based on a 2022 report to the City of Cape Town’s human settlements portfolio committee, GParm was previously appointed, along with two companies including Glomix, on a housing project.

The contact person on that report was Siphokazi September.

In January, the city confirmed that September, its then housing director, had been dismissed.

This appears to be linked to allegations by City Manager Lungelo Mbandazayo that officials were “tailor-making” tenders for “companies linked with the underworld”.

“The investigation also saw some of the officials from the Human Settlements Department being suspended and others are attending disciplinary hearings,” Mbandazayo reportedly told the Cape Argus.

Fuelling ambitions 

Van der Watt confirmed that “the community” had tabled the idea of developing a bulk fuel depot, but said the plans had fallen through.

“King Air Industria was approached to develop a bulk fuel depot by members of the community. These were high-level initial discussions. These plans have since been rendered not financially feasible, have subsequently been cancelled and no future plans are in place to develop a fuel depot.”

Stanfield and Johnson co-own a petrol station in Bishop Lavis, Cape Town, and Johnson owns a company, NJ Diesel, which had a bulk supply contract with the City of Cape Town. Van der Watt would not say whether they were involved in the bulk fuel depot project and the facts remain unclear.

What is clear is that Stanfield and Johnson have big ambitions to move into the formal economy and there are enablers on hand to help them do it.

AmaBhungane and Daily Maverick have tracked another major example of this.

Stay tuned. DM

Comments

jcdvil Jun 20, 2024, 06:33 AM

Fantastic in depth article(although the facts make you want to puke)Love of money makes people sicko s

Fanie Rajesh Ngabiso Jun 20, 2024, 05:23 PM

Our entire capitalist society is a monument to greed, and we are all complicit at our own level. To say otherwise is to be dishonest. The law exists to keep balance, and without its proper enforcement society breaks down. The problem here is failure to enforce the law. The rest is symptomatic.

Fanie Rajesh Ngabiso Jun 20, 2024, 07:58 AM

I agree with van der Watt as long as he is not doing amything illegal. This is a policing and societal issue. Our people and honest businesses are being held to ransom by these gangs and law enforcement is responsible for preventing this and making sure our society is safe.

William Kelly Jun 20, 2024, 08:59 AM

Absolutely not. He is complicit and worse, he is feeding the beast. Two wrongs, I am afraid, do not make a right. And no-one said doing the right thing is either easy or profitable. But not doing it creates monsters for the rest of us. In the name of profit and progress. It makes me puke.

Fanie Rajesh Ngabiso Jun 20, 2024, 10:37 AM

If it is legal it is legal. If you hold a single share in a company you are potentially benefiting from crime. Is this your responsibility to monitor? Failure of law enforcement is the problem, the rest is just sad symptoms. (whether or not you puke is irrelevant)

William Kelly Jun 21, 2024, 10:34 PM

If you hold shares in a company it is absolutely your own choice which shares to buy. If you're happy to abdicate any responsibility for how that company makes its money, by paying off criminals in this case, because its easier, then that's your moral choice too.

Fanie Rajesh Ngabiso Jul 3, 2024, 11:48 PM

You completely miss my point William. Corruption exists everywhere, when I invest in Satrix for example I cannot guarantee in any way shape or from that I am not benefiting from corruption. And neither can you. And it is not my responsibility to vet every company contributing to Satrix. It is the responsibility of our legal system and the enforcement thereof. On the same premise the SABS exists to protect me as Fanie Soap from dangerous foodstuffs and products. I assume you too - or do you wander round farms and factories to make sure the toothpaste you buy is safe?

trevorgray8 Jun 20, 2024, 10:21 AM

The submission to racketeering cannot be dismissed in such a cavalier fashion. Same as schoolyard bullying or racism!

Fanie Rajesh Ngabiso Jun 20, 2024, 10:30 AM

I agree. The failure of law enforcement is the problem. The rest is just symptom. The only solution here is to fix law enforcement.

bafanak Jun 20, 2024, 01:06 PM

What are you on? Yes our law enforcement leaves much to be desired but Stanton is in jail. So if I can’t get any more work from an Eskom say, because the procurement chaps will only work with people who take care of them then I’m justified in paying kick backs because I don’t work for the police.

