The debate over a painting depicting president Jacob Zuma’s penis has produced two very distinct lines of argument: “let there be freedom of expression” says one school of thought, while another argues “it’s disrespectful, take it down”.
I must state up front that I side with those who believe that we should all be free to create art, no matter how uncomfortable it may be.
I view it in the same way I see Die Antwoord – I don’t have to like the band to appreciate it. At a concert not so long ago, I stood in awe of their act as others left disgusted or bored.
I don’t speak Afrikaans (even though I can understand the basic swear words), and yet I was impressed that this artistic project – whatever it may be – was allowed to play out before my eyes. And not only my eyes, but the eyes of the world. I wrestled with my feelings about the fact that this was the kind of music we were exporting to other countries, but when a staff member at a museum in Washington DC asked me about Die Antwoord (imagine the American pronunciation), I was pleasantly amused.
My sister is an artist. In my eyes, a brilliant artist. Over the past 30 years I have watched her go through various artistic phases, from covering her skin in wild tattoos to shaving off all her bright red hair, Sinead O’Connor-style. She has swayed with the winds of her inspiration and splashed the world in beautiful bright colours. Many of her paintings hang in my house and bring me endless joy.
I see the art world through my sister, and others like her. I believe that artists should never be banned or have their paintings taken down from gallery walls. They occupy a different dimension from those of us who slip into suits each morning, drink fancy coffee from Vida and devote thought to things like medical aids and credit card limits. And for that reason, they should be allowed to exist without interference. Because when artists produce something that touches our souls, it reminds us why we exist.
I have walked through many art galleries, from the Hermitage in St Petersburg to the MET in New York, and don't claim to have liked everything I saw. But that's the beauty of the experience: having those private thoughts, walking away or spending an eternity looking at one painting. The choice to be absorbed or to be disgusted.
While debating this issue on Twitter, I was asked how I would feel if it was me painted with my penis dangling from my trousers. It was a good question that made me think.
I can imagine that to Jacob Zuma, this painting is repulsive and offensive. I do not dispute that it's exceptionally controversial and tests the fine line between expression and insult. But it is not the first. Consider the way Zuma has been depicted by the country’s top cartoonist, Zapiro. He has been shown with a shower head glued to his head and a sperm-shooting machine gun for a penis (a reminder of the rape trial which saw him acquitted) or pulling down his pants and preparing to rape Lady Justice. Zuma is suing Zapiro (and others) for defamation of character, but the point is that this is not the first time something like this has happened, which tells us something about public perception.
The question needs to be asked: are we witnessing an assassination of Zuma’s character or are we seeing the art world holding up a mirror to a man who has never been far from controversy? Would artists have painted Barack Obama with his penis hanging out? Obama has been depicted as a monster by those who disagree with his policies, but it has never been about his private parts. The man commands too much respect for that. On the other hand, think about how former US president Richard Nixon used to be torn apart by cartoonists and painters.
This led me to ask: if artists were painting me, what would they paint? What would I see in the mirror held up by those who interpret the world with their paintbrushes? I’m not sure, but I’m willing to bet it wouldn’t be the same as Zuma.
I have an open mind to this debate. But my opinion is that the kind of life you live is directly responsible for the kind of images you will see staring back at you, and suing art galleries to ban them is a desperate and ridiculous move.
More than that, a court’s intervention in what a private gallery can or cannot display is a slippery slope. What would follow? Legal interventions in what we can or cannot hang up on the walls of our homes? The banning of artists and their works, like the kind that once existed in the country where I was born, Russia? Books being burned? Poets being exiled? If this sounds dramatic, forgive me. The truth is, there are still countries where this happens – where people go to jail for their artistic expression. Plus, the more you ban art the more interest it generates and the more people are drawn to it.
In democratic South Africa, as constitutional expert Pierre De Vos points out, there is no law to stop an artist from making such a portrait and if there were, it would be unconstitutional.
A leader cannot shout down to people and force them to see him in a certain light. If they see him as the naked emperor, then so be it.
The most tragic part of all of this is that without the ANC’s threat of legal action against the Goodman Gallery, this painting would have probably slipped by unnoticed. The endless jokes about “member of state”, “organ of state” and the “dismembering” of Zuma would not have started.
While the City Press carried the picture inside its pages, the day after the ANC’s rant it landed up on the front page of the dailies. As some political analysts have described it, it was a perfect “own goal”.
We cannot avoid this argument splintering along racial and cultural lines, and I expect a lot of reaction around this. But do read what City Press editor Ferial Haffajee - the one who first published the picture on Sunday - has to say about the issue.
"I'm tired of people who desire to kill ideas of which they do not approve," she writes. "We are in Mzansi after all, not Afghanistan..."
I can't see this case making it to court. But if it does, watch it closely, it will be a fascinating battle of right to privacy and dignity versus freedom of expression.
From my side, I do believe a country’s president should be respected. But that respect needs to be earned and cannot be shoved down our throats through the courts. Like an editor that inspires a journalist, a president should inspire his country’s citizens. DM
- E-tolls: Final countdown? Or not so... final... countdown?
