Dailymaverick logo

Business Maverick

This article is more than a year old

AGE OF (UN)ACCOUNTABILITY

Confidential out-of-court settlement between VBS and KPMG was R500m: source

Daily Maverick can disclose that the undisclosed controversial out-of-court settlement between auditor KPMG and the liquidator of VBS Bank, Anoosh Rooplal, was R500-million.
bm ed KPMG (main) VBS Bank. (Photo: Lucas Ledwaba / Mukurukuru) | KPMG. (Photo: Leila Dougan)

A source familiar with the matter told Daily Maverick that the sum was R500-million. The money will be paid to the liquidator to distribute among the creditors, who will likely feel short-changed. 

News that a confidential settlement had been reached sparked a public outcry, including from trade union umbrella group Cosatu.

More than R2-billion was stolen from the bank in an elaborate fraud heist, and KPMG was hauled to court by the liquidator on the grounds that it had signed off on the fraud. 

Rooplal had initially claimed damages of R864-million plus interest, but was sworn to secrecy following the out-of-court settlement. 

Such settlements are usually labelled “confidential”, effectively gagging both parties until the matter is signed off with a court order. 

Rooplal said in response, "by virtue of the confidentiality agreement signed with KPMG, we have no comment". KPMG said it would respond later today. DM

Comments

Loading your account…
Graeme 1 February 2024 10:54 AM

R500m is just appalling. KPMG should be paying the entire amount that went missing.

William 1 February 2024 12:37 PM

That means those that looted it would get away with it.

Graeme 1 February 2024 04:24 PM

KPMG paying a massive fine for professional incompetence in the fiasco is not the same as nabbing and prosecuting the criminals involved in the fiasco. We still need a “name, shame and prosecution” of the people that were involved in the diversion of funds, as well the names of the recipients of the funds. Remember this admission of guilt every time you drive past a KPMG branded building.

Confucious Says 1 February 2024 11:02 AM

The new SA motto (based on anc maths): I'm only guilty if I'm caught! And if I'm caught I will pay back the money! Then I'm not guilty!

Helen 1 February 2024 02:38 PM

...but not all the money.

JP K 1 February 2024 07:54 PM

Of course this is not just the ANC though... Bain KPMG and large multinationals have been doing this for a long time. Think of the financial crisis of 2008. How many people got prosecuted... like one programmer thrown under the bus. Can anyone who's a lawyer explain why criminal charges are not laid and corporate veil isn't pierced? My understanding is that companies do the sums weighing up the expected value (cost) of being caught and paying a fine and the expected value (profit) of bending the rules.

Just 1 February 2024 12:11 PM

And where is the prosecution of the ANC politicians and cadres related to looting at VBS Bank?

c***e@s***.co.za 1 February 2024 02:26 PM

It was the EFF that we mainly in cahoots. I don’t know why they don’t make them pay back the money!

c***e@s***.co.za 1 February 2024 02:26 PM

It was the EFF that we mainly in cahoots. I don’t know why they don’t make them pay back the money!

Patrick Barta 1 February 2024 02:16 PM

Some jail time is needed for those implicated in addition to full settlement.

Schalk Burger 1 February 2024 02:24 PM

I cannot agree more. These professional people with their huge salaries, nice cars and big bonusses are not doing their jobs and this is at the expense of the poor.

Kev 1 1 February 2024 02:34 PM

Totally agree - money has been followed into executives and politicians bank accounts, why have they not repaid ? They should all be in jail.

Schalk Burger 1 February 2024 02:23 PM

KPMG staff should be charged for criminal negligence! The money is not what this is about. It is about professionalism of professional people.

Mark Gory Gory 1 February 2024 03:11 PM

Shut them down. Repeatedly found wanting. Jail time

Ndivhuwo R 1 February 2024 04:40 PM

Although of course the report on VBS suggests more than just criminal negligence on the side of the auditors!

V***z@y***.com 1 February 2024 02:24 PM

And once again the criminals are free to loot again, with only a slap over the wrist for their crimes.... It's a freaking joke that the people that can actually do something about it, do absolutely nothing!!!

Josie Rowe-Setz 1 February 2024 02:28 PM

In 2023, KPMG's global revenue was $36.4 billion, marking an 8% increase from the previous year. Source; statista.

Geoff 1 February 2024 02:42 PM

I think R500 m is pretty good. Remember, the thieves were primarily at VBS and Councilors, mostly ANC

s***o@a***.co.za 1 February 2024 03:12 PM

We demand transparency when it concerns government but we accept this clandestine , opaque deals when it is the fraud committed by the private sector. This is a public issue and concerns thousands of the poorest citizen of this country . The agreement should be made public.

Berthold Alheit 1 February 2024 03:15 PM

Fully agree that all guilty parties should be prosecuted.

hillcrestzim 1 February 2024 09:07 PM

A claim against the auditors would be based on professional indemnity claim whose outcome is not always certain and such claims usually take years to settle, so at times this kind of settlement becomes pragmatic. If the Police and Courts do their part, more money could be recovered from those who benefited illegally from the theft.

Albert Smith 2 February 2024 07:37 AM

Why has Deloitte not paid a similarly big fine for signing off on fraud multiples bigger that this at Steinhoff?

Arved von Oettingen 2 February 2024 09:54 AM

"It's not the principle, it's the money!" Why has the money not been recovered from the guilty, (EFF), parties? It should be easier to successfully prosecute these criminals now that KPMG has admitted guilt?

s***a@g***.com 2 February 2024 03:51 PM

Indeed covering themselves