Dailymaverick logo

South Africa

This article is more than a year old

WATER SHEDDING

Minister Mchunu slams absentee Joburg mayor after two-thirds of the city hit by water cuts

In Joburg, the water crisis continues to disrupt daily life and essential services, with schools forced to close and residents struggling to access basic necessities.
Minister Mchunu slams absentee Joburg mayor after two-thirds of the city hit by water cuts Johannesburg mayor Kabelo Gwamanda. (Photo: Gallo Images / Fani Mahuntsi) | Water coming from a tap in Alexandra on 29 May 2023. (Photo: Gallo Images / Luba Lesolle) | Minister of Water and Sanitation Senzo Mchunu. (Photo: Gallo Images / OJ Koloti)

Water and Sanitation Minister Senzo Mchunu slammed absentee Joburg Mayor Kabelo Gwamanda, who, like his predecessor Thapelo Amad, has missed several water crisis meetings.

At a meeting on Friday, 22 September, to manage severe water cuts across three Gauteng cities, Mchunu questioned why Joburg’s mayor was absent. There were water cuts in two-thirds of the city and by 25 September it was still struggling. 

Two sources said Gwamanda had missed several meetings on the water crisis. He has left the management of the crisis to the city entity Johannesburg Water and individual councillors. The mayor has only issued statements on renaming William Nicol Drive to Winnie Mandela Drive. His office has yet to respond to two requests for comment. 

The City said: “The MMC represented the City at the meeting.  We cannot comment on the minister’s alleged frustration.”

Rand Water, the bulk supplier, blamed the water cuts on a thunderstorm which caused power surges at the Zuikerbosch Water Treatment Plant, which covers two-thirds of the city’s supply.

On Sunday, another power outage at the plant and at the Palmiet Pumping Station set back Mchunu’s pledge to restore water for the long weekend. Rand Water said excessive use was also straining the system.    

Johannesburg Water spokesperson Nombuso Shabalala said: “Not all customers within these supply zones are affected as customers in low-lying areas will get water and customers in high-lying areas may experience poor pressure to no water.”

Water cuts extended

Johannesburg’s water supply has been stuttering for months. Areas in the southwest of the city are more often without water than with it. Rahima Moosa Hospital in Coronationville now exclusively uses borehole water and tankers to keep it running. 

Read more in Daily Maverick: Day Zero comes to parts of Joburg as water cuts roll through city and taps run dry 

The past week has seen the cuts extended to the city’s north, east and west, with a councillor predicting total system collapse. Rand Water is believed to be “water shedding” or supplying its 17 million consumers on a rotational basis. However, Rand Water has denied this and, in turn, blamed municipalities which lose up to 60% of water supplied, CEO Sipho Mosai said in a TV interview last week. 

Parts of Tshwane and Ekurhuleni have also been without water for almost 10 days and water protests are growing.

DA councillor Ralf Bittkau wrote, “Our two main supply dams, Sterkfontein and Katse, are currently at 102% and 97%, which gives us plenty of water to draw from. While Katse is above 55%, we are okay, but going into an El Niño [low rainfall weather system], which may last three to seven years, we don’t know what will happen. We are dealing with a state entity [Rand Water] that, like Eskom, cannot cope with demand.”

Residents have started WhatsApp groups where disaster managers will pin borehole locations in case of a complete system collapse. Both Rand Water and Johannesburg Water deny the system is near collapse. “Rand Water is able and can supply water to its municipal customers,” it said at the weekend.    

Johannesburg Water’s latest report shows that it loses 44.8% of supplied water to leaks, illegal connections and bursts.

Councillor Bridget Steer said although the dams may be full, the city’s water could only be distributed if Rand Water’s treatment plants and pumping stations worked optimally. While Johannesburg has invested in reservoirs to deal with multiyear supply problems in areas including Brixton, Crosby, Coronationville, Westbury, Claremont and Melville, the 10,957km pipe infrastructure needed urgent upgrading.

Johannesburg has a R20-billion infrastructure backlog but its 2023/24 capex budget is lower than most other cities as its spending on staff and contractors balloons. So far this year, the city has reported 4,190 pipe bursts a month, showing the age of the system.

Each pipe burst results in area outages, an additional strain on residents for whom multiday water cuts are now standard. Johannesburg’s emergency services have attended to more than 200 fires in the past season, most in the inner city. The water cuts make fighting the fires harder. At the weekend, a fire raged in the west (Quellerina and surrounds), and because of the water cuts, it ran wild because the hydrants were dry, according to residents. 

Schools forced to close

During the past week, numerous schools which don’t have alternative water supplies have had to close. 

Raylene Nadassen of St Theresa’s College in Coronationville said, “The water [cuts] have significantly impacted learners over the past few weeks. They are not planned and are ongoing without explanation given. There is no fresh water to drink, wash hands, and sanitation is impacted significantly; going to the toilet is a cumbersome exercise. We go for weeks with a trickle of water.

“The school has had to invest in JoJo tanks so learners can continue to be educated. But without rain, how will we fill the tanks? Tankers won’t fill them because the school is not on their allocation. I think it’s inhuman not to have running water at a school. By withholding a basic necessity, it has a massive impact on education. 

“Weeks without water is inconsiderate as it breeds illness and sickness. Our learners deserve to be comfortable at school.” 

