--- title: "IOL publicly apologises to Daily Maverick for false reporting" description: "Almost three years after Independent Online (IOL) published a made-up story claiming that Daily Maverick paid students to sow certain political narratives, IOL has retracted the story and apologised." type: "NewsArticle" publisher: "Daily Maverick" site: "https://www.dailymaverick.co.za" section: "INDEPENDENT RETRACTION" author: "Rebecca Davis" author_url: "https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/author/rebeccadavis-2-2/" canonical_url: "https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2023-02-23-iol-publicly-apologises-to-daily-maverick-for-false-reporting/" published: "2023-02-23T23:12:50" lang: "en-ZA" word_count: 526 --- # IOL publicly apologises to Daily Maverick for false reporting > Almost three years after Independent Online (IOL) published a made-up story claiming that Daily Maverick paid students to sow certain political narratives, IOL has retracted the story and apologised. By Rebecca Davis · Published 24 February 2023, 01:12 SAST ## Key points - IOL recently issued an apology and retraction for an article published in March 2020 which falsely claimed that Daily Maverick had asked a student to write negative tweets about Dr Iqbal Survé. The Johannesburg High Court had previously found Modibe Modiba, the student who made the false claims, to have disseminated “patently false and defamatory” allegations. Judge Keoagile Matojane awarded damages against Modiba on a punitive scale due to his “obstinate attitude and recalcitrance”. Despite the absurdity of Modiba’s claims, IOL went on to publish multiple articles treating his allegations as factual. Modiba has since leveraged the attention he garnered by lying about Daily Maverick to launch his own ‘news outlet’, while IOL continues to serve as a platform for attacks on other media outlets and journalists. This episode serves as a reminder of the importance of truth-telling in journalism. - IOL has issued an unconditional retraction and apology to Daily Maverick for false claims made against them. - The Johannesburg High Court found Modibe Modiba guilty of disseminating “patently false and defamatory” allegations. - IOL went on to publish a number of other articles treating Modiba's allegations as factual. - Modiba was able to exploit the online attention he garnered by lying about Daily Maverick to establish his own “news outlet”. ## Content *“*Daily Maverick asked me to write and do negative tweets about Dr Iqbal Survé,*”*ran the headline of an article published by the Survé-owned news website *IOL* in March 2020. The content of the article, authored by *IOL* journalist Ayanda Mdluli, consisted of false claims made by a student called Modibe Modiba and uncritically reported by Mdluli. Modiba lied about having received money from *Daily Maverick* to disseminate a smear campaign targeting Survé, the EFF and the Public Investment Corporation (PIC). Now *IOL* has published an[unconditional retraction of the article and an apology](https://www.iol.co.za/dailynews/news/apology-to-daily-maverick-and-branko-brkic-38ba349a-df80-4281-a02b-30b89d7f7f9b) — bringing to an end a shameful episode in South African media’s recent history. #### **Claims made against Daily Maverick ‘unlawful and defamatory’** *IOL*’s apology states: “*Daily News* Editor Ayanda Mdluli, and *Independent Online* editor Lance Witten hereby unconditionally retract the article and apologise to Daily Maverick and its editor Branko Brkic for the harm that was occasioned through the publication of Mr Modiba’s unlawful and defamatory allegations.” ![(Image: Supplied)](https://cdn.dailymaverick.co.za/i/USm4_NrcUnxVbvdYTQ0KnSdL6K0=/200x100/smart/filters:strip_exif\(\)/file/dailymaverick/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/IMG_6573.jpg) *(Image: Supplied)* As[previously covered by *Daily Maverick*](https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/article/2022-08-16-court-ruling-against-modibe-modiba-an-expected-outcome-to-a-fake-story-with-dangerous-implications/), Modiba was found by the Johannesburg High Court in August 2022 to have disseminated “patently false and defamatory” allegations. Judge Keoagile Matojane’s damning judgment stated: “It is hard to conceive of a more damaging accusation \[than that which Modiba made against *Daily Maverick*\] that is likely to injure the good esteem and harm the reputation of a news publication.” Matojane awarded damages against Modiba — which he has yet to pay — on a punitive scale due to his “obstinate attitude and recalcitrance”. --- **Visit [*Daily Maverick's* home page](https://www.dailymaverick.co.za?utm_source=direct&utm_medium=in_article_link&utm_campaign=homepage) for more news, analysis and investigations** --- #### **Allegations were repeated in a number of other IOL articles** Despite the absurdity of Modiba’s claims, and the fact that he produced no evidence to support them, *IOL* went on to publish a number of other articles treating his allegations as factual. A[subsequent article by Ayanda Mdluli](https://www.iol.co.za/news/opinion/why-is-sanef-defending-daily-maverick-no-matter-what-asks-mothelo-44578196) referred to Modiba as a “whistleblower”, rehashed Modiba’s lies, and quoted the little-known Information and Communication Technology Union (Ictu) as criticising both *Daily Maverick* and the South African National Editors’ Forum (Sanef) over the issue. Yet[another article of the same period](https://www.iol.co.za/news/politics/zindzi-mandela-backs-former-daily-maverick-contributor-in-smear-campaign-expose-44180598), again written by Mdluli, again reiterated Modiba’s falsehoods and once again trotted out Ictu to bash *Daily Maverick* — on this occasion with the ostensible news hook that Zindzi Mandela had expressed support for Modiba on Twitter. Although the original article airing Modiba’s lies has now been taken off the *IOL* website, the stories repeating and amplifying the false claims are still available online. #### **Modiba now runs his own ‘news outlet’** Modiba was able to exploit the online attention he garnered by lying about *Daily Maverick* to establish his own “news outlet”, a platform called The Insight Factor, which regularly hosts interviews with Radical Economic Transformation-aligned political figures and has expressed vocal support for beleaguered Public Protector Busisiwe Mkhwebane. *IOL*, meanwhile, continues to serve as a platform for attacks on other media outlets and journalists. Most recently, millionaire businessman Survé[penned a broadside](https://www.iol.co.za/news/opinion/a-free-and-independent-media-is-crucial-to-save-our-democracy-6763a582-244f-4f28-a103-9c5fce7cb5c2) against media “funded by capitalist interests”, and accused Wits journalism professor Anton Harber of “censorship” for Harber’s criticism of Independent Media. **DM**