Fanie Rajesh Ngabiso Jun 20, 2024, 02:44 PM

Stop blaming the symptoms - it's boring and useless. Focus on fixing the problem, which is one thing and one thing only: Lack of law enforcement. Resolve this single problem and we will all be happy. You included.

Fanie Rajesh Ngabiso Jun 20, 2024, 02:47 PM

Also I'm not sure how you tie an individual being in jail to rendering a company illegal. They are separate entities and are correctly treated as such. If the company is found to be contravening the law then the law needs to be enforced (as I have already said) and your problem will go away.

Fanie Rajesh Ngabiso Jun 20, 2024, 02:51 PM

And if you say gangs are the problem, which are related to Stanton (sic) then I agree. And again their operations are illegal and can only be stopped by enforcement of the law. It is ALL about lack of law enforcement.

Middle aged Mike Jun 20, 2024, 10:40 AM

"The submission to racketeering cannot be dismissed in such a cavalier fashion." Neither should blame shifting from the organs of state responsible for preventing this in the first place. The cops and NPA do bugger all to stop it and deployed cadres of the glorious liberation movement are involved.

Fanie Rajesh Ngabiso Jun 20, 2024, 12:21 PM

100% agree. This is the point. It is unrealistic to expect citizens to operate perfectly in a mafia state. Fix the damned state. Enforce the law.

Deon.schoeman Jun 20, 2024, 08:20 AM

SA is a crime scene ….

PaulKay K Jun 20, 2024, 08:46 AM

“The only way to make the construction mafia disappear is if we ensure we work directly with the communities. The mafias disappear because communities get upset if they [the mafia] become involved in a project.” So, by consciously employing the mafia itself, the mafia is neutered? Makes sense for the purse strings...

Middle aged Mike Jun 20, 2024, 09:08 AM

I'm seeing this thing as a bit of a binary. If you want to do property development you have to pay the mafia/community protection money because there is no law enforcement. If developers choose not to then I suspect there will be no development. Not sure which is worse.

Fanie Rajesh Ngabiso Jun 20, 2024, 10:09 PM

Business face Hobson's choices in the face of societal breakdown. They should not be put in a position where such choices are necessary. Government - Enforce the law!

Roger Sheppard Jun 21, 2024, 08:47 PM

...and "Hobson's Choice' means there is NO choice! So...make the LAW work! Yes! Agree! HOW: Get Ngabiso into the circuit of search, research, and then ACTION! Get him a uniform, some weapons training & paratroopers fitness, some authority...and we shall all be OK. Great! Ready Fanie M'Boytjie!

Fanie Rajesh Ngabiso Jun 21, 2024, 10:55 PM

Well said random Roger.

Tim Bester Jun 20, 2024, 08:21 AM

Where there be money there be criminals.

JOHN TOWNSEND Jun 20, 2024, 05:10 PM

Agreed. And this is why we need a response from OM. How on earth did they feel they could utilise funds we invest with them in this manner.

Middle aged Mike Jun 20, 2024, 08:46 AM

Fantastic expose, thank you. Shows what happens when the criminal justice system has been offline for a couple of decades. A friend of mine who used to develop commercial properties in predominantly low income areas before he gave up on South Africa and emigrated told me that it was typical for 10 percent or more of a project budget to be spent on gravy for facilitators linked to connected cadres and 'community members'. Faling this planning approvals and such like would drag on forever and pop up protests and property destruction would derail work.

trevorgray8 Jun 20, 2024, 10:18 AM

Business cries about the construction mafia with good reason. However in this case the company involved seems happy to accede to these corrupt players? Were dockets registered? Were are the authorities in this regard? Are the companies involved "off the hook" or blameless? the

Middle aged Mike Jun 20, 2024, 10:42 AM

"W(h)ere are the authorities in this regard? Not a serious question surely?

