Using an NGO called the Association for Free Research and International Co-operation (Afric) and working with political technologist Peter Bychkov, who works for Yevgeny Prigozhin, a businessman known as “Putin’s chef”, a plan was hatched to create a disinformation campaign that favoured the ANC and put out propaganda against the opposition DA and EFF for the 2019 election.
Yulia Afanaseva suggests ‘EFF manifesto sucks’ video
The main Russian operative who wrote the disinformation campaign is Yulia Afanaseva (pictured in South Africa), a Prigozhin employee. Afanaseva has been in South Africa several times for Afric.
Documents reveal plans to make an “Eff manifesto sucks” video and to develop deep disinformation on both the EFF leader Julius Malema and the DA leader Mmusi Maimane.
The Dossier Centre, funded by the Russian former oligarch and businessman turned rights activist Mikhail Khodorkovsky, is in possession of documents which reveal that Bychkov’s so-called “Back-Office” in St Petersburg despatched political analysts to South Africa in February 2019 under the auspices of Afric and the International Anti-Crisis Center (IAC), a geopolitical research centre whose work aligns with Russian geopolitical strategy, both of which are used as a cover for Prigozhin’s activities in South Africa.
(Note: Khodorkovsky, formerly Russia’s richest man, spent 10 years in a Russian prison, from 2003-2013 — Ed)
Under the guise of analysis or research they prepared a document which contains details of the alleged disinformation campaign.
The Russian-owned Afric Centre appears to have gotten out of the blocks too late, as there is no evidence of meaningful or organised disinformation in the South African 2019 election campaign. But what is significant is that a pattern of influence-buying and disinformation led by a Prigozhin-influencer network has made its way to South Africa.
Who is Yevgeny Prigozhin?
In 2018, the US department special counsel investigating Russian interference in the US election, Robert Mueller, indicted Prigozhin for allegedly using his catering company (he started his career as a hot-dog salesman) to fund the Internet Research Agency (IRA) which led the cyberwar on presidential candidate Hillary Clinton during 2016 elections. This is now regarded as a contributing factor in bringing US President Donald Trump into the White House. The trolling agency, the IRA, is regarded as the progenitor of the Russian disinformation movement which has been unleashed in many countries around the world, according to reports and investigations.
Afric and IAC are offshoots of the IRA and, through it, Prigozhin has sought to extend Russian influence and his own business empire throughout the continent. He and other representatives of the IRA are currently on a US sanctions list and he is now making a significant effort to do a range of business deals in South Africa, too.
The South African-related documents, verified by the Dossier Centre, reveal the anatomy of a campaign to favour the ANC and the “preparation of recommendations to discredit DA and EFF” and the “development of proposals for theses for use in public rhetoric of the ANC”. It also suggests the “Preparation of recommendations to discredit the EFF leader Julius Malema”.
Moreover, Prigozhin is known for his links to the paramilitary Wagner group which was sanctioned by the US in 2014 for its role in the Ukraine. Hundreds of its men were reportedly killed in US airstrikes after attacking American positions in Syria in 2018. Wagner is active in several African countries including the Central African Republic, Madagascar, Libya and the Sudan. In August 2018 three Russian investigative journalists were murdered in the CAR — they were reportedly investigating the Wagner group.
Russians target ANC opposition
The document, drawn up by Afanaseva, is an apparent attempt to curry favour with the ANC. It recommends “creating a pilot version of the video dedicated to the 25th anniversary of democracy”; suggests “Digital Strategy Development for the ANC”; the “Creation of information content for distribution on their own information resources”.
In addition, the document by the Russian agency, drawn up in January 2019, recommends:
Analysis of sociological data to predict election results for the ANC;
Analysis of the launch of the DA’s voter registration campaign;
Risk analysis during the ANC election campaign;
GOOD party of Patricia de Lille perception study;
ATM party research (this is the party run by Vuyo Zungula with Mzwanele Manyi as an electoral candidate. The Sunday Times reported at the weekend that former President Jacob Zuma and ANC secretary-general Ace Magashule had been part of setting it up); and
Preparation of recommendations on counter-propaganda against the opposition ATM party.
