Spotlight contacted farm worker, and healthcare worker organisations, sex worker and other civil society organisations to get their views and statements.
Missing from the conversation
Hours before the lockdown was set to commence at midnight on Thursday 26 March, the Sex Workers Education and Advocacy Taskforce (SWEAT) and Sisonke, the national movement of sex workers, in a statement said this “drastic decision” translates into many uncertainties for unskilled workers including sex workers.
“[We] have noted with concern how sex workers are missing from the general conversations about support for workers throughout the pandemic and lockdown,” the statement reads.
The organisations said it was not clear if they will be prioritised in the government’s support plans, given that President Cyril Ramaphosa said, “we are going to support people whose livelihoods will be affected”.
Since Ramaphosa announced the lockdown, various ministers have announced details of support programmes for households and businesses. These include using the Unemployment Insurance Fund (UIF) to subsidise workers during this time. However, these measures do not cover workers in the informal sector and Small Business Development Minister Khumbudzo Ntshavheni said the support packages of her department are not geared for informal businesses.
The only assurance that this economic group seemingly has is the assurance of a “safety net” Ramaphosa mentioned in his announcement. It is also unclear how workers of non-compliant employers that are not registered with the fund will be affected. Minister of Employment and Labour Thulas Nxesi during the ministerial briefing last week did say, however, he does not see why workers should be punished for “rogue employers”, so it remains to be seen how these workers will be accommodated.
Although there was reference to informal workers, sex workers have not once been explicitly mentioned during all the government briefings thus far.
SWEAT argues the loss of income that sex workers will suffer due to the pandemic will also mean a “loss of shelter, inability to access food, healthcare, medications and other basic necessities for sex workers and their dependents”.
According to SWEAT’s figures (from 2013) there are about 158,000 sex workers in South Africa – each of whom has on average seven dependants. Sex work is still a crime in South Africa, making it difficult for them to demand labour rights. Questioning the inclusivity of the support programmes for vulnerable and poor groups, the organisation said: “Since the outbreak, sex workers have been the first group of workers to be affected financially by the spread of the virus.”
Outside the cities
Organisations geared toward rural healthcare also raised concerns. Russell Rensburg, director of the Rural Health Advocacy Project (RHAP), told Spotlight they appreciate that the lockdown must have been a very difficult decision to make. Rensburg said if everyone adheres to the lockdown, it can help curb the spread of infection.
“It is not without risk, but given the Easter holiday weekend coming up, it was the right decision and alleviates the risk of the epidemic spreading to rural areas.”
Rensburg said it is now important to prioritise the populations most at risk, particularly people living with HIV and TB.
“We also need the provincial authorities to work on province-specific plans, particularly Gauteng, Western Cape and KwaZulu-Natal.”
These three provinces have the most Covid-19 cases.
Rensburg told Spotlight that the social mitigation measures that the government had announced seem inadequate, particularly for the poor.
“Rural communities have amongst the highest unemployment rates and are almost completely dependent on government grants and remittances from family, so the lockdown could deepen food insecurity.”
Rensburg said rural health systems, particularly at primary healthcare level, remain neglected and underfunded.
“The lack of outreach services and high levels of poverty often translates into lower health seeking and unmet needs. What this means,” he said, “is that many people don’t know their health status or are unaware of the underlying conditions that place them at greater risk. We need a surge in health promotion activities that inform [rural]communities on how best to protect themselves.”
Rensburg also called for the protection and support of health workers, including community health workers (CHWs).
Healthcare worker concerns
Spokesperson for the nursing union Denosa, Sibongiseni Delihlazo, told Spotlight some of the major concerns nurses have include issues with personal protective equipment, which is a non-negotiable for every health worker in the workplace during this trying time.
“There must be provision of transport for nurses, as essential service workers, because the majority of them don’t have cars and are reliant on public transport.”
Delihlazo noted that nurses are not well-paid and will need support.
Many community health workers also raised concern that they have not been provided with personal protective equipment.
On Thursday 26 March, the head of the Health Department in the Western Cape, Dr Beth Engelbrecht, said CHWs who primarily deliver medicines do not need protective equipment. However, Spotlight understands many CHWs across the country will also be part of Covid-19 tracing teams.
There were also calls from the farmworker communities for government to urgently address lay-offs in the sector.
Wendy Pekeur, director of the Ubuntu Rural women and youth movement, told Spotlight they are concerned about farmworkers who rely on their jobs to feed their families. She said children on farms who are dependent on feeding schemes will now miss out. The organisation, in partnership with the Carmen Stevenson Foundation, on Tuesday 24 March managed to feed 200 children on four farms.
Pekeur said one farm in Stellenbosch recently dismissed 22 seasonal workers “due to the Corona fears”.
“We are worried that the Department of [Employment and] Labour does not have the capacity to monitor violations of labour rights during this lockdown period, and precarious workers whose jobs are already insecure will suffer more. And this whilst the sector has a history of extreme rights violations.”
