South Africa


Age of the Assassin: A man died for his country today – RIP Charl Kinnear

Age of the Assassin: A man died for his country today – RIP Charl Kinnear

How much longer can we pretend that we live in a country of functioning law and order?

In December 2019 SAPS withdrew police protection from the home of Lieutenant-Colonel Charl Kinnear, a top-detective with the Anti-Gang unit who was investigating high-profile gang members in Cape Town and beyond. Around 3pm on Friday 18 September 2020, Kinnear was assassinated outside his home in Bishop Lavis. His killers waited and murdered him as he pulled up in his vehicle.

Charl Kinnear died for his country on Friday and he did so exposed, vulnerable and without police protection.

By SAPS’ own account Kinnear, a section commander, was “involved in investigations into several high profile cases resulting in multiple arrests.”

In January 2020, colleague Vincent Cruywagen wrote of how Kinnear’s wife Nicolette lived in terror when police who were assigned to protect their home were removed in December 2019. A month earlier two men had been arrested outside Kinnear’s home.

At the time South African Policing Union spokesperson, Graham Daniels, warned prophetically:

“This places the life of the police officer and his family in danger. We need to gather more information on why the decision was taken and who gave the order to remove Kinnear’s protection.”

Trade Union Solidarity also spoke out with spokesperson Ronel Stander, highlighting that “Lieutenant-Colonel Kinnear is known for working with high-profile cases. Solidarity wants to know who gave the order to remove the personal safety at his house and what was the motive behind it.”

In January, when SAPS national spokesperson Brigadier Vish Naidoo was asked about the withdrawal of Kinnear’s protection he failed to respond.

This was what Western Cape SAPS spokesperson Andrè Traut said:

“Information of this nature was not shared with the media and problems regarding the protection of members were dealt with internally.”

Which it wasn’t, of course. Kinnear is dead now.

To work in the violent, corrupt and corruptible milieu – the underworld where South Africa’s various mafias thrive by threat and blood – requires guts, courage and integrity. 

What Kinnear represented was the best-of-the-best in the SAPS. 

While the corrupt and the venal hog headlines, men and women like Kinnear do a dangerous and thankless job. 

Those corrupt members of SAPS who have colluded with underworld figures now have a direct burden to carry– they helped kill Charl Kinnear.

Kinnear represented one of many brilliant SAPS members, who each day risk their lives. 

Like an officer in the DPCI, also in the Western Cape, who was recently plugged with four bullets from a stolen police gun supplied to a criminal by a corrupt cop and which in turn was used to seriously wound a dedicated, good cop.

That is how bad things are in the SAPS in the Western Cape where Kinnear lived and worked every day of his life.

SAPS, in an urgent media communication after news of his murder, broke on 18 September, even managed to get Kinnear’s rank wrong.

“The National Commissioner of the South African Police Service, General Khehla John Sitole has expressed outrage at the killing of one the SAPS top investigators, Colonel Charl Kinnear.”

Kinnear was a Lieutenant Colonel.

SAPS big brass seemed to swing swiftly into action in the aftermath, with Sitole announcing the triggering of a “72-Hour Activation Plan”  to “mobilise critical departments including crime intelligence, forensic experts, the Hawks and tactical units to ensure that evidence or information that could assist in the successful investigation of this case is not lost”.

The brazen assassination has sent shockwaves through the SAPS and has angered and outraged all who knew and loved Kinnear. 

SAPS knew Kinnear was working on life-threatening cases involving Nafiz Modack and other gang leaders in the violence-torn Western Cape and they most likely know who was responsible for this callous and brazen murder of a good man.

“The likes of the colonel are difficult to find. Believe me. He served with pride. We all loved him in SAPS. We all respected him,” said a colleague who asked not to be named.

Kinnear’s death should mark a turning point in the life and history of the Western Cape SAPS and its relationship with underworld figures.

Root out the corrupt, arrest the kingpins, there is enough evidence to do so.