What will happen next?

Daily Maverick has spoken to councillors, officials, experts and political leaders. Some solutions are being planned, such as additional reservoirs to store more water. Water restrictions are at Level 1 and could increase if consumption does not ease or the rains don’t come soon (although the supply dams are at reasonable levels). 

Level 1 restrictions are now in place until 31 March 2024, providing that residents avoid hosepipe use, swimming pool refilling and water feature use between 6am and 6pm.

By 25 September, most affected reservoirs were slowly filling, but many were still at critical levels. Councillors said that water was returning. DM

This is the first in our community-led local investigations. The article was co-written with Michael Thompson, who lives in Coronationville and keeps Daily Maverick abreast of water and other community issues. If you would like to undertake a Johannesburg investigation or report with us, please write to ferial@dailymaverick.co.za

Comments (10)

Con Tester Sep 26, 2023, 11:50 AM

“Both Rand Water and Johannesburg Water deny the system is near collapse.” Well, that settles it then: The system *IS* near collapse.

Nonechez@gmail.com Sep 26, 2023, 12:41 PM

But wait, isn’t the minister Munchuu and the esteemed mayor drawing salaries? Well folks, open a class action against them, and any minister who is pulling a fast one, by just making noise at meetings. The least you can do is debit the mayor for a days pay for every meeting missed. Not one person is going to do anything about the catastrophe that is South Africa until you hit them in their hip pocket. An urgent class action to sue the city council for the destruction of of every bit of infrastructure can be a start time to cough up. Neutrally they won’t be able to cover the cost of the wholesale destruction but a few hundred thousand each will go a long way towards initiating repair don’t you think. As for name calling and offering solutions, I can’t come up with anything better than this at the moment. Additionally why should the people suffering from such incompetence come up with solutions? From all the comments I’ve read to date, the people being paid grab on public solutions , and turn them into words that they have come up with. What I would like to see, and hear is the honest to G-ds truth for once only then will the community step up to serve.

Con Tester Sep 26, 2023, 01:59 PM

As public servants, the citizens of Joburg will be the ones paying for their defence, and they can't be sued in their private capacities for their incompetence and mismanagement. And that's assuming that a class action suit of the kind you propose stands any chance of even getting off the ground because they will have their arses covered with reams of T's & C's.

Just another Comment Sep 26, 2023, 05:49 PM

So, while the mayor of Cape Town is on the streets of the city suburbs overseeing and helping to mop up the mess caused by the storms, the mayor of Johannesburg sits on his fat backside and does nothing about fixing the water crisis. The difference, ladies and gentlemen, is that the DA gives a stuff, while the ANC and EFF (and that other nowhere excuse for a political party that the mayor belongs to) couldn't give a shoveling shit about the residents of Johannesburg!

Fanie Rajesh Ngabiso Sep 26, 2023, 09:08 PM

Agree 100% Ukhetho DA!

Heinrich Holt Sep 26, 2023, 09:22 PM

I do not know why everybody complains about the renaming of streets and other infrastructure. For me it makes total sense to name it after the fools and idiots who caused the decay off it all the last three decades. If this is an unfair take on the matter, then at the very least those who fought for freedom forgot the little small matter of passing on the qualities of leadership, succession planning, and taking care of the assets entrusted to you.

Tessa and Colin Weakley Sep 27, 2023, 07:22 AM

44% of water supplied to CoJ is lost due to burst pipes, leaks, and illegal connections. This us a huge number and one worth focusing on by the Jhb Water engineers. We need to make sure Repairs are done to the required standards. Perhaps ask Jhb Water how many Repairs have had to be re visited and redone, within the last year. It's hard to believe that there's any other reason for the water shortage.

Peter Sturrock Sep 27, 2023, 10:58 AM

Minister Mchunu is a fine one to talk. He was in Makhanda/Grahamstown on 16th August to see the pitiful state of our Municipal service delivery and water supply in particular. Our water shedding got so bad that DW&S had to intervene. Minister Mchunu addressed residents in the City Hall on 16th August and undertook to return "between 16th and 20th September" to provide an update on progress. Needless to say the situation has not improved by any measure and he never kept his undertaking to return. Queries in this regard are not responded to by Municipal officials such as the Speaker.

James Francis Sep 27, 2023, 01:20 PM

How useless are you if an ANC minister tells you you're not doing your job?

James Francis Sep 27, 2023, 01:22 PM

A vote for the ANC or its partners is starting to look treasonous. Don't help the ANC continue to use poverty and service delivery as weapons in its bid for a one-party state.

Jill Schlachter Sep 29, 2023, 10:13 AM

I think there is a factual error in the article, in referencing the Palmiet Pumping Station. To my best knowledge, the Palmiet Pumping Station is on the Palmiet River, in the Overstrand District, between Bettys Bay and Kleinmond, in the Western Cape. Poor editing! See above: On Sunday, another power outage at the plant and at the Palmiet Pumping Station set back Mchunu’s pledge to restore water for the long weekend. Rand Water said excessive use was also straining the system.

mally2 Sep 29, 2023, 11:36 AM

If anyone expected anything different from such a politically chosen and obviously out of his depth Mayor, they must be living in a fool's paradise. The string of incompetent mayors in Jhbg. recently degrades the post and makes a mockery of it.