South Africa

GROUNDUP DM VINDICATED

Daily Maverick wins defamation case as court slaps guest contributor Modibe Modiba with R100,000 damages

Daily Maverick wins defamation case as court slaps guest contributor Modibe Modiba with R100,000 damages
A magistrate has got it so wrong that a High Court judge has said: “Mistakes such as this have a potential to bring the judiciary into disrepute.”. (Illustration: Lisa Nelson)

Modibe Modiba ordered to remove comments and apologise for ‘patently false and defamatory allegations’.

An erstwhile guest columnist at Daily Maverick, who accused the media outlet of “racism” and of paying him, and other students, a weekly stipend to write articles critical of Independent News and its owner, Iqbal Survé, the EFF, and others, has been ordered to remove his defamatory comments and apologise.

Johannesburg high court Judge Keoagile Matojane said Modibe Modiba’s statements were defamatory and ordered him to pay Daily Maverick R100,000 in damages.

Daily Maverick sued Modiba for damages following his “series of false and defamatory” tweets and articles.

Despite being served with the summons, to which Modiba tweeted, “We’ll meet in court”, and then, “No place to hide as all they does is threaten and threaten but never act”, he did not file a notion of intention to defend the court action and did not attend court when the matter was argued.

Judge Matojane said it was clear that he had made a choice not to engage, and thus Daily Maverick was entitled to apply for default judgment against him.

Read the judgment, dated Monday 15 August 2022,  here.

In its complaint, Daily Maverick said Modiba had first tweeted that he had decided to stop writing for it because “they only publish articles where you criticise black leaders/ANC or EFF. Once you start writing about anything else, which is seen as ‘anti white’, they have a problem”.

In another tweet he accused Daily Maverick of briefing him to write negative articles about Survé and former Public Investment Corporation CEO Dan Matijila, to “spy on the EFF” and to “create false stories”.

He said Daily Maverick was using bogus Twitter accounts and using students to “influence the narrative”.

Independent Online then posted an article quoting Modiba claiming that Daily Maverick recruited students and paid them to write and tweet negative stories in a smear campaign against prominent people viewed as proponents of transformation.

Daily Maverick editor, Branko Brkic, in his affidavit and in evidence, said he had published four of Modiba’s “unsolicited” articles during 2019. He had not been paid.

Others had been rejected because they were poorly written, lacked depth, were incoherent and, as “opinion pieces”, lacked real conclusion.

Modiba’s tweets, which began in January 2020, had reached more than 50,000 followers and were extensively retweeted and “liked”.

The IOL article was retweeted by, amongst others, EFF leader Julius Malema, with 3.6 million followers. The EFF then published a statement saying it was “not surprised that political hitmen Daily Maverick had been paying columnists to write negative articles against those they disagree with”.

Then IOL published another article, asking why the  SA National Editors Forum (Sanef) was defending Daily Maverick.

The Information Communication Technology Union called Daily Maverick “a third force masquerading as a media house”.

Judge Matojane, in his ruling handed down on 12 August, said the statements were obviously defamatory.


Visit our Marikana anniversary page for analysis and reflections on the massacre that occurred 10 years ago.


“It is hard to conceive of a more damaging accusation that is likely to injure the good esteem and harm the reputation of a news publication or a journalist.

“Based on the responses to [Modiba’s] tweets which were disseminated widely, and his elaboration on them in repeated interviews on IOL, the patently false and defamatory allegations were believed and taken seriously.”

Regarding the damages to be awarded, the Judge said Brkic’s position as founder and editor, required that he be seen as honest and ethical.

“He testified that Daily Maverick is an online daily newspaper that has around seven million readers and it also publishes a weekly newspaper. He testified that it was founded to defend truth and honesty and its reputation is everything.

“He testified about the hurt he experienced. He could not count the number of times he has been called a racist since the publication of the defamatory comments.”

The Judge said Brkic had testified that “the insinuation that Daily Maverick and its journalists are all racist is not only harmful but despicable …. that the harm caused was incalculable”.

Daily Maverick’s lawyers had reached out to Modibe prior to the court case in an attempt to settle the matter amicably, asking him to delete the defamatory statements and apologise, but he refused and escalated his attacks with taunting tweets.

While initially Daily Maverick was claiming R500,000 damages from Modiba, its lawyers, in supplementary papers filed with the court, indicated it no longer sought a “punitive or exemplary amount” but rather compensation which would vindicate Daily Maverick, in the eyes of the public.

Judge Matojane said R100,000 was an appropriate award of damages.

He declared the published statements to be defamatory and unlawful and directed Modiba to remove the statements from all platforms and to issue an unconditional retraction of them within 24 hours.

He also ordered that Modiba pay the costs of the application on a punitive scale because of his “obstinate attitude and recalcitrance”. DM

First published by GroundUp.

This article was amended on 17 August 2022: a previous version said the “South African Federation of Trade Unions called for Daily Maverick’s closure”. In fact, it was a SAFTU affiliate, the Information Communication Technology Union, that supported Modiba’s position.

Gallery

Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • Amyisrael Chai says:

    Well done. I hope for his sake that his friend Iqbal helps him pay his fine.

  • Graeme de Villiers says:

    Will it be possible to have updated follow-ups to this please? As in, when the money is paid, proof/confirmation that the tweets and posts have been deleted etc.
    As an example, Brian Molefe still hasn’t paid his money back despite the court orders against him, so although this ruling has been made, I will be happier to read of it’s successful conclusion.

  • Sean Dames says:

    Well done for weathering the fight. It is said ” He who has big shoes to fill, will eventually stand on many toes”

  • Change is Good says:

    Fiery youth with no experience and EQ. Not the best combination for a person, nor those around them. This kind of anger often comes through from one generation the other. The youth of today need to forge their own way for SA to succeed and not to take on the hurt of the past.
    Obstinate attitude and recalcitrance only makes people unhappy and I hope that this writer reflects and makes decisions that will not set him back in his future career, future relationships and future life.

  • Karel Vlok says:

    Eish, not easy being a journalist, especially an honest one.

    Not that I count, but both uppermanagement (that’s my wife) and I enjoy your publication.

  • Madelein Jansen says:

    The RET faction and EFF have taken many leaves from the Bell Pottinger Misinformation textbook. If DM spend time and money defending false accusations, they have less time attending to the important stuff. Keep up the good work Branko and team.

  • Tim Price says:

    Congratulations DM. Keep on fighting for truth and justice.

  • Henning Swanepoel says:

    It’s called sensationalism Mr Modiba, your type makes those who want peace and to get on with each other sick to the core!

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted

X

This article is free to read.

Sign up for free or sign in to continue reading.

Unlike our competitors, we don’t force you to pay to read the news but we do need your email address to make your experience better.


Nearly there! Create a password to finish signing up with us:

Please enter your password or get a sign in link if you’ve forgotten

Open Sesame! Thanks for signing up.

MavericKids vol 3

How can a child learn to read if they don't have a book?

81% of South African children aged 10 can't read for meaning. You can help by pre-ordering a copy of MavericKids.

For every copy sold we will donate a copy to Gift of The Givers for children in need of reading support.

A South African Hero: You

There’s a 99.8% chance that this isn’t for you. Only 0.2% of our readers have responded to this call for action.

Those 0.2% of our readers are our hidden heroes, who are fuelling our work and impacting the lives of every South African in doing so. They’re the people who contribute to keep Daily Maverick free for all, including you.

The equation is quite simple: the more members we have, the more reporting and investigations we can do, and the greater the impact on the country.

Be part of that 0.2%. Be a Maverick. Be a Maverick Insider.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options