Maverick Citizen

PROGRESS? WHAT PROGRESS?

South Africa stagnates in fight against corruption — Transparency International

(Photo: Gallo Images / Sowetan / Vathiswa Ruselo)

Transparency International, a global movement working towards ridding business, governments, civil society and ordinary people of corruption, on Tuesday released its annual Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI) report. The CPI measures the levels of perceived corruption in the public sectors of 180 countries.

‘Two years into the devastating Covid-19 pandemic, this year’s Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI) reveals that corruption levels have stagnated worldwide. Despite commitments on paper, 131 countries have made no significant progress against corruption over the last decade and this year 27 countries hit historic lows in their CPI score. Meanwhile, human rights and democracy across the world are under assault,” reads the report.  

See the CPI Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI) report here.

It says that South Africa is among the 131 countries that have over the past 10 years stagnated in ranking, scoring 44 on a scale of 0 to 100, alongside countries such as Tunisia, Ghana, Hungary, Kuwait and Senegal. At the top of the scale (in the 80s) are Denmark, Finland, New Zealand, Norway, Singapore, Sweden and Switzerland, and right at the bottom are Somalia and Syria, with 11 and 13. 

corruption transparency south africa
How some African countries rank in the Transparency International 2021 Corruption Perceptions Index report. South Africa comes in at 44. (Source: Transparency International)

Karam Singh, the executive director of civil society organisation Corruption Watch, asserted: “It is extremely disheartening to find ourselves, year after year, in the same position on the CPI, with marginal shifts up or down. 

“The poor perceptions of how South Africa is faring in its efforts to truly tackle and dismantle the systems that enable corruption are perhaps to be expected, when one considers the staggering levels of corruption we have witnessed.

“As a civil society organisation working relentlessly to expose the gaps that enable corruption, and find solutions for creating a society free from this scourge, we can only hope that recent developments to bring corruption to the fore in the country will result in swift and effective prosecutions, and a restoration of public confidence in the political will to end impunity and lack of accountability.”  

Corruption Watch Legal researcher Mashudu Masutha, representing Defend our Democracy, which last month hosted an Anti-Corruption week campaign, told Maverick Citizen: “To improve South Africa’s performance on the CPI requires political will from the politicians of the country. 

“[This] requires a change in attitude towards commitments that South Africa has already signed towards anti-corruption, things like at the Ungass [UN General Assembly Special Session], which was a political declaration of mobilising transparency efforts for public procurement and also national levels of commitment towards anti-corruption policy. 

“There needs to be safeguarding of media independence, the rule of law, the judiciary and support of oversight bodies that provide institutional checks and balances.” 

The report states that countries that have sound protections against the violations of human, civil and political rights generally tend to do well in guarding against corruption. 

Sub-Saharan Africa scored 33 out of 100, which the report says signifies an urgent need for the countries to mitigate the devastation caused by corruption. 

Hennie van Vuuren, the executive director of Open Secrets, said, “We must follow the trends of corruption in South Africa and they are clearly worrying as we see them at all levels of government. Local government is the most obvious, but also the ongoing issues of high-level corruption that plague the state and private sector are pretty central and the trend is not a positive one. 

“But one can also add that there’s a problem with this Corruption Perceptions Index where the more we keep on repeating a thing the more we legitimise what is in effect a flawed measure of corruption around the globe. This is primarily the perceptions of so-called experts and business people… the majority come from the Global North. 

“Now we see this year that Africa features as worst on the list. We have systemic problems of corruption on the continent, but we have a systemic problem of corruption around the globe.”  

Van Vuuren pointed out that Denmark, which is in the top 10 countries, just four years ago was involved in “the biggest money-laundering scam we’ve ever seen” when the country’s biggest bank, Danske Bank, was found guilty of laundering in excess of €200-billion (about R4-trillion).  

Van Vuuren said that of the other top 10 countries, Singapore is a tax haven and used for “offshoring”, while Switzerland “built its fortune off a criminal economy by moving illicit assets around the world”.   

He said using such measures of corruption “just continues to absolve the wealthy countries who are complicit in the system of corruption around the world… we can fix South Africa, whatever that means, but unless the global financial systems change in a way that’s fairer, more just, we will always just be tinkering away at the margins.” DM/MC

Gallery

Comments - share your knowledge and experience

Please note you must be a Maverick Insider to comment. Sign up here or sign in if you are already an Insider.

Everybody has an opinion but not everyone has the knowledge and the experience to contribute meaningfully to a discussion. That’s what we want from our members. Help us learn with your expertise and insights on articles that we publish. We encourage different, respectful viewpoints to further our understanding of the world. View our comments policy here.

All Comments 3

  • A change in attitude from politicians towards corruption? Not likely from our lot – they are corruption personified. However. crucial to corruption are the tax havens and northern banks willing to take the money. A good point about Denmark and Switzerland – but what about London and Dubai? What about Bain and similar enterprises and the flawed big four auditing firms? So easy to point fingers at the bloated crooks of Africa, so much more difficult to hold the enablers and middlemen accountable. Sad and scary.

    • Good comment Virginia. The question: “Where to now?” Or worse: ” How much worse is it going to get before there is any sort of fight back?”

    • From a Capitalist perspective corruption is good as it allows business to maximise profits The South African government should be commended for creating a business friendly enviroment that allows corrupt big business to make millions in profits at the expense of South Africa. If this were openly said it would enrage 99 of the people hence the all the political parties and the mainstream media conspire to deceive the population by blaming lazy workers, incompetent blacks communism and the white man !!
      saftu.org.za/zwelinzima-vavi-on-illicit-cash-flows-and-why-unions-must-be-concerned/

  • Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted