South Africa

South Africa

Op-Ed: #FeesMustFall – the students’ side

Op-Ed: #FeesMustFall – the students’ side

If you want to understand why the students are protesting, take a moment (or two) to step back and listen to what the students have to say, even if it is just by reading articles such as this. By ALICE DRAPER.

Prior to the minister of higher education’s announcement about the fee increase, tensions around the country were high. Students feared not being able to continue studying, while many university staff feared further disruptions.

On Monday morning, minister Blade Nzimande announced that the government advised universities not to increase the fees by more than 8%, and that the government would cover this increase for students on NSFAS (National Student Financial Aid Scheme) and the “missing middle” which he categorised as students whose families earn less than R600,000 per annum.

The general stance of students across the country was that they rejected this proposal and thus, protests were to continue. This led to the conclusion from a lot of the general public that the students are either “ungrateful” or want “everything handed to them”.

It is easy for everyone sitting at home to base their views on the main stories in the media (burning buildings, violence and so on) and on what their friends and colleagues are saying about the protests. However, if you actually want to understand why the students are protesting, it is important to take a moment (or two) to step back and listen to what the students have to say, even if it is just by reading articles such as this.

There are a few reasons that the protests are continuing, which appear to be universal across most universities in the country.

  • The #FeesMustFall protests are about more than just the fee increments. They are about the lowering of fees to the point that they are affordable for the general, poorer masses of the population. While NSFAS may cover a certain criterion of poor students, many people falling in the “missing middle” still cannot afford to attend university, with or without a fee increment.
  • Students who are in debt and are going to be financially excluded demand that this debt is cleared, or that they are assisted and a middle ground is found that allows the students to continue studying.
  • Many universities have issued interdicts which have silenced both students and staff, withheld them from protesting and victimised those who have been involved in the protests. The demand is that students and university staff are not victimised or punished for being involved in the #FeesMustFall protests.
  • Covering the fee increments of students whose families earn less than R600,000 is too broad a definition of what the “missing middle” is. Deciding on who is eligible to pay the increased university fees should include a number of factors; particularly how many children are in the family and the kinds of financial burdens that family has.
  • The university staff and management must stand on the side of the students and work with the students in developing strategic plans which can persuade the government to take the student demands seriously, and properly address them.

The demands delve deeper than this, and vary among different institutions. However, this appears to be the general stance that most university student bodies have taken. In addition to understanding the general demands of the students, understanding the positions that students are in is also crucial to understanding both sides of the protests.

Not every student involved in the protests is burning down buildings, cars, or attacking other students and staff. In fact, most students are protesting peacefully or attending meetings, talks and other gatherings to try to negotiate ways in which a lowering of fees, or free fees, can be achieved.

We need to stop assuming that students are protesting because they are failing, self-entitled, or barbaric. They are protesting because many of them have spent too long struggling to make ends meet. They are protesting because getting into university was something so challenging for many (largely due to poor schooling) and finding the funds was even more challenging. They are protesting because they know they do not have the funds to continue studying, and they might at any point be financially excluded. Students are protesting because they do not have any other options. Putting their lives in danger, risking being arrested or subjected to police brutality is not something people choose to do because it is fun; it is something they do because they are desperate, and do not have other options.

While it is undeniable that some students have been involved in violent activities such as burning down buildings and using force to gain numbers in the protests – and in no way should these activities be condoned – it is important to at least try to understand why some students have resorted to this.

The University of KwaZulu Natal (UKZN), where most of the violence has occurred this year, have been protesting against tuition fees almost annually, long before the #FeesMustFall movement started. Their protests and demands were met with little to nothing. Students are frustrated and tired of being ignored; and mostly angry. While burning down buildings in no way solves the need for cheaper education, it brings public and media attention, and makes more people aware that there is a fee crisis. It is in no way ideal, but neither is it ideal to be trapped in a cycle of poverty, and not being able to attend university.

You may believe that this generation is “self-entitled”. However, the reality is that too many years have passed in which a tertiary education has become increasingly inaccessible to the broader masses of the public. Section 9 of the South African Constitution states that “Everyone has a right… a) to basic education, including adult basic education; and b) to further education, which the state, through reasonable measures, must make progressively available and accessible”.

Aside from the students NSFAS covers, before the #FeesMustFall protests last year, the government had done very little to make university more available and accessible. The protests occurring countrywide right now are crucial and valid, and it is in the best interests of South African citizens to support them so that less violent and more progressive solutions can be reached. DM

Photo of Grahamstown protests from 23 September 2016 by Alice Draper.


Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted

We would like our readers to start paying for Daily Maverick...

…but we are not going to force you to. Over 10 million users come to us each month for the news. We have not put it behind a paywall because the truth should not be a luxury.

Instead we ask our readers who can afford to contribute, even a small amount each month, to do so.

If you appreciate it and want to see us keep going then please consider contributing whatever you can.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options