The 16-page document looks like a classic ground analysis for a disinformation campaign. It recommends the use of focus groups, polling and desktop as well as social media analysis. In a separate section called the “Document Registry” which the Dossier Centre did not access, the Russian research centre also appears to have a registry of documents or research which includes:
Cases to discredit the party DA and its leader Maimane;
Suggestions to discredit the EFF;
Proposals to discredit the campaign slogans of the DA;
Theses for use during the election campaign for the ANC;
Analysis of the activities of opposition parties and recommendations to counter them;
Analysis of the perception of the Commission of Inquiry into Allegations of State Capture by the audience of social networks (Facebook, Twitter);
Digital strategy for the ANC;
Scenario plan for a documentary against the DA;
Storylines for caricatures against the DA;
Information about the influence of foreign companies on elections;
Attending an event to launch the EFF’s manifesto, preparing a critical analysis and recommendations for countering the EFF;
Attending an event to launch the DA’s manifesto, preparing a critical analysis and recommendations for countering the DA; and
Creating “EFF-manifesto sucks” video.
It didn’t work, says expert
William Bird of Media Monitoring Africa, which set up a partnership with the Independent Electoral Commission to monitor disinformation, says:
“There was not much of a co-ordinated effort. The ANC was trying something, but it was not effective in that you don’t see evidence of a national narrative being steered (by propaganda or disinformation).”
Bird says their monitoring revealed the ANC had started accounts (called sock puppet accounts) to retweet its messages, but that these had not gained traction. He said that the DA had complained that the ANC was using social media to spread the Alexandra #TotalShutdown campaign, but DA spokesman Mabine Seabe told Daily Maverick they did not detect a foreign hand behind this.
With China now the dominant political and trade partner in most countries across Africa, Russia is making a play for influence. In October, Russian President Vladimir Putin will host an Africa-Russia Summit in Sochi. The nuclear company Rosatom is signing deals across the continent and oligarchs such as Prigozhin, who are being frozen out of the West, see Africa as a new stage of both political and commercial influence.
Prigozhin wants mines, arms and a stake in a Rosebank hotel
The Dossier Centre has also revealed that Prigozhin, or his emissaries, are looking for opportunities in South Africa. These include:
According to the documents, deals are being explored with “Zana Gold” on mining gold, tantalite, copper and chromium deposits in Zimbabwe.
According to a translated document: “At the moment, on the territory of South Africa, there is one of the high-ranking military of Zimbabwe, who asks about a possible meeting and negotiations with the Russian side related to the military-industrial complex. The second representative of the Zimbabwe army is in Zimbabwe and is ready to take part in the negotiations on its territory.”
A company called “SWATCo” is said to be interested in ammunitions supply and the supply of short-barrelled weapons to South Africa.
Meetings were held with DevelCo for the full purchase of, or the purchase of a controlling stakes in, a leading industrial packaging company named MCG Industries which supplies leading companies such as Heineken, Nestlé and Tiger Foods.
A proposal was received from “Choyal Investments” for the joint purchase and development of 18 two-storey buildings as office premises in an industrial park.
An offer to build a Radisson Blu hotel in Rosebank, Johannesburg, from a South African design group.
Analysts say that Prigozhin uses his centres — Afric and IAC — to build support for his business interests. In the guise of legitimate civil society organisations, they are used as an advance guard to curry favour with whomever in the state they are interested in getting into business with. Election disinformation campaigns, it appears, form a part of the package.
Approached for comment, Bychkov denied any knowledge. He told MBK-Media, which assisted Daily Maverick:
“Yes, listen, well, if someone somewhere wrote something, it’s a fantasy, I have never dealt with all this African politics. I am in St Petersburg and doing other things.”
Afanaseva’s mobile phone was off.
DA Federal Executive chairperson James Selfe said the evidence of interference by Prigozhin’s networks should be referred to Parliament’s joint standing committee on intelligence and perhaps even to the Inspector-General of Intelligence.
“This company is embedded in the security establishment of the Russian Federation.” But Selfe also added: “If there was such a thing (the disinformation network) it was very poorly executed.”
Daily Maverick also approached the EFF for comment and will add it as it becomes available. We also approached Afric president in South Africa, José Matemulane, for comment, but he did not respond to several telephone calls. DM
"The sad truth is that most evil is done by people who never make up their minds to be good or evil." ~ Hannah Arendt