Your get out of jail free card from the thought police.
21 January 2018 14:51 (South Africa)
South Africa

#ANCdecides2017: Delegates cast their vote amid horse-trading, rigging claims, rumours and possibility of cross-slate voting

  • Carien du Plessis
    carien du plessis
    Carien du Plessis

    Jill of all trades but really, mistress of none, Carien has of late been a political tourist chasing elections and summits in various parts of the world, especially in Africa. 

    After spending her student days at political rallies in South Africa right through the country's first democratic elections in 1994, and after an extended working holiday in London, Carien started working for newspapers full-time in 2003. She's pretty much had her share of reporting on South African politics, attending gatherings and attracting trolls, but still finds herself attracted to it like a moth to a veld fire. 

    Her ultimate ambition in life is to become a travelling chocolate writer of international fame.

  • South Africa
Photo: President Jacob Zuma, with Zweli Mkhize and Cyril Ramaphosa during  the nominations process on Day 2 of the ANC elective conference at Nasrec . Photo Daily Maverick.

One weekend can be a long time in ANC politics, as the drawn-out start of the party’s 54th national congress at the Nasrec Expo Centre has proved. While a new president is only expected by late on Monday, the horse-trading in the two days before show that there could be an interesting twist in the tale. By CARIEN DU PLESSIS.

It was a tense Sunday night as delegates at the ANC’s elective conference started voting for the party’s next top six leadership just after midnight. An original message to the media that voting would only start in the morning fuelled a lot of distrust, as the same message wasn’t conveyed to the conference plenary discussing party treasurer-general Zweli Mkhize’s financial report at the time. The national executive committee and some of the top six officials apparently didn’t know either.

They are doing this while there is a full plenary sitting? What is going on?” an enraged delegate told Daily Maverick just before 1am. Whether there was a misunderstanding or a message was deliberately distributed to confuse delegates into returning to their hotel rooms is still unclear. Party spokesperson Zizi Kodwa only said “voting is under way” when asked what happened.

Such was the distrust that Human Settlements Minister Lindiwe Sisulu – also deputy presidential candidate on deputy president Cyril Ramaphosa’s slate – told the BBC overnight that there were fears of rigging and talk of cameras in the voting booths checking up on the way delegates were voting.

Whether the rigging is real or imagined is hard to tell from the media pen outside a heavily-policed fence (some “rules” prohibit journalists from speaking to delegates, for a reason that has not been communicated), but what is real is that the Ramaphosa camp was a lot less confident by Sunday evening than they were on Friday going into the conference. They were boosted by the disqualification of around 100 to 150 delegates from three provinces who were expected to vote for ANC MP Nkosazana Dlamini Zuma.

Tonight we vote. And those who believe in prayer had better pray. It's closer than was earlier calculated,” the message came from a Ramaphosa backer.

The Dlamini Zuma camp was optimistic, but not as bolshie as always either.

It’s a very even race.

Meanwhile former presidential candidates were hedging their bets. On Saturday ANC chairperson and National Assembly Speaker Baleka Mbete threw her weight behind Ramaphosa. There is talk now that she would be caretaker president until 2019 should Ramaphosa get elected and President Jacob Zuma be forced to step down.

Then there is ANC treasurer general Zweli Mkhize, who ran for president but was nominated for deputy president, but dramatically announced his withdrawal as deputy presidential candidate at the 11th hour during nominations in plenary late on Sunday. Mpumalanga premier David Mabuza was spotted smiling broadly as Mkhize did so.

Mabuza was nominated deputy president on Dlamini Zuma’s slate, but the story from inside the Ramaphosa camp is that there were fears that Mkhize would divide Sisulu’s vote and this was painted as a victory for that camp.

Mkhize was nominated by 193 branches in the Eastern Cape. The province also nominated Ramaphosa for president.

Already several weeks ago, however, there was word that Mkhize, despite being well-loved in the party, realised that his presidential campaign wasn’t taking off. From within the Dlamini Zuma camp there was talk that he would be a number one on their nomination list as an additional member of the NEC, and then be appointed finance minister should she win.

