Defend Truth


Political blame game erupts over how two Western Cape towns ran dry

Political blame game erupts over how two Western Cape towns ran dry
Parts of Vredendal were without water for almost a week earlier this month after infrastructure repairs led to the shortage. (Photo: Nathi Qondile)

Despite assurances that the water crisis in the Matzikama Municipality was not ‘political’, insults were traded in the Western Cape legislature about who was responsible for the situation that has crippled households and businesses.

A mini-debate in the Western Cape legislature on Thursday about the water crisis in the Matzikama Municipality turned into a political blame game between the DA and the ANC.

This week, Daily Maverick reported on the towns of Vredendal and Vanrhynsdorp being left without water for seven days. At the time of the crisis, Vanrhynsdorp was at its peak of flower season which attracts many tourists to the area.

Read more in Daily Maverick: How two Western Cape towns ran dry – Coke bottles, missing director, ageing canals, broken pipes

Thursday’s mini-debate was initiated by the ANC’s Patrick Marran from questions to the DA’s Anton Bredell, MEC for Local Government, Environmental Affairs and Development Planning. 

Marran asked what had led to the water crisis and what interventions Bredell had put in place. Bredell cited an emergency phase to repair the aged pump station and a project to replace an old asbestos pipeline and construct a new pump.

In his response to Bredell, Marran said: “The crisis in Matzikama was not about bulk water, it was about the inability of the DA-run municipality and province to simply maintain water infrastructure.”

The municipality is run by a DA/Freedom Front Plus coalition following a by-election in July 2022.

Read more in Daily Maverick: Boks ticked – spring comes early for the DA in Vanrhynsdorp thanks to PA, GOOD and FF+ voters

Marran continued: “What happened in Matzikama is water apartheid… The water eventually came for some, those in the dorp, and who are better off.” 

He said those who were poor and working class, “Coloured and African, had to suffer extra days without water”.

Ferlon Christians of the ACDP asked Bredell what he was doing to hold people accountable.

“There must be an administration that must be held responsible for the shortage of water. I want to know, are those officials going to account and are they going to be brought to book?” said Christians.

Western Cape water crisis

The Mangaung informal settlement in Vredendal was hit by a weeklong water shortage on 8 September 2023. (Photo: Nathi Qondile)

The EFF’s Moses Thembile Klaas said the water crisis was an “infringement” of people’s constitutional rights. He claimed the DA “placed incompetent individuals” in positions of power who could not create proper infrastructure and could not create municipal water plans.

He asked Bredell, “What was the municipality doing to ensure that people received adequate drinking water?”

In response to all the questions, Bredell said it always astonished him “how the ANC will stand up in this House and will try to badmouth the DA when their national government is so corrupt and they steal everything from the poorest of the poor”.

He said the issue of sabotage was the biggest of all that was being dealt with. Bredell said police and the Hawks were brought in to investigate.

“I’m not going to pull that into a political discussion, but I’m really worried because there is definitely sabotage,” said Bredell.

The province had sent five engineers to the municipality. “That’s how serious this is… we want to solve this as soon as possible.”

Bredell said DA municipalities were in the process of implementing water management plans throughout the province, but that ANC-led municipalities in the Western Cape would not be implementing these plans because they did not care for the poor.

“They don’t care about the poor because they know if the poor suffer, they will vote for them for the shameless R350 grant. They want to keep people captured so they can suck the votes out of them,” said Bredell.

“This government is doing everything possible when we take over from the ANC to rectify the neglect of infrastructure. The ANC governed Matzikama – they’ve never spent a cent on infrastructure – that’s why the people sit with asbestos pipes,” he continued.

He added: “We don’t play politics with this. We’re there to serve the people… the people have a right to a dignified life. To have a dignified life, you need to have water and we will provide that water.”

Farming activist Billy Claasen, of the Rural and Farmworkers Development Organisation, blamed the water crisis on the municipality. On 30 August, he posted on Facebook that the situation was the fault of not only the local administration, but also councillors. 

Claasen said all the councillors “should resign or be fired”. DM


Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • Denise Smit says:

    Good that Bredell is quoted verbatim about the probability of sabotage and what they are doing to address the situation. The municipal manager was also actively involved from the beginning to urgently address the situation even for long term measures. The sabotage is ANC/EFF tactics. They are trying to sabotage the DA where there is a possibility they may win votes in 2024. This has been 10 days of water problems. What about Grahamstown, what about Toyando, what about Lichtenburg, what about Zeerust, etc, etc where people have had water problems for years. DM must place articles about the years of neglect in the other provinces. Have any one of you ridden on the potholed roads of the Freestate, Mpumalanga, North West and Kwa Zulu Natal. You won’t be able to get in one piece to your destination. Start doing your work without a political objective included, please. Denise Smit

  • Vincent Britz says:

    Well that’s no surprise that there was sabotage! Let’s be honest here, the ANC is so hard up to take over the western cape that the ANC would go to any length to make the DA look bad! The facts speak for themselves, the western cape is the best run province’s with the most clean run municipality’s, better health care, better service delivery. What does the ANC have?? Just look at there track record over the last 20 years, the whole country has gone to shit due to the ANC and there corrupt politicians that only want to fill there pockets while leading a bunch of no brain followers that blindly follow the ANC criminals! Only once SA is like Zimbabwe will the dumb blind no brain followers realize that they are only going to live a life of suffering by the hands of there leadership. Then it’s too late!!!! We as true south Africans must stand together and stop the ANC government from staying in power!!!

  • Steve Davidson says:

    To Denise and Vince, many thanks for your excellent comments. I like you am totally and utterly gatvol with these ANC and EFF mamparras who couldn’t organize a pee up in a brewery if they could find the brewery in the first place. And if they did they’d probably burn it down if they weren’t given free beer.

    I’m actually ‘enjoying’ watching Colliers Brink giving the morons in Pretoria hell for – once again – totally stuffing up a place through their crooked incompetence and then blaming it on the DA!

    Frankly this country needs the DA’s total competence to get it back on track, although I obviously won’t hold my breath it’ll happen. What it needs is perhaps a pilot scheme say in the Eastern Cape to show the rest of the country how it’s done, where the fantastic city and province people from the Cape go up there and take over for six months but when I see that those idiots voted the ANC back in in two EC places yesterday, I despair.

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted


This article is free to read.

Sign up for free or sign in to continue reading.

Unlike our competitors, we don’t force you to pay to read the news but we do need your email address to make your experience better.

Nearly there! Create a password to finish signing up with us:

Please enter your password or get a sign in link if you’ve forgotten

Open Sesame! Thanks for signing up.

We would like our readers to start paying for Daily Maverick...

…but we are not going to force you to. Over 10 million users come to us each month for the news. We have not put it behind a paywall because the truth should not be a luxury.

Instead we ask our readers who can afford to contribute, even a small amount each month, to do so.

If you appreciate it and want to see us keep going then please consider contributing whatever you can.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options