Maverick Citizen

REFLECTION

Power to the people? Realising the full potential of civil society requires that we work better and smarter

Power to the people? Realising the full potential of civil society requires that we work better and smarter
Civil society has the potential to lead change, but only if it works differently by marshalling its strengths and overcoming its weaknesses. (Photo: iStock)

Facing up to South Africa’s deepening civilisational crisis requires an introspection by progressive civil society on the strengths and shortcomings of pro-poor organisations and movements. Are the current strategies of civil society making a difference? Are they capable of birthing the change that is needed to prevent state failure in South Africa?

South Africa’s income-poor are facing an existential crisis. The political and economic systems, and our failure to actualise our Constitution’s promise of dignity and fundamental human rights, are failing them.

Since the advent of democracy, the most vulnerable have faced a triple whammy of HIV/Aids (causing at least three million deaths), Covid-19 (340,000 excess deaths and counting) and natural disasters — like the April 2022 “rain bombs” over KwaZulu-Natal — that are increasingly linked to the climate crisis.

civil society

Unemployed graduates from KwaZulu-Natal and Pretoria gather at Burgers Park before marching to the Union Buildings in Pretoria to hand over a memorandum to officials demanding that the government find solutions to rising unemployment. (Photo: Gallo Images / Phill Magakoe)

Arbitrary load shedding is a new assault on the poor. It is not class neutral, as we have shown in recent articles on health and basic education:

Read more in Daily Maverick: “Rolling blackouts take heavy toll on the many who are struggling to survive

Read more in Daily Maverick: “Rolling blackouts aggravate levels of absenteeism, incomplete homework, disrupted classes in SA

Read more in Daily Maverick: “Rolling blackouts and the daily horror story faced by healthcare workers

If we don’t do something, it’s only going to get worse.

Since 2012, all of these storms (literal and metaphorical) have been made worse by fiscal austerity and cuts in public spending on key socioeconomic rights — especially access to healthcare services and quality basic education — as is well documented in recent research by the Public Economy Project of the Southern Centre for Inequality Studies at Wits University.

Fiscal consolidation (a Treasury euphemism for austerity) has worsened the crisis of mass unemployment, mass hunger and femicide.

That South Africa is fast approaching a tipping point, was seen in the July 2021 riots, and the November 2021 “no-vote” in the local government elections, where two-thirds of eligible voters didn’t bother to vote.

It is a miracle we escaped a further social breakdown in 2022.

As research by the Rivonia Circle and Ipsos has shown (read it here), both pointed to a loss of trust in all existing political parties and of conviction in the most fundamental act of democratic practice — voting — as well as in the rule of law among millions of poor people, and young people especially.

Conditions favourable to people’s power in SA

civil society poverty

A man walks between shacks in the impoverished settlement of Masiphumelele, Cape Town. (Photo: EPA / Nic Bothma)

But why are the poor and marginalised so vulnerable and apparently defenceless in the face of this crisis? We are not living in China, Hong Kong, Russia, India, Swaziland or Zimbabwe, whose governments have launched a war imprisoning and assassinating activists.

In contrast to these countries, South Africa has:

  • A transformative and pro-poor Constitution and a judiciary that is mandated to ensure the government implements it, and the private sector does not violate it.
  • A vibrant, diverse and active civil society that employs at least 250,000 people and spends billions of rands a year.
  • A potentially powerful trade union movement, albeit one weakened by factionalism and poor leadership.
  • A mostly independent media, although with skewed patterns of ownership and where the print and digital media mainly talks to the urban elites, leaving out vast swathes of our country’s poor and rural population.
  • Free and fair elections overseen by the Independent Electoral Commission, an independent statutory body that up to now has avoided political influence.

Most countries where the poor are under attack, have none of the above.

In addition, civil society has many other advantages: professional skills, access to knowledge and information, access to law and lawyers, funding, support in poor communities, connections to academia and linkages with international networks, to name just the most obvious.

Since 1994, civil society has frequently used this power to good end. It has notched up many important victories and saved many lives.

civil society

Food scarcity in Gqeberha. Walmer Angel Project and Sihlambesinye Comunity Services provide food to Walmer township residents. (Photo: Deon Ferreira)

Yet it has not reversed the trend towards deepening inequality and now barbarism. Children are starving on our watch.

