Daily Maverick

GroundUp: Michael Komape case – Calls for help from school unanswered for years

Former principal’s testimony supports the Komape family’s case against the state. By Ciaran Ryan for GROUNDUP.

First published by GroundUp

The former principal of Mahlodumelo School in Limpopo, Maphalane Malothane, testified in court on Monday that several appeals were made to the Limpopo Department of Education for funding for new toilets to replace the “sinking” toilets that caused the death of Michael Komape in 2014.

Every appeal for funds, starting in 2004 and continuing virtually every year until 2009, went unanswered. The school eventually decided to use its own funds to build new toilets, she told the Polokwane High Court.

Michael Komape drowned in a pit latrine at the school on 20 January 2014. His body was discovered hours later by his mother. His hand was protruding from a pool of human faeces.

The state had called on Malothane to buttress its case against a nearly R3-million damages claim from the family. But Malothane turned out to be a star witness for the family.

Under cross-examination by Advocate Vincent Maleka for the family, Malothane was asked about her repeated requests for funding to replace toilets that were damaged and “sinking”.

What happened to your first application [for funds] to the department in 2004?” Maleka asked.

Nothing,” replied Malothane.

And the second application?”


The same happened virtually every year until 2009.

Is this how the department dealt with you?” asked Maleka. “By ignoring you?”

Yes,” replied Malothane.

It was only after Michael’s death that the department took steps to build new toilets.

Argument over funding

Last week, the state had called the Limpopo Department of Education’s financial administrator, Freddie Mabidi. He disputed earlier testimony from budget analyst Daniel McLaren that the department had enough funds to attend to the toilets in the province. In virtually every year since 2012, the department had been forced to return funds to the provincial treasury because they went unspent.

Mabidi explained this by saying that infrastructure projects had been frozen when the department was placed under administration by Treasury in 2011 for financial misconduct. This resulted in unspent funds being returned to the Treasury.

On Monday, Maleka questioned Mabidi about this, and pointed to departmental documents which suggested the opposite: rather than there being a freeze on infrastructure projects, funding didn’t seem to be a problem.

The Auditor General’s report on the Limpopo Department of Education in 2017 noted that being placed under administration had not had the desired effect, but required the establishment of an intervention team to fix the problems in the department.

Mabidi also disputed a 2012 internal report from Dr Anis Karodia, head of an intervention task team sent to Limpopo to fix the department. Karodia wrote that most senior managers “treat their positions as mere jobs and do not work with the resilience that high-profile jobs at this level calls for, or for that matter do not walk the extra mile”.

Mabidi said these were the words of “an angry person”.

Maleka continued to read from the damning report, which describes the Limpopo Department of Education as suffering from woeful and inadequate planning, financial mismanagement, poor service delivery and inefficient operational control.

The trial continues on Tuesday. DM

Photo: Freddie Mabidi, financial administrator for the Limpopo Department of Education, testifies in the Polokwane High Court. Photo: Ciaran Ryan

At EFF congress, keep an eye on money man Marshall Dlamini
By Micah Reddy for amaBhungane
Missing millions: Police investigate ANCWL social development arm
By Henriette Geldenhuys
Wanted: A storage facility for Dudu Myeni’s furniture
By Jessica Bezuidenhout
Drowned refugee teenager Samuel just wanted to wash and swim
By Biénne Huisman
Why Ramaphosa is wrong about SOEs.
By Tim Cohen
Senatla out to impress Powell in season swansong
By Craig Ray
Invisibility and visibility — it’s always been this tug of war for Chinese South Africans
By Ufrieda Ho
Imbokodo looking to make their mark in front of home crowd at Cape Town Sevens
By Yanga Sibembe
Power failure: Red tape (and Gwede Mantashe) are keeping us in the dark
By Stephen Grootes
Ethiopia’s new party is welcome news, but they face big hurdles
By Yohannes Gedamu