At issue here is Anthony Butler’s column in the Business Day last week, which was as much funny-ha-ha as it was weird.
He uses academic labels that I presume are used in “masculinity studies”, but those terms are loaded, and he sabotages his own cause, like a soccer player scoring an own goal. Except he does so without apparent regret.
In his piece, entitled “ANC’s young ‘men’ test our gender conventions”, Butler makes the point that there’s much confusion among (South African) men nowadays over what it means to be a man.
He sticks these labels (if he was a member of the League he’d probably be accused of name-calling) onto ANC Youth League spokesman Floyd Shivambu and his president, Julius Malema.
The parts about the young lions engaging in “provisional transgender experiments” that question society’s traditional gender conventions, on first reading evoke rather comical mental images of, say, Shivambu in heels, lipstick and fake eyelashes on a underlit stage. Butler writes Shivambu adopts “‘hyper-feminine’ submissive behaviours when listening to his ‘dominant male’ partner, Malema”, who, in this reading, one imagines dressed in leather and chains, and maybe also a Stetson hat.
Scholars of masculinity studies (who must have been sniggering in a puerile manner after coining the term) have called this submissiveness “sissification”.
Butler then goes further by not only playing the men, but also the ball, saying the League’s nationalisation drive involves “fetishistic ideological transvestism”, which involves “the erotically charged donning of the intellectual clothing of class opponents”. What this implies is that the League gets off on the way they go about pushing their nationalisation campaign by dressing up as the enemy.
And then Butler returns to the men, saying League bosses have engaged in “petticoating” and “pinaforing” when it comes to President Jacob Zuma, describing “a form of forced feminisation in which a man is dressed in women’s clothing in order to humiliate him”.
(In my mind’s ear, there’s an invisible pause after this sentence for more Beavis and Butthead-type chuckles.)
Butler then asks whether men like these described above (he also brought up fired Sowetan columnist Eric Miyeni in his piece) can “ever lead fulfilling lives, comfortable with their own gender identities”, or whether they’ll forever feel threatened by strong women like DA spokeswoman Lindiwe Mazibuko, DA leader Helen Zille, poet and performer Lebo Mashile and City Press editor Ferial Haffajee.
Then he takes the somewhat twisted humour to the loo, saying international experience shows that “gender-neutral toilets” in Luthuli House would allow the League’s leaders to go to the toilet without first having to ask themselves if they’re male or female.
Once the short-lived, but soundless giggles subsided, I got as angry as Germaine Greer, at least.
For Greer is well-known as an opponent of “man-made women”, or men who want to be women cosmetically, on the outside, i.e. minus penis and plus boobs and all the other pretty things, but who would change their minds on the sex-change if a uterus and ovaries came with the package.
She has also argued that men who crossdress adopt exaggerated “female” behaviour – applying too much make-up, wearing high heels and sexy clothing, and embellishing on their mannerisms. They are more woman-like than real women, in what seems to be “some ghastly parody”.
While the merits of Greer’s argument can be debated at a time where we want to believe that everything goes and every person is more or less equal, never mind how they choose to express their sexuality, she has a point.
In theatre, crossdressing men act out female stereotypes, often to comic effect. Butler does more or less the same. He makes the league’s macho male bosses out to be stereotypes of women, and this makes us laugh. He does the same thing to the League that he is accusing the League of doing to Zuma (the “pinaforing”).
Butler makes submissiveness out to be a female trait, obviously with a lot of sexual overtones, and ditto “sissification” ( which means having unsuitable female qualities), which has associations of cowardice and weakness. These terms weren’t exactly what came to mind when I saw a woman the other day, obviously poor and with no shoes, astride a big log next to the road, fiercely wielding an axe with which she chopped firewood.
“Submissive” and “sissies” are also not labels you could give sports heroes like swimmer Natalie du Toit, the Williams sisters in tennis, or the Russian Nurgalieva twins, who are champions of several ultramarathon runs.
Similarly we have political figures like ANC stalwart Winnie Madikizela-Mandela, DA leader Helen Zille, and countless others who just don’t do submisison or sissy-hood.
That doesn’t make them less womanly.
So, when men behave submissively or cowardly, why should this mean that they cross the gender boundary (and what does this boundary mean anyway)? Can they not simply be considered as humans who behave in a certain way? Does submissive or cowardly behaviour have to be gender-specific? Can’t we homo sapiens just be multi-faceted, complex organisms in our own right, without dragging gender stereotypes into the mix? (Keep in mind that much of our behaviour as men and women is acquired through socialisation according to these stereotypes, rather than being absolutes present from birth, in the way our physical attributes are.)
It might be true that the young lions, and men like Miyeni, are uncertain about what their gender requires of them in a world where traditional perceptions are changing, but the reasons for this are way more complex and interesting than a petticoat here and a pinafore there. People well-versed in gender studies should know better than to be, on the surface at least, insensitive to this. DM
- Malema wants rights organisations to protect his human rights, swoop on Hawks
- Ten tips for a budding politician philanderer and his squeeze
- Malema talks change and walks war with Zuma
- Government surprises by scrapping private prisons
- Gatekeepers to blackness should contemplate the Camembert
- Mazibuko topples Trollip as DA parliamentary leader
- Malema hearing resumes as youth get fired up for march
- Zuma's Cabinet reshuffle, the morning after
- While Zuma gets on with real business, Malema whines about planned march
- Malema drums up support ahead of economic freedom march
- Public Works PR crash and minister Gwen blames bladdie officials again
- Cosatu's conundrum - to march with Malema or to leave a vacuum
- Zuma's staying power (and office) is costing taxpayers millions
- Fight uncertainty with uncertainty, and avoid being flavour of the month
- DA plot thickens as more endorsements for caucus leaders trickle in
- ANC slams Dalai Lama court drama
- ANC Youth hits back at Blade
- Cele's friendliest of warnings to journalists reporting his departure
- ANC pushes on with Malema hearing, all in good time for the Youth League
- Madonsela's riveting report: Shiceka wasted our money on luxury. And he lied.
- Parliament to probe R14 million People's Assembly
- Blade Nzimande calls DA anti-toll campaign a tea party, while he too hates the tolls
- DA debates its rules as Mazibuko's campaign goes out there
- JujuTube for economic freedom in our lifetime
- Qwelane will have to explain why gay is not OK
- Parliament's chief talker quits quietly
- As a total breakdown of NYDA's kiss fest spending is published, outrage turns to anger
- South Africa, the ANC and this point in space/Dalai/Lama/time/continuum
- Malema gets hospital-sized man-flu on the eve of his disciplinary
- Parliament and media at each others' throats again
- Gwen's woes mount as Auditor-General details Public Works shambles
- ANC conference season upon us again
- Young Lions embark on a power strip show in provinces
- Bizos comes up for the courts
- Zuma spy tape drama playing again
- DA young gun Mazibuko ready to fire first salvo in mid-term caucus elections
- Will it be home, sweet, busy home for Zuma?
- One small step for Daso, one young leap for the DA
- Zuma to Cele: Tell me why you shouldn't leave
- As Mantashe warns of implosions, Youth League plans revolt in October
- Bah humbug to the Rugby World Cup, but the green and gold is goddamnawful
- Dubula continua: ANC asks to appeal That Judgment
- Gwen Mahlangu-Nkabinde courts cancellation of police deals
- ANC MPs to rethink Secrecy Bill
- Zuma praised as Ngcobo tipped to investigate arms deal
- DA quietly tasting the bittersweet fruits of success
- Silence in the spook house: DA wants intelligence watchdog to take a peek
- Mogoeng: Protecting judiciary not an overnight project
- Bad judgement made me think Malema could be right
- Digital grapevine rumours on Madiba died a quiet death
- Spy wars, episode two: Njenje to shed light on "resignation"
- Malema's disciplinary is likely to be a slow, long, drawn-out affair
- Crimes, damned crimes and their statistics
- Mogoeng: How to make a revolution with what's coming
- Mogoeng's appointment likely to steam ahead
- Tokyo ropes in Winnie to clean up the toilet mess
- Mogoeng must thank the Lord - and Malema
- DA ropes in younger Mbeki on economic freedom
- Secrecy Bill could be first big one for Mogoeng
- Youth League to party even as its world is ending
- Aluta continua for Malema as his charges stand
- Good call, bad call, or better to venture no call at all?
- Malema hearing takes a breather
- Luthuli House changes its mind about Luthuli House
- Violence Inc: Luthuli House scenes a bitter taste of Polokwane fruits
- Malema hearing: League's hands-off approach fails
- ANC's Malema dilemma: Damned if they don't do it right
- Malema's pre-disciplinary presser: the ANC can't touch this
- Power to the tweeple as DA hosts another Twitter Town Hall meeting
- Disciplinary action: Malema prays for divine intervention
- Sticks and stones may break Malema's bones... but maybe not
- Five percent payrise for all the president's men
- Things the Roman Emperor taught us about roller coaster rides
- Land reform green paper out, at last. Almost.
- Young lions regroup as disciplinary charges notch up
- Full house for ANC Youth League as four more officials charged
- ANC NEC squashes Save Juju campaign
- ANC shoots from its branches as party structures called into line
- Malema's disciplinary: Not everyone in the League standing by their man
- DA puts out race fires claims
- Malema and the Disciplinary Committee: A Rough Guide
- Double toil and trouble for Malema - and deja vu as he is charged again
- Be the change you want to see - join the ANC
- If you canít beat them, join them and tip the scales
- Young Lions meow as ANC clears its throat
- Municipal union bargains on bigger numbers
- Chief Justice controversy: Why did Sisi Khampepe say no to Jacob Zuma?
- Young Reds want to probe Malema (while he's down)
- No-show Gwen raises ire of MPs and protector
- Sowetan sies no wrong in "public interest" porn-like pic
- New Chief Justice Mogoeng, the answer to Zuma's judicial prayers
- Van der Vyver wins civil claim, but would the police ever pay?
- Decision time: ANC to press on with Malema charges
- Outgoing Ngcobo may be flush over toilet privacy, but jury still out over a successor
- A brief look: Municipal workers rubbish fears of lawlessness during today's strike
- Malema charging up for another long week in politics
- Friends are few, and the Youth League apologises
- Fires rage in Parliament over Public Protector's report
- Even bright academics can be sheep crossdressed as wolves
- For taxis, the Gauteng roads toll bells ring no more
- Operation historic healthcare one step closer, but figures still scanty
- Solidarity whenever: Unions struggle to find unity
- Will health tax cost us an arm and a leg?
- Shiceka's ready to roll, but does he still rock Zuma's world?
- Zuma promises to improve hardships of being a woman
- Analysis: How do you solve a problem like Malema?
- Youth League lives to die another day, maybe
- A brief look: Unbridled joy as Zuma addresses Khoi-San
- A brief look: Tannie Evita and the Tea Lady
- Malema and his troops set for a bladdie Monday
- After Malema's assassination plan claims, now Numsa joins the list
- Stand by your woman, man
- Malema to students: You are a generation of economic freedom fighters
- No love lost as NYDA's kissing fest report finally comes out
- Women's Month has ANC petticoats showing again
- Miyeni affair: Text, mines & videotape
- ANC's Young Lions defiant on Botswana, choose more enemies to fight
- Miyeni affair - the morning after
- ANC interrupts Youth League's Botswana regime change dreams
- Youth League's message to the nation: Malema can't be bought for R200,000