Africa

WAGNER GROUP OP-ED

Russia’s military, mercenary and criminal interests in west Africa look set to expand in 2023

Russia’s military, mercenary and criminal interests in west Africa look set to expand in 2023
A mural depicting the logo of the Russian Wagner Group and a slogan in Russian by the informal pro-Russia organisation 'Narodna Partola' (People Patrol), in Belgrade, Serbia, 20 January 2023. (Photo: EPA-EFE / Andrej Cukic)

The knock-on effects of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine have reshaped its engagement in west Africa: Western sanctions have had a disruptive impact on Russian businesses on the continent while, at the same time, engaging in Africa has become more strategically important for Russia in its newly politically and economically isolated state. The mercenary organisation Wagner Group has rapidly become the most influential form of Russian engagement in Africa.

In late January 2023, the US government announced the designation of the Wagner Group as a “transnational criminal organisation”. As investigations into Wagner’s activities show, the group is deeply, and allegedly increasingly, involved in illicit economies, particularly the smuggling of mineral resources such as gold. 

There are several countries in west and central Africa that could prove fertile ground for Wagner’s potential expansion, both military and economic, in 2023.

The fallout of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has had major consequences for Russia’s engagement around the world in 2022. West Africa is no exception. 

Russia has sought to increase its political involvement in Africa since the 2014 invasion of Crimea. But as Russia has become more economically and politically isolated under the increasing weight of Western sanctions, the importance of Africa as a strategically significant region for Russia to engage in – both to facilitate business opportunities (to shore up its ailing domestic economy) and to court political allies – has escalated.

At the same time, Western sanctions – which prevent targeted entities from accessing much of the global banking system and globalised supply chains – have had a disruptive effect on the business interests of Russian oligarchs in west Africa.

For example, Russian gold producer Nordgold – which has been placed under sanctions along with its former major shareholder, oligarch Alexey Mordashov – has had to find new routes to export gold from its mines in Guinea and Burkina Faso (where it recently received a new mining licence), reportedly via Dubai.

Illicit economies (and the ambiguous legal “grey zones” through which criminal actors and sanctioned entities seek to publicly present themselves as legitimate) also play a significant part in this geopolitical wrangling. 

Sanctioned Russian entities in Africa – which are primarily concentrated in the mining sector – may be turning to illicit means of transporting goods, minerals and money to fly under the radar of international sanctions.

The Wagner Group often appears to work as a proxy for the Russian state in Africa, seeking to pursue Russian state interests and disrupt Western influence on the continent

In late January 2023, the US government took the unusual step of designating Wagner as a “transnational criminal organisation” – a move that signals a new approach in defining and levying sanctions on Wagner and its enablers. 

The group is reportedly involved in illicit economies, such as industrial-scale smuggling of natural resources (particularly gold), which enables it, and probably indirectly the Russian state, to evade sanctions. 

These activities are more fully documented in an upcoming in-depth report by the Global Initiative Against Transnational Organized Crime, “The grey zone: Russia’s military, mercenary and criminal engagement in Africa”.

But the Wagner Group is also responsible for grotesque violence against civilians in several African countries. In Mali, for example, Wagner troops were reportedly involved in a joint operation with the Malian armed forces in January 2022, in which an elderly woman was burnt to death inside her home after a soldier began looting and setting buildings on fire. 

So while Wagner involvement in illicit economies is important in and of itself, the group’s entrenchment in African countries – primarily authoritarian regimes – facilitated by its illicit activities, simply extends its window of opportunity to carry out apparent human rights abuses against civilians.

Wagner Group – entrenching its role in illicit economies?

Controlled by Yevgeny Prigozhin, a close ally of Vladimir Putin, the Wagner Group appears to offer a package of services designed to appeal to autocratic leaders: mercenary troops who can help ensure territorial control; and political strategists who can manipulate and shape public debate using social media and, at times, disinformation

In return, as various reported examples show, Wagner seeks commercial gain, not just in cash but in access to natural resources, particularly in mining, which it exploits through a complex network of linked companies.

The group has expanded rapidly across Africa following its first documented military engagement on the continent, when about 500 troops were deployed to Sudan in late 2017. 

In 2022, Wagner troops were deployed in the Central African Republic (CAR), Mali, Libya and Sudan. 

Meanwhile, Wagner’s political influence operations have been active in several other African countries.

Timeline of Wagner Group presence in Africa. Indicative dates only. (Source: Global Initiative Against Transnational Organized Crime)

Wagner has been accused of using whatever means necessary – including criminal activity on a vast scale – to achieve its apparent aims of commercial gain and furthering Russian influence. 

International NGOs, independent and UN experts and the media have all levelled accusations at the group: from the indiscriminate use of violence against civilians in its military engagements to disinformation campaigns and election-rigging, to industrial-scale smuggling of natural resources.

