REFLECTION
Accountability: It’s a pity we’ve seen and heard so little from NPA boss Shamila Batohi
Advocate Shamila Batohi now has her well-respected adviser Advocate Mthunzi Mhaga as the current acting spokesperson of the National Prosecuting Authority – but that’s not enough.
Over the past few weeks, a recording of the Hawks’ interview with Moroadi Cholota, the former PA to Ace Magashule when he was the premier of the Free State, has been widely circulated.
Cholota was interviewed last month in the United States, where she is currently studying.
Magashule was charged in November 2020. At the time, the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) announced Cholota as its star witness in the fraud, theft, corruption and money laundering case.
For a moment it looked like the NPA had a watertight case. But the about-turn by the prosecuting authority last month – when it said Cholota was no longer a witness – came as a shock to many observers.
The recording, which the Magashule camp has been circulating with glee, points to potential bungling of the case by investigators and prosecutors.
The NPA has now charged Cholota alongside Magashule, and has applied for her extradition to face trial in SA.
During the 96-minute interview that took place last month, it is clear from the very beginning that Cholota had no intention of turning against her former boss. The NPA’s case against Magashule rests on their being able to prove that he centralised major state contracts in his office and dished them out to pliable business people in return for favours.
Cholota is central to their case: the NPA claims that, when she solicited funding for cash-strapped students, she was acting on Magashule’s instruction. It is Cholota who penned letters to business people – including the late Ignatius Mpambani and fraud accused Edwin Sodi – requesting that they fund the studies of Free State students at various universities.
But Cholota denied this, even going as far as telling the investigators that in some cases she was acting of her own volition, without Magashule’s involvement.
In the recording, she also takes issue with being announced as a state witness without her consent or knowledge. The Hawks investigator then seeks to downplay the gaffe and assures her that the decision to make her a state witness was merely based on her testimony to the Zondo Commission.
But that’s not how it works.
Clearly, they jumped the gun in parading Cholota as their witness when she was not.
Mind you, the interview took place a year after Magashule was initially charged. This does not inspire confidence. As things stand, the case against Magashule is starting to look a bit wobbly. And, although that may be the case, the reality is that more than R1-billion of public funds cannot be accounted for in the Free State. That includes the R235-million in the famous asbestos case, for which Magashule is being charged. Then there is R500-million that was paid to contractors to build houses, before any work was done – and not a single house was built.
Add to that the R300-million that disappeared in the ill-fated Estina Dairy project in Vrede.
That is just in the Free State – and there are more cases.
Crimes were committed and the NPA has the responsibility to bring the perpetrators to book.
The latest threat of legal action by Accountability Now against the National Director of Public Prosecutions, Advocate Shamila Batohi, if she does not move forward on cases, is a reflection of a broader frustration among South Africans about the slow pace of prosecutions of those behind the mass looting of state resources. Accountability Now argues that the NPA is dragging its feet in key corruption cases. Batohi is partly to blame for this widely held perception.
For a top prosecutor, she is nowhere to be seen. She hardly does any media interviews.
If the fight against corruption is to be seen to be done, then our top prosecutor should be at the forefront.
For over a year I have been asking for an interview with Batohi, without success. Ironically, her appointment was announced by President Cyril Ramaphosa exactly three years ago, on 4 December 2018. But we have seen and heard very little from her.
Granted, Batohi now has her well-respected adviser Advocate Mthunzi Mhaga as the current acting spokesperson of the NPA – but that’s not enough.
It should not take a threat of legal action to jolt Batohi to convene a media briefing. There is now one scheduled for Monday, 6 December 2021.
Her position does not allow for her to be a backroom operator – it’s a very public job. And the fight against corruption is a public affair.
If the fight against corruption is akin to a boxing match, then the general impression from the ringside is that it is the NPA that is standing at the cutman’s corner with a bloody nose.
Not only were billions of public funds stolen at the height of State Capture, but we have also seen very little accountability. Batohi should regularly update the country on the progress of these cases. Right now, it does not look like we are winning the fight. DM168
Sibusiso Ngalwa is the politics editor of Newzroom Afrika and chair of the South African National Editors’ Forum.
This story first appeared in our weekly Daily Maverick 168 newspaper which is available for R25 at Pick n Pay, Exclusive Books and airport bookstores. For your nearest stockist, please click here.
Become an Insider
Batohi should hold a press conference at least once a month to update the nation on progress with each of the high profile state capture cases. This need not disclose sensitive information but should report what progress if any has been made in the past month. South Africa deserves to be given enough information to know if the NPA is doing its job, has sufficient funding, tools and competent personnel. At the moment it is all a deep black hole. Who knows if Batohi is discharging her duties properly or simply putting up a false front? It is high time she took the country into her confidence and told us what the status is with the prosecution of high profile cases.
I believe there are several crucial factors at play in this mess.
A captured NPA, which I’m sure is being constantly sabotaged from within, coupled with layers institutional incompetence.
It takes an incredible amount of hard work & attention to minute detail to bring a successful prosecution & not to be kicked out on a technicality. I doubt this hollowed-out institution has the capability or capacity to do this, even more so given the deluge of cases it’s “trying to deal” with.
Furthermore, if govt. was serious about bringing these cases to successful prosecution they would’ve allocated the NPA a comparable budget to what the window-dressing Zondo show was allocated.
As for Magashule’s PA changing her tune, why is anyone surprised? Who knows what threats these gangsters have made against her or her family if she doesn’t wind her neck in….
Another disastrous shambles inflicted on SA by the ANC & our spineless president.
The only possible outcome will be the ‘resignation’ (as with Cronje recently) of Batohi ! What a disgraceful waste of SA’s limited resources . No doubt … accompanied with ‘generous’ handshakes …and the country’s continued slide into a gangster state, with a useless NPA !
The whole thing is extremely upsetting When Shamila Batohi first took the job, we were all excited, because she had very good crime fighting credentials. It is a similar story to the presidential one- high hopes at the beginning, and then a slow downward journey of disappointment, followed by increasing anger and frustration. This seems to be a recurring pattern in South Africa.
The only surprise here is that people are surprised. A hopelessly inadequate appointment from the start expected to do a difficult job with her hands tied behind her back and, let’s be honest, a zero capability with respect to investigative ability in the form of the SAPS and Hawks. We’re getting exactly what the ANC always wanted – the destruction of SA as a political entity.
All is lost, it seems
It seems to be incredibly difficult to get rid of useless/criminal people in high positions. They are
suspended, sometimes for years,and then often leave with golden handshakes, or retire with full
benefits. In one case the head of the Crime Intelligence division, was eventually prosecuted after
many years of fully paid suspension,but this only came about as a result of the shake up of the NPA. There seems little doubt that State Capture was responsible for this and Batohi was handed a hollowed
out organisation, and had to virtually start from scratch to get it back on the rails. She has a SAPS which seems to operate without real leadership,and well trained and effective intelligence,the Hawks who are more like Sparrows,and is seemingly dependant on people who are just not up to the job. It is
almost like she was set up for failure?