South Africa


‘Deeply sorry’ DA changes its tune over ‘us vs them’ posters in KZN

DA election posters erected on Phoenix Highway sparked outrage, in the wake of the deaths of 36 people during the July riots in the area. (Photo: Mandla Langa)
By Des Erasmus
07 Oct 2021 13

KwaZulu-Natal DA chairperson and campaign manager Dean Macpherson issued a statement on Thursday afternoon saying that the controversial ‘us versus them’ local government election posters that had been erected in the Phoenix area, and were also to be erected in other parts of eThekwini, were in the process of being removed.

“In my sincere effort to honour the bravery and heroism of law-abiding citizens who were left to fend for themselves during the July riots and insurrections, the posters have regretfully caused hurt to some people. I am deeply sorry and apologise for this,” said Macpherson. 

The two-tier posters are branded with the DA logo, albeit on a darker blue background, and read: “THE ANC CALLED YOU RACISTS THE DA CALLS YOU HEROES.” 

The reference is to the violent riots and looting that engulfed large parts of KwaZulu-Natal, and to a lesser extent Gauteng, in July and led to the deaths of 359 people nationwide – the vast majority of them in KwaZulu-Natal. 

But of those deaths, 36 were in the Phoenix area, and it is this that sparked racially charged controversy. 

The deaths of these mostly black residents – from neighbouring settlements – that led to nationwide outrage at the time of the riots, as it appeared they had been targeted by residents of the predominantly Indian township.  Forty-three people were arrested and several cases are before the courts.

(For a detailed account of what took place, please see : July Unrest: what really happened in Phoenix)

Macpherson had previously tried to defend the messaging of the posters when interviewed by Daily Maverick on Tuesday, saying: 

“For the last three months the ANC has gone around this province, and more particularly the city [of eThekwini], calling everybody racist for defending their properties, defending their businesses, defending their families and their communities. That is a fact of life. 

“The second point is that we vehemently disagree with that. We don’t subscribe to that. We think that the ANC has used the race card to hide the terrible conflict and damage that has been inflicted on the city because the ANC decided to have a family argument on our streets, costing billions of rands and hundreds of lives. 

“We think that anyone that actually stood up, was the blue line between total anarchy and chaos that we were subjected to, [and] are heroes.”

It is understood that the posters also caused divisions within the DA itself, with several councillors telling Daily Maverick that they found them “insensitive” and “crass”, but that Macpherson, and party leader John Steenhuisen, had “doubled down” on their necessity. 

Indeed, Steenhuisen defended the wording on the posters this week when confronted by journalists. 

Macpherson’s tune may have changed, no doubt under duress, but Steenhuisen was yet to issue a statement at the time of publication. 

In his statement, Macpherson contends that the posters were “unsanctioned by the DA leader, party structures and party campaign leadership” and would therefore be removed. 

“Sometimes in politics our words may be poorly chosen, but I wish to assure the public, without contradiction, that my intentions are always sincere.

“My intended message was that in the massive void created by a failing state, unable to secure South Africans’ homes and businesses during the riots, some heroic residents were forced to stand up and do what the police and army were unable to do. This action was met with allegations of racism from the ANC.

“At no point did I nor the DA, and at no point would I or the DA [sic] ever condone or support those who undertook vigilante actions. In fact, I once again condemn those who undertook vigilante actions, which cost lives and damage to property.

“The DA is a party of non-racialism and it was never my intention to cause any other perception.

“I remain steadfastly committed to all people in South Africa, united in our diversity, and our campaign will continue to show South Africa that only the DA can and will get things done.”

Macpherson had previously tried to water down the way the message was perceived – as one stoking racial tensions – by telling Daily Maverick that the ANC-led eThekwini administration had approved the posters. 

“The only people who have been stoking up racial tensions have been the ANC and the EFF by calling all Indians racist bloodthirsty killers,” he said. 

The ANC in KwaZulu-Natal had described the posters as “a disgusting act of the DA to pit people against each other”.

“It shows the true colour of the DA that is desperate to an extent of spreading lies to gain votes. Their actions reveal that they are a party that will do anything as they thrive through creating division and perpetuating racism.” DM


Comments - share your knowledge and experience

Please note you must be a Maverick Insider to comment. Sign up here or sign in if you are already an Insider.

Everybody has an opinion but not everyone has the knowledge and the experience to contribute meaningfully to a discussion. That’s what we want from our members. Help us learn with your expertise and insights on articles that we publish. We encourage different, respectful viewpoints to further our understanding of the world. View our comments policy here.

All Comments 13

  • Can’t call a spade a spade – true to form politicians who “cannot run a bath – never mind a government/municipality” (acknowledge Mboweni and Manyi)

  • It is unfortunate that the July riots are painted as a race issue when in reality it was Looters vs Victims. I am quite sure if the suburbs under attack were predominantly black, that “black” suburbs would also have defended themselves.

    Should the people just have stood aside and let the mobs do what they want?

    Marikana is painted as police vs protestors, no race involved.

  • I’d like to hear from Steenhuisen on this, preferably in the form of an apology without weasel words about the actions of other parties. His strenuous defence of the posters when questioned by journalists doesn’t jibe with the claim that the posters were “unsanctioned by the DA leader, party structures and party campaign leadership”.

  • Rather than arrest, prosecute and sort out the insurrectionists, the Cyril-lite ANC decided rather to bash the Indian peoples who quite reasonably sought to protect their property when the police and security services were cowering in their barracks under orders from the Zuma-heavy ANC.

    No sensible, thinking sane person can see it any other way than this.

  • The DA needs to get better sloganeers on board. They have a history of poor or abrasive posters. It can’t be that hard to do better

  • Did anyone notice how little any political parties got their hands dirty in the clean-up efforts or charity drives after the riots, but nonetheless they all seem happy to use common South Africans coming together and supporting each other to try and gain votes? And I wish they would stop telling me how awful the other parties are and instead show me how great they are; great by contrast isn’t necessarily all that wonderful these days.

  • The tone-deaf DA again shoots itself in the foot all by itself. Race-baiting in a divisive context, the DA deserves all the lashing they get for this. They just don’t get the numbers: simple maths shows that pinning election hopes on minority causes is not going to put the DA in government. Simple fact. And here is the result. They have no one else to blame because this changes everything for 1 November. Even the most frustrated voter now is forced to confront the inevitable truth about the DA.

  • It is important that we do not get sidetracked by an insensitive poster in one area of South Africa, which all other political parties will jump on to take advantage. We must remember that the only reason why 359 people died at all, is because of ANC infighting. Politics is about point scoring and the DA are not particularly good at it, because they focus on other things, like running their constituencies well under trying circumstances..
    What we need to do is unseat the ANC in any way possible. The corruption scandals have not gone away and continue to diminish the nation.

  • Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted