South Africa

DAYS OF ZONDO

Themba Maseko & Johann van Loggerenberg: State Capture whistle-blowers call for protection after home burglaries

From left: Themba Maseko, former GCIS CEO. (Photo: Gallo Images / Netwerk24 / Tebogo Letsie) | Former SA Revenue Service executive Johann van Loggerenberg. (Photo: Gallo Images / Alet Pretorius)

The homes of high-profile whistle-blowers Themba Maseko and Johann van Loggerenberg were both broken into recently. They suspect the robberies were attempts at intimidation and have called on the government to implement reforms to protect whistle-blowers.

Former SA Revenue Service (SARS) executive Johann van Loggerenberg believes that if the government was seriously concerned about protecting whistle-blowers, criminals would not have been able to break into his home in the early hours of Tuesday.

“Continued calls upon the government to assist us in assessing risks to us, risk to the evidence we hold and to assist in ensuring our well-being have received no response or action or even acknowledgement. We remain under immense pressure on many levels,” he said.

Van Loggerenberg has provided crucial evidence on State Capture at SARS and has testified at the Zondo and Nugent commissions; he’s also a complainant and State witness in numerous cases in front of the National Prosecuting Authority and Inspector-General of Intelligence.

Yet he and other whistle-blowers say the state has not offered them any protection, leaving them vulnerable to threats against their safety.

Van Loggerenberg said his home and home office were burgled on Tuesday and the culprits gained entry to the premises “with some sophistication”, leading him to suspect that it was a targeted attempt to intimidate him.

As police are investigating the case, he did not elaborate on aspects he said “suggest that it may not have been ordinary criminal conduct”. He said copies of evidence were stolen (the originals are kept elsewhere).

“I have no doubt that if my safety as a whistle-blower and witness was of any concern to the government and if I had been meaningfully assisted in ensuring my safety, the culprits would either not have had the opportunity to commit the crimes they have, or alternatively would have been caught in the act,” he said.

Former Government Communication and Information System (GCIS) boss Themba Maseko’s home was broken into last week. Maseko was removed as GCIS head after refusing instructions from former president Jacob Zuma and Ajay Gupta to divert the government’s entire R600-million advertising budget to The New Age newspaper.

In the first of his State Capture reports, acting Chief Justice Raymond Zondo said Maseko “proved himself to be one of the foremost resistors of state capture. He stood up to the efforts of the Guptas, backed by the then President Zuma, to extract unjustified amounts from the public purse.”

After the burglary, Maseko told Fin24, “The events look absolutely suspicious to me, and it appears to be an attempt to target me and silence a person who spoke up on corruption.

“I have no shadow of a doubt in my mind that this is more than just a random criminal event.”

Whistle-blowers regularly provide the media and law enforcement agencies with information to expose corruption at great personal cost.

Gauteng Department of Health director of financial accounting Babita Deokaran was murdered in August 2021 in what was believed to be a targeted hit. She was a key witness in the Special Investigating Unit’s probe into alleged Covid-19 personal protective equipment procurement corruption in the province.

Describing former SAA treasurer Cynthia Stimpel, Zondo, in his report, said such whistle-blowers “are the final defence against corruption and state capture taking hold in [state-owned entities]”, without whom the chances of exposing illegal acts reduce considerably.

Following the burglary at his home, Van Loggerenberg said, “It is no secret that whistle-blowers in South Africa remain under severe and constant strain on many levels with absolutely no support from the government.

“We only have to refer to well-publicised cases where whistle-blowers and State witnesses had been assaulted, threatened, surveilled, murdered, or had to leave the country for their own safety. Many of us have been victims of suspicious house invasions, theft and threats.”

Last week, Whistleblowers for Change, a group that includes a number of witnesses who testified at the Zondo Commission and whistle-blowers in other matters, called on legislators to amend the Protected Disclosures Act, which they said fails to protect the lives and livelihoods of those who speak out.

They proposed introducing compensation for whistle-blowers for loss of income, expanding the list of individuals and entities to whom protected disclosures can be made, and establishing procedures for the physical protection of whistle-blowers.

Van Loggerenberg said decisive action to protect whistle-blowers cannot be further delayed. “The continued inaction and tardiness of the government in dealing with the entire topic of whistle-blowers spells disaster for our young and developing constitutional democracy.” DM

Gallery

Comments - share your knowledge and experience

Please note you must be a Maverick Insider to comment. Sign up here or sign in if you are already an Insider.

Everybody has an opinion but not everyone has the knowledge and the experience to contribute meaningfully to a discussion. That’s what we want from our members. Help us learn with your expertise and insights on articles that we publish. We encourage different, respectful viewpoints to further our understanding of the world. View our comments policy here.

All Comments 9

  • The protected disclosures legislation needs to be dramatically strengthened to provide adequate protection for whistleblowers. The current legislation is completely inadequate, and it is shocking the vulnerable state that these heroes who come forward to stop the corruption are placed in. It is a disincentive to come forward when this is how minimal the real support is that is provided. This is how the corrupt are managing to continue their looting- through victimization, intimidation, and fear. Until there is proper protection for whistleblowers, corruption will not be defeated.

    • Fully agree. Many whistle blowers have already been targeted, and even murdered, like Babita Deokaran. Judge Zondo himself has been targeted. So has the Constitutional Court. Who next? Once the NPA gets going with high profile cases, I just wonder how safe those prosecutors will be? Zuma’s request (demand) that Billy Downer recuse himself in his corruption case adds to the fear that those guilty of major corruption and participate in state capture will go to all kinds of lengths to silence whistle blowers, and even witnesses. Why did Magashule’s ex personal assistant, Maroadi Cholota, change her tune of first becoming a state witness, and then a few months later made a 180 degree turn. I am afraid that as Zondo is about to deliver his part 2 and part 3 reports, the threat to whistle blowers, witnesses, prosecutors, and investigators will increase, making actual prosecutions and eventual convictions so much more difficult

  • This is a disgrace and totally at odds with everything promised by the state and the president. That patriots put their shoulders to the wheel and risk life, health, livelihood and family to have the Government give the proverbial finger is outrageous and deeply demotivating. Apartheid dirty tricks all over again. Utterly contemptible.

  • This lack of protection is a clear indication that the President has no intention of fighting corruption, despite his statements of the opposite.

    • At this stage it is far easier and safer for a whistleblower to remain stumm than to speak out. The president will not honour his commitment to protect them, the SAPS won’t offer anything because it’s easier to stick with politicians, the Hawks show little interest in investigating the cases and there simply isn’t any government organ that has the slightest interest in defending anyone except the lazy ANC politicians. I guess that’s how CR wants it.

  • The ANC elitists will do nothing to enable the protection of whistleblowers as they protect only themselves from exposure and prosecution. Opposition parties should be driving the passing of enabling legislation in parliament to protect whistleblowers.

  • What will it take to make Cyril act in the interests of the Country and afford protection to Zondo key witnesses and whistleblowers immediately? Do we need mass action? Do we need to set up fund raising campaigns so that security companies can protect critical parties? Which organisation can put this into action before more assasinations take place. Van Loggerenberg could have easily been killed by the intruders.

  • My heart sank when I read the President’s speech at the handover of the Zondo Report:
    “This Commission would not have reached this stage if the whistleblowers in various entities did not come forward to uncover some of these acts wrongdoing, often at great risk and cost to themselves. We need to thank them for their courage and service to the country.”
    A simple thanks is not quite going to cut it, is it?
    Different day, same government , same mess.

  • Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted