GROUNDUP
Mowbray police assault — SAPS and Ipid tight-lipped three months after vicious assault
The victim has left work out of fear. Nearly three months later, the names of the officers involved have not been published and it’s unclear if any action has been taken against them.
The barber who was assaulted by police officers in Mowbray, Cape Town, last year has left his place of work because he fears being assaulted again. And yet, nearly three months later the South African Police Service (SAPS) and the Independent Police Investigative Directorate (Ipid), remain mum on the outcome and identities of the officers who carried out the assault.
Barber, Juma Igiranieza, was assaulted on 7 November by SAPS members during a raid at his workplace, Perfect Touch Boutique and Salon.
GroundUp published CCTV footage on 10 November showing several police, one in plain clothes, carrying out the assault. In the footage, at least two officers participate directly in the assault and none of the other police appear concerned by it. The officers unleash a barrage of punches on Igiranieza, strike him repeatedly with a wooden device, and smother him with plastic.
The officers were allegedly looking for Igiranieza’s boss whom they accused of selling drugs. Igiranieza was taken to Groote Schuur Hospital for treatment following the assault.
The officers are members of the SAPS Special Provincial Task Unit called Operation Restoration (Reto). The charges being investigated against them are attempted murder, torture and assault.
When asked whether the officers had been identified, whether they had been charged and if they had faced any consequences, Ipid spokesperson, Robbie Raburabu referred GroundUp to SAPS, saying: “The information you are looking for would not be provided by Ipid but rather SAPS. Issues of discipline that are only dealt with by the employer.”
But when we went to SAPS, spokesperson FC Van Wyk sent us back to Ipid, saying “Kindly be informed that the circumstances surrounding the incident cited in your enquiry are now the subject of an investigation by Ipid. You are advised to refer your enquiry to the spokesperson of the mentioned department for a response.”
At a meeting of the South African National Editors Forum a few weeks after the incident Minister of Police Bheki Cele stated: “I am told that Ipid is working on this particular case and many others and will make recommendations. We will try to move fast.”
Read more in Daily Maverick: Bheki Cele responds to video evidence of police assault during barber shop raid
‘Complete travesty’
On Monday, the Western Cape Department of Police Oversight and Community Safety slammed Ipid’s report for the second quarter of the 2023/24 financial year. The report shows that in the Western Cape, from July to September 2023, 196 cases were registered with Ipid for investigation. Of the 1,276 cases countrywide, the Western Cape had the second highest behind Gauteng.
The 196 cases included 146 assault cases.
Reagan Allen, Western Cape police minister, said: “The high number of cases is deeply worrying, and quite frankly a disgrace. It suggests that there is an unacceptable level of ill-discipline within the ranks of SAPS that requires urgent attention. It’s a complete travesty that the very service that should be protecting all of us, while upholding the law, have allegedly made themselves guilty of committing crime.”
If anyone has credible information identifying the officers involved in the assault, please let us know via email: [email protected]. Your confidentiality is assured.
Video of the assault
This is an abbreviated version of the video. Download the full 11 minute video. Warning: both videos depict violence and most people will find it distressing.
DM
First published by GroundUp.
Mr Cele, I am asking you politely as a law abiding citizen to please fulfill your mandate and take the strongest possible action to prevent abuse of human rights by our national police force.
Thank you
Cele has been briefed a few times I daresay….the problem with er, memory loss!
What a bunch of cowardly criminals. How much do we not get to hear about, when there are no cameras?
The courts should criminalise refusal to execute state office, with automatic minimum sentencing – but alas the majority of politicians are too bent to even get that enacted. Dereliction of duty should be punishable under law, but in SA we don’t even punish police or politicians for breaking the law – only ordinary citizens.
I wish Cele’s lips were more regularly long-term silenced! Perhaps he could begin to read and then apply himself – you know: Noddy and Big Ears stuff! A most disappointing person.