For example, Wagner’s gold mining operations in Sudan and its proximity to the country’s military leaders are being used to carry out gold smuggling on an extensive scale. This has allegedly intensified since the start of the war with Ukraine, to bolster Russia’s gold reserves and counter Western sanctions.


Visit Daily Maverick’s home page for more news, analysis and investigations


Central African Republic – diluting presence but retaining influence

CAR is the most well-developed example of the Wagner business model in Africa. 

Wagner has provided President Faustin-Archange Touadéra with military and political strategy support. This has proven pivotal in sustaining Touadéra’s embattled presidency against an onslaught of rebel groups and has led to Wagner taking a leading role in the CAR’s security apparatus. 

Clashes between Wagner personnel and rebel groups continued into 2022. 

In March last year, at least seven people were killed after Wagner troops were ambushed by militants from the Popular Front for the Rebirth of Central African Republic rebel group. 

Two months earlier, the Russians had allegedly been responsible for the massacre of more than 30 civilians in what was purportedly a targeted operation against the Union for Peace rebel group. 

The mercenaries have, in fact, been accused of the killing and torture of civilians on several occasions. 

Wagner violence against civilians in the Central African Republic, 2022. (Source: Acled)

In exchange for their services, the Wagner Group appears to have developed a large footprint in the CAR’s economy, with access to natural resources such as gold, diamonds and timber. 

Wagner-linked companies have been granted access to natural resources by the CAR government, often expropriating existing rights granted to other companies.

Outside of the mining concessions that Wagner has been able to gain control over, the group has also been accused of looting and smuggling diamonds and gold. 

According to a local business in Lobaye, as far back as 2019, Wagner has been covertly buying diamonds from local collectors. The group has also allegedly purchased gold and diamonds directly from rebel groups. Elsewhere in the country, Wagner troops have attacked artisanal mining communities and confiscated diamonds and gold. For example, they were recently accused of taking over a local diamond sector in a conflict-affected area of the CAR by force, via a diamond company the group is alleged to control.

In the first half of 2022 alone, Wagner reportedly carried out attacks on mines in at least six different locations in the CAR – attacks that appear to be “more like raids for plunder”, as opposed to strategic attempts to secure and extract resources in the medium to short term. 

Furthermore, experts have told the Global Initiative Against Transnational Organized Crime of reports of Russian nationals manning customs points, including at the border entering Garoua-Boulaï in Cameroon, a key transit point which plays an important role in gold flows, allegedly with the consent of the CAR government.

In light of stretched resources resulting from military needs in Ukraine, Wagner is seemingly seeking to extract rents from as many informal and illicit economies as possible. 

According to a UN source, the group is reportedly looking to exploit the annual cattle migration into the CAR from neighbouring Cameroon and Chad, which takes place each year between November and April. According to UN personnel interviewed by the Global Initiative Against Transnational Organized Crime, armed groups are known to draw substantial resources from this, either by engaging in cattle theft directly or by providing protection to herders.

Mali – the latest theatre for Wagner’s operations

Since the first Wagner troops arrived in Bamako in November 2021, at least 1,000 Wagner officers have been deployed in Mali, primarily across the central regions but also further afield

The relationship between the Malian military and France, Mali’s former main international partner, worsened to the extent that Paris put an end to Operation Barkhane, its counterterrorism mission in Mali in mid-August 2022. 

Russia has been sowing anti-French and pro-Russian sentiment in Mali for over five years, cultivated via a sophisticated use of soft power and social media. But the end of Operation Barkhane opened a window of opportunity for even greater Russian military engagement in Mali.

Wagner Group areas of operation in Mali (Source: Acled and Menastream, adapted from Jules Duhamel, Areas of operation – Wagner Group (Mali), 24 July 2022,

The Wagner Group did not carry out operations alone, instead conducting patrols alongside the Malian armed forces and self-defence militias. Since their arrival in Mali, the Russian mercenaries have been repeatedly implicated in operations that have targeted and killed civilians. 

In March 2022, several hundred civilians were killed in the village of Moura in an attack allegedly involving the Wagner Group; in October, the group was once again accused of a civilian massacre in the same central region of Mopti. 

Islamist armed groups across the Sahel regularly exploit intercommunal tensions and grievances against the government, and the fact that the victims of the latest massacre in which the Russian mercenaries are implicated all belonged to the Fulani community is likely to simply exacerbate such grievances. 

As Jama’at Nusrat al-Islam wal-Muslimin – an umbrella coalition of al-Qaeda-aligned groups – continues its recruitment approach of winning “hearts and minds”, Wagner activity has simply “created more fertile ground for such outreach efforts”.

Wagner may have Mali’s gold mining sector in its sights. 

Obtaining payment through mining concessions is part of a clear Wagner playbook adopted by the group across a range of its engagements in Africa; were similar strategies to be underway in Mali, it is likely that such entry points are already being exploited. 

A lack of public information on how Wagner has been paid by Mali’s junta has spurred speculation that Wagner may be given access to mining concessions in the future, as an alternative form of payment. 