- Mvula Trust scandal: Minister Baloyi changes tack
- Mvula trust, minister Baloyi and the basic question of trust
- The Phiyega Problem
- Oscar: The day our newsroom went quiet
- Humphrey Mmemezi: An embodiment of all that Mamphela Ramphele loathes
- Mvula Trust: The inconvenient questions
- Exclusive: Water Affairs Deputy Minister, her friends and the R30-million tender
- Get OUTA here: Sanral's win, everyone else's loss
- That race card ain't no trump card
- Gauteng's e-tolling volcano
- FIVE MINUTES: South Africa, 27 September
- E-tolls: the lawyers slug it out
- Humphrey Mmemezi rides into the sunset, for now
- Higgs boson and the loss of our collective compass
- Death of a (textbook) salesman: Motshekga blames the supplier
- Reporter's notebook: Chaos and pain in Marlboro Gardens
- Ketani murder: ex-wife steps out
- Outa's Wayne Duvenage, out of Avis
- Humphrey Mmemezi: Have you any shame, sir?
- Betty Ketani: A murder less experienced
- Zuma squeezes the oxygen from General Cele's job
- The week we learned to listen. And prepare for new battles.
- Crime: Cold case files, South Johannesburg, chapter 1
- The realpolitik of SKA
- PaintingGate: the Gallery strikes back
- Analysis: Painting debate will test our democracy
- Unchain my art
- Gauteng's Highway to Hell, revisited
- Extra! Extra! Coming soon to a court near you: The Richard Mdluli Show
- Maldonado's triumph unites polarised Venezuela
- Defiance 2.0: Malema's back, alive & kicking
- Nazir Alli: E-tolling scandal's first victim
- That sinking feeling: Khoza 2.0 unleashes a storm of... silence
- Analysis: Which model will the police follow - Marc Ishlove's or Richard Mdluli's?
- E-tolling: Judge Prinsloo and hope for South Africa
- E-tolls: The puppet-masters drop their masks
- E-tolls: Judge's admission of urgency Outa hurt Sanral
- Reporter's notebook: Sanral's raging bronco vs Outa's angry rider
- Chuck Colson, Nixon's 'master of dirty tricks', has left the building
- Analysis: Malema's organised demise
- Lights go off on SA electric car project
- Radovan Krejcir is just a symptom
- E-Tolls: A dogfight on the cards
- A fissioning of poetry with imaginative adventures in humanness
- E-tags: The silence before the storm?
- The Princess of Bergplaas
- The Future Eaters... effectively beyond parody
- Malema suspension: ANCYL chess game continues
- His back to the wall, Malema's down to primal instincts - fight or flight
- SKA goes into referee's optional extra time
- The 'Monster', his men and the twists and turns of the Modimolle trial
- African financial ministers back Nigerian for World Bank job
- ZANEWS: Weekly Digest – S4 Episode 27
- ZANEWS: The Misfortune Teller (Part 2) Feat. The DA Team
- ZANEWS: The Misfortune Teller (Part 1)
- ZANEWS: Old School
- ZANEWS: Show me the Money!
- ZANEWS: Juju in Memoriam
- ZANEWS: Tokyo Adrift
- ZANEWS: Coming To America
- ZANEWS: Touchy-feely Boers
- ZANEWS: Weekly Digest # 25
- ZANEWS: Hail to the Chief
- ZANEWS: The Devil Wears Gaga
- ZANEWS: Lindiwe's African Dream
- ZANEWS: The Constitution and Other Fairytales
- ZANEWS: Star Wars Ep. VII – A No Hope
- ZANEWS: Sex, Drugs & Boerie Roll
- ZANEWS: Juju's in the panic room
- ZANEWS: Amazing Zooma
- ZANEWS: Buns in the oven
- ZANEWS: Eye Spy
- ZANEWS: Sirious?!?
- ZANEWS: Flushed Away?
- ZANEWS Weekly Digest
- ZANEWS: Dubul' ibhunu e Gabbana
- ZANEWS: Life after PDV
- ZANEWS: The Donald is angry
- An advice to a monster
- Ster: Return to Art for the Sake of Art
- Missing. One Maverick writer. Might be in Fifth Dimension.
- The SA economy's Cosatu migraine
- France finally arrive at Rugby World Cup
- Libyan War's forgotten sufferers
- Only 12 years after Dubya, another Texan wants to be president
- The 2010 World Cup: Was it all worth it?
- Analysis: Twitter, a @realpoliticalpowerplayerSA
- SKA's little Mozambican brother, still an embryo
- Lewis Pugh: Frack off, Shell!
- The Square Kilometre Array, a project The Karoo deserves
- Press Council hearings in Cape Town - speaking to empty chairs, again
- The Chinese Sphinx: How China reports on Egypt
- Nightmare at Baragwanath refuses to end
- Reporter's notebook: A most curious vigil
- Justice slowed by toxicology reports is justice denied
- Gauteng's mean streets offer police a reality check
- 'Fela! The Musical' comes to South Africa - well, kinda...
- 63rd Cannes: The Bang Bang Club, the movie - where art doesn't imitate life
- 63rd Cannes: Applause, emotion and Life Above All
- 63rd Cannes: Winnie, the movie, Winnie, the dilemma
- 63rd Cannes: Judging the jurors
- Cannes it all come together?
- ZANews Friday: Thabo Mbeki is the obvious choice for Bafana Bafana
- ZANews: Zuma, De Villiers, and Percy Montgomery's hair
- ZANews: Hellen Zille and national security
- ZANews debuts, politicians Shaik in their boots