Mental health ‘cannot be ignored’ when addressing violence against women and children

Mental health ‘cannot be ignored’ when addressing violence against women and children
In this archive photo, protesters speak out against gender-based violence in Mitchells Plain, Cape Town. (Photo: Gallo Images / Ashley Vlotman)

Emerging research on violence against women and children finds that mental illness is common in women who’ve experienced intimate partner violence as well as men who’ve experienced childhood sexual, physical and emotional abuse.

“Mental health is important with regard to thinking about interpersonal violence and risk factors,” said Mercilene Machisa, a researcher at the South African Medical Research Council during a webinar on the intersections between violence against women and children on Tuesday. 

The importance of mental health was highlighted in a survey conducted by the South African Medical Research Council and Gender Links in 2011 with a sample size of about 900 women and men.

“Mental health is an underlying issue [in this country] and we need to take it seriously. In some countries, children being raped is rare, here it’s a norm. We need to think about what’s happening to perpetrators and why they can do this without feeling remorse,” said Shaanaz Matthews, director of the Children’s Institute.

Research has found that 19.8% of adolescents in South Africa reported some form of sexual abuse (boys 20%, girls 19%) over their lifetime — 11.7% reported having been forced to have sex. 

According to Machisa and Lehlogonolo Makola, a researcher at the Children’s Institute, the way that violence has been normalised in communities and in households has contributed to children’s trauma. This in turn leaves them becoming adults with PTSD, depression or anxiety. 

“Exposure to interpersonal violence in the home has negative consequences for children’s health, development and wellbeing,” said Makola.

Essentially, children who grow up in violent homes were at a greater risk of experiencing violence as well as becoming perpetrators, said Makola.

Machisa’s research found that at least 80% of women and men were abused as children. Fifty-six percent of those men had physically abused women, while 50% of the women had reported experiencing interpersonal violence in their lifetime. Machisa said there were direct associations between men’s childhood abuse (including witnessing a mother being abused) and intergenerational transmission. 

An emerging trend in the fight against violence against women and children is the importance of mental health for the women and children who are being abused and for the perpetrators, who are often men. “It’s long been acknowledged that we need gender-transformative solutions. We can’t afford to address one without the other,” said Machisa. 

Maloka said it was crucial for an intersectional approach when it came to addressing violence against women and children. Matthews added that if we were to address violence against women and children, mental health services needed to be better and more accessible for people in rural areas. 

Access to mental health services is also linked to how little the government spends on mental healthcare. In 2019, 3% of the total healthcare budget went to mental healthcare.

In previous research done by the Children’s Institute, Matthews said that they had looked at children who had post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). “We found high levels of anxiety and depression as well. A year later a third of those children still had full symptoms for PTSD… this tells us a lot about the mental health services,” said Matthews.

Another problem was that mental health services would only be provided to the abused child, instead of the entire family because of the different ways the abuse affected everyone in the household. 

The webinar was hosted by the Children’s Institute, the South African Medical Research Council and Sonke Gender Justice. DM


Comments - Please in order to comment.

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted

We would like our readers to start paying for Daily Maverick...

…but we are not going to force you to. Over 10 million users come to us each month for the news. We have not put it behind a paywall because the truth should not be a luxury.

Instead we ask our readers who can afford to contribute, even a small amount each month, to do so.

If you appreciate it and want to see us keep going then please consider contributing whatever you can.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options