Bak Steen Jun 20, 2024, 09:10 PM

Please don’t correct a person’s spelling if you understand what they are saying… it’s derogatory and quite frankly pathetic…. Perhaps read your own post again? Punctuation is also important, if not more so. I’m sure your friend that emigrated is much better off now and extremely happy.

Fanie Rajesh Ngabiso Jun 21, 2024, 07:18 AM

He is not correcting for himself but rather to clarify for those reading his comment. Your comment really is OTT and needless.

Middle aged Mike Jun 21, 2024, 02:49 PM

Yawn, again.

holzgusta Jun 20, 2024, 11:30 AM

Should I be worried about Old Mutual's involvement ?? I have a small portfolio at OMW.

Derek Jones Jun 20, 2024, 11:52 AM

I am worried about OM. Definitely.

Donald bemax Jun 20, 2024, 02:53 PM

I agree .. Old Mutual , like many other banking and investment institutions are looking for a buck or two by looking the other way.... investigate and prosecute.. failing which a norm will be established.( if it hasn't been already)

Allrite Jack Jun 20, 2024, 01:13 PM

I have to agree with Van der Watt, the job has to get done. Since the ANC under Zuma, abolished our only effective police unit, the Scorpions, law & order has practically disappeared from South Africa. The only alternative now is to use gangs representing the coloured community but pay market rates.

3608783 Jun 20, 2024, 01:20 PM

a lot of passing the buck from Van der Watt

Middle aged Mike Jun 20, 2024, 01:29 PM

While I find the idea of dealing with the likes of the nice Mr Stansfield repulsive I'm not sure what a developer is supposed to do otherwise short of getting out of the development business.

langeraa Jun 20, 2024, 02:10 PM

Business is business and as long as you remain legal, businesses will do business with whoever is able to produce the best terms and conditions. This is life An argument would be that "in the end the involvement of the Cosa Nostra in trade in New York, ultimately benefitted the people of New York".

EL Williams Jun 20, 2024, 02:48 PM

Old Mutual needs to talk to the thousands of us who have trusted them thus far.

EL Williams Jun 20, 2024, 02:49 PM

Old Mutual needs to talk to the thousands who have trusted them so far.

Charles Parr Jun 20, 2024, 04:33 PM

It appears that the role of the SAPS in not assisting the developer needs to be fully investigated and, if I had to hazard a guess, I'd say that someone high up in the SAPS is protecting his (criminal) turf. It's high time that we demanded proper explanations from public servants for not doing their jobs.

Robert de Vos Jun 20, 2024, 05:38 PM

Bravo! And now when do we see the Old Mutual employees in court?

Middle aged Mike Jun 20, 2024, 06:04 PM

What did they do that you think is illegal?

Bak Steen Jun 20, 2024, 09:40 PM

Mikey, if you do business with someone on a relatively grand scale, it is important to know the ethics of your client or partner. If you choose to ignore ethics and only focus on profitability then you are an accomplice by default. Money flow is a power. We should all learn to use it wisely.

Middle aged Mike Jun 21, 2024, 02:48 PM

I didn't ask for a lesson in business ethics but rather what they commenter thought might be illegal in the OM staffers conduct.

Middle aged Mike Jun 21, 2024, 02:48 PM

I didn't ask for a lesson in business ethics but rather what they commenter thought might be illegal in the OM staffers conduct.

Bak Steen Jun 20, 2024, 09:35 PM

There is a much bigger, underlying issue here… This is Gotham politics. Big business that stands with a corrupt government is always questionable. The protection and encouragement through legislation to grow the SME sector of our economy is where our salvation lies.

Trenton Carr Jun 20, 2024, 10:24 PM

Well what do you know... Looks like crime does pay.

stewart81 Oct 11, 2024, 01:01 PM

There clearly is no functioning justice in SA if people like this alleged criminal can continue their malfeasance and remain almost untouched by the law and aided in their criminality by the likes of Old Mutual. I do not buy the excuse that Stansfield is elected to represent the community! Twaddle!