Crime is not the real fear of white people
- Johann Redelinghuys
- 14 May 2012 06:13 (South Africa)
White guilt for the years of apartheid is justified. It is right that we should have overwhelming remorse for standing by and allowing the “crime against humanity” to which black people were subjected under the previous regime. But what we are doing now is compounding the crime by looking the other way when we see what so many incompetent leaders are doing. And seeing them getting away with it.
It’s an embarrassment to talk about black and white people in such graphic terms. Are we not beyond all that by now? Well, the answer would seem to be that we are not. Much as we would wish to live in a colour-blind society where race really does not matter anymore, the truth is that it permeates debate and discussion and it matters very much. Whether we talk about the future of our children, the state of our healthcare, education or any other aspect of our lives here, race is, if not one of the top subjects, then always just under the surface.
A shining example of excellent performance is that of auditor-general Terence Nombende who, last week, did not care that he was breaking ranks and heaped scorn on the poor performance of government and public servants for their recklessness and disastrous governance. Three weeks ago Reuel Khoza picked up a great deal of flak for his comments. They are two notable black men who have dared to criticise incumbent leaders and who want to set better standards.
But it is the white people who, generally, are the co-dependent collaborators in this slide into mismanagement. Partly to blame for this is our unique political situation. The ANC is so overwhelmingly powerful and as a political party so dominant the normal checks and balances of a functioning democracy are absent. In first-world countries like Australia, Canada, the UK, US, and even in the BRIC countries (Brazil, Russia, India and China) the political party in power has to face a vigorous opposition on a daily basis. If the ruling party does not perform, it is hoofed out. In South Africa, no matter how badly the ANC may perform, the sheer weight of numbers will ensure it stays in power. With its limited number of white supporters the ANC is clearly a “black” party. White people, mostly, have become disengaged.
Of course, there is the DA and Helen Zille is doing a stout defensive job, but she is seen primarily as a Cape-based figure. Which leaves Gauteng, the economic power house of the country, without any meaningful opposition to the ANC.
But my concern is not so much for the politics. It is for the combined effects of disengagement and hyper-sensitivity to be politically correct. Fear of openly criticising any black leader, either in government or the private sector, makes us cower lest we are branded as racists. A black person like Reuel Khoza might get away with it, but white people don’t come into the open. My friends in America tell me that a very similar situation exists there. Any criticism of Barack Obama is immediately branded as racist.
South African business leaders and the chairmen of listed boards, tread very carefully when having to address poor performance if the object of their focus is a black person. They are more inclined to let it slide than they would if a white person were the target. Talented young black people often have to lose the benefit of coaching and constructive criticism for this reason. Watch the “treading on eggshells” when there is any sense of potential conflict and the exaggerated politeness white people tend to show at social gatherings when interacting with those who are black, especially politicians. Julius Malema is in the wilderness for the moment, but remember how white people backed off when he defended bad behaviour by claiming “it is in my culture!”
It is right to call for the playing fields to be levelled. But the process of fixing this is being managed very badly. When a white matriculant with eight distinctions is excluded from medicine or veterinary science to make way for a black matriculant with only a 30% pass, all we are doing is creating resentment and devaluing the qualification. It is not so much the injustice of it. It is that the response and criticism are mostly covert.
One of the most inspiring episodes in the history of this democracy has been the rejection by civil society, the trade unions and anyone who wanted to join the clamour of the misguided e-tolling saga. For once race did not seem to matter. We were united in our efforts, and look what was achieved. Imagine how we could do the same when addressing other national questions, without the fear of open criticism. DM
- The textbook, talented leadership of Mr Julius Malema
- The down – and up – side of recklessness and greed
- Race and gender issues: not going anywhere
- Sloppy board governance: Failing South Africa’s critical executive leadership
- Low efforts, low satisfaction: Combatting the new workplace epidemic
- Shame on the racist rant from the Black Business Council!
- The visits of French president and Polish prime minister: a scattering of welcome fairy dust
- Uncomfortable questions about Sasol’s hired gun
- Manufacturing is not our route to riches
- The Minister is chasing away jobs!
- The Age of the Sovereign Individual is upon us
- ‘I applied my mind’: a welcome comment from the President
- Stressful news about executive stress
- The comic opera at the SABC board plays on
- The right way is not always the best way
- Double benefit of focus on farming
- Indecision is crippling us
- An ‘African MBA’ would be a mistake
- The inequalities of the wage gap won’t go away
- Privileged access: no longer just for the top dogs
- Are there different degrees of CV fraud?
- Is the ‘born free’ generation really so free?
- Labour Brokers are here to stay
- Unemployment can be beaten
- Top CEOs are feeling the pinch
- Performance anxiety: The curse of our time
- Black Economic (Dis)empowerment: It’s time to rethink our strategy
- Why mobile phones are more important than toilets
- She was a lady with a vision
- South Africa should beef up its strengths
- Jacko Maree has failed in the most important task of a CEO
- Bridging the gap: Time to embrace immigrant skills
- Gender diversity on boards still undermined by stereotyping, male-dominated networks
- Be careful what you wish for
- Please stop the mindless nonsense of trying to ‘create’ entrepreneurs to satisfy some extravagant political agenda!
- The heavy hand of government is everywhere
- The good people at Standard & Poor's may not be aware of all our resources
- Our systems of education and first-rung employment are broken
- Only disruptive leadership can achieve real change
- 'Shooting from the hip' is now the norm - and deeply damaging
- Our leaders' confused moral compass
- Government ownership: Watch out for the collapse of independence
- US and South Africa: Leading in disaster and disastrous leadership
- CEO departures and the 'perfect storm' in the boardroom
- You can't play the 'happy game' without hope and expectations
- A major leadership resource, ignored in the new South Africa
- The value of the people who create value
- Living the paradox: Life in South Africa
- A leader without a vision gets nothing done
- It’s spring! It's a good time for cleaning up our act
- So, do we want to be a global player or not?
- Big business: A critical piece missing from Manuel's plan
- Enduring values cannot be legislated
- Being a CEO - and playing the leadership game - is tough
- Career Management 101: Don't send a CV!
- The shifting sands of executive payouts
- The Perils of “Young Blood”
- Gender Diversity: Good for Business
- Nationhood: Our fragile national self-esteem
- Employment: Make Peace with the Gig Economy
- Crime is not the real fear of white people
- Dilemmas of the South African Diaspora
- Be careful what you use to vote for whom, and when and why
- Golden Schmolden Years
- Beware the Psychopaths
- Executive salaries are determined by supply and demand. It's not a conspiracy
- Reckless transformation is doing great damage
- Listen and stay close to your stakeholders
- Career Management 2020
- The New Non-Executive Director
- Working on a resolution toward a 'portfolio life'
- Facing the dilemmas of succession
- The misguided notion of 'job creation'
- High CEO turnover and the role of the chairman
- Life starts at 60, and not only for Alan Knott-Craig
- African leaders are misguided when they try to hold on to Africa for the Africans