Read more in Daily Maverick: “Desperate children are eating cow dung to line their stomach for lifesaving medicine, say researchers” 

A failure of strategy? 

Why?

With most of the tools civil society needs at its disposal, it has to be asked whether there has been a failure of political strategy and tactics by progressive social movements (including NGOs, the trade unions and the political left) that has allowed deepening inequality and the immiseration of the poor to reach unprecedented levels.

Could it be that the problem is more about our organisational behaviour than objective barriers or state repression; which is not to underestimate the dangers faced by activists in some areas, notably the murders of members of Abahlali baseMjondolo and the threats of xenophobes like Operation Dudula and so on.

Civil society has shown great strengths. But it also has great shortcomings.

Although activism has occasionally been the subject of some research and analysis, such as the 2020 Social Justice Sector Review report, there has not been enough constructive, but critical, analysis and introspection.

Read: Building from below and beyond borders – The Mail & Guardian 

Unless we improve, there is a danger that civil society will not be able to rise to the accelerating challenges of worsening austerity, xenophobia, corruption, violent conflict and climate breakdown (to name but a few) that confront society, and find desperately needed solutions which will only come if we can build power below.

In fact, the problem is not so much the lack of alternatives and solutions to the ANC’s mismanagement and corruption, but the credibility, resonance and power of those who advocate for them.

The observations below are intended as provocative but constructive criticism. Feel free to disagree, but at least consider them:

  1. In recent years, many activists have been lulled into an endless stream of conferences, workshops and policy processes that frequently lead nowhere; we are losing the ability for self-critical reflection about what leads to change and what leads to co-option. In this context, the very notion of “civil society” can be problematic. It starts by assuming a certain type of behaviour, which is then obligingly performed, and leaves activists often unable to build alliances across race, gender and class.
  2. Although civil society advocates for the poor, it is rarely led by the poor. In fact, much as civil society rails against the status quo, civil society have also acquired a stake in it, with medical aid schemes, pensions and privileges. While there has been some organisational transformation, it hasn’t been deep enough, particularly to open the doors to leadership by women and young people for whom society offers no future. The issue is not that my generation should step aside, but that my generation should pass the baton and cede the space; accept the leadership and the priorities of people who must now literally lead in the face of extinction.
  3. Generally, there is too much performance, too little politics and too little work done to build power and agency among the poor and middle classes. Activism is not about building the power of our organisations, but the power of the communities they are meant to serve.
civil society

Alicia Garza. (Photo: Paras Griffin / Getty Images for Essence)

Alicia Garza, the co-founder of Black Lives Matter, recounts in her 2021 book, The Purpose of Power, How to Build Movements in for the 21st Century, that: “Building broad support did not mean we had to water down our politics. It didn’t mean we had to be less radical. It meant that being radical and having radical politics was not a litmus test for whether or not one could join our movement…  winning is about more than being right — it’s also about how you invite others to be part of a change they may not even have realised they needed.”

  1. But instead of broadening its base, civil society frequently works in echo chambers, talking to the converted in an invented language of acronyms and jargon, directing its ire at its obvious opponents (usually in government or business), but leaving a vast swathe of the population out of the conversation.
  2. Yes, mobilising outrage at the status quo is necessary, but it’s not being sufficiently linked to catalysing hope in a social and economic reorganisation that is possible. Fighting for, winning and holding on to “small” reforms that can improve people’s lives, dignity and socioeconomic freedom gives people a sense of their own power.
    As Naomi Klein has put it: “No is not enough!”
  3. Is this because civil society doesn’t know how to speak in a language of the mass of ordinary people? By this I do not mean not talking down to “the masses”, but understanding the psychology of poverty and deprivation and what type of communication galvanise struggles for alternatives.
  4. Although there has been a welcome move towards creating coalitions and alliances around issues, civil society organisations in practice are often not working together, even when they work on the same rights such as health or education. On any given day, there are a dozen workshops on the same issue in different locations and none talk to one another.
  5. Finally, even though we are on the cusp of social implosion, there seems to be no galvanising alternative vision of how society can be reorganised, particularly a feasible alternative economic programme. Despite being a donor buzzword, there is no shared “theory of change” or political strategy to build an alternative power that people can trust and governments will have to listen to.