While some media investigations have claimed that Wagner has established gold mining companies in Mali, our research has not been able to independently verify these claims. 

It remains to be seen in future whether, as international observers expect, Wagner will develop the same mechanisms for exploiting mining resources and smuggling in Mali as they have in Sudan and the CAR

Where will Wagner go in 2023?

As the war in Ukraine has not turned into the quick victory that Putin expected, some Wagner troops have been withdrawn from deployment in Africa to redirect forces towards Ukraine. 

Unofficial estimates from local observers, UN and diplomatic staff in CAR, for example, suggest that the number of Wagner troops in the country has more than halved. 

However, the vulnerability of the CAR government to rebel forces means that the mercenaries remain a powerful influence in CAR’s security apparatus. In addition, the situation in Ukraine has not prevented Wagner from deploying troops in new environments such as Mali.

In fact, some evidence suggests that Wagner may be aiming to expand into new territories. 

In Burkina Faso, events surrounding coups in January and September 2022 have fuelled Western fears that Wagner will begin operating there. Following the January coup, another Russian private military company – the Officers Union for International Security – publicly offered the new Burkinabé government Russian military “instructors”. The Officers Union for International Security represents the Russian military “instructors” in the CAR.   

The question of whether Burkina Faso would align itself with France (its former colonial power) or with Russia became a central part of the country’s political turmoil. 

In their announcement of the September coup on state TV, the latest coup leaders declared their wish to seek “other [international] partners ready to help us in our fight against terrorism”. 

In late January 2023, a spokesperson for the Burkinabé government announced that they were giving all French special forces soldiers one month to depart the country. This came shortly after French authorities announced they had received a letter demanding the departure of its ambassador to Burkina Faso.

The latest coup saw hundreds of protesters in Ouagadougou waving Russian flags, attacking a French embassy and cultural centre, and holding Russian flags atop UN armoured vehicles

This was an escalation of other pro-Russia protests seen in the wake of the January coup and the months since.

Prigozhin made several supportive statements following both coups. 

The September coup could, according to certain analysts, mark the first instance of Russia directly instigating a coup, rather than simply capitalising on it. Others, however, strongly disagree. 

According to a Burkinabé security analyst, for example, claims of Russian involvement in initiating the coup in September are “completely false – the coup was the direct result of [former interim president] Damiba’s leadership, who was more interested in playing politics and restoring the old regime”. 

Moreover, Burkina Faso’s Minister of Foreign Affairs has recently denied any link between the government and Wagner, arguing that state soldiers and members of the Volunteers for the Defence of the Homeland, a self-defence armed group, are “the Wagner of Burkina Faso”, in a statement appearing to suggest they have no intention of seeking the support of Wagner troops.

While most focus has been on Burkina Faso, increasingly close military ties between Russia and other countries in the region, such as Cameroon, with whom Russia signed a military deal in April 2022, have also raised concerns among Western players. 

It is not just international actors showing concern about possible Wagner involvement in the region. The president of Ghana publicly alleged that Burkina Faso had already entered into an agreement with the mercenaries, offering them a mine in exchange for their services – claims that are not supported by any evidence thus far and have been denied by the Burkinabé authorities.

Nevertheless, given the resources required to finance and man the ongoing war in Ukraine, and significant investment in Mali, Wagner may be spread too thin to expand operations into new territories, such as Burkina Faso, even if invited to do so. 

Reports of Wagner recruiting from prisons in Russia since mid-2022 highlight the extent of their stretched human resources. Where Wagner will source their manpower will therefore be an important question going forward.

From a strategic point of view, we can also expect Wagner to deepen its economic footprint in west Africa and the CAR in the coming months, particularly in high-value sectors such as gold and diamonds. 

As Russia continues to be economically isolated by sanctions, maintaining flows of gold into Russia – obtained through Prigozhin’s network of companies or smuggled by Wagner troops – secures an economic lifeline. 

At the same time, Russian presence in several west African countries continues to contribute, indirectly and in some cases directly, to growing instability across the region. DM

This article appears in the Global Initiative Against Transnational Organized Crime’s quarterly Observatory of Illicit Economies in West Africa (WEA-Obs) Risk Bulletin.

Gallery

Comments - Please in order to comment.

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted

X

This article is free to read.

Sign up for free or sign in to continue reading.

Unlike our competitors, we don’t force you to pay to read the news but we do need your email address to make your experience better.


Nearly there! Create a password to finish signing up with us:

Please enter your password or get a sign in link if you’ve forgotten

Open Sesame! Thanks for signing up.

We would like our readers to start paying for Daily Maverick...

…but we are not going to force you to. Over 10 million users come to us each month for the news. We have not put it behind a paywall because the truth should not be a luxury.

Instead we ask our readers who can afford to contribute, even a small amount each month, to do so.

If you appreciate it and want to see us keep going then please consider contributing whatever you can.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options