Ben Turok - a lifetime of putting his head above the parapet
- Onkgopotse JJ Tabane
- 28 Jun 2012 02:11 (South Africa)
Meet the independent mind of Professor Ben Turok. Forget the fact that he rattled the cage by refusing to vote for the Secrecy Bill in Parliament (a rare move in that discipline-obsessed movement). He’s far from backing down yet – in fact, this week, as the ANC gathered for its national policy conference, the Prof was on form once again.
At an event to mark the 57th anniversary of the Freedom Charter, proceedings got off to an excellent start for him when the chairperson of the ANC acknowledged his 85th birthday milestone, and the whole hall chimed in to congratulate him. His mood seemed chipper – when asked about his disciplinary case, he gleefully said the case had “since died down” and, with an added dose of irreverence, quipped: “Do you think they will still charge me?”
In all seriousness, it’s a fair question, and one that was particularly apt at this celebration. Turok represents the last of those who don’t second-guess the meaning of the Freedom Charter. He was there with those who wrote the document, and can explain the exact meaning of each phrase, as well as the intention of the movement.
Asked whether the Freedom Charter was sacrosanct and what forum would be relevant to change it, his opinion was clear: just implement the damn thing. Because we’re so much better at revising policies than actually doing anything with them.
“Today, we are too cautious,” he said, differing somewhat from the reasoning of president Jacob Zuma earlier in the day, who had emphasised the need to be circumspect in implementing certain things after 1994. Turok was clear that the second transition was very relevant, and pointed out the need to distinguish between primary and secondary contradictions – but added that analysis should focus on emphasis and priority. And then, that action should be taken.
But, because nobody can put things quite like the Prof himself, it’s perhaps better to let him have the floor from here on out. And to that end, here are some of the most quotable quotes from his address, combining critical analysis with his characteristic bluntness and pragmatism.
“Mbeki was very heavy-handed. He used to say that you are free to differ, but he would send subtle messages that you are not so free. He clamped down on debate.”
“When I see a T-shirt with a leader’s face on it, I worry about him. Because he will soon think he is God. We are killing our own leaders this way.”
On the compromises of 1994
“After 1994 the ANC went very slowly. ‘Hamba kahle.’ We swallowed the doctrines of the world bank and IMF. We became the darlings of these institutions.”
‘’The issue of a low deficit makes no sense. Any businessperson knows that you have to spend more in order to make more. You borrow – you are in debt; you invest so that you can make more money and pay back your loan. The ANC implemented a different logic.”
“You must spend more to move your economy. Growth is an IMF nonsense concept.”
“You can’t talk the economy into growing. You have to do something. We are watching with interest to see what will be so different from this policy conference.”
On class oppression
“The underbelly of class oppression and racial oppression are intricately linked – you have to deal with both if you are serious about freedom.”
On the second transition
“The first transition was laced with preoccupation with changing the state machinery – no one asked then, ‘Where is the working class?’
On corporate transformation
“Companies don’t really want to transfer skills. We have to find solutions for corporate transformation elsewhere.”
On the lethargy of black business
“What upsets me about black business is that it wants a share of the white establishment, but they are not wanting to talk about freedom…There is no singing of the liberation song. The ANC must discuss what the role of black business ought to be in the transformation of the economy.”
On political education
“Political education is the lifeblood of an organisation. The ANC however, closed its political education department in 1994. Why do you think that is so? Is it because those who ran that department did not agree with the policy trajectory?”
Of course, these critical references were thrown out in the comfort of a branch meeting. But for me, it signals hope in the ANC. The branch members were equally critical of the movement in the kind of questions that they were asking, and the underlying theme was that the ANC sold out in 1994.
Professor Turok, for his part, was at great pains to indicate that the ANC did not sell out, but rather went into strategic retreat in dealing with the issues of the economy as robustly as it should have in 1994. But if these debates on the relevance of the Freedom Charter are anything to go by, we have to believe that something new will emerge out of the ANC’s current round of debates about the need to do something radical to change the economy.