Pekeur said that in cases where farmworkers are expected to work, health and safety inspectors who are too few will struggle to monitor compliance on farms. She stressed the need for government to partner with advice offices, trade unions and farmworker committees to make sure all safety measures are adhered to. Pekeur also called on Ramaphosa and Nxesi to “urgently address the lay-offs”.
“Talking to businesses alone will not solve the problem,” she said. “Please speak to the workers who produce the food we eat as they have lots to say.”
Minister of Agriculture and Land Affairs Thoko Didiza last week stressed the importance of food security. Didiza said the agricultural sector will continue with harvests and production to keep the food supply chain going. When Didiza addressed the media earlier last week, she only briefly referred to farmworkers.
She said: “Together with the industry we are working on sector operational procedures that would ensure adherence to the measures announced by the president. This includes the provision of sanitation to employees within the sector, especially farmworkers.”
Didiza said the department had set aside R1.2-billion to help mitigate the impact of the pandemic and ensure sustainable food production after the pandemic.
“The department soon will make the details of this package together with the application channels available,” she said.
Rights under lockdown
The head of SECTION27’s health programme, Sasha Stevenson, noted that even as the decision to lock down the country is supported by the best available health evidence, everyone recognises that it will have wide-ranging social impacts.
“The HIV epidemic in South Africa demonstrated that human rights are a fundamental component of public health,” she told Spotlight.
“And, in a time of crisis, the human rights principles of prioritising the needs of the most vulnerable, abiding by guarantees of equality and non-arbitrariness, and upholding rights to information, participation, the underlying determinants of health, and security for people who are or will become unemployed or sick are critically important.”
Concerns about possible rights violations and what recourse there will be for the public were also aired at the ministerial press briefing on Wednesday 25 March. Questions were raised over the human rights training of the army officers and members of the police meant to enforce the regulations.
Justice Minister Ronald Lamola reiterated that the lockdown and the enforcement thereof is guided by the law and the Constitution and everyone will have to act within the law. Some constitutional law experts, however, have warned that some of the regulations issued in terms of the Disaster Management Act are too vague, leaving people with much uncertainty, which will affect adherence.
Defence Minister Nosiviwe Mapisa-Nqakula told the briefing that although army officers are not trained in crowd control they had human rights training.
Social solidarity vs social disintegration
The line between social solidarity and social disintegration also seems to be not too solid for some. Dr Louis Reynolds, a member of the People’s Health Movement of South Africa, told Spotlight the pandemic could lead to social solidarity when “there is adequate support such as food, water, sanitation as well as empathy, trust and a sense of togetherness”.
“But, on the other hand, three weeks of lockdown in a context of massive inequality such as ours could also lead to social breakdown, especially in townships with large households and poverty and lack of knowledge.
“Widespread fake news could lead to false hopes or divisions among groups and fuel xenophobic attacks. So, frustration at lack of essentials, a culture of violence, high crime levels, gender-based violence and issues like toxic masculinity will make things worse,” he warned.
Reynolds said the lockdown time can be an opportunity for popular education, raising awareness, stopping fake news, preventing unscrupulous people from exploiting the crisis, building social solidarity and supporting each other. He stressed, however, it is vital to make sure that everyone’s basic needs are met in terms of water, sanitation, food, income and social grants.
“We must recognise our indebtedness to those on the front line, that includes health workers as well as people in townships and rural areas where the real battle rages,” he said.
Plans for support
Minister of Social Development Lindiwe Zulu said during a media briefing last week that social grants will still be paid, with special measures for hygiene and other protection at the pay points.
The food banks and local community food distribution centres will provide indigent and qualifying households with food during this time. Old age homes, rehabilitation and child and youth care centres, will also be provided with food. Zulu said community workers will be roped in to deliver food to beneficiaries to limit the movement of people.
Zulu did not have much to immediately offer victims of domestic abuse who during lockdown will be forced to be cooped up with their perpetrators. She did acknowledge, however, that this is a serious issue and mentioned the helpline victims can call (0800-428-428) as well as the existing shelters for vulnerable women that will remain open.
The Minister of Human Settlements, Water and Sanitation, Lindiwe Sisulu, announced measures to get water tankers to drought-stricken regions, especially in rural areas, to improve access to water. Water with which to wash hands is essential in the hygiene drive against Covid-19 transmission.
Despite Sisulu’s efforts on a national level, some residents, especially in Khayelitsha, complained that the municipality was still cutting off water for non-payment. One community activist, Qaba Mbola, accused the City of Cape Town of sending these households to the “guillotine” and “sentencing them to death” without access to water. DM
*Note: SECTION27 is mentioned in this article. While Spotlight is published by SECTION27 and the Treatment Action Campaign, Spotlight is editorially independent, an independence that the editors guard jealously. Spotlight is a member of the South African Press Council.
This article was produced by Spotlight – health journalism in the public interest.
"Have no fear of perfection - you'll never reach it." ~ Salvador Dalí