South Africa


‘Illegal’ school teaches hundreds of pupils whom education department hasn’t placed

Grade 10 teacher Nosiphiwo Sakathi interacts with learners in a classroom at the community created Mfuleni Combined School. (Photos: Vincent Lali)

Mfuleni Combined School is run by volunteers and based in an illegally occupied college but the Western Cape Department of Education says it is unable to provide funding.

First published in GroundUp.

Although the Western Cape Department of Education (WCED) views the Mfuleni Combined School in Cape Town as an “illegal institution”, it continues to be a place of schooling for about 2,000 learners.

Department spokesperson Bronagh Hammond said, “The WCED cannot fund an illegal institution. We are guided by the Public Finance Management Act and other regulations – and therefore it would not be possible to do so.”

Community leader Nomnikelo Sidloyi says the school came about after community leaders collected 1,000 names of unplaced learners on waiting lists at schools in Mfuleni in January. Since then the school has continued to grow, and more learners keep arriving.

“When we asked parents why their kids could not be placed, they said they occupied land in Mfuleni and now their kids’ schools are far [away]. Other parents said their kids came from other provinces,” says Sidloyi.

“There are four high schools and seven primary schools here. Consequently, high schools have difficulty accommodating all the kids coming from the primary schools,” she says.

Sidloyi says the decision was made to occupy the building of the Rosendal Department of Higher Education Training Centre as a temporary measure until a new school is built for Mfuleni.

“We made a decision to force the college students [about 50 of them] out of the school because parents brought more unplaced learners and they needed more space,” says Sidloyi.

About 52 community volunteers work as cleaners, receptionists and teachers from 8am to 2pm weekdays.

Community leader Letho Dlali said they need a feeding scheme. “Most of the learners come from poor families. They don’t have money for food to eat during lunch breaks … Hunger makes learners battle to concentrate and fall asleep in class.”

Dlali said they lack computers and photocopiers and get assistance from other schools to produce school circular letters.

Parents have to buy textbooks and stationery.

“We want the department to provide us with facilities to help the volunteers do their job,” said Dlali.

When GroundUp visited, some learners were sitting on a grey blanket spread out on the floor.

Volunteer grade 11 teacher Mninawe Mabhele said many learners had no desks or chairs. “Some learners stand against the wall while others sit on the floor. You can’t move around freely in such congested classrooms,” he said. “There are about 56 learners in some classes and more continue to enrol every day.”

Mabhele said, “You instruct learners to wear masks, but they take them off when you are not looking.”

Julia Yaso, who volunteers as a receptionist, said, “Yesterday [30 March], we registered about 300 kids. Today, we have already registered about 200 kids.”

The learners come from Nyanga, Khayelitsha, Kraaifontein, Philippi, Mitchell’s Plain, Samora Machel and other townships, she said.

“Desperate parents keep us busy all day. Some say they could not register their kids in schools because they were unable to apply online,” said Yaso.

“The parents say education officials promise to phone them about where to register their kids, but they don’t do so. Now, they worry that the first school term has ended and their kids are still out of school.”

However, Hammond said, “We have attempted, on numerous occasions to obtain the details of the learners so we can place them accordingly … Two weeks ago, the group finally granted us access to some information, but it is unfortunately not adequate to successfully place learners. We need certain information so that which can identify the learners’ correct grades and previous schools.” DM


Comments - share your knowledge and experience

Please note you must be a Maverick Insider to comment. Sign up here or sign in if you are already an Insider.

Everybody has an opinion but not everyone has the knowledge and the experience to contribute meaningfully to a discussion. That’s what we want from our members. Help us learn with your expertise and insights on articles that we publish. We encourage different, respectful viewpoints to further our understanding of the world. View our comments policy here.

No Comments, yet

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted