South Africa


Whistle-blowers are important guardians of our democracy

President Cyril Ramaphosa. (Photo: Simon Dawson/Bloomberg via Getty Images)

We cannot let down whistle-blowers like Babita Deokaran. We must ensure their disclosures result in prosecutions and do much more to protect them.

Over the course of the three years since the Commission of Inquiry into State Capture started its work, we have heard of the lengths to which the perpetrators of corrupt acts have gone to conceal their misdeeds.

It has been an extremely complex undertaking to unravel the networks of influence that enabled corruption. Among other things, vast webs of front companies were established to move funds around and disguise payments made to politically connected individuals.

The same patterns have been seen in a number of investigations into corruption being undertaken by the Special Investigating Unit, the Directorate for Priority Crime Investigation, the NPA’s Investigating Directorate and others.

As these investigations progressed and the net began to close on implicated individuals, we have seen witnesses being threatened, their families intimidated, being forced into hiding, and even killed.

The murder of Babita Deokaran, a senior finance official in the Gauteng health department, is a stark reminder of the high stakes involved in our collective quest to remove this cancer from our society.

While we do not yet know the motive for her murder, she was a key witness in a SIU investigation into the procurement of personal protective equipment in the department.

The SAPS and the private security teams who apprehended seven suspects last week are to be commended for their work. The docket has been transferred to the Hawks, and the investigation will yield further information on why Ms Deokaran was murdered.

Regardless of the circumstances behind this tragedy, Ms Deokaran was a hero and a patriot. As are the legions of whistle-blowers who, at great risk to themselves, help to unearth instances of misdeeds, maladministration, cronyism and theft.

Without their brave and principled interventions we would be unable to unmask those committing corruption. Though much focus in recent times has been on whistle-blowers in the public sector, we also owe a debt of gratitude to those in the private sector whose actions receive less attention, but are equally important.

Whistle-blowers are important guardians of our democracy. They raise the alarm against unethical acts and practices in government and organisations.

They speak out in good faith and with a reasonable expectation not only that action will be taken on their disclosures, but that they will be protected and not suffer victimisation or prejudice.

In South Africa there is extensive legislative protection for whistle-blowers, including through the Protected Disclosures Act, Labour Relations Act, Companies Act, Protection against Harassment Act, and the Constitution itself.

In addition the Department of Justice, working with other law-enforcement agencies, administers the Office of Witness Protection to provide support to vulnerable and intimidated witnesses in any judicial proceedings.

Entering witness protection is voluntary, and neither the SAPS nor the NPA can compel a witness to do so. Should a witness receive threats to their life or feel unsafe, they have to inform investigators and apply for admission to the programme. This successful programme has played a key role in securing successful prosecutions since its inception, particularly with regards to organised crime.

It is clear that as the fight against corruption gathers momentum, we need to urgently review our current approach not only to witness protection, but also to the broader protection of whistle-blowers.

While numerous systems are in place to enable whistle-blowers to report anonymously, we need to tighten up existing systems and provide greater support to those who publicly come forward with information.

As society, we need to identify where existing laws and policies are inadequate in protecting the livelihoods, reputations and safety of whistle-blowers – and work together to address these.

The intent of the criminals who target whistle-blowers is not only to silence particular individuals – it is also to send a message to other potential whistle-blowers.

Day by day, brave South Africans like Babita Deokaran are standing firm that they will not be party to corruption and they are prepared to bear witness against it.

As the South African people we salute her and all the whistle-blowers in the public and private sectors who are exposing corruption to the harshest of glares. They are doing so without expectation of acknowledgement or reward. Theirs is the highest form of public service.

We cannot let them down. We must, and we will, ensure that their disclosures result in prosecutions and do much more to ensure that they are protected from harm.

As South Africans, we want to send a strong message that we will not be intimidated. Those behind the killing of witnesses and whistle-blowers will be arrested and face the might of the law, as will all who are found guilty of the very corruption these assassins are trying to cover up. DM

This is the President’s weekly letter to the nation released on Monday.


Comments - share your knowledge and experience

Please note you must be a Maverick Insider to comment. Sign up here or sign in if you are already an Insider.

Everybody has an opinion but not everyone has the knowledge and the experience to contribute meaningfully to a discussion. That’s what we want from our members. Help us learn with your expertise and insights on articles that we publish. We encourage different, respectful viewpoints to further our understanding of the world. View our comments policy here.

All Comments 10

  • Mr President, let us piece together what we do know. Firstly Ms Deokaran was a courageous whistle-blower who had been providing information for some years into corrupt activities in the Gauteng Department of Health. A great deal of money and effort was expended in tracking her movements such that she could be silenced. Now, which senior figures have been fingered, going back over the last decade and more in corruption at the most senior levels? Do the names Richard Payne and Brian Hlongwa feature at all? And what about the recently resigned Minister of Health?

  • And yet this brave woman reported threats and intimidation, but nothing was done? Same for Kinear?
    Less talk and much more action required to fix this problem. DO SOMETHING?
    And yes, the 7 arrested were probably the small fry. When are we going to see prosecutions of the big fish?
    Jon mentions 3, but there are sooooo many more.

  • Bla bla bla … all talk, but no walking the talk. How can any South African feel safe when there are criminals in parliament? When health MECs get an inhouse ‘fine’ for transgressing Covid-19 protocol, but for the rest of SA, we are told that it is a ‘criminal offense’. Clean out your own anc house first ….

  • In South Africa the guilty go un paid leave with full benefits and whistle-blower get murdered. The thanks for this lovely state of affairs goes entirely to the ANC and its cadre deployment policy.

  • Whistleblowers who expose looting of public funds should not only be protected, but should be rewarded according to the value of the looting they expose or prevent.

  • Well let’s see if protection for whistleblowers is increased- as far as we know, all the paper protections maybe there, but are they accessible, because the whistleblowers themselves complain of lack of protection-a really disgraceful state of affairs because thesebrave people really risk their lives in the service of exposing the staggering amount of dishonest and unethical behaviour in both the public and private sphere, but overwhelmingly in government positions

  • Mister President, with respect, you are a sham. Yes, whistleblowing is the highest form of public service but who in government rewards whistleblowers. Truthtellers get hung, drawn and quartered by the very government you lead in full frontal view, televised, popularised and dunked in the perspective of multiple commentators who add insult to your injury by pontificating on the inadequacy of the state’s response. It’s a sham, Mister President, a total and utter sham. I had hoped…

  • He he he.

    In Zuma’s time nothing would have happened. Nothing. Nada. Zilch. Not even talk.

    Thank you. I for one see positive change and remain hopeful for everyone in this country’s sake that we will see more.