The revolution advocated for by the left, while necessary, is presented in a way that is far-fetched and dogmatic. As a result, recent history suggests that when revolutions do take place; when poor people are eventually pushed over the edge and see an opportunity to shake the system, the movements that spring up often bypass official civil society. And are ultimately defeated.

Most of my comments above are criticisms. I apologise for that. The alternative is to immediately rebuild trust, work with a common purpose and seek to make tangible progress by fighting together for the reforms we agree on.

Let’s agree that disagreement does not make us enemies.

It’s not about us, it’s about society.

We have reached a point in SA where civil society’s strategy should be to take power, get ourselves dirty in advancing democracy, and work within government and Parliament, as well as outside.

Read more in Daily Maverick: “Maverick Citizen’s tip for 2023 – get involved in 18 months of activism for democracy and service delivery

We all have a country to win.

In South Africa, the crisis combined with expectations linked to the 2024 elections mean the next two years will be mission critical.

Civil society has the potential to lead change, but only if it works differently by marshalling its strengths and overcoming its weaknesses.

Unlearning the behaviours, habits and attitudes that have disempowered activism is not easy, and the challenges of the moment are hard, but more of the same is not an option.

Yes, we all can. DM/MC

Gallery

Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • Robert Pegg says:

    Unfortunately, the same situation exists in many African countries. They can’t blame apartheid, but some blame colonization, although the masses have more to worry about than history. Political parties must set an example and stop squabbling like children. The rot starts at the top and good governance is what SA needs. People need to trust the politicians and everything else will follow.

  • Ann Bown says:

    Excellent article…from today we need to wake up the sleeping giant that still lives within Civil Society – if not now, then when? Yes💪🏽

  • Kim Webster says:

    We are witnessing the tyranny of an unproductive majority penalizing productive minorities. It is unsustainable and this article is asking that minority group to fix it.

  • Colleen du Toit says:

    Another excellent analysis by @MarkHeywood. I wonder who is listening? Many civil society activists of my generation hark back to the days of Sangoco and wish for a new national / multi-sectoral civil society association. However there seems no sign of such a body emerging. A civil society national conference billed as ‘Civil Society Unmuted’, hosted by Kagiso in October 2022 seemed to raise hope of coordinated action, but so far not even a report on the resolutions of that meeting has emerged. People working at the ‘grassroots’ are focused on urgent sectoral concerns and everyday ‘bread and butter’ issues including the battle just to keep food on the table – you are quite right Mark to observe that there seems to be no over-arching vision for change and a strategy to achieve that. Perhaps the Social Justice sector Assembly currently taking place will provide new ideas – visionary leadership has traditionally emerged from within that sector – however I believe in the passion and power of youth-led organisations that are getting on with important work in their local areas – time now for these to band together and lead us towards a more hopeful and unified tomorrow!

  • jenduncan24 says:

    I am passionate about our country, heart broken by the unemployment rate and what our country’s children in communities are suffering as a result of poverty, lack of protection from violence, and abuse.
    I read this article and am fired up to do something , but what? Where do we start!?

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted

X

This article is free to read.

Sign up for free or sign in to continue reading.

Unlike our competitors, we don’t force you to pay to read the news but we do need your email address to make your experience better.


Nearly there! Create a password to finish signing up with us:

Please enter your password or get a sign in link if you’ve forgotten

Open Sesame! Thanks for signing up.

We would like our readers to start paying for Daily Maverick...

…but we are not going to force you to. Over 10 million users come to us each month for the news. We have not put it behind a paywall because the truth should not be a luxury.

Instead we ask our readers who can afford to contribute, even a small amount each month, to do so.

If you appreciate it and want to see us keep going then please consider contributing whatever you can.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options

Become a Maverick Insider

This could have been a paywall

On another site this would have been a paywall. Maverick Insider keeps our content free for all.

Become an Insider

Every seed of hope will one day sprout.

South African citizens throughout the country are standing up for our human rights. Stay informed, connected and inspired by our weekly FREE Maverick Citizen newsletter.