South Africa

Health-e News: A living Hell for patients at Holy Cross Hospital

By Health-e News 10 April 2017

Sick patients have been forced to leave their beds at the Holy Cross Hospital in the Eastern Cape and head outside to a nearby stream to fetch their own water because taps in the government health facility ran dry. The scenario is part of an ongoing litany of horror stories that have unfolded at the hospital for several years. It’s a desperate situation that needs urgent attention, write Zizo Zikali and Asavela Dalana for HEALTH-E NEWS.

The beleaguered Holy Cross Hospital, situated 20km outside Flagstaff in the Eastern Cape, is once again battling various challenges following years of difficulties and unsuccessful turnaround efforts.

Back in August 2015 an NSP Review visit revealed a lack of access to running water, which is devastating for a hospital.

The water shortage has lasted just over a week but is by no means the longest experienced at the hospital where recurring water outages have lasted up to six weeks.

But the water cut was just one of several problematic issues at the hospital since January 2017. For more than a week community members have embarked on protest action, demanding improved health services.

The hospital services 11 traditional councils under Flagstaff’s Ingquza Hill Local Municipality.

Community leader Dumisani Mbangatha said patients were spending long hours in queues waiting to be treated, and there was a persistent shortage of doctors.

People who suffer from chronic illnesses are sent back home without their medication, and there is also a shortage of water,” he said.

The community also claimed that the hospital was collapsing under the watch of CEO Gloria Mazek, and demanded that she step down.

In response to the outcry, Eastern Cape Health MEC Dr Pumza Dyantyi visited Holy Cross Hospital following the protests, and took possession of a memorandum detailing the community’s grievances. She elected a task team that comprises all community stakeholders to investigate all the complaints raised.

The team included delegates from St Elizabeth Hospital, Ingquza Hill Local Municipality, the Congress of Traditional Leaders of South Africa, the local youth council, the African National Congress and community development workers.

Holy Cross Hospital board chairperson Mthuthuzeli Sinukela said the Department of Health had not recruited new hospital staff for the past few years, apart from the appointment of a few doctors in line with the mandate of the Eastern Cape Department of Health.

He denied claims by community leaders that the hospital lacked doctors, stating that the long waits experienced by patients were the result of a high patient load.

Over the past few months, while the investigations were ongoing, problems at the hospital continued and at one point the taps ran dry.

Patients who were admitted at that time said they were told to find ways of sourcing their own water, as no other supplies or measures had been put in place.

Officials claimed that a borehole, the main supplier of water to the town, was the cause of the water cut, which effected the entire area in which the hospital is situated. Ward councillor Pumla Dutshwa told community members that water would be restored soon and apologised as days passed before the water supply was finally restored.

One of the patients affected by the water cut, Babalwa Somsi, explained that she and others had been instructed to go and fetch their own water, or go to their homes to wash and drink.

Some of us do not have families nearby and some are critically ill. We did not know what to do,” she said.

It was this crisis that prompted some of the patients to venture outside to a local stream to get water.

Hospital staff said they had to bring their own water from home, and were constantly concerned about the needs of patients.

The recent water crisis at Holy Cross Hospital comes after a visit in 2013 by the Eastern Cape Health Crisis Action Coalition. At that time a litany of issues was identified by the Office of the Health Standards Compliance (OHSC) as critical to the turnaround of the hospital, which, it found, was on the brink of total failure at the time.

A September 2013 special NSP Review Report titled “Death and Dying in the Eastern Cape” detailed the death of a toddler at the hospital. The attending doctor told a story of failure at several stages including lack of oxygen and access to emergency services.

While there have been signs of improvement since then, the hospital appears to have once again been plagued by setbacks.

The 2013 turnaround strategy was sparked after a healthy 12kg infant – identified by the pseudonym “Baby Ikho” – was admitted to the hospital with a severe chest infection. He died five days after his first birthday because Holy Cross Hospital had run out of oxygen.

After this the Office of Health Standards Compliance (OHSC), a new state entity charged with upholding health standards, inspected the hospital and issued a damning report, and the hospital CEO was transferred.

The OHSC was officially established in 2013 as one of government’s weapons against dysfunctional health facilities. It is an independent public entity that is legally empowered to monitor and enforce norms and standards in all health facilities, including private hospitals.

The OHSC report confirmed that Holy Cross failed to meet basic standards, and it scored a dismal 43%.

The report described hospital management as weak, finding that staff lacked critical skills and that facilities and equipment were poorly maintained. Some of the medicine in the pharmacy had expired. The fridge that was supposed to store laboratory specimens was set at 21 degrees, rendering it useless.

These findings were sent both to the hospital and the Eastern Cape Crisis Action Coalition, an alliance of organisations formed to fight for better healthcare in the province.

Conditions improved for a while, and in a follow-up assessment by the OHSC in 2016, the hospital scored 60%. Not quite the 80% required, but an improvement on the previous score.

But the improved situation did not last for long, and by January 2017 patients were once again protesting against poor conditions at Holy Cross Hospital.

Investigations into the current situation have been concluded and on Tuesday MEC Dr Dyantyi returned to the hospital to collect the report outlining the findings of the task team’s investigation.

Provincial Health spokesperson Sizwe Khuphelo said the MEC would be going through all the information and recommendations thoroughly before taking any action.

The MEC has promised swift action based on the findings. It remains to be seen if the much-needed changes will be implemented. For the rural community the hospital serves, the situation is desperate. DM

Photo: Nurses gather water from a tank provided by the municipality – the only source of water for the week, published by Spotlight on 21 October 2015. (Image: Gary Horlor)