South Africa


Chamber of Business CEO: Violence and vandalism was orchestrated, took months of planning

Chamber of Business CEO: Violence and vandalism was orchestrated, took months of planning
Unrest and looting in Johannesburg and Durban, South Africa. (Photos: Felix Dlangamandla / Shiraaz Mohamed / Leila Dougan)

On the fourth day of the SAHRC hearings into the July looting, the focus shifted to the devastating impact on businesses in KwaZulu-Natal. 'I can’t tell people to reinvest their money if politicians won’t stand with me and say this is wrong,' the hearing was told on Thursday.

The South African Human Rights Commission (SAHRC) heard on Thursday that the CEO of the Pietermaritzburg & Midlands Chamber of Business (PMCB), Melanie Veness, had seen seven dead bodies while surveying the damage to businesses following the eight days of violence that engulfed KwaZulu-Natal and to a lesser extend Gauteng in July. 

Veness also told the commission that she believed the riots were not “just about looting”.

“[It] was about destroying, it was orchestrated. I think that was the hardest thing for me, you could see how orchestrated it was — water sprinkling systems were disabled, linings were pulled out of ceilings, machines were emptied of fuel to try and set the machines on fire, [the looters] destroyed everything that was in there, they defecated all over the place.”

The criminality started following the jailing of former president Jacob Zuma on charges of contempt of court. Zuma was released on medical parole after serving a fraction of his 15-month sentence. 

According to Veness, the unrest cost the 700 or so private-sector businesses belonging to her chamber “over R1-billion”, but final figures were still awaited from insurance companies. 

Larger companies were able to claim from the South African Special Risk Insurance Association (Sasria), said Veness, but “a lot of medium businesses didn’t have that cover. Lots of businesses found themselves woefully underinsured. 

“Small businesses weren’t insured. One of my black-owned businesses in Plessislaer, his stock was destroyed, his business set alight, it set him back seven years. He had bought parts to manufacture machinery, those were destroyed. He has gone back to working under a tree in Dambuza (near Edendale township).” 

The SAHRC is in KwaZulu-Natal hearing evidence from those affected by the unrest, which cost the national economy over R50-billion, led to the loss of over 300 lives — the vast majority in KZN — and, at conservative estimates, left over 100,000 people unemployed. 

Premier Sihle Zikalala, who is also expected to testify before the commission in the coming weeks, has stated publicly that the majority of those who died during the unrest were looters that were “crushed” and killed while stampeding for stolen goods, or who had been fighting amongst themselves over the same. 

“That first day I stood in Barnsley Road (near Edendale township), I thought I was in a war zone, most of the businesses were destroyed….I walked past young people’s bodies on the road,” Veness told the commission. 

She said it was “absolutely horrific” to see the bodies, which she later described as “twisted”.  

China mall in Barnsley Road was completely burned and gutted. Makro was looted over a few days, as was a SAB warehouse and dozens of other businesses, including the historic Asmalls. 

“I asked politicians to come and stand with me and say they condemned what had happened, to say they support any investment in this region, and that the people responsible would face the full might of the law. I am still waiting,” said Veness. 

Veness said she had tried to contact premier Zikalala, but he did not answer her calls. As for the response from Msunduzi mayor Mzimkhulu Thebolla, Veness said it sounded like he “was commiserating”, but that there was also “talk from the ground that he agreed with what was happening”. 

“He never stood with me publicly and said that what had happened was wrong.

“I can’t tell people to reinvest their money if politicians won’t stand with me and say this is wrong.”

Many of the thousands of looters were armed and allegedly drunk, hundreds descended on business areas and malls, with scores driving to their preferred places of looting. 

Police were largely absent in trying to curb the unrest, and residents throughout the province in townships and suburbs resorted to fending for themselves by creating impromptu community patrols to defend their families, properties and food sources such as shopping centres, while waiting for the deployment of the defence force.  

“[The unrest is] something I don’t want to think can happen in our country again. The trust deficit is going to cost our city and our province and our country. The action we wanted to see [from police] in response to it was absent.”

Veness said that she regularly attended a “business fighting crime” forum, had a good relationship with SAPS, and had cell phone numbers of police brigadiers and captains, but that “literally no one was responding” during the unrest. 

