Cosatu also exploits the poor out of self-interest
- Osiame Molefe
- 08 Mar 2012 10:41 (South Africa)
It’s getting harder to tell who “speaks” for the poor in SA, yet much is said and done in their name. It was laughable last year when the middle-classes descended on Company Gardens in Cape Town and the JSE in Sandton holding lattes in one hand and signs in the other proclaiming, “We are the 99%”.
Hardly, dears. But even Cosatu’s strike against labour broking and toll roads on Wednesday was another example of this misguidedness.
During the protest, Zwelinzima Vavi said the ANC is presiding over an “economic apartheid”. He accused the party of standing idly by as workers were forced to eke out a living off starvation wages. That’s not entirely true. The protest, intentionally, conflated the two separate issues of inequality and poverty, and glossed over how differently each affected the unions’ members.
Not all of Cosatu’s 2-million members can be considered poor or living in poverty. Among the protesters were teachers, who represent about 3% of the labour force. Their union, the SA Democratic Teachers Unions, is among the most vocal within the labour movement, yet its members earn significantly more than other groups on account of having received more education.
Public sector workers too are equally vocal and numerous. The National Health and Allied Workers Union, with estimated its 230,000 members, has been blamed for driving the public wage bill to unsustainable levels. And, like teachers, public sector workers earn more than other workers, many of them above the R15,000-a-month cut-off that would categorise them as low-income earners by most banks’ definition.
Among the unions’ members, it is teachers and public sector workers who will be most directly affected by the tolling of Gauteng’s freeways, because they earn enough to make it probable they own cars. It is also probable they will be among the freeway users who earn the least, so the flat-rate toll fee would affect their nett incomes disproportionately, so they complained, rightly so.
Sandwiched between the working class elite and the unemployed are low-income earners – miners, textile workers and factory workers. They don’t earn enough to afford cars, so are isolated from the direct impact of tolling Gauteng’s freeways, but were co-opted into Wednesday’s protest with passable arguments of the knock-on effects of toll roads.
Arguably, the Gauteng freeway tolls, which are excessive, would only serve to further increase the demand for (and investment attractiveness of) a functional, integrated mass transit system. Such a system would benefit the carless working class, who’ve been pining for it for years. This makes me wonder, how objective an argument did the unions’ leadership present to members before resolving to oppose the tolling?
Nonetheless, even low-income earners might not meet the varied and complex definitions of poverty, while unions can rightly argue that they represent those affected by inequality, they’d have a harder time proving their claim to speak for the poor. Unions represent the employed. In South Africa, poverty has stronger links to unemployment that it does to inequality.
Thankfully, Vavi does not seem to have fooled anyone into believing that Wednesday’s protest had nothing to do with Mangaung. Why else unite the workers behind an endless list of disparate issues other than to show your alliance partner that you have the power to hurt it?
By Statistics SA’s most recent estimates, almost 40% of the labour force either has no job or has given up looking. These 6.3-million South Africans are the ones forced to eke out a living on nothing.
Who speaks for them? No one, it seems.
The advocates of relaxing labour laws to allow the 40% access to jobs, any jobs, also do not speak for them, and could do with reading the UN’s papers on the decent work agenda. This is not the 1940s. The time for growing nations off cheap and bountiful labour has passed, especially in South Africa’s on-paper “progressive society”.
There’s no other way out of the stand-off between government, labour and business over unemployment and its consequent poverty. We have to innovate, not only in terms of the goods and services, but also in the way we conceptualise the resources we have and what can be done with them. DM
- Why do 16-million people not constitute an economy?, in Daily Maverick.
- ANALYSIS: the DA's battle to buddy up to the everyman
- SA's very own ‘Made in Israel’ war of words
- Limpopo textbooks - only the beginning of basic education's woes
- Fixing the criminal justice system starts by rooting out corruption at the top
- This time Cosatu rebuts the divisive youth wage subsidy with words, not stones
- The broad church means the ANC is too big not to fail
- Opposition MPs stake their claim on foreign relations morality in Tibet debate
- Lindiwe Sisulu's message of change
- Crisis or challenge, school infrastructure is nowhere near where it should be
- Political forecast for the week of 18 June: E-tolls, looming strikes, eurozone meltdowns and premiers on bikes
- PSC report could be straw that breaks some premiers' backs
- Art in a sling: Breaking walls and building a nation in paint and print
- Fighting graft with faith: Western Cape religious leaders talk corruption
- Basic education: Some gloom, some doom and a mountain still to be done
- SA's new political tool: Freedom of Cape Town for the Obamas
- Education: Waiting for the dam to burst
- Mthethwa to challenge Western Cape community safety bill
- Public sector unions and government set on a collision course
- Cabinet's mid-term report card: F for fail
- Despite objections, government stands by e-tolling
- Zwelinzima Vavi: Political consciousness leaves quietly
- E-education: A virtual dream for many public school students
- Cape Town's vision 2040
- The Spear: Black anger and white obliviousness
- Employment: Western Cape model provides glimmer of hope
- Brainstorm: The state of income inequality in South Africa
- Reporter's notebook: Decoding the Democratic Alliance
- As one struggle continues, the other should not be forgotten
- Analysis: The youth wage subsidy should not go the way of the nationalisation debate
- Another internecine war rocks the government
- Analysis: DA's young Turks tackle the race issue
- Despite indications to the contrary, South Africa's democracy is growing up
- South Africa: War criminals' holiday destination no more?