On Sunday the delay in conference proceedings were partially ascribed to the fact that Mkhize was locked in talks with both camps.

He denied that he went with either. Late on Sunday night his spokesperson, Tahera Mather, posted a message from him on Facebook: “It is not true I joined NDZ. I would have announced. We challenged both candidates and stood on principle of unity. We needed no deal so we have no need to announce a side – ZM.”

Perhaps, then, rumours of the deal with Dlamini Zuma came from the Dlamini Zuma camp itself, to bolster support for her.

Timeslive reported that Mkhize’s closeness to Mabuza was the key, and that the agreement for Mkhize to have the Treasury portfolio was Mabuza himself rather than the presidential candidates.

Mabuza is known as a master strategist, even a schemer. Mabuza and Mkhize have been close allies for a long time and, together with Gauteng chairperson Paul Mashatile, were key to a “unity” campaign driven by the party. (Mashatile was nominated as treasurer-general on the Ramaphosa slate, but the Dlamini Zuma slate was divided between Maite Nkoana-Mashabane and Nomvula Mokonyane for that position. Mokonyane declined nomination.)

But here is the twist.

It was Mabuza and Mkhize who, in 2012, were responsible for bringing in Ramaphosa as deputy president on Zuma’s ticket. And overnight there was talk from inside the caucuses that Mpumalanga was singing songs in favour of Zuma.

It came from David Dube, a key Ramaphosa campaigner in that province, so should be treated with some caution. After all, Ramaphosa had more than 100 branch nominations from there, but Mabuza’s role in bringing in Ramaphosa in 2012 lends some weight to this rumour.

Dube’s whatsapp message read: “No one saw this one coming! What a shocker! The whole plenary was stunned!”

It continued: “So electrifying! Mpumalanga delegates openly singing siyavuma! No one could believe it! Mpumalanga delegates surprised everyone by chanting CR17 all the way!”

This raises the possibility of cross-slate voting, where Mpumalanga’s considerable delegation – or at least the 200-plus branches that controversially nominated “unity” – would throw their weight behind Ramaphosa for president, and Mabuza for deputy. Even if, however, Dlamini Zuma gets elected with Mabuza as her deputy, Mkhize would still bag the job as finance minister.

This would be a positive for the economy, because he enjoys the confidence of the business community and is also a darling among diplomats.

Either way, one thing most delegates had in common this weekend was a relief that Zuma’s presidency of the party will soon be over.

At least two sources in the Dlamini Zuma camp said there was a strong likelihood that she would ask Zuma to step down soon after the conference as well, because they realise that he has become a liability to the party. They say there is even support for this among some of their four daughters – the same children who, in 2005, convinced their mother not to accept an appointment as former president Thabo Mbeki’s deputy after he fired Zuma.

Did the attempted delay in voting on Sunday night have anything to do with the horse-trading mentioned above, to leave time for Mpumalanga to lobby their position? It’s not clear yet. Mpumalanga was one of the provinces that voted first overnight.

By late Monday afternoon or evening, however, when the ANC’s election results are expected to be announced, some of this speculation should come to an end at last. DM

Photo: President Jacob Zuma, with Zweli Mkhize and Cyril Ramaphosa during the nominations process on Day 2 of the ANC elective conference at Nasrec . Photo Daily Maverick. 

  • Carien du Plessis
    carien du plessis
    Carien du Plessis

    Jill of all trades but really, mistress of none, Carien has of late been a political tourist chasing elections and summits in various parts of the world, especially in Africa. 

    After spending her student days at political rallies in South Africa right through the country's first democratic elections in 1994, and after an extended working holiday in London, Carien started working for newspapers full-time in 2003. She's pretty much had her share of reporting on South African politics, attending gatherings and attracting trolls, but still finds herself attracted to it like a moth to a veld fire. 

    Her ultimate ambition in life is to become a travelling chocolate writer of international fame.

  • South Africa

Get overnight news and latest Daily Maverick articles






Reader notice: Our comments service provider, Civil Comments, has stopped operating and will terminate services on 20th Dec 2017. As a result, we will be searching for another platform for our readers. We aim to have this done with the launch of our new site in early 2018 and apologise for the inconvenience.