South Africa


Four days of Ramaphosa at the State Capture Commission could be crucial for SA’s future

Deputy Chief Justice Raymond Zondo. (Photo: Gallo Images / Veli Nhlapo) | President Cyril Ramaphosa. (Photo: Waldo Swiegers / Bloomberg via Getty Images)

Where were you and what did you do? What did you know and when did you know it? These are the types of questions that President Ramaphosa, who was the ANC's and South Africa's number two at the apogee of the State Capture, will face as he appears at the Zondo Commission of Inquiry on April 28 and 29; and again on two days later in May. This could be the most important testimony the commission hears, for a variety of reasons.

President Cyril Ramaphosa is unlikely to be the gripping witness Norma Mngoma was when he appears before the Zondo Commission of Inquiry on Wednesday, 28 April, and the following day.

After all, he did not make a habit of going to the alternative Cabinet meeting-place at the Gupta family’s Saxonwold mansion, and there are no reports of payola being made to him in cash and spirited into the boot of his car. Or even of him being gifted a Louis Vuitton man bag.

But his testimony is likely to be the most important in terms of answering questions of political culpability during the era of State Capture. It is unlikely that former president Jacob Zuma, who was head of state through the era, will appear before the State Capture Inquiry. So, the big questions will fall to Ramaphosa.

He will open with a statement on Wednesday, April 28, when he starts two days of testimony as ANC president and he is likely to treat it as a profound national moment of mea culpa for the damage that State Capture did to South Africa.

While the different factions of the ANC have lobbed missiles at the Zondo Commission, Ramaphosa has been steadfast in his support. He has set aside four full days to give testimony – a sign of political seriousness and support for the process.

His opening statement is likely to be more contrite than the testimony of ANC Chairperson Gwede Mantashe, who told the commission that the ANC had not been captured, although people in it may have been. National Assembly Speaker Thandi Modise stepped further towards accepting some culpability when she apologised and said that Parliament could have done more than it did to stop the process from becoming ineluctable by acting earlier.

Ramaphosa is likely to face the questions that often surface in the public square: what did you do, what did you say, and why didn’t you do more?

Appointed as ANC deputy president in 2012 and South Africa’s president six years later, he was in office through the years when State Capture ran rampant through South Africa.

All the major damage was done from 2012, as the graphic shows. In that year, Dudu Myeni was appointed as SAA chairperson, starting the airline’s crash and burn. A year before, a teary Fikile Mbalula (the then sports minister) told the ANC National Executive Committee that the Gupta family had told him of the transport minister portfolio he would get before Zuma officially informed him – later, several deputy ministers reported similar occurrences.

In 2013, the Gupta family landed a plane of wedding guests at Waterkloof Air Force Base. Mantashe told the commission that this was the first time the ANC realised the Guptas’ growing influence over the government.

From then on, South Africa notched up highwater marks of State Capture.   

These included the Prasa trains purchase, with millions of rands diverted to the ANC; the Transnet locomotives purchase, with billions extracted by the Gupta network; the appointment of Tom Moyane as SA Revenue Service commissioner and the evisceration of the revenue agency and revenue collection.

At Denel, under chairperson Dan Mantsha (later, one of Zuma’s lawyers), the defence company’s intellectual property was exported in a dodgy deal with VR Laser Asia, co-owned by Gupta lieutenant Salim Essa.

Former GCIS CEO Themba Maseko revealed in 2016 that he had severe pressure placed on him by Ajay Gupta to advertise in The New Age newspaper. Later, eight other ANC cadres gave evidence of this kind of pressure to Mantashe – seven were too scared to put it in writing.  Bell Pottinger’s “White Monopoly Capital” campaign against the media, the banks and anybody who wouldn’t ring the Gupta bell started in 2016.

Through it all, Ramaphosa was in office.

The only known action he took was to lead the campaign against the appointment of Des van Rooyen as finance minister in December 2015 when Nhlanhla Nene was axed. Because of Ramaphosa’s intervention, Van Rooyen lasted only two days and became known as the “Weekend Special”.

Mantashe revealed under questioning by Alec Freund SC that two ministers had come forward to report corruption in their departments. He also confirmed that the ANC secretariat had received reports of the Gupta family’s growing influence. He had told ministers and senior civil servants not to comply with illegal instructions.

Ramaphosa could face questions about his knowledge of these reports and what action he took as media reports of State Capture grew in number and detail.

The commission’s brief is to ascertain if State Capture occurred and also to recommend steps to prevent it in future. The evidence leader could ask Ramaphosa about the role of cadre deployment (the ANC policy of choosing party-aligned cadres for deployment into all levers of the state) as one of the instruments used in State Capture. He was chair of the party’s deployment committee, which should have approved the boards of state-owned enterprises. The most expensive and egregious corruption was at Transnet, Eskom and Denel through board manipulation.

Also, as deputy president, Ramaphosa chaired the ANC’s political committee at Parliament. The commission has repeatedly returned to the theme of how parliamentary oversight failed to nip State Capture in the bud before it harmed South Africa so severely. The president is likely to face a grilling on this aspect of his underutilised power too. 

For his part, Ramaphosa is likely to reveal that he was not kept in the loop about Zuma’s decisions, such as the nuclear project he tried to ram through, and about Zuma’s regular Cabinet reshuffles. Instead, as Norma Mngoma has revealed, a shadow state has operated where the Guptas were making key decisions. The president could argue that he was ignorant of its operations.

Ramaphosa will be keen to move the discussion to what can be done to prevent more State Capture. And this could see him turn to the gains of the era of state reform he has attempted since becoming president in 2018. DM


Comments - share your knowledge and experience

Please note you must be a Maverick Insider to comment. Sign up here or sign in if you are already an Insider.

Everybody has an opinion but not everyone has the knowledge and the experience to contribute meaningfully to a discussion. That’s what we want from our members. Help us learn with your expertise and insights on articles that we publish. We encourage different, respectful viewpoints to further our understanding of the world. View our comments policy here.

All Comments 10

  • Don’t expect any fireworks. This is nothing more than a PR exercise by Cyril to show the country, that unlike Zuma, he has no qualms about testifying at the Commission.
    Nothing wrong with that.

  • It’s quite simple isn’t it? Should cr have tried to stop jz, he would have been sent away, like many others (Nene, Ghordan etc.). He hung in there knowing that his turn at being the king of the anc would come, no matter the cost to SA and it’s people. Now it’s his turn to rule …

  • For your opening remarks re Norma to have any semblance of possibility … an awful amount of make-up (nay even plastic surgery), brow manicuring and ‘claw’ extensions would have to be in place ! Despite his acclaimed personal ‘wealth’ status … not sure CR has the means to afford that !

  • Gwede and his Karpowerships happening AS CYRIL SPEAKS…… Not much clarity or transparency there! Energy experts say wrong deal – better options. Seriously….. This is all a huge circus. We should be Fixing the mess and stop wasting money on Zondo!! Politics is so corrupt. Put Zuma & Ace in jail

  • The ANC can never self correct. As the ANC constantly preaches “it is a broad church”. And that is precisely its weakness. Whatever one faction of the church wants will be opposed by another faction. Witness election of Ramaphosa with counterbalance Magashula. So it can never expunge itself.

  • It all depends on how much truth he tells. From what heard today talking under oath before a commission isn’t much different from chatting to a stranger in a pub. Let’s be honest – the slightest bit of honesty here could sink the ANC.