Our Burning Planet

DM168 Op-Ed

Our Burning Planet: Kids, about your inheritance…

Our Burning Planet: Kids, about your inheritance…
Pinnock:Dear Children

My generation has left you a shitshow of planetary proportions. It’s going to take you a long time to get out of the muck. So sorry.

First published in the Daily Maverick 168 weekly newspaper.

As 2021 begins, let’s discuss your inheritance. Basically, you’ll be starting from scratch. The generation that has been in power since World War 2 – my generation – has used up almost everything.

For our pleasure, leisure and fragile sense of security, we dammed most of the Earth’s rivers to generate electricity for factories to make things we used a few times then threw away. Go and check the dumps if you don’t believe me.

It’s true we kept the lights on at home so you could do your homework and charge your cellphones. Wind farms and solar panels helped, and I hope that’s all you’ll be using in your future. But for too long we kept the machinery going on coal and oil, which put so much carbon dioxide into the sky your planet will be a lot hotter than ours.

I can’t offer you any advice about how to cope with this, except to say really, really sorry. Maybe by the time you grow up Antarctica will be free of ice and might be quite pleasant. It’s worth a try.

I hope you understand we needed all the stuff coal and oil gave us – well, we thought we did. Two-and-a-half planets’ worth from a single planet, to be exact. We failed to notice we were all suffering from hurry sickness, so we didn’t have time to stop and think about what we were doing.

Talking about homework, what you learnt at school will be of little use for the sort of lives you’ll be living because it’s geared towards the sort of life we’re living, which won’t be around when you grow up.

It’s a pity, but we had to keep you busy during the day while we drained your future’s natural resources without providing renewable ones. Your resources will probably be good for about two weeks after you inherit them.

We built many really beautiful buildings you’d love, but tore them down to build cheap, featureless boxes with a life span equal to ours. You might get a few more years out of them, but not many. They’re yours to use while they last.

I’m really embarrassed about the wild animals we painted on your nursery walls and all the cuddly elephants, lions, bears and whales and stuff. Bum steer. I suspect they’ll deepen your sense of loss when you can’t find them for real.

But you see, we needed their tusks to make pretty carvings, their bones to make disgusting wine, their skins, their oil and their bile. Well, we didn’t really, but were convinced we did. We forgot to remember they’d run out and now we can’t bring them back. Extinct. You’ll be the first generation to live with a separation crisis about the depletion of the living world.

In time, other of life’s creatures may reach across the depths of space to greet you. But until that happens, you alone on Earth are aware of this possibility. It may be a long wait.

But keep all those toys as mementos. They’ll be valuable some day. You could put them in a museum of lost animals.

And while I’m thinking of it, sorry about the fish. No fish. See what you can do with the sea urchins and jellyfish that took over. There must be something.

Oh yes, I need to explain those deserts. They used to be farms. Strange, hey? Anyway, we pulled out all the natural plants and planted wheat and things like that. We called it the Green Revolution. Only it didn’t revolve.

We pumped mineral-rich water from nonrenewable underground aquifers year after year until the soil was so full of salt nothing would grow. Then rain washed most of the topsoil into the rivers because there were no plants to hold it. It went out to sea, where the fertilisers we used in it killed fish. So it wasn’t just the plastic.

Then there’s the economy. It’s difficult to explain why you have no money. It would’ve been so useful. Fewer and fewer of us scooped up more and more of it, fiddling the books or selling stuff that at root we really didn’t need. It was like draining the swamp of value. I really can’t say what happened to it in the end. It kind of vanished.

So think of your inheritance as a challenge – the challenge of starting from scratch. And, by the way, don’t forget to pay off our $100-trillion debt to the World Bank.

It really needs it because it also can’t find the money.

Speaking of inheritance, we did leave you some things that are really durable. Plastic comes to mind. It’s just so useful, but it did kill the oceans and most of the sea birds, so you have to be careful. Maybe you’ll work out what to do with those huge plastic trash heaps floating in the sea. They’re yours. You can have them, courtesy of the 20th century.

I can add toxic dumps. They’ll last, especially the nuclear ones that’ll be around for the next 200,000 years or so. Your best brains can work out the sort of Keep Out signs that’ll make sense for that long. It’s an interesting challenge.

I almost forgot the virus. How remiss, given that we’re all masked up and locked down. We hacked down tropical forests to plant oil palm trees so we could have cheap oil for frying our breakfasts and making potato crisps. Cheaper than whale and sunflower oil. Pity about the orang-utans. We were closely related, you know.

Then we hunted forest creatures we’d never eaten before and they turned out to be full of dangerous pathogens that killed half the world’s population. But in a way that’s good – fewer people to feed. A word of warning though – never eat bats. Come to think of it, don’t eat any wild creatures. You can never tell.

As a solace in the hard times we’ve bequeathed you, try to keep this in mind, something we missed in our scramble to buy the world: the Earth is your mother and you are her gift to the universe. Your wisdom and understanding are also its wisdom and understanding. In fact, you are the eyes of the universe looking at itself. That’s pretty cool. Treasure it above all else and use it to care for all life, including your own.

In time, other of life’s creatures may reach across the depths of space to greet you. But until that happens, you alone on Earth are aware of this possibility. It may be a long wait.

Meanwhile, the wild living things that survived us are the only fellow citizens you’ll ever have. They share equally your right and privilege to be on Earth. Do them no harm. Respect their lifeways. They’re fellow travellers on this blue spaceship and will give you great joy.

We wish you a long and happy life, though I’m sorry it won’t be as long and happy as ours. Not for a while, anyway. You have so much work to rebuild from the wasteland we left you. Again, I am sorry. We screwed up. Best of luck.


Your parents DM168

This story first appeared in our weekly Daily Maverick 168 newspaper which is available for free to Pick n Pay Smart Shoppers at these Pick n Pay stores.

Absa OBP

Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • Steyn Grobler says:

    I enjoyed this. It is amazing what a well written apology can do.

  • Ritchie Morris says:

    Thank you Dr Don for a thought provoking and somewhat tongue in cheek article. However, poignant.
    BUT – it all comes back to carrying capacity. The number of human animals and our way of life is not suitable for the Earth. As an example…………
    On 28 November 2020 Dr Greg Mills had an article in the DM titled, “Malawi’s lesson for Africa: Tomorrow starts today”. It notes that Malawi’s population is expected to double by 2050, from around 20 million today, and will be near 70 million by 2100. Malawi currently has a population density of 165 people per km2. Its the highest in the southern Africa region – by FAR – see other country comparison at the end of this article. Malawi’s carrying capacity was exceeded many years ago – that is why there are so many Malawians living elsewhere – many in South Africa. As a Malawian said to me in Hout Bay, ‘MALAWI IS FULL’ – and that is why he was looking for work in South Africa – he needed to feed his family. Dr Mills continued that ‘Malawi has the EIGHTH HIGHEST birthrate worldwide – there is 1 birth every 45 seconds and 1 death every 4 minutes. Already TWO-THIRDS of the population is under the age of 24″. The rest of this article paints a grim picture – why should it be allowed to persist?
    THE CARRYING CAPACITY OF THE EARTH HAS BEEN EXCEEDED – compounded by lifestyle expectations and certain countries greed and need to satisfy their own needs by ‘stealing’ resources from other countries via dubious and illegal means. That’s why the Earth is in the state it is – inequitable resource use and abuse of natural systems. And this is the reason why Dr Don Pinnock felt it necessary to write this poignant apology.
    Unless leaders – politicians, religious, medical, business managers – right down to civil society and individuals manage population growth, the Earth is screwed and the kids inheritance that Dr Don refers to will be further diminished. One sentence of Dr Mills article shines light on where the problem is and where a solution may lie, “It demands deciding what not to do as much as what to focus on, a political task if ever there was one. It requires getting government out of business….” And here is the problem in many countries – governments (especially Politicians) have become too powerful in final decision making – many are incapable of making rationale decisions around policy that support carrying capacity principles. Many politicians are not qualified to make decisions about matters they are responsible for. Decision making must be taken back by the technical and scientific experts and business leaders. Governments must listen, and if they make the wrong decision, held accountable, not propped-up by further aid.

    SADC population densities (people per km2): Malawi = 165, Swaziland = 79, Lesotho = 74, South Africa = 47, Zimbabwe = 42, Mozambique = 37, Angola = 24, Zambia = 23, Botswana = 4 and Namibia = 3. Its a crude criteria, but illustrates how many people need to be supported by how much land. Environmental resources vary spatially.
    If the population of Malawi is ALLOWED to double in the next 30 years, its a disaster in the making. Why let it happen?
    Thank you.

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted

home delivery

Say hello to DM168 home delivery

Get your favourite newspaper delivered to your doorstep every weekend.

Delivery is available in Gauteng, the Western Cape, KwaZulu-Natal, and the Eastern Cape.

A South African Hero: You

There’s a 99.7% chance that this isn’t for you. Only 0.3% of our readers have responded to this call for action.

Those 0.3% of our readers are our hidden heroes, who are fuelling our work and impacting the lives of every South African in doing so. They’re the people who contribute to keep Daily Maverick free for all, including you.

The equation is quite simple: the more members we have, the more reporting and investigations we can do, and the greater the impact on the country.

Be part of that 0.3%. Be a Maverick. Be a Maverick Insider.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options

MavericKids vol 3

How can a child learn to read if they don't have a book?

81% of South African children aged 10 can't read for meaning. You can help by pre-ordering a copy of MavericKids.

For every copy sold we will donate a copy to Gift of The Givers for children in need of reading support.