Our Burning Planet

THE CONVERSATION

Study demonstrates green spaces are good for wellbeing, yet many in SA cannot access them

Study demonstrates green spaces are good for wellbeing, yet many in SA cannot access them
Villagers in Sterkspruit, Eastern Cape enjoy a traditional ceremony of their son coming from an initiation school, in the midst of nature. (Photo: Felix Dlangamandla)

Despite limited access to nature in many developing countries, research shows a strong appreciation for its contribution to physical, psychological and spiritual wellbeing among the lowest socioeconomic groups, reinforcing the need to address existing patterns of inequality.

The benefits of experiencing nature for physical, psychological and spiritual wellbeing are widely documented. But much of the research on these benefits has been done in relatively affluent countries in the global North. There’s little research that has been done in developing countries on the benefits of being in nature.

Development and urban planning approaches in developing countries reflect this. While they rightfully emphasise economic development, housing and sanitation, they commonly treat access to green space as a luxury to enjoy once basic needs are met.

In an era of accelerating urbanisation, particularly in developing countries, nature experience is becoming increasingly rare. And as with many other types of amenities, access to nature and green spaces is highly skewed along socioeconomic lines.

In South Africa, there remains a stark contrast in access to nature and green spaces between areas that were divided along racial lines during apartheid. It includes highly uneven distribution of city trees and green spaces, a situation that has been dubbed “green apartheid”.

Our research

We have been researching for the past decade the relationships isiXhosa-speaking people in urban and rural settings in South Africa’s Eastern Cape Province have with their natural environment. Our definition of “nature” includes anything from dense natural forest in rural areas, to patches of bush and communal grazing land around towns and villages.

We found that across a range of urban to rural locations, age and gender, most people we interviewed had a strong appreciation for nature. Even though many had limited access to natural spaces, and seldom visited them, they valued such spaces for their contribution to a sense of wellbeing, identity and shared heritage. Many also described how visiting nature eased feelings of hardship, stress, and loneliness.

Employment, housing, water and sanitation remain urgent priorities for urban and rural development. Nevertheless, as our research shows, the contribution access to nature makes to people’s wellbeing is important. Growing evidence suggests that access to green space has the most pronounced benefits among the lowest socioeconomic groups.

Making access to nature a luxury that few can afford continues to reinforce existing patterns of deep inequality.

Relationships with nature

To test the generality of our qualitative findings, we conducted an in-depth, questionnaire-based survey of nearly 700 Eastern Cape rural and urban residents. This included questions about respondents’ feelings of attachment to nature, past and present nature access and resource use, cultural and religious beliefs and practices, and socio-economic indicators.

We also explored the contribution that being in nature made to the best and worst times respondents remembered experiencing during their life.

Religion and spirituality featured strongly in the lives of people we interviewed. Three-quarters of respondents practised both Christian and African indigenous religions, including recognition of ancestral spirits. Only 1% neither belonged to a church nor held African indigenous religious beliefs. Ninety per cent of respondents engaged in various rituals including male initiations, and many of these require time spent in natural settings and use of natural products.

Access to nature thus helps to ensure that spirituality remains a part of everyday reality, and vice versa.

We asked respondents to remember and describe the happiest period they had experienced in their lives, and whether being in nature featured and contributed. The most commonly reported best time was childhood or youth, often associated with rural life and being in nature. People reminisced about stick fighting and traditional parties for young people, safe spaces for teenage courtship in nature and swimming in rivers and dams.

Other times widely remembered as the best in people’s lives were associated with educational and related achievements, marriage and relationships, the birth of children, and men’s time spent in the bush as part of their traditional initiation into manhood.

Overall, best periods strongly related to social aspects of life, such as family relationships, community and personal achievements. Only 27% of respondents mentioned best times that reflected material domains such as work, money or housing.

Fifty-six per cent of the respondents said they accessed nature during the best time in their life, and nearly all of those (94%) felt that accessing nature contributed to it being the best time in their life. The reasons for this included the contribution of being in nature to a sense of wellbeing and joy, and as a site for celebrations, recreation and ritual practices.

We also asked respondents to describe the worst time they had experienced in their life. The death of loved ones was overwhelmingly associated with the worst period. Other worst experiences included ill health or injury, and setbacks or failure in life. Thirty-six per cent of respondents reported spending time in nature during this difficult time, and of these, 74% felt that it helped them cope better.

Mourners found that experiencing peace and calm in nature assisted with the healing process. Some respondents said the peaceful surroundings were conducive to prayer. Others felt the presence of the ancestors when being in nature.

Of those who did not spend time in nature during their most difficult time, 30% thought that it might have helped them cope better. Overall, 45% of respondents felt that accessing nature either helped or could have helped them deal with the worst time in their lives.

Nature access: a basic necessity or a luxury?

The rural areas and urban townships of the Eastern Cape are among the least developed in South Africa. They are characterised by high rates of poverty, dependence on social welfare, unemployment, poor access to quality schooling and medical care, and high rates of crime, including gender-based violence.

Within this context, we found that wellbeing and happiness are multidimensional and strongly enhanced by social and family relationships, religion and spirituality, and access to natural spaces for material, recreational and spiritual purposes.

Unfortunately, access to natural spaces is becoming increasingly difficult and dangerous for many people, especially women and girls and in urban areas. For children, and especially girls, fear of crime and competing expectations around the home are limiting opportunities to play outdoors in natural spaces. This means they miss out on the benefits that being in nature has for mental and physical health in children. DM

Susanne Vetter: Associate Professor, Department of Botany, Rhodes University; Michelle Cocks: Associate Professor of Environmental Anthropology, Rhodes University; Valerie Møller: Professor of Sociology, Rhodes University.

First published by The Conversation.

Gallery
Absa OBP

Comments - Please in order to comment.

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted

We would like our readers to start paying for Daily Maverick...

…but we are not going to force you to. Over 10 million users come to us each month for the news. We have not put it behind a paywall because the truth should not be a luxury.

Instead we ask our readers who can afford to contribute, even a small amount each month, to do so.

If you appreciate it and want to see us keep going then please consider contributing whatever you can.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options