“[SAPS] may have been overwhelmed for a while, but the looting went on for days. People sat on top of their looted goods waiting for transport to arrive. There was no adequate response during or afterwards.” 

Her relationship with SAPS prior to the riots was “good” said Veness, and each party would share with the other information that could assist in tackling crime, but there had been no early warning for the riots. 

Veness said that while she desired an equal society, there was “a tendency to make what happened in July about that inequality”. 

“People who led the insurrection used that to their advantage. It was too well orchestrated. To see what was spray-painted on walls — Free Zuma, Ramaphosa must go back to Venda, White monopoly Capital, it was about power….”

If the riots were in response to economic needs, said Veness, the unrest would have happened “organically”. 

“This was planned, it took months and months of planning and the modus operandi was the same everywhere.”

Businesses had lost 15 years of growth because of the riots, said Veness. “We have an exacerbation of employment. People are getting paid out, but will they put that back into the economy?” DM 


Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • Trevor Pope says:

    The ANC is up to their necks in this and there won’t be any consequences. More undeveloping of our country.

  • James McQueQue says:

    So many people rocked up in cars to loot. This does not seem like the destitute to me. Now the destitute will become even more destitute and the so called reformers in the ANC will be blamed.

  • Hermann Funk says:

    …and the president is fast asleep.

  • Fanie Rajesh Ngabiso says:

    ANC / EFF : Synonymous; The point of intersection of arrogance, incompetence and corruption.

    It is overwhelmingly evident to me that neither these parties, nor the vast majority of the South African electorate who keep them in power, are competent to make decisions in their own collective best interests, let alone mine.

    We are all – black, indian, coloured and white – witnessing the lemming-like implosion of our beautiful South Africa.

    I would truly rather my 14 year old son was running this country.

    He would do a far better job, and he would be honest.

  • Coen Gous says:

    Not any surprises here, The ANC is slowly but surely “f…..g themselves. Riots caused by ANC, billions looted, never to be recovered. Yet still Mickey Mouse, ala Ramaphosa stick with his guns, albeit without bullets. Now he himself, and his billionaire brother-in-law, Motsepe, have become the biggest funders of the ANC. Motsepe possibly bought his position in African soccer as well. How disgusting the ANC has become after 2007. But their actions with Zuma and afterwards will come to bite them big time. So will the idiot McKenzie, a criminal, and his PA party. The 2 of them, and the EFF make good fellows. But Malema will not last till the 2024 elections. His crimes will eventually catch up with him, as will many cadres in the ANC. Manuel was right, the ANC is well on its way to self-destruction, and well-deserved, despite Motsepe’s millions.

  • Sandra Goldberg says:

    This is one of the saddest articles I have ever read, but it also makes me very angry- angry that it happened to the small businesses who will be lucky if they ever rebuild, angry at the torching of warehouses and trucks,angry at the vile arrogance of the instigators and those who defecated on the ruins of shops. Most angry however, at the promises made by the president of the country to bring the criminals to justice- a solemn vow that they would be punished, and a subsequent breaking of that promise,as not ONE mastermind has been brought to book- that is the most heinous act of all.

  • Rolando MacJones says:

    Oh gosh. Finally a journalist reports on the other side of the story.

    Actually the neighbourhood watches and ‘vigilantes’ were the only thing standing between complete destruction and some kind of life.

    It is disgusting the way this has been portrayed in the media.

    Societies were overrun with marauding invaders. Yes they did enter people’s homes. Yes they did loot and burn.

    The media narrative is ‘racist whities and coloureds and indians’.

    Jeezuz dudes do you have no standards for blacks? The tyranny of low standards.

    Cos yes, all of the looters and burners and invaders were black.

    Think about that. The racism of low expectations?

    Indians should not defend their suburbs because poor blacks – they can’t help themselves.

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted

We would like our readers to start paying for Daily Maverick...

…but we are not going to force you to. Over 10 million users come to us each month for the news. We have not put it behind a paywall because the truth should not be a luxury.

Instead we ask our readers who can afford to contribute, even a small amount each month, to do so.

If you appreciate it and want to see us keep going then please consider contributing whatever you can.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options