Defend Truth

GRUBBY POLICY OP-ED

What could — and should — the Ukraine war cost South Africa?

What could — and should — the Ukraine war cost South Africa?
A protester in Pretoria holds a poster of President Putin of Russia in front of the Russian Embassy on 11 March 2022. (Photo: Gallo Images / Beeld / Deaan Vivier)

The increasingly unambiguous position of the ANC-led government towards Russia’s war in Ukraine — trending towards unequivocal support of Moscow — could, and should not be, cost-free. It should at least penalise those selling the country’s values for a caviar lifestyle.

Foreign policy has traditionally been seen by South Africa’s ruling party as the one domain in which it could embellish its revolutionary credentials, with no or little collateral cost, while being conservative in its domestic economic affairs.

Hence the fraternal ties with Cuba, its constant anti-imperialist polemic, mutterings for Africa about a new international economic order, and failure to call out human rights transgressions across Africa (and among ANC allies elsewhere) since 1994.

A failure to uphold human rights has, to invert Mandela’s famous phrase, been the light that has constantly guided post-apartheid South Africa’s foreign policy post-Madiba.

Now, however, by supporting Russia, Pretoria is stepping into an altogether different realm, where the consequent prospect of pain could exponentially increase.

Attendance by Defence and Military Veterans Minister Thandi Modise at a security conference right in the middle of the conflict amid revelations of mass human rights atrocities perpetrated by the Russians against Ukrainian civilians was a sign.

So too was the ANC Youth League’s shameful endorsement of sham referenda in military-occupied territories where “votes” were cast endorsing Russia’s occupation of Ukrainian territory.

Then, the loading of the Lady R in Simon’s Town naval dockyard was an even clearer indication of actual and not simply moral malfeasance. The scuttle since is that the Lady R was loaded with missile and artillery propellant and ordnance, much of this said to be expired materiel that otherwise would have had to be destroyed.

The ANC government has neither confirmed nor denied these charges. In answer to a question posed by the opposition in Parliament, Modise wrote in December last year: “I will be giving you hearsay and tomorrow you will be saying I am a liar. And I am very clear: I don’t want to be called a liar. I am waiting for the paperwork, I am waiting for the people who know.”

Surely that paperwork — even by the standards of a notoriously slow bureaucracy — would have been done by now. Yet South Africa is yet to hear Modise’s explanation. Until then, the “liar” tag is going to stick.

Follow the money

This is the half of it. There are rumours, too, of large-scale Russian oil shipments to South Africa, and of roubles being washed through South African banks. It would be surprising on current form if these deals were not middle-manned by ANC big-wigs who appear to admire Russia’s oil oligarch model.

But, as ever, the answer to these suspicions and allegations is in the money trail.

This can only be encouraged by an international environment in which there are no consequences. There are a variety of tools to signal American opprobrium for instance, including the Magnitsky Act, a tool of individual sanctions named for the tax lawyer Sergei Magnitsky who died in a Moscow prison in 2009.

It authorises the US government to sanction those foreign government officials worldwide who are deemed to be human rights offenders by freezing their assets and preventing them from entering the US.

Question is whether the US — and South Africa’s other purported allies — care enough about South Africans or care more about intergovernmental relations to make this call?

There is a difference, widening apparently according to opinion polls, between the two groups. More than 70% of South Africans believe the government ought to condemn the war and two-thirds believe it should offer Ukraine military, diplomatic or moral support, a survey by The Brenthurst Foundation has shown.

Visit Daily Maverick’s home page for more news, analysis and investigations

The ANC’s moral vacuum reinforces the perception that it is an out-of-touch old-style “liberation movement” unable to provide leadership in the modern era.

Even ANC stalwart Ronnie Kasrils has admitted on these pages that he is “by no means an uncritical fan of Putin or capitalist Russia”. That’s a relief, since it was a bit hard to tell. 

But there are wider consequences to remaining schtum. South Africa is rumoured not to be alone in profiting from this war, despite the whining about Africa being a victim of higher food, oil and fertiliser prices, and the depression in global earnings.

How much Malian and Burkinabe gold, one should ask, is being shipped to Moscow right now with the operations of the Wagner group in that country? Just how many Russian arms exports are being funnelled into this and other conflicts, especially via Russian allies in Uganda, Burundi and Sudan?

Such activities add a premium to the perception of the risks of doing business in South Africa and elsewhere.

Ideological windmill

The ANC will hope it can slip and slide its way out of this. President Cyril Ramaphosa will claim that he is doing this to be able to help position South Africa to make peace in Ukraine, even though South African credibility is now shot, no more an honest broker in Kyiv as it is today in Tel Aviv.

Anyway, the unprincipled predilection for compromise that would allow Russia to hold on to territory it has stolen by force won’t just now suit the Ukrainians.

Essentially, the ANC has mortgaged one of South Africa’s last remaining selling points — its human rights traditions and common liberal democratic values — for a combination of ideological windmill tilting and the prospect of grubby financial gain.