We require more people like Turok, though – people not beholden to anyone. People who are thoroughly introspective and have the courage of their convictions. Of course, not everyone is immune to the patronage that can disappear when their head rises above the parapet. But even one such voice is a start. DM
JJ Tabane is CEO of Oresego Holdings. He writes in his personal capacity.
- Dear Comrades Gwede and Blade… Let's talk frankly
- Dear Comrade Jessie Duarte... Let’s talk frankly
- Dear Peter Bruce… Let’s talk frankly
- Dear Allister Sparks, let’s talk frankly…
- Dear King Goodwill Zwelithini...Let’s talk frankly
- Dear Cecil John Rhodes… Let’s talk frankly
- Dear Robert Gabriel Mugabe... let’s talk frankly
- Dear comrade journalist Karima Brown... let's talk frankly
- Dear Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma, let’s talk frankly
- Dear President Angie Motshekga, Let’s Talk Frankly...
- Dear Zwelinzima Vavi, let’s talk frankly
- Dear Irvin Jim, let’s talk frankly
- Dear Dalai Lama, let’s talk frankly...
- Dear Stephen Bantu Biko, let’s talk frankly
- Dear Minister Ngoako Ramatlhodi, let’s talk frankly
- Dear Comrade Ronnie, let’s talk frankly… again
- Dear voter… let’s talk frankly ahead of the polls
- Dear Comrade Ronnie Kasrils, let's talk frankly
- Dear Comrade Chris Hani... Let’s talk frankly about the last 21 years
- Dear free-spirited Trevor Manuel… Let’s talk frankly
- Dear President Museveni… Let’s talk frankly
- Dear Voter, let’s talk frankly about…the EFF’s magic wand
- Dear Con-mander Julius Malema... let's talk frankly
- Dear Dr Mamphela Ramphele… Let’s talk frankly
- Dear North West Premier Thandi Modise, let's talk frankly
- Dear Advocate Thuli Madonsela, let's talk frankly: do take heart
- Dear Lindiwe Mazibuko, let’s talk frankly
- Dear Mmusi Maimane, let’s talk frankly about what we really must believe
- Mfundi Vundla, let’s talk frankly about the threat to write out the ‘Generations’ cast entirely.
- Dear Minister Gigaba, let’s talk frankly about ten ways you can save money
- Dear South Africans, let’s talk frankly: 20 reasons to celebrate twenty years of our democracy – Part Two
- Dear South Africans, let's talk frankly: Twenty reasons to celebrate twenty years of our democracy – Part One
- Dear Comrade Nxasana, let’s talk frankly…
- Dear Minister Nathi Mthethwa, let’s talk frankly
- Khanyi Dhlomo: Illuminating Luminance
- Dear Minister Radebe, let’s talk frankly...
- Dear Gauteng Radio Listeners, let’s talk frankly...
- An ode to Vuyo: He ran a good race; his morning will remain alive
- Dear spindoctors, dear journalists, let’s talk frankly...
- Dear Premier Helen Zille, let’s talk frankly...
- Dear Zwelinzima Vavi, let’s talk frankly...
- Are too many cooks spoiling the broth?
- Dear Minister Gigaba, let’s talk frankly...
- Dear Minister Gordhan, let’s talk frankly...
- State of the nation: The good, the bad and the ugly
- Business must learn how to play ball in the current political environment
- Dear Minister Martins, let's talk frankly...
- Dear Minister Pule.. Let's talk frankly
- Dear Minister... let's talk frankly
- Dear Minister... let's talk frankly
- Ben Turok - a lifetime of putting his head above the parapet
- 13 conversations about one thing: the hypocrisy of Cosatu
- Young professionals must take centre stage to help shape the future of South Africa
- Labour broker issue and other signals of the collapsing alliance
- Tough love is a farce, rather engage ANCYL
- Government communications' own Operation Vula
- Media - state relations: Quo vadis?