South Africa


Judgment reserved in city’s bid to overturn interdict preventing eviction of 31 families living in Obs main road

Barbara Vuza has been living outside the former Arcadia House old age home in Observatory since 2020, along with about 30 other families. (Photo: Mary-Anne Gontsana)

Former occupiers of Arcadia House in Observatory are still living along the street.

Judgment was reserved this week in the case brought by the City of Cape Town to overturn an interdict preventing it from evicting about 31 families living in tents and shacks along Main Road in Observatory. The group of mostly backyarders have named the area the “Singabalapha” (“We belong here”) informal settlement.

They originally occupied the Arcadia House old age home, owned by the Cape Peninsula Organisation for the Aged (CPOA) in May 2020. They were evicted and the building was demolished. Then they settled on the lawn outside and obtained an urgent interim interdict preventing the City from evicting them.

At the time, Acting Judge Selwyn Hockey accused the City of using its by-laws as a “quick fix” to evict the occupiers and said the City was “abusing by-laws” to circumvent the provisions of PIE (the Prevention of Illegal Eviction and Unlawful Occupation of Land Act).

The City approached the Western Cape High Court to overturn the interdict. The matter on Monday was heard by judges Patricia Goliath, Kate Savage and James Lekhuleni.

Advocate Ismail Jamie for the residents argued that the way in which the by-laws were being implemented was “unconstitutional and unlawful” and that the residents were under constant attack by the City.

Advocate Karrisha Pillay for the City disputed this, saying there was no evidence that occupiers’ items had been confiscated. She said video evidence of action by law enforcement officers showed no serious aggression towards occupants. She said no by-law had been used to evict the residents.

Judge Goliath said they were concerned that upholding the interdict could “paralyse” the City in this matter and future similar matters.

Judgment was reserved.

Singabalapha informal settlement residents picket outside the Western Cape High Court on Monday. (Photo: Mary-Anne Gontsana)

No toilets, no taps

Barbara Vuza lives with her sister Mase and eight other relatives in a small, dark wood-and-zinc structure. She says there are about 31 homes in the settlement.

“There’s no electricity here, so we use candles. We have no toilets or taps for water,” she said, pointing to five 20-litre bottles. “For a toilet, we use buckets or we ask to use the toilets at the Pick n Pay nearby.”

Vuza says she has been on the City’s housing list since 1985 and her sister since the Nineties. They want the City to allocate houses to them, give them land or renovate vacant buildings near the city centre. DM

First published by GroundUp.




Comments - share your knowledge and experience

Please note you must be a Maverick Insider to comment. Sign up here or sign in if you are already an Insider.

Everybody has an opinion but not everyone has the knowledge and the experience to contribute meaningfully to a discussion. That’s what we want from our members. Help us learn with your expertise and insights on articles that we publish. We encourage different, respectful viewpoints to further our understanding of the world. View our comments policy here.

No Comments, yet

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted