South Africa


South Africa’s justice system is showing signs of rot

There are still many good judges doing sterling work, but the justice system is rotting. For example, why has John Hlophe been able to stay Judge President of the Western Cape high court (pictured) for 22 years? (Archive photo: Liezl Human)

Judges and lawyers who care need to do all they can to stop it.

We are fortunate that during the Jacob Zuma presidency, the judiciary remained largely “uncaptured”. But for a long time, there have been warning signs of rot setting in.

The fault lies not only with judges, but with the justice system — from failures by the police through to the Legal Practice Council, the Judicial Service Commission, the Office of the Chief Justice and the Minister of Justice.

Here are a few examples we’ve either reported, investigated or are directly involved in:

  • For months almost no cases were heard at the Parow Sexual Offences Court because of broken stenography machines. No one took responsibility for fixing them. Neither the Department of Justice, the Office of the Chief Justice nor the Parow Regional Court appeared the slightest bit concerned when we contacted them.
  • A murder trial in the Khayelitsha Magistrates Court was postponed — not for the first time — because the court had run out of photocopy paper.
  • It has taken over 15 months for an acting judge in the Western Cape high court to deliver a vital judgment on emergency accommodation. We frequently report extremely late judgments.
  • In April this judgment was handed down by an acting judge in the Western Cape high court. We invite you to browse it. Many high school students, let alone lawyers, would be embarrassed to do something this incompetent.
  • It took five years for the NPA to get a guilty verdict against a teacher who sexually abused a learner. The case was repeatedly postponed for poor reasons. Needless postponements are standard practice in South African courts, and both lawyers and judges are to blame.
  • We have taken the Legal Practice Council to court because of its failure to act against a corrupt lawyer who committed forgery. Our inbox is inundated with complaints about this moribund institution. As one leading lawyer told us: “I don’t know if there is anything the Legal Practice Council has done since its inception that hasn’t been tinged with ineptitude, cowardice or stupidity.”
  • The Judicial Service Commission, especially as evidenced in recent public interviews it has conducted, has become hostage to the political whims of the EFF. It has failed to hold corrupt judges like John Hlophe to account. It is disgraceful that Hlophe has remained Judge President of the Western Cape high court for 22 years.
  • The Office of the Chief Justice was used by Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng as his personal travel agency, resulting in profligate expenditure.
  • The Minister of Justice has given a hand-waving inadequate explanation of his role in his former law firm’s shoddy investigation of Lottery corruption, for which it received millions of rands. There should have at least been an investigation, if not the resignation of the minister.

Of course, we also frequently report judgments in which courts have worked, judges have diligently applied their minds to complicated ethical problems and reached decisions that serve justice. But there are many other examples of failure.

The situation will get much worse unless good lawyers and judges, who surely constitute the majority, start to take action to reverse the rot. They need to ally with organisations like Judges Matter and speak out more frequently when their colleagues and institutions let the justice system down. DM

First published by GroundUp.



Comments - share your knowledge and experience

Please note you must be a Maverick Insider to comment. Sign up here or sign in if you are already an Insider.

Everybody has an opinion but not everyone has the knowledge and the experience to contribute meaningfully to a discussion. That’s what we want from our members. Help us learn with your expertise and insights on articles that we publish. We encourage different, respectful viewpoints to further our understanding of the world. View our comments policy here.

All Comments 2

  • I agree wholeheartedly,I left the police after 28 years of honest hardworking graft.Now that I am retired ,the community still trusts me.I have numerous people come to me especially women, as regards maintenance not being paid , sexual cases where forensics are so far behind etc, I never worked with maintenance, caught a few rapists ,etc,after 17 years working for the 1st time at a station I got to do with domestic violence(I mainly caught, drugs, f/arms, stolen cars,fraud, theft, house breaking etc).The only thing I can say that there is a lot of cheap talk about women’s rights, men having to pay maintenance, but the goverment and the justice department are facing especially women and children.The people that come to see me have given me the overall impression that court staff ,are dilly dallying, don’t have their best interests at heart , and like “arbitration”and sorting things out without a court case.I don’t profess to be an expert but these are worrying signs of a failing system.I still get lots of info about other crimes and there setups, and I relay these to people I trust in saps(and they are few)and they do their utmost to adress these crimes but it seems as if the “good cops”are getting fewer and fewer!!!

  • Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted