South Africa

Days of Zondo

End of the line as Zondo tells Zuma appearance dates are non-negotiable

Deputy Chief Justice Raymond Zondo Picture: Veli Nhlapo Former president Jacob Zuma Picture: THULI DLAMINI
By Erin Bates
21 Sep 2020 10

Former President Jacob Zuma is running out of options. Next month, the State Capture Inquiry’s legal team will again argue why the Chairperson should sign off a summons against Zuma. Deputy Chief Justice Raymond Zondo has decided on new dates for Zuma’s second appearance – and they are not up for discussion.

State Capture Inquiry Chairperson Deputy Chief Justice Raymond Zondo expects former President Jacob Zuma to testify at the commission from Monday, 16 November to Friday, 20 November 2020. “We do not negotiate dates with witnesses,” Zondo said sternly on Monday, 21 September 2020. 

Monday’s sitting began with Zondo updating the public on correspondence between Zuma’s legal team and the secretariat of the Commission of Inquiry into Allegations of State Capture, Corruption and Fraud. 

“Previously, I determined that today up to Friday would be the week when the former President, Mr Jacob Zuma, would appear before this commission,” said Zondo. “He was notified thereof and after some time his attorneys wrote to the commission and said that he would not be appearing before this commission during this week.”

Going through some changes 

Per Zondo, the former president’s attorneys gave at least three reasons why Zuma would not testify this week. They were: Zuma was preparing for his criminal trial, the 78-year-old received medical advice he should limit his movements due to his age and Covid-19, and Zuma was taking legal advice after a vital change to the inquiry’s regulations. 

“I do not want to comment at this stage on his reasons for deciding that he would not appear before this commission this week,” Zondo said on Monday morning. 

In July, President Cyril Ramaphosa and Minister of Justice Ronald Lamola co-signed a change to a secrecy clause in the Rules and Regulations. Previously, a clause muzzled the inquiry’s investigators. Since the change, investigators who have completed their work for the commission can now migrate to other law enforcement agencies. 

Advocate Hermione Cronje, who leads the Investigative Directorate at the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA), told Daily Maverick the amendment was a “shot in the arm” for the NPA. “It’s human capital, but it’s domain knowledge. It’s their understanding. They’ve been debating these issues across teams. They have a much better understanding from the top,” Cronje said of the inquiry’s investigators. 

Since the State Capture Inquiry began public hearings in August 2018, Zuma appeared for only five days of testimony, during which he repeatedly denied allegations against him and reported he did not recall critical facts. 

On Friday, 19 July 2019 which was the last day of evidence from Zuma to date, he briefly withdrew cooperation altogether claiming he was enduring cross-examination by head of the legal team and evidence leader, Advocate Paul Pretorius SC. 

“Chair, quite frankly, this is a joke,” Zuma’s representative Advocate Muzi Sikhakhane SC told Zondo. Sikhakhane argued Zuma should receive the same treatment as Minister of Public Enterprises, Pravin Gordhan, and former Minister of Finance, Nhlanhla Nene. 

Other witnesses, such as Mzwanele Manyi, have similarly criticised Zondo and the inquiry’s legal team for treating some witnesses as sweethearts. When Advocate Kate Hofmeyr interrogated Manyi about his conduct at the Department of Labour, Manyi griped he was being “crucified” at the commission

With or without you

Since Zuma will not return this week, evidence on corruption in the Free State has been moved forward. 

Zondo announced that on Friday, 9 October 2020 at 9am he will hear the legal team’s application for an order from him authorising the issuing of a summons against Zuma. 

“He and his lawyers have been informed that, unless I am satisfied on that date that there are good grounds for them not to appear, if they do not appear that application will proceed without them,” said Zondo. 

“They have been informed that should they wish to make use of a virtual appearance before the commission and if they inform the commission timeously arrangements will be made for them to appear virtually before the commission.” 

He added: “But that application will proceed with or without them unless I am satisfied that there are good grounds for them not to be here.” 

Zondo recorded a remark in one of the letters from Zuma’s attorneys, which suggested dates should be negotiated.  “No dates will be negotiated with them or with him,” said a stony-faced Zondo. “This commission has made it clear to the attorneys who represented him before that this commission does not negotiate dates with witnesses.”

It’s a date 

Zondo concluded repeating the dates set down for Zuma’s second leg of evidence at the State Capture Inquiry.  “The dates of 16 to 20 November 2020 have been determined for his appearance. That is all I wanted to say about that matter,” said Zondo. Pretorius then introduced the week’s evidence on corruption in the Free State. DM

Gallery

Comments - share your knowledge and experience

Please note you must be a Maverick Insider to comment. Sign up here or sign in if you are already an Insider.

Everybody has an opinion but not everyone has the knowledge and the experience to contribute meaningfully to a discussion. That’s what we want from our members. Help us learn with your expertise and insights on articles that we publish. We encourage different, respectful viewpoints to further our understanding of the world. View our comments policy here.

All Comments 10

  • Typical Zuma. Ducking and diving, lying, denying, delaying, obfuscating etc. – anything to avoid having to account for his nefarious misdeeds, which has crippled this country to the point of a virtual wasteland. Yet there are people in SA who believe that he wants his day in court. Round him up, bring him kicking and screaming, this farce can no longer be tolerated! Wait for it – the next move will be a trumped up report from Cuba, stating that he is too ill too infirm and too old to appear even while he toyi toyis with gusto.

    • Equally likely is that in the meantime he will find a private jet waiting for him at an obscure airfield from where he will be whisked off to Dubai like the Guptas, or Haiti, Cuba, Russia, who knows. He’s a flight risk. Arrest him on suspicion NOW and lock him up until he gets “his day in court”. He won’t appear otherwise.

  • Interesting how those involved in corruption perceive the commission to be “crucifying them” while those with nothing to hide are “treated as sweethearts.” Zuma’s ducking and diving will continue until his death or orange overalls. I doubt it will be the latter.

  • Since July, ” investigators who have completed their work for the commission can now migrate to other law enforcement agencies”. While Cronje thinks this is very valuable, she has not moved on bringing charges, seizing assets or passports. What exactly are she and Batoyi waiting for?

    • The actual consequence will be – NOTHING – and he knows it. He was, is and will be protected by the anc until either he or the organisation eventually dies.

  • I would really prefer that all the assets of the corrupt regime are liquidated and any overseas assets repatriated. don’t want to have to spend my tax on providing luxury accommodation in jail for any of these criminals. let them spend the remainder of their lives in poverty.

  • I think that saying “Former president Jacob Zuma is running out of options.” is wishful thinking. It has also being said so many times in the past that it has lost its meaning. Zuma has a lot more options open to postpone and/or bypass these attempts to hold him to account. One of his next reasons ,I think, will be health related. And, if a court ever finds him guilty, he will ‘pull a Shaik’ and get away with it.