Our Burning Planet


Gwede Mantashe hints at ‘special approach’ to refloat sinking Karpowership deal

Mineral Resources and Energy Minister Gwede Mantashe. (Photo: Gallo Images / Netwerk24 / Felix Dlangamandla)
By Tony Carnie
07 Jul 2021 21

Mineral Resources and Energy Minister Gwede Mantashe has hinted strongly that he supports extraordinary measures to keep the controversial Karpowership emergency power plan afloat.

Responding on Wednesday to questions on whether the government was putting alternative plans in place in the event that the R218-billion Turkish-led powerships emergency power procurement plan collapses due to environmental or Transnet refusals, Mineral Resources and Energy Minister Gwede Mantashe said:

“If it’s emergency procurement we must behave as [if] it’s an emergency and not deal with it like it’s any other contract that is given… so it’s going to be quite an interesting case for all of us — and in future we can talk to it.” 

He added that a number of parties — including chambers of commerce in the Eastern Cape — were appealing against the recent decision by the Department of Forestry, Fisheries and Environmental Affairs to reject Karpowership’s environmental impact assessment (EIA) in its current form.

The minister had previously indicated that all emergency power bidders, including Karpowership, have to reach financial close by the end of this month and that this date was non-negotiable. But his comments on Wednesday suggest that this may no longer be the case.

Mantashe, who was speaking on energy policies during a webinar hosted by the Absa Group, did not indicate how he thought the Karpowership matter should be resolved, saying he preferred “dealing with facts” rather than speculating.

But he remarked that he had previously been given information that the Karpowership project would be “frustrated in many ways”, including through the EIA process, Transnet approvals, an apparent refusal by Eskom to purchase this power or that the Turkish proposal would be delayed in the courts.

“We did our best to understand the reasons for all this,” he said, commenting that even the rival bidder who had launched a court case against the granting of preferred bidder status to Karpowership was also proposing to use gas.

Mineral Resources and Energy Minister Gwede Mantashe has breathed new life into the Karpowership plan. (Photo: Supplied by Karpowership)

In response to other questions about Eskom’s plans to transition away from coal to “cleaner energy”, Mantashe said it was “unfortunate that this debate is so polarised”, because “gas will be a major factor in the transition”.

The development and expansion of nuclear power in South Africa also held great potential and was “one of the most exciting fields, if you do your own quiet research”.

Just because the previous 9,600MW Russian nuclear power plant proposal launched by Jacob Zuma had collapsed, this did not mean that nuclear power expansion was off the table.

The development of new modular nuclear power plants made this technology “very, very attractive”, he said, noting that the government had issued requests for information and received 25 expressions of interest from nuclear vendors across the world.

So, if these companies were able to supply modular nuclear power stations, “let’s go for it”, Manthashe suggested.

Some banks were also putting “undue pressure” on the government by saying that they would only fund certain types of energy technology and this would “force us to move away in an unplanned way towards new technology funded by banks and collapse technology that we have relied on for some time, without a proper transition”.

South Africa was moving from high carbon energy to lower carbon energy — rather than directly from coal to renewable energy. He insisted, nevertheless, that South Africa’s commitment to the Paris Climate Agreement was real rather than symbolic.

Noting that senior officials of his department had visited Mozambique recently to discuss the availability of natural gas to supply South Africa, he suggested that some coal-fired power stations in Mpumalanga could be converted to run on gas instead of coal.  This was “quite a serious proposition” he said, as the economy of Mpumalanga could collapse and die if alternative energy and job proposals were not developed.

Responding to questions on plans to import electricity from the expansion of the Inga hydropower scheme in Democratic Republic of the Congo, a senior official of his department further indicated that South Africa remained committed to seeing this project reach fruition — although there was still “a lot of work to do” to make it possible to transmit energy from the distant central African nation. DM/OBP

Absa OBP

Comments - share your knowledge and experience

Please note you must be a Maverick Insider to comment. Sign up here or sign in if you are already an Insider.

Everybody has an opinion but not everyone has the knowledge and the experience to contribute meaningfully to a discussion. That’s what we want from our members. Help us learn with your expertise and insights on articles that we publish. We encourage different, respectful viewpoints to further our understanding of the world. View our comments policy here.

All Comments 21

  • Any lender, bank, consulting engineer, auditor or lawyer that signs this Mantashe deal up as a client had better get used to being blacklisted by the rest of South Africa. The entire deal stinks.

    • This whole RMIPPPP smells like a week old dead rat. It makes absolutely no economic or ecological sense. Too expensive at R 1.48-1.88/kWh.
      Karen Breytenbach, who was the head of the IPP office at the ministry from 2011-2019 was not replaced for sweet nothing.
      Feel free to find the interview with our “wise” minister with CNBC Africa, on 24 June. I mean the disingenuous dinosaur. Title: Minister Gwede Mantashe on latest developments in South Africa’s energy sector.
      If you endured the full 19 mins of his mumblings you deserve an award. Energy expert Eberhard labelled it full of “mistruths”.

  • There could be worse things for SA energy development than Minister Mantashe remaining attached to the Karpowerships deals as they sink.

  • I believe that the deal has already been signed. Barbara Creecy will bow and capitulate to her more senior anc comrade mantashe – all for the good of the anc. Remember – SA and its people do not count. The anc is all that matters? They need to stay ‘in control’ so that the plundering can continue.

  • Note how they tried to paint part of the company Logo, the entrance walkway, and even the deck a bright green. No amount of green washing will work ?

  • “The development of new modular nuclear power plants made this technology “very, very attractive”, he said…”;
    By all accounts, development of corruption aligned to most of the government (ANC) tenders probably remains even more attractive.

  • Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted