Can Sean Summers plug the hole in PnP’s basket?

Can Sean Summers plug the hole in PnP’s basket?
(Graphic: Jocelyn Adamson; Images: Midjourney AI)

Ackerman children stay on the board but have fewer powers, while CEO Sean Summers has more freedom to implement sweeping changes, such as paying off debt in a back-to-basics plan.

Not enough investment into its stores and people, poor relationships with suppliers and franchisees, and high dividend payouts have pushed Pick n Pay into a hole that will be difficult — though not impossible — to crawl out of.

Some analysts believe flat sales, trading expenses and startling gross profit margin contraction point to systemic issues at Pick n Pay.

Even if it is not commercially insolvent, PnP is technically insolvent, and throwing more money at the problem will not be enough to see it back in the black.

Soon after he was reappointed, CEO Sean Summers admitted that the damage was largely self-inflicted. Rolling blackouts, crime and a stagnating economy didn’t help. Pick n Pay’s October interim results — showing a 97.5% loss in trading profit — were a reality check. 

“Pick n Pay has fallen out of love with its customers, its people and its suppliers. This is what lies ahead of us. This is why it’s so exciting. Because from here, we only go up,” Summers said.

It was far worse than he could have imagined. This week, it was clear PnP had plunged deeper into the abyss after its results reflected a R3.19-billion loss for the year. Group turnover rose by just 5.4% — saved by its Boxer stores. The discount retailer was up by 17.3% and the Pick n Pay Clothing standalone stores were up by 17%.

Gross profit margin declined from 19.6% to 18.1% and trading expenses rose by almost 12% as a result of higher bad debt and R307-million in employee restructuring costs. Trading profit fell by 87.4% to R385-million.

Jean Pierre Verster from Protea Capital Management said PnP had paid shareholders too much, instead of reinvesting in the business. “This is typical when you have a family that controls the company and wants to distribute as much cash as possible from the company. Pick n Pay was paying out too much capital.”

Ninety One assistant portfolio manager Achumile Mashalaba concurred. “PnP recently dropped the payout ratio, but most recently it was close to 70%. That links to the problem where you are underinvesting in your store base and in your supply chain, because you are paying this money out as dividends,” he said.

Strategic mistake

pnp dividends

(Graphic: Achumile Mashalaba)

Since 2018 and with the exception of 2020, PnP has consistently paid shareholders higher dividends. In 2018, it paid 68.2% compared with Shoprite’s 51.6% and Clicks’ 62.3%. In 2021, PnP paid 78.4%, Shoprite 57.1% and Clicks 61.7%. In the 2023 financial year, the corresponding figures were 69.3%, 57.2% and 65%.

Verster adds that the Ekuseni strategy — to service PnP’s customers through three tailored banners, Pick n Pay, QualiSave and Boxer — was a strategic mistake. Before that, PnP’s biggest headache was its hypermarkets. With QualiSave, Summers’ predecessor Pieter Boone changed the range of the smaller stores, which didn’t work because it was too limited.

“Stores then went from being profitable to becoming loss-making. So instead of just having a problem with the hypermarkets, it now also had a problem with some of the smaller stores.”

The retailer has announced aggressive action to turn the ship around. It will recapitalise the business through a R4-billion rights offer, in which the Ackerman family relinquish their majority stake and hope to raise between R6-billion and R8-billion from Boxer’s listing on the JSE later this year. 

Gareth Ackerman will step down as chairperson. The Ackerman family are following their rights and have also committed R1-billion towards the recapitalisation, and the three Ackerman children — Gareth, Suzanne and Jonathan — will remain on the board, but no longer nominate the chair, CEO and chief financial officer.

Summers has more freedom to implement management’s sweeping changes, which include closing the loss-making stores, scrapping the QualiSave brand and converting them back to PnP stores, and paying off debt as part of a “back-to-basics” plan.

It’s going to be painful. Mashalaba said Shoprite had painted PnP into a tight corner because it had focused on South Africa, where it invested billions in stores. “It’s made it extremely tough for other competitors because shoppers don’t really have a reason to shop [elsewhere] any more.”

PnP’s sales growth numbers of -2% were staggeringly low, he said. “Generally, food retailers benefit from higher inflation because it is supposed to add to their top line. It speaks to a really struggling business.”

Broken relationships

PnP also has to fix broken relationships with franchisees. Summers said franchisees had been brought back into the fold. “I can say without any shadow of a doubt that at the moment, our relationships with franchisees in the main are better than they’ve been for a long time.”

Its fraught relationships with suppliers was another sticking point that affected PnP’s promotional ability. Mashalaba said the turnaround strategy was a good way to ensure PnP’s survival, but the retailer would look different in future. “It will be a smaller business. The cash injection will allow them to pay off their debt and also reinvest into the store offering. It won’t be the old PnP as we know it.”