Its friend Russia has shown, yet again, that states which appear strong on the outside can be weak on the inside. State strength is not measured in terms of the hardware of legitimacy through performance (not that South Africa or Russia fare particularly well in this regard), but also inner strengths: political legitimacy, the ability to provide services to the population, care and the levels of trust that accompany these values.

Although a few people might be profiting from this moral collapse, as ever, the people will pay, including those South Africans for whom the cost of doing business has just got steeper.

At the very least, the international community, led by the US, should do us all a favour and ringfence and penalise those leading the country down this darkening path. DM

Gallery

Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • Jane Crankshaw says:

    Both the US and EU should have been harder on South Africa during the Zuma years and supported the minority’s attempts at bringing the ruling party to order! Prosecution of the Guptas & the politically connected by the West ( holding their ill-gotten gains) should have been stronger at the time. Now, our second biggest trading partners ( the EU) have abandoned all hope of a healthy partnership with us and we have no choice but to align ourselves more strongly with our BRICS partners. Goodbye to a healthy economic and democratic relationship with the West. Time to start learning Russian and Cantonese! Voetsak ANC!

  • Patrick Devine says:

    It would be fitting and appropriate that the ANC elite join the Gupta brothers on the list of corrupt, venal looting scum, by being added to the Magnitsky act.

  • Dennis Bailey says:

    Absolutely with you, but what might the international community, led by the US, doing us all a favour and ringfencing and penalising those leading the country down this darkened path look like?

  • Louis Potgieter says:

    We are simply not receiving balanced reportage about Ukraine. (I condemn Russia for their actions.) However, the US is fighting a proxy war against Russia in Ukraine to crush her, despite great risk and cost. The cost will be the sacrifice of the Ukrainian nation, who stand to be obliterated. The risks are war escalation and the nuclear option – with global consequence. This is according to dissident voices in the US, who say the war was avoidable.

    The US acts in the name of Democracy, which is a bit of a sham in the US. NATO is the US. The BRICS and others are increasingly turning against the hegemon, not so much supporting Russia.

  • Confucious Says says:

    All that the and is doing is strengthening the us/them status, where “us” are on the morally correct side of things, and “them” being the and and their ilk who are blinded by greed and fear… and make criminally bad decisions.

  • Scott Gordon says:

    Scary stuff .
    If we were getting Russian oil , it would be known by now .
    To celebrate the BRICS meeting I suspect super yacht Noord will dock here somewhere , for the VIPs .
    Maybe an offer from China to upgrade some of our harbours , for a % share 🙂

  • Steve Davidson says:

    I hate to say it, but this is one time that apartheid can be blamed to a certain extent for what has happened. First, Verwoerd’s biblical hewers-0f-wood-and-drawers-of-water ‘bantu education’ idiocy has meant – at the very least – we have two generations of poorly-educated countrymen and women who have gone on to poorly-educate the following generation; secondly, if ‘Hotlips’ P W Botha hadn’t been such a coward and ran away from his Rubicon, who knows how things might have turned out – Mandela would have been released a lot sooner, and maybe the ANC’s camps in the rest of Africa wouldn’t have created thieves like Zuma, Fraser and the rest of them. They might also not have been so beholden to the Soviets particularly, which beholdeness morphed into the BRICS group. While I am obviously totally against Putin’s war in Ukraine, I can to a certain extent realise the difficulty that Cyril finds himself in.

  • Cunningham Ngcukana says:

    Sometimes we get outraged by the callous disregard of the Russian criminality in Ukraine that we also become venal like the ANC regime. We fail to make the distinction between the ANC administration and the people of South Africa who indeed are in solidarity with the people of Ukraine. We must as citizens be able to show our disdain what the ANC administration is doing not to call for the punishment of a country and its citizens. We have other people saying very horrible things in these pages in response to this unacceptable behaviour that disregards the human suffering and destruction in Ukraine meted out by the terrorist regime of Putin. We have these governments that in these situations do not represent who we are as a country. Maduro and the Syrian fellow surely do not represent their countries and there cannot be non -alignment when the UN Charter and international law is violated and UN Secretary – General has called Russia out. However, we remain convinced that the criminality of Russia will not stand as the world and the valiant people of Ukraine have shown. The Russian thugs will be defeated no matter how long it takes and the Russian war criminals will be brought to justice. Rather, call for sanctioning of individuals in the government and private sector who cosy up to the Russian thugs.

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted

X

This article is free to read.

Sign up for free or sign in to continue reading.

Unlike our competitors, we don’t force you to pay to read the news but we do need your email address to make your experience better.


Nearly there! Create a password to finish signing up with us:

Please enter your password or get a sign in link if you’ve forgotten

Open Sesame! Thanks for signing up.

We would like our readers to start paying for Daily Maverick...

…but we are not going to force you to. Over 10 million users come to us each month for the news. We have not put it behind a paywall because the truth should not be a luxury.

Instead we ask our readers who can afford to contribute, even a small amount each month, to do so.

If you appreciate it and want to see us keep going then please consider contributing whatever you can.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options