- Africa goes hi-tech: But where are all those keen investors?
- A warning for mankind: Beware the new Big Brother
- Gents, rape isn't a thing that only other men do
- Partisan dust-up over rights of the disabled goes nowhere
- Eish, DA!
- SA news media: under pressure AND under magnifying lens
- The ANC and the battle for the 'born-frees'
- Fighting shadows: How money corrupts the ANC - and its plan to stop it
- Analysis: Will the ANC seriously consider party funding this year?
- Zuma is worst president ANC has ever had
- Tough lessons for Zille from refugee tweet debacle
- Top 10 battles raging within the tripartite alliance
- Cosatu defends 'principled position' at secrecy bill hearings
- Protests are a sign of ignorance of democracy's power
- Zimbabwe torture victims turn to SA courts
- The turbulent waters of the NPA's Zim email-strom
- Ladies and gentlemen, the contemplative Ms Mazibuko
- Refugee reactions show that South Africans stand apart from Africans
- Analysis: Steep learning curve for alliance in Western Cape
- Race is just a useful marker to distinguish the worthy from the unworthy
- UCT's admissions policy unearths middle-class black angst
- Analysis: Vavi hangs Zuma out to dry
- NGO hauls Motshekga to court over school infrastructure
- Cosatu also exploits the poor out of self-interest
- Cape Town ready for Cosatu city centre shut down
- Eastern Cape pupils picket for libraries and sanitation
- Wednesday: Over 35,000 expected in Cape Town CBD instalment of Cosatu-led nationwide protest
- Frivolous comparisons to apartheid are the only thing worse than apartheid
- Analysis: Radebe's egg-dance fails to impress as bumpy road awaits
- Analysis: The Constitutional Court is the next cow to the abattoir
- How voters' right to know is bought and sold in SA
- Helen Zille's sore spot
- Sex and sexuality in a time of societal malaise
- Cosatu takes anti-corruption fight to Free State
- Cosatu and corruption, the phantom menace
- Eat, the beloved country
- Who will take responsibility?
- Cape Town, world racism capital 2011?
- The ANC has only itself to blame for bad press
- New adult channel stokes South Africa's porn conundrum
- Carrots, sticks and Zille's latest HIV misstep
- Analysis: Just how liberal is the DA?
- Russell Tribunal deliberates Apartheid Israel amid "kangaroo court" claims
- Mogoeng's first day on the job
- Never mind creation, Gordhan's mini-budget focuses on job retention
- There is, thankfully, a Pedi word for big 'misunderstanding'
- Malema’s economic freedom lecture: Swansong or come-back hit?
- African leaders meet to talk job creation and labour standards
- Diversity a trump card as more endorsements come in for Mazibuko
- Rights groups cry foul as South Africa resumes deportations of undocumented Zimbabweans
- The day of the Archbishop's ire
- The DA's surprising proposal on domestic worker rights
- Mazibuko's star rises as she outlines her plan for the DA parliamentary caucus
- ANALYSIS: The Western Cape takes the thought leadership in job creation - now all we need is action
- ANC makes U-turn on secrecy bill - and lives to tell the tale
- Secrecy bill: to be or not to be - we're about to find out
- President's day of fun and amusement in Parliament
- Public Protector on participatory democracy, secrecy bill and her office's powers. And the country in trouble.
- Vettel victorious at Monza
- WikiLeaks cables go public, unfiltered
- Sisulu stands by decision to appoint Yengeni to defence review committee
- Vettel leads home a Red Bull 1-2 at Spa-Francorchamps
- Belgian Grand Prix: Preview
- Democratic Alliance eyes 2014 national elections with economic policy promise
- Analysis: Time for a fresh look at SA's global competitiveness
- Analysis: Missing history, lacking context bring back the great white-tax debate