Having about R12-billion in the kitty will make a big difference, but it will be at least two years before PnP breaks even and three years before it turns a profit.

It’s not just a case of fixing the balance sheet: PnP’s problems are bigger than just debt. While it has been struggling and focused internally, Shoprite has been improving its footprint and its offering, especially in areas like meat, bakery and fresh produce, and Spar has improved its fresh and ready-meal offerings, Verster said.

“Many customers switched from PnP to Checkers or Spar. Pick n Pay has a lot to fix, and the jury is still out on whether they can fix the business.”

Customers have also changed. No longer doing “big shops” at the hypermarket, they’re time-poor and opting for convenience.

Pick n Pay is highly leveraged and has identified 194 stores that are underperforming — 112 of which are operating at a loss.

There are some rays of hope: Boxer grew sales by 17.3% and opened 50 new stores. Pick n Pay Clothing opened 58 stores and delivered market-leading sales growth from its standalone stores.

And online sales are doing well: e-commerce is up by 74.4%, mostly attributable to 102.3% year-on-year growth from its on-demand platform asap! and sales of Pick n Pay groceries on Takealot’s Mr D app. DM

This story first appeared in our weekly Daily Maverick 168 newspaper, which is available countrywide for R29.


Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • Geoff Coles says:

    PnP by and large is now too expensive across the range.

  • Rae Earl says:

    I’ll go back to Pick ‘n Pay as a welcome customer when it teaches its staff at the tills to treat me like a customer instead of a time wasting nuisance. Woollies is outstanding in this respect and Checkers and Spar are really good. P&P is dismal and their stores stopped being inviting places to visit years ago.

    • Miss Jellybean says:

      Staff attitude has always been a problem at PnP even way back in the 1990’s

    • Jane Crankshaw says:

      A tragedy to see such unmotivated staff – PnP need to motivate, incentivise staff and create some pride back into the business so that the staff actually enjoy working for the business which in turn makes customers want to shop there. More equitable salaries might be a good idea – a R25m golden handshake to the outgoing CEO and a R2m a month salary for the old/new CEO whilst workers struggle on minimum wages doesn’t inspire pride and loyalty!

  • Rob Blake says:

    There are not many +70 year old CEO’s that have been successful in turning large corporates around. I doubt that Sean is going to succeed. It will require a younger individual with the requisite energy levels to achieve this.

  • Fanie Rajesh Ngabiso says:

    The Ackerman family were fierce advocates of equal rights for all under the apartheid government and Raymond Ackerman was the first to come out with the select your own items and pay at the till approach to supermarkets in South Africa, massively cutting consumer shopping costs.

    While I know history isn’t everything, the Ackermans have built a wonderful South African institution for us all and I for one hope it succeeds. The day we have to live in a Shoprite Checkers only world will be a sad one for us all.

  • Agf Agf says:

    It has been said time and time again in these comments sections; Pick n Pay has to do something about their appalling staff, particularly the cashiers. They are sullen and unhelpful. Asking “Plestik?”, is just terrible and has become a bit of a joke. The stores are grimy and just have a low class feel to them. There is something about the ambiance that puts one off. Surely management can see it? Walk across to a Checkers or a Woolies and it is so apparent.

  • Mkulu Clive says:

    I have just returned from shopping at the Durban North Hypermarket by the Sea. It’s worse than a mortuary in atmosphere and hardly any customers.
    The staff have been slovenly and not helpful for years. I hope Sean Summers has fired the Management.
    It is glaringly obvious what needs to be done at this once flagship store, it is now a shit house!
    I have been shopping there since the it started in the early 80s, it rocked and rolled with the greatest manager in a wheel chair, bring him back too, he’s the same age as Sean if he is alive.
    Sean if you read this, you can contact me on this email [email protected]
    Spar and ShopRite are eating what was once your breakfast.
    Your staff don’t have a clue how to sell or treat customers.
    I am not going to state anymore on this post, so contact if you want some more from a guy a little younger by a year or so than you!

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted


This article is free to read.

Sign up for free or sign in to continue reading.

Unlike our competitors, we don’t force you to pay to read the news but we do need your email address to make your experience better.

Nearly there! Create a password to finish signing up with us:

Please enter your password or get a sign in link if you’ve forgotten

Open Sesame! Thanks for signing up.

home delivery

Say hello to DM168 home delivery

Get your favourite newspaper delivered to your doorstep every weekend.

Delivery is available in Gauteng, the Western Cape, KwaZulu-Natal, and the Eastern Cape.