SAPS owes that to Charl Kinnear. SAPS owes that to the South African public.

A swift investigation. Arrests. And a full explanation of why it allowed this key senior detective to be rendered so vulnerable. Should they fail in this, we will have obliterated any pretence of living in a country of laws.  DM


Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • Chris Kirsten says:

    A bit late to wake up now. That is already the case, what with Councillors and politicians being murdered all over the country – for years now. Lungisa, in other news here, is but the very thin edge of the wedge. Must have had it very wrong thinking that democracy is the solution to thuggery and mayhem. So much for Mandela and de Klerk’s ideas on dialogue, but isn’t that the real solution?

  • Jacques Labuschagne says:

    While politicians are heavily bodyguarded to protect their loot.

  • Paolo Lupini says:

    Unfortunately we live in a World where the gangs with all their backing, money and complete disregard for human life run the show. Between the politicians, cops and underworld industry that are in their pockets and the complete lack of structure within our police force, they will never be brought to book … unless our government gets real, does root out the corrupt individuals and commence a strategic organised push back against the underworld. Here’s hoping….

  • Greg La Cock says:

    “A swift investigation. Arrests.” – Will never happen. Didn’t work in the wild, wild west and it won’t work here. Only thing that will is bounty hunters…. hard men vs hard men. And local sheriffs elected by local people.

    • Dr Know says:

      Beg to differ. Cosmetic surgery. Expect a quick arrest and much publicity about catching the culprits, but these will be the little fish that did the dirty work, offered up to close out the issue quickly and shield the big boykies on both sides. The convicted can expect a hero’s welcome in jail, probably well rewarded and his family taken care of on the outside.

  • Bill Gild says:

    What a terrible tragedy, and what a (further) damning indictment of the system of law and order in SA.

  • Paddy Ross says:

    “Something is rotten in the State of Denmark”(Hamlet). Whichever SAPS officer first suggested this withdrawal and the highest officer in SAPS that authorised the withdrawal should be charged with at least manslaughter or, depending on the evidence revealed, possibly murder. To withdraw police protection from such a vulnerable senior police officer was an act of criminal irresponsibility.

  • Rod Sherwood says:

    The corruption promoted and protected by the ANC in every state department and SoE is the major cause of this lawlessness. The death penalty should be mandatory for anyone who kills a policeman in these circumstances.

  • Peter Morris says:

    Absolute disgrace, May you Rest In Peace Soldier.

  • Ian Wallace Wallace says:


    So few good and incorruptible men and women in power makes the loss of one of them all the more painful.

  • Peter Davies says:

    This criminal ‘government’ has no conscience, and no shame. Words will not work with these thugs. The only thing they understand is direct hits on their lifestyle.

  • Alan Munro says:

    Absolute disgrace. That someone brave enough to stand up against the corruption and abuse that these thugs represent ends up being betrayed by their ‘colleagues’ for a little extra blood money… It’s time to step up, follow the paper trails and take down those who sanctioned this murder, SAPS.

  • Frans Ferreira says:

    A forensic audit of all involved in the mess-up is urgently needed. Just follow the money! Suspension without pay is a good start. Watching all bank accounts afterwards is also mandatory.

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted


This article is free to read.

Sign up for free or sign in to continue reading.

Unlike our competitors, we don’t force you to pay to read the news but we do need your email address to make your experience better.

Nearly there! Create a password to finish signing up with us:

Please enter your password or get a sign in link if you’ve forgotten

Open Sesame! Thanks for signing up.

We would like our readers to start paying for Daily Maverick...

…but we are not going to force you to. Over 10 million users come to us each month for the news. We have not put it behind a paywall because the truth should not be a luxury.

Instead we ask our readers who can afford to contribute, even a small amount each month, to do so.

If you appreciate it and want to see us keep going then please consider contributing whatever you can.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options

Daily Maverick Elections Toolbox

Feeling powerless in politics?

Equip yourself with the tools you need for an informed decision this election. Get the Elections Toolbox with shareable party manifesto guide.